puffyboa.xyz Speedreed

Speedreed

XENOCIDE

by

Orson

Scott

Card

(c)

1991

Orson

Scott

Card

Chapter

1

--

A

PARTING

<Today

one

of

the

brothers

asked

me:

Is

it

a

terrible

prison,

not

to

be

able

to

move

from

the

place

where

you're

standing?>

<You

answered

...>

<I

told

him

that

I

am

now

more

free

than

he

is.

The

inability

to

move

frees

me

from

the

obligation

to

act.>

<You

who

speak

languages,

you

are

such

liars.>

Han

Fei-tzu

sat

in

lotus

position

on

the

bare

wooden

floor

beside

his

wife's

sickbed.

Until

a

moment

ago

he

might

have

been

sleeping;

he

wasn't

sure.

But

now

he

was

aware

of

the

slight

change

in

her

breathing,

a

change

as

subtle

as

the

wind

from

a

butterfly's

passing.

Jiang-qing,

for

her

part,

must

also

have

detected

some

change

in

him,

for

she

had

not

spoken

before

and

now

she

did

speak.

Her

voice

was

very

soft.

But

Han

Fei-tzu

could

hear

her

clearly,

for

the

house

was

silent.

He

had

asked

his

friends

and

servants

for

stillness

during

the

dusk

of

Jiang-qing's

life.

Time

enough

for

careless

noise

during

the

long

night

that

was

to

come,

when

there

would

be

no

hushed

words

from

her

lips.

"Still

not

dead,"

she

said.

She

had

greeted

him

with

these

words

each

time

she

woke

during

the

past

few

days.

At

first

the

words

had

seemed

whimsical

or

ironic

to

him,

but

now

he

knew

that

she

spoke

with

disappointment.

She

longed

for

death

now,

not

because

she

hadn't

loved

life,

but

because

death

was

now

unavoidable,

and

what

cannot

be

shunned

must

be

embraced.

That

was

the

Path.

Jiang-qing

had

never

taken

a

step

away

from

the

Path

in

her

life.

"Then

the

gods

are

kind

to

me,"

said

Han

Fei-tzu.

"To

you,"

she

breathed.

"What

do

we

contemplate?"

It

was

her

way

of

asking

him

to

share

his

private

thoughts

with

her.

When

others

asked

his

private

thoughts,

he

felt

spied

upon.

But

Jiang-qing

asked

only

so

that

she

could

also

think

the

same

thought;

it

was

part

of

their

having

become

a

single

soul.

"We

are

contemplating

the

nature

of

desire,"

said

Han

Fei-tzu.

"Whose

desire?"

she

asked.

"And

for

what?"

My

desire

for

your

bones

to

heal

and

become

strong,

so

that

they

don't

snap

at

the

slightest

pressure.

So

that

you

could

stand

again,

or

even

raise

an

arm

without

your

own

muscles

tearing

away

chunks

of

bone

or

causing

the

bone

to

break

under

the

tension.

So

that

I

wouldn't

have

to

watch

you

wither

away

until

now

you

weigh

only

eighteen

kilograms.

I

never

knew

how

perfectly

happy

we

were

until

I

learned

that

we

could

not

stay

together.

"My

desire,"

he

answered.

"For

you."

"'You

only

covet

what

you

do

not

have.'

Who

said

that?"

"You

did,"

said

Han

Fei-tzu.

"Some

say,

'what

you

cannot

have.'

Others

say,

'what

you

should

not

have.'

I

say,

'You

can

truly

covet

only

what

you

will

always

hunger

for.'"

"You

have

me

forever."

"I

will

lose

you

tonight.

Or

tomorrow.

Or

next

week."

"Let

us

contemplate

the

nature

of

desire,"

said

Jiang-qing.

As

before,

she

was

using

philosophy

to

pull

him

out

of

his

brooding

melancholy.

He

resisted

her,

but

only

playfully.

"You

are

a

harsh

ruler,"

said

Han

Feitzu.

"Like

your

ancestor-of-theheart,

you

make

no

allowance

for

other

people's

frailty."

Jiang-qing

was

named

for

a

revolutionary

leader

of

the

ancient

past,

who

had

tried

to

lead

the

people

onto

a

new

Path

but

was

overthrown

by

weak-hearted

cowards.

It

was

not

right,

thought

Han

Fei-tzu,

for

his

wife

to

die

before

him:

her

ancestor-of-the-heart

had

outlived

her

husband.

Besides,

wives

should

live

longer

than

husbands.

Women

were

more

complete

inside

themselves.

They

were

also

better

at

living

in

their

children.

They

were

never

as

solitary

as

a

man

alone.

Jiang-qing

refused

to

let

him

return

to

brooding.

"When

a

man's

wife

is

dead,

what

does

he

long

for?"

Rebelliously,

Han

Fei-tzu

gave

her

the

most

false

answer

to

her

question.

"To

lie

with

her,"

he

said.

"The

desire

of

the

body,"

said

Jiang-qing.

Since

she

was

determined

to

have

this

conversation,

Han

Fei-tzu

took

up

the

catalogue

for

her.

"The

desire

of

the

body

is

to

act.

It

includes

all

touches,

casual

and

intimate,

and

all

customary

movements.

Thus

he

sees

a

movement

out

of

the

corner

of

his

eye,

and

thinks

he

has

seen

his

dead

wife

moving

across

the

doorway,

and

he

cannot

be

content

until

he

has

walked

to

the

door

and

seen

that

it

was

not

his

wife.

Thus

he

wakes

up

from

a

dream

in

which

he

heard

her

voice,

and

finds

himself

speaking

his

answer

aloud

as

if

she

could

hear

him."

"What

else?"

asked

Jiang-qing.

"I'm

tired

of

philosophy,"

said

Han

Fei-tzu.

"Maybe

the

Greeks

found

comfort

in

it,

but

not

me."

"The

desire

of

the

spirit,"

said

Jiang-qing,

insisting.

"Because

the

spirit

is

of

the

earth,

it

is

that

part

which

makes

new

things

out

of

old

ones.

The

husband

longs

for

all

the

unfinished

things

that

he

and

his

wife

were

making

when

she

died,

and

all

the

unstarted

dreams

of

what

they

would

have

made

if

she

had

lived.

Thus

a

man

grows

angry

at

his

children

for

being

too

much

like

him

and

not

enough

like

his

dead

wife.

Thus

a

man

hates

the

house

they

lived

in

together,

because

either

he

does

not

change

it,

so

that

it

is

as

dead

as

his

wife,

or

because

he

does

change

it,

so

that

it

is

no

longer

half

of

her

making."

"You

don't

have

to

be

angry

at

our

little

Qing-jao,"

said

Jiang-qing.

"Why?"

asked

Han

Fei-tzu.

"Will

you

stay,

then,

and

help

me

teach

her

to

be

a

woman?

All

I

can

teach

her

is

to

be

what

I

am--

cold

and

hard,

sharp

and

strong,

like

obsidian.

If

she

grows

like

that,

while

she

looks

so

much

like

you,

how

can

I

help

but

be

angry?"

"Because

you

can

teach

her

everything

that

I

am,

too,"

said

Jiang-qing.

"If

I

had

any

part

of

you

in

me,"

said

Han

Fei-tzu,

"I

would

not

have

needed

to

marry

you

to

become

a

complete

person."

Now

he

teased

her

by

using

philosophy

to

turn

the

conversation

away

from

pain.

"That

is

the

desire

of

the

soul.

Because

the

soul

is

made

of

light

and

dwells

in

air,

it

is

that

part

which

conceives

and

keeps

ideas,

especially

the

idea

of

the

self.

The

husband

longs

for

his

whole

self,

which

was

made

of

the

husband

and

wife

together.

Thus

he

never

believes

any

of

his

own

thoughts,

because

there

is

always

a

question

in

his

mind

to

which

his

wife's

thoughts

were

the

only

possible

answer.

Thus

the

whole

world

seems

dead

to

him

because

he

cannot

trust

anything

to

keep

its

meaning

before

the

onslaught

of

this

unanswerable

question."

"Very

deep,"

said

Jiang-qing.

"If

I

were

Japanese

I

would

commit

seppuku,

spilling

my

bowel

into

the

jar

of

your

ashes."

"Very

wet

and

messy,"

she

said.

He

smiled.

"Then

I

should

be

an

ancient

Hindu,

and

burn

myself

on

your

pyre."

But

she

was

through

with

joking.

"Qing-jao,"

she

whispered.

She

was

reminding

him

he

could

do

nothing

so

flamboyant

as

to

die

with

her.

There

was

little

Qing-jao

to

care

for.

So

Han

Fei-tzu

answered

her

seriously.

"How

can

I

teach

her

to

be

what

you

are?"

"All

that

is

good

in

me,"

said

Jiang-qing,

"comes

from

the

Path.

If

you

teach

her

to

obey

the

gods,

honor

the

ancestors,

love

the

people,

and

serve

the

rulers,

I

will

be

in

her

as

much

as

you

are."

"I

would

teach

her

the

Path

as

part

of

myself,"

said

Han

Fei-tzu.

"Not

so,"

said

Jiang-qing.

"The

Path

is

not

a

natural

part

of

you,

my

husband.

Even

with

the

gods

speaking

to

you

every

day,

you

insist

on

believing

in

a

world

where

everything

can

be

explained

by

natural

causes."

"I

obey

the

gods."

He

thought,

bitterly,

that

he

had

no

choice;

that

even

to

delay

obedience

was

torture.

"But

you

don't

know

them.

You

don't

love

their

works."

"The

Path

is

to

love

the

people.

The

gods

we

only

obey."

How

can

I

love

gods

who

humiliate

me

and

torment

me

at

every

opportunity?

"We

love

the

people

because

they

are

creatures

of

the

gods."

"Don't

preach

to

me."

She

sighed.

Her

sadness

stung

him

like

a

spider.

"I

wish

you

would

preach

to

me

forever,"

said

Han

Fei-tzu.

"You

married

me

because

you

knew

I

loved

the

gods,

and

that

love

for

them

was

completely

missing

from

yourself.

That

was

how

I

completed

you."

How

could

he

argue

with

her,

when

he

knew

that

even

now

he

hated

the

gods

for

everything

they

had

ever

done

to

him,

everything

they

had

ever

made

him

do,

everything

they

had

stolen

from

him

in

his

life.

"Promise

me,"

said

Jiang-qing.

He

knew

what

these

words

meant.

She

felt

death

upon

her;

she

was

laying

the

burden

of

her

life

upon

him.

A

burden

he

would

gladly

bear.

It

was

losing

her

company

on

the

Path

that

he

had

dreaded

for

so

long.

"Promise

that

you

will

teach

Qing-jao

to

love

the

gods

and

walk

always

on

the

Path.

Promise

that

you

will

make

her

as

much

my

daughter

as

yours."

"Even

if

she

never

hears

the

voice

of

the

gods?"

"The

Path

is

for

everyone,

not

just

the

godspoken."

Perhaps,

thought

Han

Fei-tzu,

but

it

was

much

easier

for

the

godspoken

to

follow

the

Path,

because

to

them

the

price

for

straying

from

it

was

so

terrible.

The

common

people

were

free;

they

could

leave

the

Path

and

not

feel

the

pain

of

it

for

years.

The

godspoken

couldn't

leave

the

Path

for

an

hour.

"Promise

me."

I

will.

I

promise.

But

he

couldn't

say

the

words

out

loud.

He

did

not

know

why,

but

his

reluctance

was

deep.

In

the

silence,

as

she

waited

for

his

vow,

they

heard

the

sound

of

running

feet

on

the

gravel

outside

the

front

door

of

the

house.

It

could

only

be

Qing-jao,

home

from

the

garden

of

Sun

Cao-pi.

Only

Qing-jao

was

allowed

to

run

and

make

noise

during

this

time

of

hush,

They

waited,

knowing

that

she

would

come

straight

to

her

mother's

room.

The

door

slid

open

almost

noiselessly.

Even

Qing-jao

had

caught

enough

of

the

hush

to

walk

softly

when

she

was

actually

in

the

presence

of

her

mother.

Though

she

walked

on

tiptoe,

she

could

hardly

keep

from

dancing,

almost

galloping

across

the

floor.

But

she

did

not

fling

her

arms

around

her

mother's

neck;

she

remembered

that

lesson

even

though

the

terrible

bruise

had

faded

from

Jiang-qing's

face,

where

Qing-jao's

eager

embrace

had

broken

her

jaw

three

months

ago.

"I

counted

twenty-three

white

carp

in

the

garden

stream,"

said

Qing-jao.

"So

many,"

said

Jiang-qing.

"I

think

they

were

showing

themselves

to

me,"

said

Qing-jao.

"So

I

could

count

them.

None

of

them

wanted

to

be

left

out."

"Love

you,"

whispered

Jiang-qing.

Han

Fei-tzu

heard

a

new

sound

in

her

breathy

voice--

a

popping

sound,

like

bubbles

bursting

with

her

words.

"Do

you

think

that

seeing

so

many

carp

means

that

I

will

be

godspoken?"

asked

Qing-jao.

"I

will

ask

the

gods

to

speak

to

you,"

said

Jiang-qing.

Suddenly

Jiang-qing's

breathing

became

quick

and

harsh.

Han

Fei-tzu

immediately

knelt

and

looked

at

his

wife.

Her

eyes

were

wide

and

frightened.

The

moment

had

come.

Her

lips

moved.

Promise

me,

she

said,

though

her

breath

could

make

no

sound

but

gasping.

"I

promise,"

said

Han

Fei-tzu.

Then

her

breathing

stopped.

"What

do

the

gods

say

when

they

talk

to

you?"

asked

Qing-jao.

"Your

mother

is

very

tired,"

said

Han

Fei-tzu.

"You

should

go

out

now."

"But

she

didn't

answer

me.

What

do

the

gods

say?"

"They

tell

secrets,"

said

Han

Fei-tzu.

"No

one

who

hears

will

repeat

them."

Qing-jao

nodded

wisely.

She

took

a

step

back,

as

if

to

leave,

but

stopped.

"May

I

kiss

you,

Mama?"

"Lightly

on

the

cheek,"

said

Han

Fei-tzu.

Qing-jao,

being

small

for

a

four-year-old,

did

not

have

to

bend

very

far

at

all

to

kiss

her

mother's

cheek.

"I

love

you,

Mama."

"You'd

better

leave

now,

Qing-jao,"

said

Han

Fei-tzu.

"But

Mama

didn't

say

she

loved

me

too."

"She

did.

She

said

it

before.

Remember?

But

she's

very

tired

and

weak.

Go

now."

He

put

just

enough

sternness

in

his

voice

that

Qing-jao

left

without

further

questions.

Only

when

she

was

gone

did

Han

Fei-tzu

let

himself

feel

anything

but

care

for

her.

He

knelt

over

Jiang-qing's

body

and

tried

to

imagine

what

was

happening

to

her

now.

Her

soul

had

flown

and

was

now

already

in

heaven.

Her

spirit

would

linger

much

longer;

perhaps

her

spirit

would

dwell

in

this

house,

if

it

had

truly

been

a

place

of

happiness

for

her.

Superstitious

people

believed

that

all

spirits

of

the

dead

were

dangerous,

and

put

up

signs

and

wards

to

fend

them

off.

But

those

who

followed

the

Path

knew

that

the

spirit

of

a

good

person

was

never

harmful

or

destructive,

for

their

goodness

in

life

had

come

from

the

spirit's

love

of

making

things.

Jiang-qing's

spirit

would

be

a

blessing

in

the

house

for

many

years

to

come,

if

she

chose

to

stay.

Yet

even

as

he

tried

to

imagine

her

soul

and

spirit,

according

to

the

teachings

of

the

Path,

there

was

a

cold

place

in

his

heart

that

was

certain

that

all

that

was

left

of

Jiang-qing

was

this

brittle,

dried-up

body.

Tonight

it

would

burn

as

quickly

as

paper,

and

then

she

would

be

gone

except

for

the

memories

in

his

heart.

Jiang-qing

was

right.

Without

her

to

complete

his

soul,

he

was

already

doubting

the

gods.

And

the

gods

had

noticed--

they

always

did.

At

once

he

felt

the

unbearable

pressure

to

do

the

ritual

of

cleansing,

until

he

was

rid

of

his

unworthy

thoughts.

Even

now

they

could

not

leave

him

unpunished.

Even

now,

with

his

wife

lying

dead

before

him,

the

gods

insisted

that

he

do

obeisance

to

them

before

he

could

shed

a

single

tear

of

grief

for

her.

At

first

he

meant

to

delay,

to

put

off

obedience.

He

had

schooled

himself

to

be

able

to

postpone

the

ritual

for

as

long

as

a

whole

day,

while

hiding

all

outward

signs

of

his

inner

torment.

He

could

do

that

now--

but

only

by

keeping

his

heart

utterly

cold.

There

was

no

point

in

that.

Proper

grief

could

come

only

when

he

had

satisfied

the

gods.

So,

kneeling

there,

he

began

the

ritual.

He

was

still

twisting

and

gyrating

with

the

ritual

when

a

servant

peered

in.

Though

the

servant

said

nothing,

Han

Fei-tzu

heard

the

faint

sliding

of

the

door

and

knew

what

the

servant

would

assume:

Jiangqing

was

dead,

and

Han

Fei-tzu

was

so

righteous

that

he

was

communing

with

the

gods

even

before

he

announced

her

death

to

the

household.

No

doubt

some

would

even

suppose

that

the

gods

had

come

to

take

Jiang-qing,

since

she

was

known

for

her

extraordinary

holiness.

No

one

would

guess

that

even

as

Han

Feitzu

worshiped,

his

heart

was

full

of

bitterness

that

the

gods

would

dare

demand

this

of

him

even

now.

O

Gods,

he

thought,

if

I

knew

that

by

cutting

off

an

arm

or

cutting

out

my

liver

I

could

be

rid

of

you

forever,

I

would

seize

the

knife

and

relish

the

pain

and

loss,

all

for

the

sake

of

freedom.

That

thought,

too,

was

unworthy,

and

required

even

more

cleansing.

It

was

hours

before

the

gods

at

last

released

him,

and

by

then

he

was

too

tired,

too

sick

at

heart

to

grieve.

He

got

up

and

fetched

the

women

to

prepare

Jiang-qing's

body

for

the

burning.

At

midnight

he

was

the

last

to

come

to

the

pyre,

carrying

a

sleepy

Qing-jao

in

his

arms.

She

clutched

in

her

hands

the

three

papers

she

had

written

for

her

mother

in

her

childish

scrawl.

"Fish,"

she

had

written,

and

"book"

and

"secrets."

These

were

the

things

that

Qing-jao

was

giving

to

her

mother

to

carry

with

her

into

heaven.

Han

Fei-tzu

had

tried

to

guess

at

the

thoughts

in

Qing-jao's

mind

as

she

wrote

those

words.

Fish

because

of

the

carp

in

the

garden

stream

today,

no

doubt.

And

book--

that

was

easy

enough

to

understand,

because

reading

aloud

was

one

of

the

last

things

Jiang-qing

could

do

with

her

daughter.

But

why

secrets?

What

secrets

did

Qing-jao

have

for

her

mother?

He

could

not

ask.

One

did

not

discuss

the

paper

offerings

to

the

dead.

Han

Fei-tzu

set

Qing-jao

on

her

feet;

she

had

not

been

deeply

asleep,

and

so

she

woke

at

once

and

stood

there,

blinking

slowly.

Han

Fei-tzu

whispered

to

her

and

she

rolled

her

papers

and

tucked

them

into

her

mother's

sleeve.

She

didn't

seem

to

mind

touching

her

mother's

cold

flesh--

she

was

too

young

to

have

learned

to

shudder

at

the

touch

of

death.

Nor

did

Han

Fei-tzu

mind

the

touch

of

his

wife's

flesh

as

he

tucked

his

own

three

papers

into

her

other

sleeve.

What

was

there

to

fear

from

death

now,

when

it

had

already

done

its

worst?

No

one

knew

what

was

written

on

his

papers,

or

they

would

have

been

horrified,

for

he

had

written,

"My

body,"

"My

spirit,"

and

"My

soul."

Thus

it

was

that

he

burned

himself

on

Jiang-qing's

funeral

pyre,

and

sent

himself

with

her

wherever

it

was

she

was

going.

Then

Jiang-qing's

secret

maid,

Mu-pao,

laid

the

torch

onto

the

sacred

wood

and

the

pyre

burst

into

flames.

The

heat

of

the

fire

was

painful,

and

Qing-jao

hid

herself

behind

her

father,

only

peeking

around

him

now

and

then

to

watch

her

mother

leave

on

her

endless

journey.

Han

Fei-tzu,

though,

welcomed

the

dry

heat

that

seared

his

skin

and

made

brittle

the

silk

of

his

robe.

Her

body

had

not

been

as

dry

as

it

seemed;

long

after

the

papers

had

crisped

into

ash

and

blown

upward

into

the

smoke

of

the

fire,

her

body

still

sizzled,

and

the

heavy

incense

burning

all

around

the

fire

could

not

conceal

from

him

the

smell

of

burning

flesh.

That

is

what

we're

burning

here:

meat,

fish,

carrion,

nothing.

Not

my

Jiang-qing.

Only

the

costume

she

wore

into

this

life.

That

which

made

that

body

into

the

woman

that

I

loved

is

still

alive,

must

still

live.

And

for

a

moment

he

thought

he

could

see,

or

hear,

or

somehow

feel

the

passage

of

Jiang-qing.

Into

the

air,

into

the

earth,

into

the

fire.

I

am

with

you.

Chapter

2

--

A

MEETING

<The

strangest

thing

about

humans

is

the

way

they

pair

up,

males

and

females.

Constantly

at

war

with

each

other,

never

content

to

leave

each

other

alone.

They

never

seem

to

grasp

the

idea

that

males

and

females

are

separate

species

with

completely

different

needs

and

desires,

forced

to

come

together

only

to

reproduce.>

<Of

course

you

feel

that

way.

Your

mates

are

nothing

but

mindless

drones,

extensions

of

yourself,

without

their

own

identity.>

<We

know

our

lovers

with

perfect

understanding.

Humans

invent

an

imaginary

lover

and

put

that

mask

over

the

face

of

the

body

in

their

bed.>

<That

is

the

tragedy

of

language,

my

friend.

Those

who

know

each

other

only

through

symbolic

representations

are

forced

to

imagine

each

other.

And

because

their

imagination

is

imperfect,

they

are

often

wrong.>

<That

is

the

source

of

their

misery.>

<And

some

of

their

strength,

I

think.

Your

people

and

mine,

each

for

our

own

evolutionary

reasons,

mate

with

vastly

unequal

partners.

Our

mates

are

always,

hopelessly,

our

intellectual

inferiors.

Humans

mate

with

beings

who

challenge

their

supremacy.

They

have

conflict

between

mates,

not

because

their

communication

is

inferior

to

ours,

but

because

they

commune

with

each

other

at

all.>

Valentine

Wiggin

read

over

her

essay,

making

a

few

corrections

here

and

there.

When

she

was

done,

the

words

stood

in

the

air

over

her

computer

terminal.

She

was

feeling

pleased

with

herself

for

having

written

such

a

deft

ironic

dismemberment

of

the

personal

character

of

Rymus

Ojman,

the

chairman

of

the

cabinet

of

Starways

Congress.

"Have

we

finished

another

attack

on

the

masters

of

the

Hundred

Worlds?"

Valentine

did

not

turn

to

face

her

husband;

she

knew

from

his

voice

exactly

what

expression

would

be

on

his

face,

and

so

she

smiled

back

at

him

without

turning

around.

After

twenty-five

years

of

marriage,

they

could

see

each

other

clearly

without

having

to

look.

"We

have

made

Rymus

Ojman

look

ridiculous."

Jakt

leaned

into

her

tiny

office,

his

face

so

close

to

hers

that

she

could

hear

his

soft

breathing

as

he

read

the

opening

paragraphs.

He

wasn't

young

anymore;

the

exertion

of

leaning

into

her

office,

bracing

his

hands

on

the

doorframe,

was

making

him

breathe

more

rapidly

than

she

liked

to

hear.

Then

he

spoke,

but

with

his

face

so

close

to

hers

that

she

felt

his

lips

brush

her

cheek,

tickling

her

with

every

word.

"From

now

on

even

his

mother

will

laugh

behind

her

hand

whenever

she

sees

the

poor

bastard."

"It

was

hard

to

make

it

funny,"

said

Valentine.

"I

caught

myself

denouncing

him

again

and

again."

"This

is

better."

"Oh,

I

know.

If

I

had

let

my

outrage

show,

if

I

had

accused

him

of

all

his

crimes,

it

would

have

made

him

seem

more

formidable

and

frightening

and

the

Rule-of-law

Faction

would

have

loved

him

all

the

more,

while

the

cowards

on

every

world

would

have

bowed

to

him

even

lower."

"If

they

bow

any

lower

they'll

have

to

buy

thinner

carpets,"

said

Jakt.

She

laughed,

but

it

was

as

much

because

the

tickling

of

his

lips

on

her

cheek

was

becoming

unbearable.

It

was

also

beginning,

just

a

little,

to

tantalize

her

with

desires

that

simply

could

not

be

satisfied

on

this

voyage.

The

starship

was

too

small

and

cramped,

with

all

their

family

aboard,

for

any

real

privacy.

"Jakt,

we're

almost

at

the

midpoint.

We've

abstained

longer

than

this

during

the

mishmish

run

every

year

of

our

lives."

"We

could

put

a

do-not-enter

sign

on

the

door."

"Then

you

might

just

as

well

put

out

a

sign

that

says,

'naked

elderly

couple

reliving

old

memories

inside.'"

"I'm

not

elderly."

"You're

over

sixty."

"If

the

old

soldier

can

still

stand

up

and

salute,

I

say

let

him

march

in

the

parade."

"No

parades

till

the

voyage

is

over.

It's

only

a

couple

of

weeks

more.

We

only

have

to

complete

this

rendezvous

with

Ender's

stepson

and

then

we're

back

on

course

to

Lusitania."

Jakt

drew

away

from

her,

pulled

himself

out

of

her

doorway

and

stood

upright

in

the

corridor--

one

of

the

few

places

on

the

starship

where

he

could

actually

do

that.

He

groaned

as

he

did

it,

though.

"You

creak

like

an

old

rusty

door,"

said

Valentine.

"I've

heard

you

make

the

same

sounds

when

you

get

up

from

your

desk

here.

I'm

not

the

only

senile,

decrepit,

miserable

old

coot

in

our

family."

"Go

away

and

let

me

transmit

this."

"I'm

used

to

having

work

to

do

on

a

voyage,"

said

Jakt.

"The

computers

do

everything

here,

and

this

ship

never

rolls

or

pitches

in

the

sea."

"Read

a

book."

"I

worry

about

you.

All

work

and

no

play

makes

Val

a

mean-tempered

old

hag."

"Every

minute

that

we

talk

here

is

eight

and

a

half

hours

in

real

time."

"Our

time

here

on

this

starship

is

just

as

real

as

their

time

out

there,"

said

Jakt.

"Sometimes

I

wish

Ender's

friends

hadn't

figured

out

a

way

for

our

starship

to

keep

up

a

landside

link."

"It

takes

up

a

huge

amount

of

computer

time,"

said

Val.

"Until

now,

only

the

military

could

communicate

with

starships

during

near-lightspeed

flight.

If

Ender's

friends

can

achieve

it,

then

I

owe

it

to

them

to

use

it."

"You're

not

doing

all

this

because

you

owe

it

to

somebody."

That

was

true

enough.

"If

I

write

an

essay

every

hour,

Jakt,

it

means

that

to

the

rest

of

humanity

Demosthenes

is

publishing

something

only

once

every

three

weeks."

"You

can't

possibly

write

an

essay

every

hour.

You

sleep,

you

eat."

"You

talk,

I

listen.

Go

away,

Jakt."

"If

I'd

known

that

saving

a

planet

from

destruction

would

mean

my

returning

to

a

state

of

virginity,

I'd

never

have

agreed

to

it."

He

was

only

half

teasing.

Leaving

Trondheim

was

a

hard

decision

for

all

her

family--

even

for

her,

even

knowing

that

she

was

going

to

see

Ender

again.

The

children

were

all

adults

now,

or

nearly

so;

they

saw

this

voyage

as

a

great

adventure.

Their

visions

of

the

future

were

not

so

tied

to

a

particular

place.

None

of

them

had

become

a

sailor,

like

their

father;

all

of

them

were

becoming

scholars

or

scientists,

living

the

life

of

public

discourse

and

private

contemplation,

like

their

mother.

They

could

live

their

lives,

substantially

unchanged,

anywhere,

on

any

world.

Jakt

was

proud

of

them,

but

disappointed

that

the

chain

of

family

reaching

back

for

seven

generations

on

the

seas

of

Trondheim

would

end

with

him.

And

now,

for

her

sake,

he

had

given

up

the

sea

himself.

Giving

up

Trondheim

was

the

hardest

thing

she

could

ever

have

asked

of

Jakt,

and

he

had

said

yes

without

hesitation.

Perhaps

he

would

go

back

someday,

and,

if

he

did,

the

oceans,

the

ice,

the

storms,

the

fish,

the

desperately

sweet

green

meadows

of

summer

would

still

be

there.

But

his

crews

would

be

gone,

were

already

gone.

The

men

he

had

known

better

than

his

own

children,

better

than

his

wife--

those

men

were

already

fifteen

years

older,

and

when

he

returned,

if

he

returned,

another

forty

years

would

have

passed.

Their

grandsons

would

be

working

the

boats

then.

They

wouldn't

know

the

name

of

Jakt.

He'd

be

a

foreign

shipowner,

come

from

the

sky,

not

a

sailor,

not

a

man

with

the

stink

and

yellowy

blood

of

skrika

on

his

hands.

He

would

not

be

one

of

them.

So

when

he

complained

that

she

was

ignoring

him,

when

he

teased

about

their

lack

of

intimacy

during

the

voyage,

there

was

more

to

it

than

an

aging

husband's

playful

desire.

Whether

he

knew

he

was

saying

it

or

not,

she

understood

the

true

meaning

of

his

overtures:

After

what

I've

given

up

for

you,

have

you

nothing

to

give

to

me?

And

he

was

right--

she

was

pushing

herself

harder

than

she

needed

to.

She

was

making

more

sacrifices

than

needed

to

be

made--

requiring

overmuch

from

him

as

well.

It

wasn't

the

sheer

number

of

subversive

essays

that

Demosthenes

published

during

this

voyage

that

would

make

the

difference.

What

mattered

was

how

many

people

read

and

believed

what

she

wrote,

and

how

many

then

thought

and

spoke

and

acted

as

enemies

of

Starways

Congress.

Perhaps

more

important

was

the

hope

that

some

within

the

bureaucracy

of

Congress

itself

would

be

moved

to

feel

a

higher

allegiance

to

humanity

and

break

their

maddening

institutional

solidarity.

Some

would

surely

be

changed

by

what

she

wrote.

Not

many,

but

maybe

enough.

And

maybe

it

would

happen

in

time

to

stop

them

from

destroying

the

planet

Lusitania.

If

not,

she

and

Jakt

and

those

who

had

given

up

so

much

to

come

with

them

on

this

voyage

from

Trondheim

would

reach

Lusitania

just

in

time

to

turn

around

and

flee--

or

be

destroyed

along

with

all

the

others

of

that

world.

It

was

not

unreasonable

for

Jakt

to

be

tense,

to

want

to

spend

more

time

with

her.

It

was

unreasonable

for

her

to

be

so

single-minded,

to

use

every

waking

moment

writing

propaganda.

"You

make

the

sign

for

the

door,

and

I'll

make

sure

you

aren't

alone

in

the

room."

"Woman,

you

make

my

heart

go

flip-flop

like

a

dying

flounder,"

said

Jakt.

"You

are

so

romantic

when

you

talk

like

a

fisherman,"

said

Valentine.

"The

children

will

have

a

good

laugh,

knowing

you

couldn't

keep

your

hands

off

me

even

for

the

three

weeks

of

this

voyage."

"They

have

our

genes.

They

should

be

rooting

for

us

to

stay

randy

till

we're

well

into

our

second

century."

"I'm

well

into

my

fourth

millennium."

"When

oh

when

can

I

expect

you

in

my

stateroom,

Ancient

One?"

"When

I've

transmitted

this

essay."

"And

how

long

will

that

be?"

"Sometime

after

you

go

away

and

leave

me

alone."

With

a

deep

sigh

that

was

more

theatre

than

genuine

misery,

he

padded

off

down

the

carpeted

corridor.

After

a

moment

there

came

a

clanging

sound

and

she

heard

him

yelp

in

pain.

In

mock

pain,

of

course;

he

had

accidentally

hit

the

metal

beam

with

his

head

on

the

first

day

of

the

voyage,

but

ever

since

then

his

collisions

had

been

deliberate,

for

comic

effect.

No

one

ever

laughed

out

loud,

of

course--

that

was

a

family

tradition,

not

to

laugh

when

Jakt

pulled

one

of

his

physical

gags--

but

then

Jakt

was

not

the

sort

of

man

who

needed

overt

encouragement

from

others.

He

was

his

own

best

audience;

a

man

couldn't

be

a

sailor

and

a

leader

of

men

all

his

life

without

being

quite

self-contained.

As

far

as

Valentine

knew,

she

and

the

children

were

the

only

people

he

had

ever

allowed

himself

to

need.

Even

then,

he

had

not

needed

them

so

much

that

he

couldn't

go

on

with

his

life

as

a

sailor

and

fisherman,

away

from

home

for

days,

often

weeks,

sometimes

months

at

a

time.

Valentine

went

with

him

sometimes

at

first,

when

they

were

still

so

hungry

for

each

other

that

they

could

never

be

satisfied.

But

within

a

few

years

their

hunger

had

given

way

to

patience

and

trust;

when

he

was

away,

she

did

her

research

and

wrote

her

books,

and

then

gave

her

entire

attention

to

him

and

the

children

when

he

returned.

The

children

used

to

complain,

"I

wish

Father

would

get

home,

so

Mother

would

come

out

of

her

room

and

talk

to

us

again."

I

was

not

a

very

good

mother,

Valentine

thought.

It's

pure

luck

that

the

children

turned

out

so

well.

The

essay

remained

in

the

air

over

the

terminal.

Only

a

final

touch

remained

to

be

given.

At

the

bottom,

she

centered

the

cursor

and

typed

the

name

under

which

all

her

writings

were

published:

DEMOSTHENES

It

was

a

name

given

to

her

by

her

older

brother,

Peter,

when

they

were

children

together

fifty--

no,

three

thousand

years

ago.

The

mere

thought

of

Peter

still

had

the

power

to

upset

her,

to

make

her

go

hot

and

cold

inside.

Peter,

the

cruel

one,

the

violent

one,

the

one

whose

mind

was

so

subtle

and

dangerous

that

he

was

manipulating

her

by

the

age

of

two

and

the

world

by

the

age

of

twenty.

When

they

were

still

children

on

Earth

in

the

twentysecond

century,

he

studied

the

political

writings

of

great

men

and

women,

living

and

dead,

not

to

learn

their

ideas--

those

he

grasped

instantly--

but

to

learn

how

they

said

them.

To

learn,

in

practical

terms,

how

to

sound

like

an

adult.

When

he

had

mastered

it,

he

taught

Valentine,

and

forced

her

to

write

low

political

demagoguery

under

the

name

Demosthenes

while

he

wrote

elevated

statesmanlike

essays

under

the

name

Locke.

Then

they

submitted

them

to

the

computer

networks

and

within

a

few

years

were

at

the

heart

of

the

greatest

political

issues

of

the

day.

What

galled

Valentine

then--

and

still

stung

a

bit

today,

since

it

had

never

been

resolved

before

Peter

died-

-

was

that

he,

consumed

by

the

lust

for

power,

had

forced

her

to

write

the

sort

of

thing

that

expressed

his

character,

while

he

got

to

write

the

peace-loving,

elevated

sentiments

that

were

hers

by

nature.

In

those

days

the

name

"Demosthenes"

had

felt

like

a

terrible

burden

to

her.

Everything

she

wrote

under

that

name

was

a

lie;

and

not

even

her

lie--

Peter's

lie.

A

lie

within

a

lie.

Not

now.

Not

for

three

thousand

years.

I've

made

the

name

my

own.

I've

written

histories

and

biographies

that

have

shaped

the

thinking

of

millions

of

scholars

on

the

Hundred

Worlds

and

helped

to

shape

the

identities

of

dozens

of

nations.

So

much

for

you,

Peter.

So

much

for

what

you

tried

to

make

of

me.

Except

that

now,

looking

at

the

essay

she

had

just

written,

she

realized

that

even

though

she

had

freed

herself

from

Peter's

suzerainty,

she

was

still

his

pupil.

All

she

knew

of

rhetoric,

polemic--

yes,

of

demagoguery--

she

had

learned

from

him

or

because

of

his

insistence.

And

now,

though

she

was

using

it

in

a

noble

cause,

she

was

nevertheless

doing

exactly

the

sort

of

political

manipulation

that

Peter

had

loved

so

much.

Peter

had

gone

on

to

become

Hegemon,

ruler

of

all

humanity

for

sixty

years

at

the

beginning

of

the

Great

Expansion.

He

was

the

one

who

united

all

the

quarreling

communities

of

man

for

the

vast

effort

that

flung

starships

out

to

every

world

where

the

buggers

had

once

dwelt,

and

then

on

to

discover

more

habitable

worlds

until,

by

the

time

he

died,

all

the

Hundred

Worlds

had

either

been

settled

or

had

colony

ships

on

the

way.

It

was

almost

a

thousand

years

after

that,

of

course,

before

Starways

Congress

once

again

united

all

of

humankind

under

one

government--

but

the

memory

of

the

first

true

Hegemon--

*the*

Hegemon--

was

at

the

heart

of

the

story

that

made

human

unity

possible.

Out

of

a

moral

wasteland

like

Peter's

soul

came

harmony

and

unity

and

peace.

While

Ender's

legacy,

as

far

as

humanity

remembered,

was

murder,

slaughter,

xenocide.

Ender,

Valentine's

younger

brother,

the

man

she

and

her

family

were

voyaging

to

see--

he

was

the

tender

one,

the

brother

she

loved

and,

in

the

earliest

years,

tried

to

protect.

He

was

the

good

one.

Oh,

yes,

he

had

a

streak

of

ruthlessness

that

rivaled

Peter's,

but

he

had

the

decency

to

be

appalled

by

his

own

brutality.

She

had

loved

him

as

fervently

as

she

had

loathed

Peter;

and

when

Peter

exiled

his

younger

brother

from

the

Earth

that

Peter

was

determined

to

rule,

Valentine

went

with

Ender--

her

final

repudiation

of

Peter's

personal

hegemony

over

her.

And

here

I

am

again,

thought

Valentine,

back

in

the

business

of

politics.

She

spoke

sharply,

in

the

clipped

voice

that

told

her

terminal

that

she

was

giving

it

a

command.

"Transmit,"

she

said.

The

word

transmitting

appeared

in

the

air

above

her

essay.

Ordinarily,

back

when

she

was

writing

scholarly

works,

she

would

have

had

to

specify

a

destination--

submit

the

essay

to

a

publisher

through

some

roundabout

pathway

so

that

it

could

not

readily

be

traced

to

Valentine

Wiggin.

Now,

though,

a

subversive

friend

of

Ender's,

working

under

the

obvious

code

name

of

"Jane,"

was

taking

care

of

all

that

for

her--

managing

the

tricky

business

of

translating

an

ansible

message

from

a

ship

going

at

near-light

speed

to

a

message

readable

by

a

planetbound

ansible

for

which

time

was

passing

more

than

five

hundred

times

faster.

Since

communicating

with

a

starship

ate

up

huge

amounts

of

planetside

ansible

time,

it

was

usually

done

only

to

convey

navigational

information

and

instructions.

The

only

people

permitted

to

send

extended

text

messages

were

high

officials

in

the

government

or

the

military.

Valentine

could

not

begin

to

understand

how

"Jane"

managed

to

get

so

much

ansible

time

for

these

text

transmissions--

and

at

the

same

time

keep

anyone

from

discovering

where

these

subversive

documents

were

coming

from.

Furthermore,

"Jane"

used

even

more

ansible

time

transmitting

back

to

her

the

published

responses

to

her

writings,

reporting

to

her

on

all

the

arguments

and

strategies

the

government

was

using

to

counter

Valentine's

propaganda.

Whoever

"Jane"

was--

and

Valentine

suspected

that

"Jane"

was

simply

the

name

for

a

clandestine

organization

that

had

penetrated

the

highest

reaches

of

government--

she

was

extraordinarily

good.

And

extraordinarily

foolhardy.

Still,

if

Jane

was

willing

to

expose

herself--

themselves--

to

such

risks,

Valentine

owed

it

to

her--

them--

to

produce

as

many

tracts

as

she

could,

and

as

powerful

and

dangerous

as

she

could

make

them.

If

words

can

be

lethal

weapons,

I

must

provide

them

with

an

arsenal.

But

she

was

still

a

woman;

even

revolutionaries

are

allowed

to

have

a

life,

aren't

they?

Moments

of

joy--

or

pleasure,

or

perhaps

only

relief--

stolen

here

and

there.

She

got

up

from

her

seat,

ignoring

the

pain

that

came

from

moving

after

sitting

so

long,

and

twisted

her

way

out

of

the

door

of

her

tiny

office--

a

storage

bin,

really,

before

they

converted

the

starship

to

their

own

use.

She

was

a

little

ashamed

of

how

eager

she

was

to

get

to

the

room

where

Jakt

would

be

waiting.

Most

of

the

great

revolutionary

propagandists

in

history

would

have

been

able

to

endure

at

least

three

weeks

of

physical

abstinence.

Or

would

they?

She

wondered

if

anyone

had

done

a

study

of

that

particular

question.

She

was

still

imagining

how

a

researcher

would

go

about

writing

a

grant

proposal

for

such

a

project

when

she

got

to

the

four-bunk

compartment

they

shared

with

Syfte

and

her

husband,

Lars,

who

had

proposed

to

her

only

a

few

days

before

they

left,

as

soon

as

he

realized

that

Syfte

really

meant

to

leave

Trondheim.

It

was

hard

to

share

a

cabin

with

newlyweds--

Valentine

always

felt

like

such

an

intruder,

using

the

same

room.

But

there

was

no

choice.

Though

this

starship

was

a

luxury

yacht,

with

all

the

amenities

they

could

hope

for,

it

simply

hadn't

been

meant

to

hold

so

many

bodies.

It

had

been

the

only

starship

near

Trondheim

that

was

remotely

suitable,

so

it

had

to

do.

Their

twenty-year-old

daughter,

Ro,

and

Varsam,

their

sixteen-year-old

son,

shared

another

compartment

with

Plikt,

who

had

been

their

lifelong

tutor

and

dearest

family

friend.

The

members

of

the

yacht's

staff

and

crew

who

had

chosen

to

make

this

voyage

with

them--

it

would

have

been

wrong

to

dismiss

them

all

and

strand

them

on

Trondheim--

used

the

other

two.

The

bridge,

the

dining

room,

the

galley,

the

salon,

the

sleeping

compartments--

all

were

filled

with

people

doing

their

best

not

to

let

their

annoyance

at

the

close

quarters

get

out

of

hand.

None

of

them

were

in

the

corridor

now,

however,

and

Jakt

had

already

taped

a

sign

to

their

door:

STAY

OUT

OR

DIE.

It

was

signed,

"The

proprietor."

Valentine

opened

the

door.

Jakt

was

leaning

against

the

wall

so

close

to

the

door

that

she

was

startled

and

gave

a

little

gasp.

"Nice

to

know

that

the

sight

of

me

can

make

you

cry

out

in

pleasure."

"In

shock."

"Come

in,

my

sweet

seditionist."

"Technically,

you

know,

I'm

the

proprietor

of

this

starship."

"What's

yours

is

mine.

I

married

you

for

your

property."

She

was

inside

the

compartment

now.

He

closed

the

door

and

sealed

it.

"That's

all

I

am

to

you?"

she

asked.

"Real

estate?"

"A

little

plot

of

ground

where

I

can

plow

and

plant

and

harvest,

all

in

their

proper

season."

He

reached

out

to

her;

she

stepped

into

his

arms.

His

hands

slid

lightly

up

her

back,

cradled

her

shoulders.

She

felt

contained

in

his

embrace,

never

confined.

"It's

late

in

the

autumn,"

she

said.

"Getting

on

toward

winter."

"Time

to

harrow,

perhaps,"

said

Jakt.

"Or

perhaps

it's

already

time

to

kindle

up

the

fire

and

keep

the

old

hut

warm

before

the

snow

comes."

He

kissed

her

and

it

felt

like

the

first

time.

"If

you

asked

me

to

marry

you

all

over

again

today,

I'd

say

yes,"

said

Valentine.

"And

if

I

had

only

met

you

for

the

first

time

today,

I'd

ask."

They

had

said

the

same

words

many,

many

times

before.

Yet

they

still

smiled

to

hear

them,

because

they

were

still

true.

***

The

two

starships

had

almost

completed

their

vast

ballet,

dancing

through

space

in

great

leaps

and

delicate

turns

until

at

last

they

could

meet

and

touch.

Miro

Ribeira

had

watched

the

whole

process

from

the

bridge

of

his

starship,

his

shoulders

hunched,

his

head

leaned

back

on

the

headrest

of

the

seat.

To

others

this

posture

always

looked

awkward.

Back

on

Lusitania,

whenever

Mother

caught

him

sitting

that

way

she

would

come

and

fuss

over

him,

insist

on

bringing

him

a

pillow

so

he

could

be

comfortable.

She

never

seemed

to

grasp

the

idea

that

it

was

only

in

that

hunched,

awkward-seeming

posture

that

his

head

would

remain

upright

without

any

conscious

effort

on

his

part.

He

would

endure

her

ministrations

because

it

wasn't

worth

the

effort

to

argue

with

her.

Mother

was

always

moving

and

thinking

so

quickly,

it

was

almost

impossible

for

her

to

slow

down

enough

to

listen

to

him.

Since

the

brain

damage

he

had

suffered

passing

through

the

disruptor

field

that

separated

the

human

colony

and

the

piggies'

forest,

his

speech

had

been

unbearably

slow,

painful

to

produce

and

difficult

to

understand.

Miro's

brother

Quim,

the

religious

one,

had

told

him

that

he

should

be

grateful

to

God

that

he

was

able

to

speak

at

all--

the

first

few

days

he

had

been

incapable

of

communicating

except

through

alphabetic

scanning,

spelling

out

messages

letter

by

letter.

In

some

ways,

though,

spelling

things

out

had

been

better.

At

least

then

Miro

had

been

silent;

he

hadn't

had

to

listen

to

his

own

voice.

The

thick,

awkward

sound,

the

agonizing

slowness

of

it.

Who

in

his

family

had

the

patience

to

listen

to

him?

Even

the

ones

who

tried--

his

next-younger

sister,

Ela;

his

friend

and

stepfather,

Andrew

Wiggin,

the

Speaker

for

the

Dead;

and

Quim,

of

course--

he

could

feel

their

impatience.

They

tended

to

finish

his

sentences

for

him.

They

needed

to

hurry

things.

So

even

though

they

said

they

wanted

to

talk

with

him,

even

though

they

actually

sat

and

listened

as

he

spoke,

he

still

couldn't

speak

freely

to

them.

He

couldn't

talk

about

ideas;

he

couldn't

speak

in

long,

involved

sentences,

because

by

the

time

he

got

to

the

end

his

listeners

would

have

lost

track

of

the

beginning.

The

human

brain,

Miro

had

concluded,

just

like

a

computer,

can

only

receive

data

at

certain

speeds.

If

you

get

too

slow,

the

listener's

attention

wanders

and

the

information

is

lost.

Not

just

the

listeners,

either.

Miro

had

to

be

fair--

he

was

as

impatient

with

himself

as

they

were.

When

he

thought

of

the

sheer

effort

involved

in

explaining

a

complicated

idea,

when

he

anticipated

trying

to

form

the

words

with

lips

and

tongue

and

jaws

that

wouldn't

obey

him,

when

he

thought

of

how

long

it

would

all

take,

he

usually

felt

too

weary

to

speak.

His

mind

raced

on

and

on,

as

fast

as

ever,

thinking

so

many

thoughts

that

at

times

Miro

wanted

his

brain

to

shut

down,

to

be

silent

and

give

him

peace.

But

his

thoughts

remained

his

own,

unshared.

Except

with

Jane.

He

could

speak

to

Jane.

She

had

come

to

him

first

on

his

terminal

at

home,

her

face

taking

form

on

the

screen.

"I'm

a

friend

of

the

Speaker

for

the

Dead,"

she

had

told

him.

"I

think

we

can

get

this

computer

to

be

a

little

more

responsive."

From

then

on,

Miro

had

found

that

Jane

was

the

only

person

he

could

talk

to

easily.

For

one

thing,

she

was

infinitely

patient.

She

never

finished

his

sentences.

She

could

wait

for

him

to

finish

them

himself,

so

that

he

never

felt

rushed,

never

felt

that

he

was

boring

her.

Perhaps

even

more

important,

he

didn't

have

to

form

his

words

as

fully

for

her

as

he

did

for

human

listeners.

Andrew

had

given

him

a

personal

terminal--

a

computer

transceiver

encased

in

a

jewel

like

the

one

Andrew

wore

in

his

own

ear.

From

that

vantage

point,

using

the

jewel's

sensors,

Jane

could

detect

every

sound

he

made,

every

motion

of

the

muscles

in

his

head.

He

didn't

have

to

complete

each

sound,

he

had

only

to

begin

it

and

she

would

understand.

So

he

could

be

lazy.

He

could

speak

more

quickly

and

be

understood.

And

he

could

also

speak

silently.

He

could

subvocalize--

he

didn't

have

to

use

that

awkward,

barking,

yowling

voice

that

was

all

his

throat

could

produce

now.

So

that

when

he

was

talking

to

Jane,

he

could

speak

quickly,

naturally,

without

any

reminder

that

he

was

crippled.

With

Jane

he

could

feel

like

himself.

Now

he

sat

on

the

bridge

of

the

cargo

ship

that

had

brought

the

Speaker

for

the

Dead

to

Lusitania

only

a

few

months

ago.

He

dreaded

the

rendezvous

with

Valentine's

ship.

If

he

could

have

thought

of

somewhere

else

to

go,

he

might

have

gone

there--

he

had

no

desire

to

meet

Andrew's

sister

Valentine

or

anybody

else.

If

he

could

have

stayed

alone

in

the

starship

forever,

speaking

only

to

Jane,

he

would

have

been

content.

No

he

wouldn't.

He

would

never

be

content

again.

At

least

this

Valentine

and

her

family

would

be

somebody

new.

On

Lusitania

he

knew

everybody,

or

at

least

everybody

that

he

valued--

all

the

scientific

community

there,

the

people

of

education

and

understanding.

He

knew

them

all

so

well

that

he

could

not

help

but

see

their

pity,

their

grief,

their

frustration

at

what

had

become

of

him.

When

they

looked

at

him

all

they

could

see

was

the

difference

between

what

he

was

before

and

what

he

was

now.

All

they

could

see

was

loss.

There

was

a

chance

that

new

people--

Valentine

and

her

family--

would

be

able

to

look

at

him

and

see

something

else.

Even

that

was

unlikely,

though.

Strangers

would

look

at

him

and

see

less,

not

more,

than

those

who

had

known

him

before

he

was

crippled.

At

least

Mother

and

Andrew

and

Ela

and

Ouanda

and

all

the

others

knew

that

he

had

a

mind,

knew

that

he

was

capable

of

understanding

ideas.

What

will

new

people

think

when

they

see

me?

They'll

see

a

body

that's

already

atrophying,

hunched

over;

they'll

see

me

walk

with

a

shuffling

gait;

they'll

watch

me

use

my

hands

like

paws,

clutching

a

spoon

like

a

three-year-old;

they'll

hear

my

thick,

half-intelligible

speech;

and

they'll

assume,

they'll

know,

that

such

a

person

cannot

possibly

understand

anything

complicated

or

difficult.

Why

did

I

come?

I

didn't

come.

I

went.

I

wasn't

coming

here,

to

meet

these

people.

I

was

leaving

there.

Getting

away.

Only

I

tricked

myself.

I

thought

of

leaving

on

a

thirty-year

voyage,

which

is

only

how

it

will

seem

to

them.

To

me

I've

been

gone

only

a

week

and

a

half.

No

time

at

all.

And

already

my

time

of

solitude

is

over.

My

time

of

being

alone

with

Jane,

who

listens

to

me

as

if

I

were

still

a

human

being,

is

done.

Almost.

Almost

he

said

the

words

that

would

have

aborted

the

rendezvous.

He

could

have

stolen

Andrew's

starship

and

taken

off

on

a

voyage

that

would

last

forever

without

having

to

face

another

living

soul.

But

such

a

nihilistic

act

was

not

in

him,

not

yet.

He

had

not

yet

despaired,

he

decided.

There

might

yet

be

something

he

could

do

that

might

justify

his

continuing

to

live

in

this

body.

And

perhaps

it

would

begin

with

meeting

Andrew's

sister.

The

ships

were

now

joining,

the

umbilicals

snaking

outward

and

searching,

groping

till

they

met

each

other.

Miro

watched

on

the

monitors

and

listened

to

the

computer

reports

of

each

successful

linkage.

The

ships

were

joining

in

every

possible

way

so

that

they

could

make

the

rest

of

the

voyage

to

Lusitania

in

perfect

tandem.

All

resources

would

be

shared.

Since

Miro's

ship

was

a

cargo

vessel,

it

couldn't

take

on

more

than

a

handful

of

people,

but

it

could

take

some

of

the

other

ship's

life-support

supplies;

together,

the

two

ship's

computers

were

figuring

out

a

perfect

balance.

Once

they

had

calculated

the

load,

they

worked

out

exactly

how

fast

each

ship

should

accelerate

as

they

made

the

park

shift

to

get

them

both

back

to

near-lightspeed

at

exactly

the

same

pace.

It

was

an

extremely

delicate

and

complicated

negotiation

between

two

computers

that

had

to

know

almost

perfectly

what

their

ships

carried

and

how

they

could

perform.

It

was

finished

before

the

passage

tube

between

the

ships

was

fully

connected.

Miro

heard

the

footsteps

scuffing

along

the

corridor

from

the

tube.

He

turned

his

chair--

slowly,

because

he

did

everything

slowly--

and

saw

her

coming

toward

him.

Stooped

over,

but

not

very

much,

because

she

wasn't

that

tall

to

begin

with.

Hair

mostly

white,

with

a

few

strands

of

mousy

brown.

When

she

stood

he

looked

at

her

face

and

judged

her.

Old

but

not

elderly.

If

she

was

nervous

about

this

meeting

it

didn't

show.

But

then,

from

what

Andrew

and

Jane

had

told

him

about

her,

she

had

met

a

lot

of

people

who

were

a

good

deal

more

fearsome

than

a

twenty-year-old

cripple.

"Miro?"

she

asked.

"Who

else?"

he

said.

It

took

a

moment,

just

a

heartbeat,

for

her

to

process

the

strange

sounds

that

came

out

of

his

mouth

and

recognize

the

words.

He

was

used

to

that

pause

now,

but

he

still

hated

it.

"I'm

Valentine,"

she

said.

"I

know,"

he

answered.

He

wasn't

making

this

any

easier,

with

his

laconic

replies,

but

what

else

was

there

to

say?

This

wasn't

exactly

a

meeting

between

heads

of

state

with

a

list

of

vital

decisions

to

make.

But

he

had

to

make

some

effort,

if

only

not

to

seem

hostile.

"Your

name,

Miro--

it

means

'I

look,'

doesn't

it?"

"'I

look

closely.'

Maybe

'I

pay

attention.'"

"It's

really

not

that

hard

to

understand

you,"

said

Valentine.

He

was

startled

that

she

addressed

the

matter

so

openly.

"I

think

I'm

having

more

problems

with

your

Portuguese

accent

than

with

the

brain

damage."

For

a

moment

it

felt

like

a

hammer

in

his

heart--

she

was

speaking

more

frankly

about

his

situation

than

anyone

except

Andrew.

But

then

she

was

Andrew's

sister,

wasn't

she?

He

should

have

expected

her

to

be

plainspoken.

"Or

do

you

prefer

that

we

pretend

that

it

isn't

a

barrier

between

you

and

other

people?"

Apparently

she

had

sensed

his

shock.

But

that

was

over,

and

now

it

occurred

to

him

that

he

probably

shouldn't

be

annoyed,

that

he

should

probably

be

glad

that

they

wouldn't

have

to

sidestep

the

issue.

Yet

he

was

annoyed,

and

it

took

him

a

moment

to

think

why.

Then

he

knew.

"My

brain

damage

isn't

your

problem,"

he

said.

"If

it

makes

it

hard

for

me

to

understand

you,

then

it's

a

problem

I

have

to

deal

with.

Don't

get

prickly

with

me

already,

young

man.

I

have

only

begun

to

bother

you,

and

you

have

only

begun

to

bother

me.

So

don't

get

steamed

up

because

I

happened

to

mention

your

brain

damage

as

being

somehow

my

problem.

I

have

no

intention

of

watching

every

word

I

say

for

fear

I'll

offend

an

oversensitive

young

man

who

thinks

the

whole

world

revolves

around

his

disappointments."

Miro

was

furious

that

she

had

judged

him

already,

and

so

harshly.

It

was

unfair--

not

at

all

what

the

author

of

Demosthenes'

hierarchy

ought

to

be

like.

"I

don't

think

the

whole

world

revolves

around

my

disappointments!

But

don't

you

think

you

can

come

in

here

and

run

things

on

my

ship!"

That's

what

annoyed

him,

not

her

words.

She

was

right--

her

words

were

nothing.

It

was

her

attitude,

her

complete

selfconfidence.

He

wasn't

used

to

people

looking

at

him

without

shock

or

pity.

She

sat

down

in

the

seat

next

to

him.

He

swiveled

to

face

her.

She,

for

her

part,

did

not

look

away.

Indeed,

she

pointedly

scanned

his

body,

head

to

toe,

looking

him

over

with

an

air

of

cool

appraisal.

"He

said

you

were

tough.

He

said

you

had

been

twisted

but

not

broken."

"Are

you

supposed

to

be

my

therapist?"

"Are

you

supposed

to

be

my

enemy?"

"Should

I

be?"

asked

Miro.

"No

more

than

I

should

be

your

therapist.

Andrew

didn't

have

us

meet

so

I

could

heal

you.

He

had

us

meet

so

you

could

help

me.

If

you're

not

going

to,

fine.

If

you

are,

fine.

Just

let

me

make

a

few

things

clear.

I'm

spending

every

waking

moment

writing

subversive

propaganda

to

try

to

arouse

public

sentiment

on

the

Hundred

Worlds

and

in

the

colonies.

I'm

trying

to

turn

the

people

against

the

fleet

that

Starways

Congress

has

sent

to

subdue

Lusitania.

Your

world,

not

mine,

I

might

add."

"Your

brother's

there."

He

was

not

about

to

let

her

claim

complete

altruism.

"Yes,

we

both

have

family

there.

And

we

both

are

concerned

about

keeping

the

pequeninos

from

destruction.

And

we

both

know

that

Ender

has

restored

the

hive

queen

on

your

world,

so

that

there

are

two

alien

species

that

will

be

destroyed

if

Starways

Congress

gets

its

way.

There's

a

great

deal

at

stake,

and

I

am

already

doing

all

that

I

can

possibly

do

to

try

to

stop

that

fleet.

Now,

if

spending

a

few

hours

with

you

can

help

me

do

it

better,

it's

worth

taking

time

away

from

my

writing

in

order

to

talk

with

you.

But

I

have

no

intention

of

wasting

my

time

worrying

about

whether

I'm

going

to

offend

you

or

not.

So

if

you're

going

to

be

my

adversary,

you

can

sit

up

here

all

by

yourself

and

I'll

get

back

to

my

work."

"Andrew

said

you

were

the

best

person

he

ever

knew."

"He

reached

that

conclusion

before

he

saw

me

raise

three

barbarian

children

to

adulthood.

I

understand

your

mother

has

six."

"Right."

"And

you're

the

oldest."

"Yes."

"That's

too

bad.

Parents

always

make

their

worst

mistakes

with

the

oldest

children.

That's

when

parents

know

the

least

and

care

the

most,

so

they're

more

likely

to

be

wrong

and

also

more

likely

to

insist

that

they're

right."

Miro

didn't

like

hearing

this

woman

leap

to

conclusions

about

his

mother.

"She's

nothing

like

you."

"Of

course

not."

She

leaned

forward

in

her

seat.

"Well,

have

you

decided?"

"Decided

what?"

"Are

we

working

together

or

did

you

just

unplug

yourself

from

thirty

years

of

human

history

for

nothing?"

"What

do

you

want

from

me?"

"Stories,

of

course.

Facts

I

can

get

from

the

computer."

"Stories

about

what?"

"You.

The

piggies.

You

and

the

piggies.

This

whole

business

with

the

Lusitania

Fleet

began

with

you

and

the

piggies,

after

all.

It

was

because

you

interfered

with

them

that--"

"We

helped

them!"

"Oh,

did

I

use

the

wrong

word

again?"

Miro

glared

at

her.

But

even

as

he

did,

he

knew

that

she

was

right--

he

was

being

oversensitive.

The

word

interfered,

when

used

in

a

scientific

context,

was

almost

value-neutral.

It

merely

meant

that

he

had

introduced

change

into

the

culture

he

was

studying.

And

if

it

did

have

a

negative

connotation,

it

was

that

he

had

lost

his

scientific

perspective--

he

had

stopped

studying

the

pequeninos

and

started

treating

them

as

friends.

Of

that

he

was

surely

guilty.

No,

not

guilty--

he

was

proud

of

having

made

that

transition.

"Go

on,"

he

said.

"All

this

began

because

you

broke

the

law

and

piggies

started

growing

amaranth."

"Not

anymore."

"Yes,

that's

ironic,

isn't

it?

The

descolada

virus

has

gotten

in

and

killed

every

strain

of

amaranth

that

your

sister

developed

for

them.

So

your

interference

was

in

vain."

"No

it

wasn't,"

said

Miro.

"They're

learning."

"Yes,

I

know.

More

to

the

point,

they're

choosing.

What

to

learn,

what

to

do.

You

brought

them

freedom.

I

approve

wholeheartedly

of

what

you

decided

to

do.

But

my

job

is

to

write

about

you

to

the

people

out

there

in

the

Hundred

Worlds

and

the

colonies,

and

they

won't

necessarily

see

things

that

way.

So

what

I

need

from

you

is

the

story

of

how

and

why

you

broke

the

law

and

interfered

with

the

piggies,

and

why

the

government

and

people

of

Lusitania

rebelled

against

Congress

rather

than

send

you

off

to

be

tried

and

punished

for

your

crimes."

"Andrew

already

told

you

that

story."

"And

I've

already

written

about

it,

in

larger

terms.

Now

I

need

the

personal

things.

I

want

to

be

able

to

let

other

people

know

these

so-called

piggies

as

people.

And

you,

too.

I

have

to

let

them

know

you

as

a

person.

If

it's

possible,

it

would

be

nice

if

I

could

bring

them

to

like

you.

Then

the

Lusitania

Fleet

will

look

like

what

it

is--

a

monstrous

overreaction

to

a

threat

that

never

existed."

"The

fleet

is

xenocide."

"So

I've

said

in

my

propaganda,"

said

Valentine.

He

couldn't

bear

her

self-certainty.

He

couldn't

bear

her

unshakable

faith

in

herself.

So

he

had

to

contradict

her,

and

the

only

way

he

could

was

to

blurt

out

ideas

that

he

had

not

yet

thought

out

completely.

Ideas

that

were

still

only

half-formed

doubts

in

his

mind.

"The

fleet

is

also

self-defense."

It

had

the

desired

effect--

it

stopped

her

lecture

and

even

made

her

raise

her

eyebrows,

questioning

him.

The

trouble

was,

now

he

had

to

explain

what

he

meant.

"The

descolada,"

he

said.

"It's

the

most

dangerous

form

of

life

anywhere."

"The

answer

to

that

is

quarantine.

Not

sending

a

fleet

armed

with

the

M.D.

Device,

so

they

have

the

capacity

to

turn

Lusitania

and

everybody

on

it

into

microscopic

interstellar

dust."

"You're

so

sure

you're

right?"

"I'm

sure

that

it's

wrong

for

Starways

Congress

even

to

contemplate

obliterating

another

sentient

species."

"The

piggies

can't

live

without

the

descolada,"

said

Miro,

"and

if

the

descolada

ever

spreads

to

another

planet,

it

will

destroy

all

life

there.

It

will."

It

was

a

pleasure

to

see

that

Valentine

was

capable

of

looking

puzzled.

"But

I

thought

the

virus

was

contained.

It

was

your

grandparents

who

found

a

way

to

stop

it,

to

make

it

dormant

in

human

beings."

"The

descolada

adapts,"

said

Miro.

"Jane

told

me

that

it's

already

changed

itself

a

couple

of

times.

My

mother

and

my

sister

Ela

are

working

on

it--

trying

to

stay

ahead

of

the

descolada.

Sometimes

it

even

looks

like

the

descolada

is

doing

it

deliberately.

Intelligently.

Finding

strategies

to

get

around

the

chemicals

we

use

to

contain

it

and

stop

it

from

killing

people.

It's

getting

into

the

Earthborn

crops

that

humans

need

in

order

to

survive

on

Lusitania.

They

have

to

spray

them

now.

What

if

the

descolada

finds

a

way

to

get

around

all

our

barriers?"

Valentine

was

silent.

No

glib

answer

now.

She

hadn't

faced

this

question

squarely--

no

one

had,

except

Miro.

"I

haven't

even

told

this

to

Jane,"

said

Miro.

"But

what

if

the

fleet

is

right?

What

if

the

only

way

to

save

humanity

from

the

descolada

is

to

destroy

Lusitania

now?"

"No,"

said

Valentine.

"This

has

nothing

to

do

with

the

purposes

for

which

Starways

Congress

sent

out

the

fleet.

Their

reasons

all

have

to

do

with

interplanetary

politics,

with

showing

the

colonies

who's

boss.

It

has

to

do

with

a

bureaucracy

out

of

control

and

a

military

that--"

"Listen

to

me!"

said

Miro.

"You

said

you

wanted

to

hear

my

stories,

listen

to

this

one:

It

doesn't

matter

what

their

reasons

are.

It

doesn't

matter

if

they're

a

bunch

of

murderous

beasts.

I

don't

care.

What

matters

is--

should

they

blow

up

Lusitania?"

"What

kind

of

person

are

you?"

asked

Valentine.

He

could

hear

both

awe

and

loathing

in

her

voice.

"You're

the

moral

philosopher,"

said

Miro.

"You

tell

me.

Are

we

supposed

to

love

the

pequeninos

so

much

that

we

allow

the

virus

they

carry

to

destroy

all

of

humanity?"

"Of

course

not.

We

simply

have

to

find

a

way

to

neutralize

the

descolada."

"And

if

we

can't?"

"Then

we

quarantine

Lusitania.

Even

if

all

the

human

beings

on

the

planet

die--

your

family

and

mine--

we

still

don't

destroy

the

pequeninos."

"Really?"

asked

Miro.

"What

about

the

hive

queen?"

"Ender

told

me

that

she

was

reestablishing

herself,

but--"

"She

contains

within

herself

a

complete

industrialized

society.

She's

going

to

build

starships

and

get

off

the

planet."

"She

wouldn't

take

the

descolada

with

her!"

"She

has

no

choice.

The

descolada

is

in

her

already.

It's

in

me."

That

was

when

he

really

got

to

her.

He

could

see

it

in

her

eyes--

the

fear.

"It'll

be

in

you,

too.

Even

if

you

run

back

to

your

ship

and

seal

me

off

and

keep

yourself

from

infection,

once

you

land

on

Lusitania

the

descolada

will

get

into

you

and

your

husband

and

your

children.

They'll

have

to

ingest

the

chemicals

with

their

food

and

water,

every

day

of

their

lives.

And

they

can

never

go

away

from

Lusitania

again

or

they'll

carry

death

and

destruction

with

them."

"I

suppose

we

knew

that

was

a

possibility,"

said

Valentine.

"When

you

left,

it

was

only

a

possibility.

We

thought

that

the

descolada

would

soon

be

controlled.

Now

they

aren't

sure

if

it

can

ever

be

controlled.

And

that

means

that

you

can

never

leave

Lusitania

once

you

go

there."

"I

hope

we

like

the

weather."

Miro

studied

her

face,

the

way

she

was

processing

the

information

he

had

given

her.

The

initial

fear

was

gone.

She

was

herself

again--

thinking.

"Here's

what

I

think,"

said

Miro.

"I

think

that

no

matter

how

terrible

Congress

is,

no

matter

how

evil

their

plans

might

be,

that

fleet

might

be

the

salvation

of

humanity."

Valentine

answered

thoughtfully,

searching

for

words.

Miro

was

glad

to

see

that--

she

was

a

person

who

didn't

shoot

back

without

thinking.

She

was

able

to

learn.

"I

can

see

that

if

events

move

down

one

possible

path,

there

might

be

a

time

when--

but

it's

very

improbable.

First

of

all,

knowing

all

this,

the

hive

queen

is

quite

unlikely

to

build

any

starships

that

would

carry

the

descolada

away

from

Lusitania."

"Do

you

know

the

hive

queen?"

demanded

Miro.

"Do

you

understand

her?"

"Even

if

she

would

do

such

a

thing,"

said

Valentine,

"your

mother

and

sister

are

working

on

this,

aren't

they?

By

the

time

we

reach

Lusitania--

by

the

time

the

fleet

reaches

Lusitania--

they

might

have

found

a

way

to

control

the

descolada

once

and

for

all."

"And

if

they

do,"

said

Miro,

"should

they

use

it?"

"Why

shouldn't

they?"

"How

could

they

kill

all

the

descolada

virus?

The

virus

is

an

integral

part

of

the

pequenino

life

cycle.

When

the

pequenino

body-form

dies,

it's

the

descolada

virus

that

enables

the

transformation

into

the

tree-state,

what

the

piggies

call

the

third

life--

and

it's

only

in

the

third

life,

as

trees,

that

the

pequenino

males

can

fertilize

the

females.

If

the

virus

is

gone,

there

can

be

no

more

passage

into

the

third

life,

and

this

generation

of

piggies

is

the

last."

"That

doesn't

make

it

impossible,

it

only

makes

it

harder.

Your

mother

and

sister

have

to

find

a

way

to

neutralize

the

descolada

in

human

beings

and

the

crops

we

need

to

eat,

without

destroying

its

ability

to

enable

the

pequeninos

to

pass

into

adulthood."

"And

they

have

less

than

fifteen

years

to

do

it,"

said

Miro.

"Not

likely."

"But

not

impossible."

"Yes.

There's

a

chance.

And

on

the

strength

of

that

chance,

you

want

to

get

rid

of

the

fleet?"

"The

fleet

is

being

sent

to

destroy

Lusitania

whether

we

control

the

descolada

virus

or

not."

"And

I

say

it

again--

the

motive

of

the

senders

is

irrelevant.

No

matter

what

the

reason,

the

destruction

of

Lusitania

may

be

the

only

sure

protection

for

all

the

rest

of

humanity."

"And

I

say

you're

wrong."

"You're

Demosthenes,

aren't

you?

Andrew

said

you

were."

"Yes."

"So

you

thought

up

the

Hierarchy

of

Foreignness.

Utlannings

are

strangers

from

our

own

world.

Framlings

are

strangers

of

our

own

species,

but

from

another

world.

Ramen

are

strangers

of

another

species,

but

capable

of

communication

with

us,

capable

of

co-existence

with

humanity.

Last

are

varelse--

and

what

are

they?"

"The

pequeninos

are

not

varelse.

Neither

is

the

hive

queen."

"But

the

descolada

is.

Varelse.

An

alien

life

form

that's

capable

of

destroying

all

of

humanity

..."

"Unless

we

can

tame

it..."

"...

Yet

which

we

cannot

possibly

communicate

with,

an

alien

species

that

we

cannot

live

with.

You're

the

one

who

said

that

in

that

case

war

is

unavoidable.

If

an

alien

species

seems

bent

on

destroying

us

and

we

can't

communicate

with

them,

can't

understand

them,

if

there's

no

possibility

of

turning

them

away

from

their

course

peacefully,

then

we

are

justified

in

any

action

necessary

to

save

ourselves,

including

the

complete

destruction

of

the

other

species."

"Yes,"

said

Valentine.

"But

what

if

we

must

destroy

the

descolada,

and

yet

we

can't

destroy

the

descolada

without

also

destroying

every

living

pequenino,

the

hive

queen,

and

every

human

being

on

Lusitania?"

To

Miro's

surprise,

Valentine's

eyes

were

awash

with

tears.

"So

this

is

what

you

have

become."

Miro

was

confused.

"When

did

this

conversation

become

a

discussion

of

me?"

"You've

done

all

this

thinking,

you've

seen

all

the

possibilities

for

the

future--

good

ones

and

bad

ones

alike--

and

yet

the

only

one

that

you're

willing

to

believe

in,

the

imagined

future

that

you

seize

upon

as

the

foundation

for

all

your

moral

judgments,

is

the

only

future

in

which

everyone

that

you

and

I

have

ever

loved

and

everything

we've

ever

hoped

for

must

be

obliterated."

"I

didn't

say

I

liked

that

future--"

"I

didn't

say

you

liked

it

either,"

said

Valentine.

"I

said

that's

the

future

you

choose

to

prepare

for.

But

I

don't.

I

choose

to

live

in

a

universe

that

has

some

hope

in

it.

I

choose

to

live

in

a

universe

where

your

mother

and

sister

will

find

a

way

to

contain

the

descolada,

a

universe

in

which

Starways

Congress

can

be

reformed

or

replaced,

a

universe

in

which

there

is

neither

the

power

nor

the

will

to

destroy

an

entire

species."

"What

if

you're

wrong?"

"Then

I'll

still

have

plenty

of

time

to

despair

before

I

die.

But

you--

do

you

seek

out

every

opportunity

to

despair?

I

can

understand

the

impulse

that

might

lead

to

that.

Andrew

tells

me

you

were

a

handsome

man--

you

still

are,

you

know--

and

that

losing

the

full

use

of

your

body

has

hurt

you

deeply.

But

other

people

have

lost

more

than

you

have

without

getting

such

a

black-hearted

vision

of

the

world."

"This

is

your

analysis

of

me?"

asked

Miro.

"We've

known

each

other

half

an

hour,

and

now

you

understand

everything

about

me?"

"I

know

that

this

is

the

most

depressing

conversation

I've

ever

had

in

my

life."

"And

so

you

assume

that

it's

because

I

am

crippled.

Well,

let

me

tell

you

something,

Valentine

Wiggin.

I

hope

the

same

things

you

hope.

I

even

hope

that

someday

I'll

get

more

of

my

body

back

again.

If

I

didn't

have

hope

I'd

be

dead.

The

things

I

told

you

just

now

aren't

because

I

despair.

I

said

all

that

because

these

things

are

possible.

And

because

they're

possible

we

have

to

think

of

them

so

they

don't

surprise

us

later.

We

have

to

think

of

them

so

that

if

the

worst

does

come,

we'll

already

know

how

to

live

in

that

universe."

Valentine

seemed

to

be

studying

his

face;

he

felt

her

gaze

on

him

as

an

almost

palpable

thing,

like

a

faint

tickling

under

the

skin,

inside

his

brain.

"Yes,"

she

said.

"Yes

what?"

"Yes,

my

husband

and

I

will

move

over

here

and

live

on

your

ship."

She

got

up

from

her

seat

and

started

toward

the

corridor

leading

back

to

the

tube.

"Why

did

you

decide

that?"

"Because

it's

too

crowded

on

our

ship.

And

because

you

are

definitely

worth

talking

to.

And

not

just

to

get

material

for

the

essays

I

have

to

write."

"Oh,

so

I

passed

your

test?"

"Yes,

you

did,"

she

said.

"Did

I

pass

yours?"

"I

wasn't

testing

you."

"Like

hell,"

she

said.

"But

in

case

you

didn't

notice,

I'll

tell

you--

I

did

pass.

Or

you

wouldn't

have

said

to

me

all

the

things

you

said."

She

was

gone.

He

could

hear

her

shuffling

down

the

corridor,

and

then

the

computer

reported

that

she

was

passing

through

the

tube

between

ships.

He

already

missed

her.

Because

she

was

right.

She

had

passed

his

test.

She

had

listened

to

him

the

way

no

one

else

did--

without

impatience,

without

finishing

his

sentences,

without

letting

her

gaze

waver

from

his

face.

He

had

spoken

to

her,

not

with

careful

precision,

but

with

great

emotion.

Much

of

the

time

his

words

must

surely

have

been

almost

unintelligible.

Yet

she

had

listened

so

carefully

and

well

that

she

had

understood

all

his

arguments

and

never

once

asked

him

to

repeat

something.

He

could

talk

to

this

woman

as

naturally

as

he

ever

talked

to

anyone

before

his

brain

was

injured.

Yes,

she

was

opinionated,

headstrong,

bossy,

and

quick

to

reach

conclusions.

But

she

could

also

listen

to

an

opposing

view,

change

her

mind

when

she

needed

to.

She

could

listen,

and

so

he

could

speak.

Perhaps

with

her

he

could

still

be

Miro.

Chapter

3

--

CLEAN

HANDS

<The

most

unpleasant

thing

about

human

beings

is

that

they

don't

metamorphose.

Your

people

and

mine

are

born

as

grubs,

but

we

transform

ourselves

into

a

higher

form

before

we

reproduce.

Human

beings

remain

grubs

all

their

lives.>

<Human

beings

do

metamorphose.

They

change

their

identity

constantly.

However,

each

new

identity

thrives

on

the

delusion

that

it

was

always

in

possession

of

the

body

it

has

just

conquered.>

<Such

changes

are

superficial.

The

nature

of

the

organism

remains

the

same.

Humans

are

very

proud

of

their

changes,

but

every

imagined

transformation

turns

out

to

be

a

new

set

of

excuses

for

behaving

exactly

as

the

individual

has

always

behaved.>

<You

are

too

different

from

humans

ever

to

understand

them.>

<You

are

too

similar

to

humans

for

you

ever

to

be

able

to

see

them

clearly.>

The

gods

first

spoke

to

Han

Qing-jao

when

she

was

seven

years

old.

She

didn't

realize

for

a

while

that

she

was

hearing

the

voice

of

a

god.

All

she

knew

was

that

her

hands

were

filthy,

covered

with

some

loathsome

invisible

slime,

and

she

had

to

purify

them.

The

first

few

times,

a

simple

washing

was

enough,

and

she

felt

better

for

days.

But

as

time

passed,

the

feeling

of

filthiness

returned

sooner

each

time,

and

it

took

more

and

more

scrubbing

to

remove

the

dirt,

until

she

was

washing

several

times

a

day,

using

a

hard-bristled

brush

to

stab

at

her

hands

until

they

bled.

Only

when

the

pain

was

unbearable

did

she

feel

clean,

and

then

only

for

a

few

hours

at

a

time.

She

told

no

one;

she

kriew

instinctively

that

the

filthiness

of

her

hands

had

to

be

kept

secret.

Everyone

knew

that

handwashing

was

one

of

the

first

signs

that

the

gods

were

speaking

to

a

child,

and

most

parents

in

the

whole

world

of

Path

watched

their

children

hopefully

for

signs

of

excessive

concern

with

cleanliness.

But

what

these

people

did

not

understand

was

the

terrible

self-knowledge

that

led

to

the

washing:

The

first

message

from

the

gods

was

of

the

unspeakable

filthiness

of

the

one

they

spoke

to.

Qing-jao

hid

her

handwashing,

not

because

she

was

ashamed

that

the

gods

spoke

to

her,

but

because

she

was

sure

that

if

anyone

knew

how

vile

she

was,

they

would

despise

her.

The

gods

conspired

with

her

in

concealment.

They

allowed

her

to

confine

her

savage

scrubbing

to

the

palms

of

her

hands.

This

meant

that

when

her

hands

were

badly

hurt,

she

could

clench

them

into

fists,

or

tuck

them

into

the

folds

of

her

skirt

as

she

walked,

or

lay

them

in

her

lap

very

meekly

when

she

sat,

and

no

one

would

notice

them.

They

saw

only

a

very

well-behaved

little

girl.

If

her

mother

had

been

alive,

Qing-jao's

secret

would

have

been

discovered

much

sooner.

As

it

was,

it

took

months

for

a

servant

to

notice.

Fat

old

Mu-pao

happened

to

notice

a

bloody

stain

on

the

small

tablecloth

from

Qing-jao's

breakfast

table.

Mu-pao

knew

at

once

what

it

meant--

weren't

bloody

hands

well

known

to

be

an

early

sign

of

the

gods'

attention?

That

was

why

many

an

ambitious

mother

and

father

forced

a

particularly

promising

child

to

wash

and

wash.

Throughout

the

world

of

Path,

ostentatious

handwashing

was

called

"inviting

the

gods."

Mu-pao

went

at

once

to

Qing-jao's

father,

the

noble

Han

Fei-tzu,

rumored

to

be

the

greatest

of

the

godspoken,

one

of

the

few

so

powerful

in

the

eyes

of

the

gods

that

he

could

meet

with

framlings--

offworlders--

and

never

betray

a

hint

of

the

voices

of

the

gods

within

him,

thus

preserving

the

divine

secret

of

the

world

of

Path.

He

would

be

grateful

to

hear

the

news,

and

Mu-pao

would

be

honored

for

having

been

the

first

to

see

the

gods

in

Qing-jao.

Within

an

hour,

Han

Fei-tzu

had

gathered

up

his

beloved

little

Qing-jao

and

together

they

rode

in

a

sedan

chair

to

the

temple

at

Rockfall.

Qing-jao

didn't

like

riding

in

such

chairs--

she

felt

bad

for

the

men

who

had

to

carry

their

weight.

"They

don't

suffer,"

Father

told

her

the

first

time

she

mentioned

this

idea.

"They

feel

greatly

honored.

It's

one

of

the

ways

the

people

show

honor

to

the

gods--

when

one

of

the

godspoken

goes

to

a

temple,

he

does

it

on

the

shoulders

of

the

people

of

Path.

"

"But

I'm

getting

bigger

every

day,"

Qing-jao

answered.

"When

you're

too

big,

either

you'll

walk

on

your

own

feet

or

you'll

ride

in

your

own

chair,"

said

Father.

He

did

not

need

to

explain

that

she

would

have

her

own

chair

only

if

she

grew

up

to

be

godspoken

herself.

"And

we

try

to

show

our

humility

by

remaining

very

thin

and

light

so

we

aren't

a

heavy

burden

to

the

people."

This

was

a

joke,

of

course,

since

Father's

belly,

while

not

immense,

was

copious.

But

the

lesson

behind

the

joke

was

true:

The

godspoken

must

never

be

a

burden

to

the

common

people

of

Path.

The

people

must

always

be

grateful,

never

resentful,

that

the

gods

had

chosen

their

world

of

all

worlds

to

hear

their

voices.

Now,

though,

Qing-jao

was

more

concerned

with

the

ordeal

that

lay

before

her.

She

knew

that

she

was

being

taken

for

testing.

"Many

children

are

taught

to

pretend

that

the

gods

speak

to

them,"

Father

explained.

"We

must

find

out

if

the

gods

have

truly

chosen

you."

"I

want

them

to

stop

choosing

me,"

said

Qing-jao.

"And

you

will

want

it

even

more

during

the

test,"

said

Father.

His

voice

was

filled

with

pity.

It

made

Qingjao

even

more

afraid.

"The

folk

see

only

our

powers

and

privileges,

and

envy

us.

They

don't

know

the

great

suffering

of

those

who

hear

the

voices

of

the

gods.

If

the

gods

truly

speak

to

you,

my

Qing-jao,

you

will

learn

to

bear

the

suffering

the

way

jade

bears

the

carver's

knife,

the

polisher's

rough

cloth.

It

will

make

you

shine.

Why

else

do

you

think

I

named

you

Qing-jao?"

Qing-jao--

Gloriously

Bright

was

what

the

name

meant.

It

was

also

the

name

of

a

great

poet

from

ancient

times

in

Old

China.

A

woman

poet

in

an

age

when

only

men

were

given

respect,

and

yet

she

was

honored

as

the

greatest

of

poets

in

her

day.

"Thin

fog

and

thick

cloud,

gloom

all

day."

It

was

the

opening

of

Li

Qingjao's

song

"The

Double

Ninth."

That

was

how

Qing-jao

felt

now.

And

how

did

the

poem

end?

"Now

my

curtain's

lifted

only

by

the

western

wind.

I've

grown

thinner

than

this

golden

blossom."

Would

this

be

her

ending

also?

Was

her

ancestor-of-the-heart

telling

her

in

this

poem

that

the

darkness

failing

over

her

now

would

be

lifted

only

when

the

gods

came

out

of

the

west

to

lift

her

thin,

light,

golden

soul

out

of

her

body?

It

was

too

terrible,

to

think

of

death

now,

when

she

was

only

seven

years

old;

and

yet

the

thought

came

to

her:

If

I

die

soon,

then

soon

I'll

see

Mother,

and

even

the

great

Li

Qing-jao

herself.

But

the

test

had

nothing

to

do

with

death,

or

at

least

it

was

not

supposed

to.

It

was

quite

simple,

really.

Father

led

her

into

a

large

room

where

three

old

men

knelt.

Or

they

seemed

like

men--

they

could

have

been

women.

They

were

so

old

that

all

distinctions

had

disappeared.

They

had

only

the

tiniest

wisps

of

white

hair

and

no

beards

at

all,

and

they

dressed

in

shapeless

sacks.

Later

Qing-jao

would

learn

that

these

were

temple

eunuchs,

survivors

of

the

old

days

before

Starways

Congress

intervened

and

forbade

even

voluntary

self-mutilation

in

the

service

of

a

religion.

Now,

though,

they

were

mysterious

ghostly

old

creatures

whose

hands

touched

her,

exploring

her

clothing.

What

were

they

searching

for?

They

found

her

ebony

chopsticks

and

took

them

away.

They

took

the

sash

from

around

her

waist.

They

took

her

slippers.

Later

she

would

learn

that

these

things

were

taken

because

other

children

had

become

so

desperate

during

their

testing

that

they

had

killed

themselves.

One

of

them

had

inserted

her

chopsticks

into

her

nostrils

and

then

flung

herself

to

the

floor,

jamming

the

sticks

into

her

brain.

Another

had

hanged

herself

with

her

sash.

Another

had

forced

her

slippers

into

her

mouth

and

down

her

throat,

choking

herself

to

death.

Successful

suicide

attempts

were

rare,

but

they

seemed

to

happen

with

the

brightest

of

the

children,

and

most

commonly

with

girls.

So

they

took

away

from

Qing-jao

all

the

known

ways

of

committing

suicide.

The

old

ones

left.

Father

knelt

beside

Qing-jao

and

spoke

to

her

face

to

face.

"You

must

understand,

Qingjao,

that

we

are

not

really

testing

you.

Nothing

that

you

do

of

your

own

free

will

can

make

the

slightest

difference

in

what

happens

here.

We

are

really

testing

the

gods,

to

see

if

they

are

determined

to

speak

to

you.

If

they

are,

they'll

find

a

way,

and

we'll

see

it,

and

you'll

come

out

of

this

room

as

one

of

the

godspoken.

If

they

aren't,

then

you'll

come

out

of

here

free

of

their

voices

for

all

time.

I

can't

tell

you

which

outcome

I

pray

for,

since

I

don't

know

myself."

"Father,"

said

Qing-jao,

"what

if

you're

ashamed

of

me?"

The

very

thought

made

her

feel

a

tingling

in

her

hands,

as

if

there

were

dirt

on

them,

as

if

she

needed

to

wash

them.

"I

will

not

be

ashamed

of

you

either

way."

Then

he

clapped

his

hands.

One

of

the

old

ones

came

back

in,

bearing

a

heavy

basin.

He

set

it

down

before

Qing-jao.

"Thrust

in

your

hands,"

said

Father.

The

basin

was

filled

with

thick

black

grease.

Qing-jao

shuddered.

"I

can't

put

my

hands

in

there."

Father

reached

out,

took

her

by

the

forearms,

and

forced

her

hands

down

into

the

muck.

Qing-jao

cried

out--

her

father

had

never

used

force

with

her

before.

And

when

he

let

go

of

her

arms,

her

hands

were

covered

with

clammy

slime.

She

gasped

at

the

filthiness

of

her

hands;

it

was

hard

to

breathe,

looking

at

them

like

that,

smelling

them.

The

old

one

picked

up

the

basin

and

carried

it

out.

"Where

can

I

wash,

Father?"

Qing-jao

whimpered.

"You

can't

wash,"

said

Father.

"You

can

never

wash

again."

And

because

Qing-jao

was

a

child,

she

believed

him,

not

guessing

that

his

words

were

part

of

the

test.

She

watched

Father

leave

the

room.

She

heard

the

door

latch

behind

him.

She

was

alone.

At

first

she

simply

held

her

hands

out

in

front

of

her,

making

sure

they

didn't

touch

any

part

of

her

clothing.

She

searched

desperately

for

somewhere

to

wash,

but

there

was

no

water,

nor

even

a

cloth.

The

room

was

far

from

bare--

there

were

chairs,

tables,

statues,

large

stone

jars--

but

all

the

surfaces

were

hard

and

well-polished

and

so

clean

that

she

couldn't

bear

to

touch

them.

Yet

the

filthiness

of

her

hands

was

unendurable.

She

had

to

get

them

clean.

"Father!"

she

called

out.

"Come

and

wash

my

hands!"

Surely

he

could

hear

her.

Surely

he

was

somewhere

near,

waiting

for

the

outcome

of

her

test.

He

must

hear

her--

but

he

didn't

come.

The

only

cloth

in

the

room

was

the

gown

she

was

wearing.

She

could

wipe

on

that,

only

then

she

would

be

wearing

the

grease;

it

might

get

on

other

parts

of

her

body.

The

solution,

of

course,

was

to

take

it

off--

but

how

could

she

do

that

without

touching

her

filthy

hands

to

some

other

part

of

herself?

She

tried.

First

she

carefully

scraped

off

as

much

of

the

grease

as

she

could

on

the

smooth

arms

of

a

statue.

Forgive

me,

she

said

to

the

statue,

in

case

it

belonged

to

a

god.

I

will

come

and

clean

you

after;

I'll

clean

you

with

my

own

gown.

Then

she

reached

back

over

her

shoulders

and

gathered

the

cloth

on

her

back,

pulling

up

on

the

gown

to

draw

it

over

her

head.

Her

greasy

fingers

slipped

on

the

silk;

she

could

feel

the

slime

cold

on

her

bare

back

as

it

penetrated

the

silk.

I'll

clean

it

after,

she

thought.

At

last

she

got

a

firm

enough

grasp

of

the

fabric

that

she

could

pull

off

the

gown.

It

slid

over

her

head,

but

even

before

it

was

completely

off,

she

knew

that

things

were

worse

than

ever,

for

some

of

the

grease

was

in

her

long

hair,

and

that

hair

had

fallen

onto

her

face,

and

now

she

had

filth

not

just

on

her

hands

but

also

on

her

back,

in

her

hair,

on

her

face.

Still

she

tried.

She

got

the

gown

the

rest

of

the

way

off,

then

carefully

wiped

her

hands

on

one

small

part

of

the

fabric.

Then

she

wiped

her

face

on

another.

But

it

was

no

good.

Some

of

the

grease

clung

to

her

no

matter

what

she

did.

Her

face

felt

as

if

the

silk

of

her

gown

had

only

smeared

the

grease

around

instead

of

lifting

it

away.

She

had

never

been

so

hopelessly

grimy

in

her

life.

It

was

unbearable,

and

yet

she

couldn't

get

rid

of

it.

"Father!

Come

take

me

away!

I

don't

want

to

be

godspoken!"

He

didn't

come.

She

began

to

cry.

The

trouble

with

crying

was

that

it

didn't

work.

The

more

she

cried,

the

filthier

she

felt.

The

desperate

need

to

be

clean

overpowered

even

her

weeping.

So

with

tears

streaming

down

her

face,

she

began

to

search

desperately

for

some

way

to

get

the

grease

off

her

hands.

Again

she

tried

the

silk

of

her

gown,

but

within

a

little

while

she

was

wiping

her

hands

on

the

walls,

sidling

around

the

room,

smearing

them

with

grease.

She

rubbed

her

palms

on

the

wall

so

rapidly

that

heat

built

up

and

the

grease

melted.

She

did

it

again

and

again

until

her

hands

were

red,

until

some

of

the

softened

scabs

on

her

palms

had

worn

away

or

been

torn

off

by

invisible

snags

in

the

wooden

walls.

When

her

palms

and

fingers

hurt

badly

enough

that

she

couldn't

feel

the

slime

on

them,

she

wiped

her

face

with

them,

gouged

at

her

face

with

her

fingernails

to

scrape

away

the

grease

there.

Then,

hands

dirty

again,

she

once

more

rubbed

them

on

the

walls.

Finally,

exhausted,

she

fell

to

the

floor

and

wept

at

the

pain

in

her

hands,

at

her

helplessness

to

get

clean.

Her

eyes

were

shut

with

weeping.

Tears

streaked

down

her

cheeks.

She

rubbed

at

her

eyes,

at

her

cheeks--

and

felt

how

slimy

the

tears

made

her

skin,

how

filthy

she

was.

She

knew

what

this

surely

meant:

The

gods

had

judged

her

and

found

her

unclean.

She

wasn't

worthy

to

live.

If

she

couldn't

get

clean,

she

had

to

blot

herself

out.

That

would

satisfy

them.

That

would

ease

the

agony

of

it.

All

she

had

to

do

was

find

a

way

to

die.

To

stop

breathing.

Father

would

be

sorry

he

didn't

come

when

she

called

to

him,

but

she

couldn't

help

that.

She

was

under

the

power

of

the

gods

now,

and

they

had

judged

her

unworthy

to

be

among

the

living.

After

all,

what

right

did

she

have

to

breathe

when

the

gate

of

Mother's

lips

had

stopped

letting

the

air

pass

through,

in

or

out,

for

all

these

many

years?

She

first

thought

of

using

her

gown,

thought

of

stuffing

it

into

her

mouth

to

block

her

breath,

or

tying

it

around

her

throat

to

choke

herself--

but

it

was

too

filthy

to

handle,

too

covered

with

grease.

She

would

have

to

find

another

way.

Qing-jao

walked

to

the

wall,

pressed

against

it.

Sturdy

wood.

She

leaned

back

and

flung

her

head

against

the

wood.

Pain

flashed

through

her

head

when

it

struck;

stunned,

she

dropped

to

a

sitting

position

on

the

floor.

Her

head

ached

inside.

The

room

swung

slowly

around

and

around

her.

For

a

moment

she

forgot

the

filthiness

of

her

hands.

But

the

relief

didn't

last

long.

She

could

see

on

the

wall

a

slightly

duller

place

where

the

grease

from

her

forehead

broke

up

the

shiny

polished

surface.

The

gods

spoke

inside

her,

insisted

she

was

as

filthy

as

ever.

A

little

pain

wouldn't

make

up

for

her

unworthiness.

Again

she

struck

her

head

against

the

wall.

This

time,

however,

there

was

nowhere

near

as

much

pain.

Again,

again--

and

now

she

realized

that

against

her

will,

her

body

was

recoiling

from

the

blow,

refusing

to

inflict

so

much

pain

on

herself.

This

helped

her

understand

why

the

gods

found

her

so

unworthy--

she

was

too

weak

to

make

her

body

obey.

Well,

she

wasn't

helpless.

She

could

fool

her

body

into

submission.

She

selected

the

tallest

of

the

statues,

which

stood

perhaps

three

meters

high.

It

was

a

bronze

casting

of

a

man

in

mid-stride,

holding

a

sword

above

his

head.

There

were

enough

angles

and

bends

and

projections

that

she

could

climb.

Her

hands

kept

slipping,

but

she

persevered

until

she

balanced

on

the

statue's

shoulders,

holding

onto

its

headdress

with

one

hand

and

the

sword

with

the

other.

For

a

moment,

touching

the

sword,

she

thought

of

trying

to

cut

her

throat

on

it--

that

would

stop

her

breath,

wouldn't

it?

But

the

blade

was

only

a

pretend

blade.

It

wasn't

sharp,

and

she

couldn't

get

her

neck

to

it

at

the

right

angle.

So

she

went

back

to

her

original

plan.

She

took

several

deep

breaths,

then

clasped

her

hands

behind

her

back

and

toppled

forward.

She

would

land

on

her

head;

that

would

end

her

filthiness.

As

the

floor

rushed

upward,

however,

she

lost

control

of

herself.

She

screamed;

she

felt

her

hands

tear

free

of

each

other

behind

her

back

and

rush

forward

to

try

to

break

her

fall.

Too

late,

she

thought

with

grim

satisfaction,

and

then

her

head

struck

the

floor

and

everything

went

black.

***

Qing-jao

awoke

with

a

dull

ache

in

her

arm

and

a

sharp

pain

in

her

head

whenever

she

moved--

but

she

was

alive.

When

she

could

bear

to

open

her

eyes

she

saw

that

the

room

was

darker.

Was

it

night

outside?

How

long

had

she

slept?

She

couldn't

bear

to

move

her

left

arm,

the

one

with

the

pain;

she

could

see

an

ugly

red

bruise

at

the

elbow

and

she

thought

she

must

have

broken

it

inside

when

she

fell.

She

also

saw

that

her

hands

were

still

smeared

with

grease,

and

felt

her

unbearable

dirtiness:

the

gods'

judgment

against

her.

She

shouldn't

have

tried

to

kill

herself

after

all.

The

gods

wouldn't

allow

her

to

escape

their

judgment

so

easily.

What

can

I

do?

she

pleaded.

How

can

I

be

clean

before

you,

O

Gods?

Li

Qing-jao,

my

ancestor-of-theheart,

show

me

how

to

make

myself

worthy

to

receive

the

kind

judgment

of

the

gods!

What

came

at

once

to

her

mind

was

Li

Qing-jao's

love

song

"Separation."

It

was

one

of

the

first

that

Father

had

given

her

to

memorize

when

she

was

only

three

years

old,

only

a

short

time

before

he

and

Mother

told

her

that

Mother

was

going

to

die.

It

was

exactly

appropriate

now,

too,

for

wasn't

she

separated

from

the

goodwill

of

the

gods?

Didn't

she

need

to

be

reconciled

with

them

so

they

could

receive

her

as

one

of

the

truly

godspoken

ones?

someone's

sent

a

loving

note

in

lines

of

returning

geese

and

as

the

moon

fills

my

western

chamber

as

petals

dance

over

the

flowing

stream

again

I

think

of

you

the

two

of

us

living

a

sadness

apart

a

hurt

that

can't

be

removed

yet

when

my

gaze

comes

down

my

heart

stays

up

The

moon

filling

the

western

chamber

told

her

that

it

was

really

a

god,

not

an

ordinary

man-lover

who

was

being

pined

for

in

this

poem--

references

to

the

west

always

meant

that

the

gods

were

involved.

Li

Qing-Jao

had

answered

the

prayer

of

little

Han

Qing-jao,

and

sent

this

poem

to

tell

her

how

to

cure

the

hurt

that

couldn't

be

removed--

the

filthiness

of

her

flesh.

What

is

the

loving

note?

thought

Qing-jao.

Lines

of

returning

geese--

but

there

are

no

geese

in

this

room.

Petals

dancing

over

a

flowing

stream--

but

there

are

no

petals,

there

is

no

stream

here.

"Yet

when

my

gaze

comes

down,

my

heart

stays

up."

That

was

the

clue,

that

was

the

answer,

she

knew

it.

Slowly,

carefully

Qing-jao

rolled

over

onto

her

belly.

Once

when

she

tried

to

put

weight

on

her

left

hand,

her

elbow

buckled

and

an

exquisite

pain

almost

made

her

lose

consciousness

again.

At

last

she

knelt,

her

head

bowed,

leaning

on

her

right

hand.

Gazing

down.

The

poem

promised

that

this

would

let

her

heart

stay

up.

She

felt

no

better--

still

filthy,

still

in

pain.

Looking

down

showed

her

nothing

but

the

polished

boards

of

the

floor,

the

grain

of

the

wood

making

rippling

lines

reaching

from

between

her

knees

outward

to

the

very

edge

of

the

room.

Lines.

Lines

of

woodgrain,

lines

of

geese.

And

couldn't

the

woodgrain

also

be

seen

as

a

flowing

stream?

She

must

follow

these

lines

like

the

geese;

she

must

dance

over

these

flowing

streams

like

a

petal.

That

was

what

the

promise

meant:

When

her

gaze

came

down,

her

heart

would

stay

up.

She

found

one

particular

line

in

the

woodgrain,

a

line

of

darkness

like

a

river

rippling

through

the

lighter

wood

around

it,

and

knew

at

once

that

this

was

the

stream

she

was

supposed

to

follow.

She

dared

not

touch

it

with

her

finger--

filthy,

unworthy

finger.

It

had

to

be

followed

lightly,

the

way

a

goose

touched

the

air,

the

way

a

petal

touched

the

stream.

Only

her

eyes

could

follow

the

line.

So

she

began

to

trace

the

line,

follow

it

carefully

to

the

wall.

A

couple

of

times

she

moved

so

quickly

that

she

lost

the

line,

forgot

which

one

it

was;

but

soon

she

found

it

again,

or

thought

she

did,

and

followed

it

to

the

wall.

Was

it

good

enough?

Were

the

gods

satisfied?

Almost,

but

not

quite--

she

couldn't

be

sure

that

when

her

gaze

slipped

from

the

line

she

had

returned

to

the

right

one.

Petals

didn't

skip

from

stream

to

stream.

She

had

to

follow

the

right

one,

along

its

entire

length.

This

time

she

started

at

the

wall

and

bowed

very

low,

so

her

eyes

wouldn't

be

distracted

even

by

the

movement

of

her

own

right

hand.

She

inched

her

way

along,

never

letting

herself

so

much

as

blink,

even

when

her

eyes

burned.

She

knew

that

if

she

lost

the

grain

she

was

following

she'd

have

to

go

back

and

start

over.

It

had

to

be

done

perfectly

or

it

would

lose

all

its

power

to

cleanse

her.

It

took

forever.

She

did

blink,

but

not

haphazardly,

by

accident.

When

her

eyes

burned

too

much,

she

would

bow

down

until

her

left

eye

was

directly

over

the

grain.

Then

she

would

close

the

other

eye

for

a

moment.

Her

right

eye

relieved,

she

would

open

it,

then

put

that

eye

directly

over

the

line

in

the

wood

and

close

the

left.

This

way

she

was

able

to

make

it

halfway

across

the

room

until

the

board

ended,

butting

up

against

another.

She

wasn't

sure

whether

that

was

good

enough,

whether

it

was

enough

to

finish

the

board

or

if

she

needed

to

find

another

woodgrain

line

to

follow.

She

made

as

if

to

get

up,

testing

the

gods,

to

see

if

they

were

satisfied.

She

half-rose,

felt

nothing;

she

stood,

and

still

she

was

at

ease.

Ah!

They

were

satisfied,

they

were

pleased

with

her.

Now

the

grease

on

her

skin

felt

like

nothing

more

than

a

little

oil.

There

was

no

need

for

washing,

not

at

this

moment,

for

she

had

found

another

way

to

cleanse

herself,

another

way

for

the

gods

to

discipline

her.

Slowly

she

lay

back

on

the

floor,

smiling,

weeping

softly

in

joy.

Li

Qing-jao,

my

ancestor-of-the-heart,

thank

you

for

showing

me

the

way.

Now

I

have

been

joined

to

the

gods;

the

separation

is

over.

Mother,

I

am

again

connected

to

you,

clean

and

worthy.

White

Tiger

of

the

West,

I

am

now

pure

enough

to

touch

your

fur

and

leave

no

mark

of

filthiness.

Then

hands

touched

her--

Father's

hands,

picking

her

up.

Drops

of

water

fell

onto

her

face,

the

bare

skin

of

her

body--

Father's

tears.

"You're

alive,"

he

said.

"My

godspoken

one,

my

beloved,

my

daughter,

my

life,

Gloriously

Bright,

you

shine

on."

Later

she

would

learn

that

Father

had

had

to

be

tied

and

gagged

during

her

test,

that

when

she

climbed

the

statue

and

made

as

if

to

press

her

throat

against

the

sword,

he

flung

himself

forward

with

such

force

that

his

chair

fell

and

his

head

struck

the

floor.

This

was

regarded

as

a

great

mercy,

since

it

meant

he

didn't

see

her

terrible

fall

from

the

statue.

He

wept

for

her

all

the

time

she

lay

unconscious.

And

then,

when

she

rose

to

her

knees

and

began

to

trace

the

woodgrains

on

the

floor,

he

was

the

one

who

realized

what

it

meant.

"Look,"

he

whispered.

"The

gods

have

given

her

a

task.

The

gods

are

speaking

to

her."

The

others

were

slow

to

recognize

it,

because

they

had

never

seen

anyone

trace

woodgrain

lines

before.

It

wasn't

in

the

Catalogue

of

Voices

of

the

Gods:

Door-Waiting,

Counting-to-Multiples-of-Five,

ObjectCounting,

Checking-for-Accidental-Murders,

Fingernail-Tearing,

Skin-Scraping,

Pulling-Out-of-Hair,

Gnawing-at-Stone,

Bugging-Out-of-Eyes--

all

these

were

known

to

be

penances

that

the

gods

demanded,

rituals

of

obedience

that

cleansed

the

soul

of

the

godspoken

so

that

the

gods

could

fill

their

minds

with

wisdom.

No

one

had

ever

seen

Woodgrain-Tracing.

Yet

Father

saw

what

she

was

doing,

named

the

ritual,

and

added

it

to

the

Catalogue

of

Voices.

It

would

forever

bear

her

name,

Han

Qing-jao,

as

the

first

to

be

commanded

by

the

gods

to

perform

this

rite.

It

made

her

very

special.

So

did

her

unusual

resourcefulness

in

trying

to

find

ways

to

cleanse

her

hands

and,

later,

kill

herself.

Many

had

tried

scraping

their

hands

on

walls,

of

course,

and

most

attempted

to

wipe

on

clothes.

But

rubbing

her

hands

to

build

up

the

heat

of

friction,

that

was

regarded

as

rare

and

clever.

And

while

head-beating

was

common,

climbing

a

statue

and

jumping

off

and

landing

on

her

head

was

very

rare.

And

none

who

had

done

it

before

had

been

strong

enough

to

keep

their

hands

behind

their

back

so

long.

The

temple

was

all

abuzz

with

it,

and

word

soon

spread

to

all

the

temples

in

Path.

It

was

a

great

honor

to

Han

Fei-tzu,

of

course,

that

his

daughter

was

so

powerfully

possessed

by

the

gods.

And

the

story

of

his

near-madness

when

she

was

trying

to

destroy

herself

spread

just

as

quickly

and

touched

many

hearts.

"He

may

be

the

greatest

of

the

godspoken,"

they

said

of

him,

"but

he

loves

his

daughter

more

than

life."

This

made

them

love

him

as

much

as

they

already

revered

him.

It

was

then

that

people

began

whispering

about

the

possible

godhood

of

Han

Fei-tzu.

"He

is

great

and

strong

enough

that

the

gods

will

listen

to

him,"

said

the

people

who

favored

him.

"Yet

he

is

so

affectionate

that

he

will

always

love

the

people

of

the

planet

Path,

and

try

to

do

good

for

us.

Isn't

this

what

the

god

of

a

world

ought

to

be?"

Of

course

it

was

impossible

to

decide

now--

a

man

could

not

be

chosen

to

be

god

of

a

village,

let

alone

of

a

whole

world,

until

he

died.

How

could

you

judge

what

sort

of

god

he'd

be,

until

his

whole

life,

from

beginning

to

end,

was

known?

These

whispers

came

to

Qing-jao's

ears

many

times

as

she

grew

older,

and

the

knowledge

that

her

father

might

well

be

chosen

god

of

Path

became

one

of

the

beacons

of

her

life.

But

at

the

time,

and

forever

in

her

memory,

she

remembered

that

his

hands

were

the

ones

that

carried

her

bruised

and

twisted

body

to

the

bed

of

healing,

his

eyes

were

the

ones

that

dropped

warm

tears

on

to

her

cold

skin,

his

voice

was

the

one

that

whispered

in

the

beautiful

passionate

tones

of

the

old

language,

"My

beloved,

my

Gloriously

Bright,

never

take

your

light

from

my

life.

Whatever

happens,

never

harm

yourself

or

I

will

surely

die."

Chapter

4

--

JANE

<So

many

of

your

people

are

becoming

Christians.

Believing

in

the

god

these

humans

brought

with

them.>

<You

don't

believe

in

God?>

<The

question

never

come

up.

We

have

always

remembered

how

we

began.>

<You

evolved.

We

were

created.>

<By

a

virus.>

<By

a

virus

that

God

created

in

order

to

create

us.>

<So

you,

too,

are

a

believer.>

<I

understand

belief.>

<No--

you

desire

belief.>

<I

desire

it

enough

to

act

as

if

I

believed.

Maybe

that's

what

faith

is.>

<Or

deliberate

insanity>

It

turned

out

not

to

be

just

Valentine

and

Jakt

who

came

over

to

Miro's

ship.

Plikt

also

came,

without

invitation,

and

installed

herself

in

a

miserable

little

cubicle

where

there

wasn't

even

room

to

stretch

out

completely.

She

was

the

anomaly

on

the

voyage--

not

family,

not

crew,

but

a

friend.

Plikt

had

been

a

student

of

Ender's

when

he

was

on

Trondheim

as

a

speaker

for

the

dead.

She

had

figured

out,

quite

independently,

that

Andrew

Wiggin

was

the

Speaker

for

the

Dead

and

that

he

was

also

the

Ender

Wiggin.

Why

this

brilliant

young

woman

should

have

become

so

fixed

on

Ender

Wiggin,

Valentine

could

not

really

understand.

At

times

she

thought,

Perhaps

this

is

how

some

religions

start.

The

founder

doesn't

ask

for

disciples;

they

come

and

force

themselves

upon

him.

In

any

event,

Plikt

had

stayed

with

Valentine

and

her

family

for

all

the

years

since

Ender

left

Trondheim,

tutoring

the

children

and

helping

in

Valentine's

research,

always

waiting

for

the

day

that

the

family

journeyed

to

be

with

Ender--

a

day

that

only

Plikt

had

known

would

come.

So

during

the

last

half

of

the

voyage

to

Lusitania,

it

was

the

four

of

them

who

traveled

in

Miro's

ship:

Valentine,

Miro,

Jakt,

and

Plikt.

Or

so

Valentine

thought

at

first.

It

was

on

the

third

day

since

the

rendezvous

that

she

learned

of

the

fifth

traveler

who

had

been

with

them

all

along.

That

day,

as

always,

the

four

of

them

were

gathered

on

the

bridge.

There

was

nowhere

else

to

go.

This

was

a

cargo

ship--

besides

the

bridge

and

the

sleeping

quarters,

there

was

only

a

tiny

galley

and

the

toilet.

All

the

other

space

was

designed

to

hold

cargo,

not

people--

not

in

any

kind

of

reasonable

comfort.

Valentine

didn't

mind

the

loss

of

privacy,

though.

She

was

slacking

off

now

on

her

output

of

subversive

essays;

it

was

more

important,

she

felt,

to

get

to

know

Miro--

and,

through

him,

Lusitania.

The

people

there,

the

pequeninos,

and,

most

particularly,

Miro's

family--

for

Ender

had

married

Novinha,

Mira's

mother.

Valentine

did

glean

much

of

that

kind

of

information,

of

course--

she

couldn't

have

been

a

historian

and

biographer

for

all

these

years

without

learning

how

to

extrapolate

much

from

scant

bits

of

evidence.

The

real

prize

for

her

had

turned

out

to

be

Miro

himself.

He

was

bitter,

angry,

frustrated,

and

filled

with

loathing

for

his

crippled

body,

but

all

that

was

understandable--

his

loss

had

happened

only

a

few

months

before,

and

he

was

still

trying

to

redefine

himself.

Valentine

didn't

worry

about

his

future--

she

could

see

that

he

was

very

strong-willed,

the

kind

of

man

who

didn't

easily

fall

apart.

He

would

adapt

and

thrive.

What

interested

her

most

was

his

thought.

It

was

as

if

the

confinement

of

his

body

had

freed

his

mind.

When

he

had

first

been

injured

his

paralysis

was

almost

total.

He

had

had

nothing

to

do

but

lie

in

one

place

and

think.

Of

course,

much

of

his

time

had

been

spent

brooding

about

his

losses,

his

mistakes,

the

future

he

couldn't

have.

But

he

had

also

spent

many

hours

thinking

about

the

issues

that

busy

people

almost

never

think

about.

And

on

that

third

day

together,

that's

what

Valentine

was

trying

to

draw

out

of

him.

"Most

people

don't

think

about

it,

not

seriously,

and

you

have,"

said

Valentine.

"Just

because

I

think

about

it

doesn't

mean

I

know

anything,"

said

Miro.

She

really

was

used

to

his

voice

now,

though

sometimes

his

speech

was

maddeningly

slow.

It

took

a

real

effort

of

will

at

times

to

keep

from

showing

any

sign

of

inattention.

"The

nature

of

the

universe,"

said

Jakt.

"The

sources

of

life,"

said

Valentine.

"You

said

you

had

thought

about

what

it

means

to

be

alive,

and

I

want

to

know

what

you

thought."

"How

the

universe

works

and

why

we

all

are

in

it."

Miro

laughed.

"It's

pretty

crazy

stuff."

"I've

been

trapped

alone

in

an

ice

floe

in

a

fishing

boat

for

two

weeks

in

a

blizzard

with

no

heat,"

said

Jakt.

"I

doubt

you've

come

up

with

anything

that'll

sound

crazy

to

me."

Valentine

smiled.

Jakt

was

no

scholar,

and

his

philosophy

was

generally

confined

to

holding

his

crew

together

and

catching

a

lot

of

fish.

But

he

knew

that

Valentine

wanted

to

draw

Miro

out,

and

so

he

helped

put

the

young

man

at

ease,

helped

him

know

that

he'd

be

taken

seriously.

And

it

was

important

for

Jakt

to

be

the

one

who

did

that--

because

Valentine

had

seen,

and

so

had

Jakt,

how

Miro

watched

him.

Jakt

might

be

old,

but

his

arms

and

legs

and

back

were

still

those

of

a

fisherman,

and

every

movement

revealed

the

suppleness

of

his

body.

Miro

even

commented

on

it

once,

obliquely,

admiringly:

"You've

got

the

build

of

a

twenty-year-old."

Valentine

heard

the

ironic

corollary

that

must

have

been

in

Miro's

mind:

While

I,

who

am

young,

have

the

body

of

an

arthritic

ninety-year-old.

So

Jakt

meant

something

to

Miro--

he

represented

the

future

that

Miro

could

never

have.

Admiration

and

resentment;

it

would

have

been

hard

for

Miro

to

speak

openly

in

front

of

Jakt,

if

Jakt

had

not

taken

care

to

make

sure

Miro

heard

nothing

but

respect

and

interest

from

him.

Plikt,

of

course,

sat

in

her

place,

silent,

withdrawn,

effectively

invisible.

"All

right,"

said

Miro.

"Speculations

on

the

nature

of

reality

and

the

soul."

"Theology

or

metaphysics?"

asked

Valentine.

"Metaphysics,

mostly,"

said

Miro.

"And

physics.

Neither

one

is

my

specialty.

And

this

isn't

the

kind

of

story

you

said

you

needed

me

for."

"I

don't

always

know

exactly

what

I'll

need."

"All

right,"

said

Miro.

He

took

a

couple

of

breaths,

as

if

he

were

trying

to

decide

where

to

begin.

"You

know

about

philotic

twining."

"I

know

what

everybody

knows,"

said

Valentine.

"And

I

know

that

it

hasn't

led

anywhere

in

the

last

twentyfive

hundred

years

because

it

can't

really

be

experimented

with."

It

was

an

old

discovery,

from

the

days

when

scientists

were

struggling

to

catch

up

with

technology.

Teenage

physics

students

memorized

a

few

wise

sayings:

"Philotes

are

the

fundamental

building

blocks

of

all

matter

and

energy.

Philotes

have

neither

mass

nor

inertia.

Philotes

have

only

location,

duration,

and

connection."

And

everybody

knew

that

it

was

philotic

connections--

the

twining

of

philotic

rays--

that

made

ansibles

work,

allowing

instantaneous

communication

between

worlds

and

starships

many

light-years

apart.

But

no

one

knew

why

it

worked,

and

because

philotes

could

not

be

"handled,"

it

was

almost

impossible

to

experiment

with

them.

They

could

only

be

observed,

and

then

only

through

their

connections.

"Philotics,"

said

Jakt.

"Ansibles?"

"A

by-product,"

said

Miro.

"What

does

it

have

to

do

with

the

soul?"

asked

Valentine.

Miro

was

about

to

answer,

but

he

grew

frustrated,

apparently

at

the

thought

of

trying

to

give

a

long

speech

through

his

sluggish,

resisting

mouth.

His

jaw

was

working,

his

lips

moving

slightly.

Then

he

said

aloud,

"I

can't

do

it."

"We'll

listen,"

said

Valentine.

She

understood

his

reluctance

to

try

extended

discourse

with

the

limitations

of

his

speech,

but

she

also

knew

he

had

to

do

it

anyway.

"No,"

said

Miro.

Valentine

would

have

tried

further

persuasion,

but

she

saw

his

lips

were

still

moving,

though

little

sound

came

out.

Was

he

muttering?

Cursing?

No--

she

knew

it

wasn't

that

at

all.

It

took

a

moment

for

her

to

realize

why

she

was

so

sure.

It

was

because

she

had

seen

Ender

do

exactly

the

same

thing,

moving

his

lips

and

jaw,

when

he

was

issuing

subvocalized

commands

to

the

computer

terminal

built

into

the

jewel

he

wore

in

his

ear.

Of

course:

Miro

has

the

same

computer

hookup

Ender

has,

so

he'll

speak

to

it

the

same

way.

In

a

moment

it

became

clear

what

command

Miro

had

given

to

his

jewel.

It

must

have

been

tied

in

to

the

ship's

computer,

because

immediately

afterward

one

of

the

display

screens

cleared

and

then

showed

Miro's

face.

Only

there

was

none

of

the

slackness

that

marred

his

face

in

person.

Valentine

realized:

It

was

Miro's

face

as

it

used

to

be.

And

when

the

computer

image

spoke,

the

sound

coming

from

the

speakers

was

surely

Miro's

voice

as

it

used

to

be--

clear.

Forceful.

Intelligent.

Quick.

"You

know

that

when

philotes

combine

to

make

a

durable

structure--

a

meson,

a

neutron,

an

atom,

a

molecule,

an

organism,

a

planet--

they

twine

up."

"What

is

this?"

demanded

Jakt.

He

hadn't

yet

figured

out

why

the

computer

was

doing

the

talking.

The

computer

image

of

Miro

froze

on

the

screen

and

fell

silent.

Miro

himself

answered.

"I've

been

playing

with

this,"

he

said.

"I

tell

it

things,

and

it

remembers

and

speaks

for

me."

Valentine

tried

to

imagine

Miro

experimenting

until

the

computer

program

got

his

face

and

voice

just

right.

How

exhilarating

it

must

have

been,

to

re-create

himself

as

he

ought

to

be.

And

also

how

agonizing,

to

see

what

he

could

have

been

and

know

that

it

could

never

be

real.

"What

a

clever

idea,"

said

Valentine.

"Sort

of

a

prosthesis

for

the

personality."

Miro

laughed--

a

single

"Ha!"

"Go

ahead,"

said

Valentine.

"Whether

you

speak

for

yourself

or

the

computer

speaks

for

you,

we'll

listen."

The

computer

image

came

back

to

life,

and

spoke

again

in

Miro's

strong,

imaginary

voice.

"Philotes

are

the

smallest

building

blocks

of

matter

and

energy.

They

have

no

mass

or

dimension.

Each

philote

connects

itself

to

the

rest

of

the

universe

along

a

single

ray,

a

one-dimensional

line

that

connects

it

to

all

the

other

philotes

in

its

smallest

immediate

structure--

a

meson.

All

those

strands

from

the

philotes

in

that

structure

are

twined

into

a

single

philotic

thread

that

connects

the

meson

to

the

next

larger

structure--

a

neutron,

for

instance.

The

threads

in

the

neutron

twine

into

a

yarn

connecting

it

to

all

the

other

particles

of

the

atom,

and

then

the

yarns

of

the

atom

twine

into

the

rope

of

the

molecule.

This

has

nothing

to

do

with

nuclear

forces

or

gravity,

nothing

to

do

with

chemical

bonds.

As

far

as

we

can

tell,

the

philotic

connections

don't

do

anything.

They're

just

there."

"But

the

individual

rays

are

always

there,

present

in

the

twines,"

said

Valentine.

"Yes,

each

ray

goes

on

forever,"

answered

the

screen.

It

surprised

her--

and

Jakt,

too,

judging

from

the

way

his

eyes

widened--

that

the

computer

was

able

to

respond

immediately

to

what

Valentine

said.

It

wasn't

just

a

preset

lecture.

This

had

to

be

a

sophisticated

program

anyway,

to

simulate

Miro's

face

and

voice

so

well;

but

now

to

have

it

responding

as

if

it

were

simulating

Miro's

personality

...

Or

had

Miro

given

some

cue

to

the

program?

Had

he

subvocalized

the

response?

Valentine

didn't

know--

she

had

been

watching

the

screen.

She

would

stop

doing

that

now--

she

would

watch

Miro

himself.

"We

don't

know

if

the

ray

is

infinite,"

said

Valentine.

"We

only

know

that

we

haven't

found

where

the

ray

ends."

"They

twine

together,

a

whole

planetful,

and

each

planet's

philotic

twine

reaches

to

its

star,

and

each

star

to

the

center

of

the

galaxy--"

"And

where

does

the

galactic

twine

go?"

said

Jakt.

It

was

an

old

question--

schoolchildren

asked

it

when

they

first

got

into

philotics

in

high

school.

Like

the

old

speculation

that

maybe

galaxies

were

really

neutrons

or

mesons

inside

a

far

vaster

universe,

or

the

old

question,

If

the

universe

isn't

infinite,

what

is

beyond

the

edge?

"Yes,

yes,"

said

Miro.

This

time,

though,

he

spoke

from

his

own

mouth.

"But

that's

not

where

I'm

going.

I

want

to

talk

about

life."

The

computerized

voice--

the

voice

of

the

brilliant

young

man--

took

over.

"The

philotic

twines

from

substances

like

rock

or

sand

all

connect

directly

from

each

molecule

to

the

center

of

the

planet.

But

when

a

molecule

is

incorporated

into

a

living

organism,

its

ray

shifts.

Instead

of

reaching

to

the

planet,

it

gets

twined

in

with

the

individual

cell,

and

the

rays

from

the

cells

are

all

twined

together

so

that

each

organism

sends

a

single

fiber

of

philotic

connections

to

twine

up

with

the

central

philotic

rope

of

the

planet."

"Which

shows

that

individual

lives

have

some

meaning

at

the

level

of

physics,"

said

Valentine.

She

had

written

an

essay

about

it

once,

trying

to

dispel

some

of

the

mysticism

that

had

grown

up

about

philotics

while

at

the

same

time

using

it

to

suggest

a

view

of

community

formation.

"But

there's

no

practical

effect

from

it,

Miro.

Nothing

you

can

do

with

it.

The

philotic

twining

of

living

organisms

simply

is.

Every

philote

is

connected

to

something,

and

through

that

to

something

else,

and

through

that

to

something

else--

living

cells

and

organisms

are

simply

two

of

the

leels

where

those

connections

can

be

made."

"Yes,"

said

Miro.

"That

which

lives,

twines."

Valentine

shrugged,

nodded.

It

probably

couldn't

be

proven,

but

if

Miro

wanted

that

as

a

premise

in

his

speculations,

that

was

fine.

The

computer-Miro

took

over

again.

"What

I've

been

thinking

about

is

the

endurance

of

the

twining.

When

a

twined

structure

is

broken--

as

when

a

molecule

breaks

apart--

the

old

philotic

twining

remains

for

a

time.

Fragments

that

are

no

longer

physically

joined

remain

philotically

connected

for

a

while.

And

the

smaller

the

particle,

the

longer

that

connection

lasts

after

the

breakup

of

the

original

structure,

and

the

more

slowly

the

fragments

shift

to

new

twinings."

Jakt:

frowned.

"I

thought

the

smaller

things

were,

the

faster

things

happened."

"It

is

counterintuitive,"

said

Valentine.

"After

nuclear

fission

it

takes

hours

for

the

philotic

rays

to

sort

themselves

back

out

again,"

said

the

computer-Miro.

"Split

a

smaller

particle

than

an

atom,

and

the

philotic

connection

between

the

fragments

will

last

much

longer

than

that."

"Which

is

how

the

ansible

works,"

said

Miro.

Valentine

looked

at

him

closely.

Why

was

he

talking

sometimes

in

his

own

voice,

sometimes

through

the

computer?

Was

the

program

under

his

control

or

wasn't

it?

"The

principle

of

the

ansible

is

that

if

you

suspend

a

meson

in

a

powerful

magnetic

field,"

said

computerMiro,

"split

it,

and

carry

the

two

parts

as

far

away

as

you

want,

the

philotic

twining

will

still

connect

them.

And

the

connection

is

instantaneous.

If

one

fragment

spins

or

vibrates,

the

ray

between

them

spins

and

vibrates,

and

the

movement

is

detectable

at

the

other

end

at

exactly

the

same

moment.

It

takes

no

time

whatsoever

for

the

movement

to

be

transmitted

along

the

entire

length

of

the

ray,

even

if

the

two

fragments

are

carried

light-years

away

from

each

other.

Nobody

knows

why

it

works,

but

we're

glad

it

does.

Without

the

ansible,

there'd

be

no

possibility

of

meaningful

communication

between

human

worlds."

"Hell,

there's

no

meaningful

communication

now,"

said

Jakt.

"And

if

it

wasn't

for

the

ansibles,

there'd

be

no

warfleet

heading

for

Lusitania

right

now."

Valentine

wasn't

listening

to

Jakt,

though.

She

was

watching

Miro.

This

time

Valentine

saw

when

he

moved

his

lips

and

jaw,

slightly,

silently.

Sure

enough,

after

he

subvocalized,

the

computer

image

of

Miro

spoke

again.

He

was

giving

commands.

It

had

been

absurd

for

her

to

think

otherwise--

who

else

could

be

controlling

the

computer?

"It's

a

hierarchy,"

said

the

image.

"The

more

complex

the

structure,

the

faster

the

response

to

change.

It's

as

if

the

smaller

the

particle

is,

the

stupider

it

is,

so

it's

slower

to

pick

up

on

the

fact

that

it's

now

part

of

a

different

structure."

"Now

you're

anthropomorphizing,"

said

Valentine.

"Maybe,"

said

Miro.

"Maybe

not."

"Human

beings

are

organisms,"

said

the

image.

"But

human

philotic

twinings

go

way

beyond

those

of

any

other

life

form."

"Now

you're

talking

about

that

stuff

that

came

from

Ganges

a

thousand

years

ago,"

said

Valentine.

"Nobody's

been

able

to

get

consistent

results

from

those

experiments."

The

researchers--

Hindus

all,

and

devout

ones--

claimed

that

they

had

shown

that

human

philotic

twinings,

unlike

those

of

other

organisms,

did

not

always

reach

directly

down

into

the

planet's

core

to

twine

with

all

other

life

and

matter.

Rather,

they

claimed,

the

philotic

rays

from

human

beings

often

twined

with

those

of

other

human

beings,

most

often

with

families,

but

sometimes

between

teachers

and

students,

and

sometimes

between

close

co-workers--

including

the

researchers

themselves.

The

Gangeans

had

concluded

that

this

distinction

between

humans

and

other

plant

and

animal

life

proved

that

the

souls

of

some

humans

were

literally

lifted

to

a

higher

plane,

nearer

to

perfection.

They

believed

that

the

Perfecting

Ones

had

become

one

with

each

other

the

way

that

all

of

life

was

one

with

the

world.

"It's

all

very

pleasingly

mystical,

but

nobody

except

Gangean

Hindus

takes

it

seriously

anymore."

"I

do,"

said

Miro.

"To

each

his

own,"

said

Jakt.

"Not

as

a

religion,"

said

Miro.

"As

science."

"You

mean

metaphysics,

don't

you?"

said

Valentine.

It

was

the

Miro-image

that

answered.

"The

philotic

connections

between

people

change

fastest

of

all,

and

what

the

Gangeans

proved

is

that

they

respond

to

human

will.

If

you

have

strong

feelings

binding

you

to

your

family,

then

your

philotic

rays

will

twine

and

you

will

be

one,

in

exactly

the

same

way

that

the

different

atoms

in

a

molecule

are

one."

It

was

a

sweet

idea--

she

had

thought

so

when

she

first

heard

it,

perhaps

two

thousand

years

ago,

when

Ender

was

speaking

for

a

murdered

revolutionary

on

Mindanao.

She

and

Ender

had

speculated

then

on

whether

the

Gangean

tests

would

show

that

they

were

twined,

as

brother

and

sister.

They

wondered

whether

there

had

been

such

a

connection

between

them

as

children,

and

if

it

had

persisted

when

Ender

was

taken

off

to

Battle

School

and

they

were

separated

for

six

years.

Ender

had

liked

that

idea

very

much,

and

so

had

Valentine,

but

after

that

one

conversation

the

subject

never

came

up

again.

The

notion

of

philotic

connections

between

people

had

remained

in

the

pretty-idea

category

in

her

memory.

"It's

nice

to

think

that

the

metaphor

of

human

unity

might

have

a

physical

analogue,"

said

Valentine.

"Listen!"

said

Miro.

Apparently

he

didn't

want

her

to

dismiss

the

idea

as

"nice."

Again

his

image

spoke

for

him.

"If

the

Gangeans

are

right,

then

when

a

human

being

chooses

to

bond

with

another

person,

when

he

makes

a

commitment

to

a

community,

it

is

not

just

a

social

phenomenon.

It's

a

physical

event

as

well.

The

philote,

the

smallest

conceivable

physical

particle--

if

we

can

call

something

with

no

mass

or

inertia

physical

at

all--

responds

to

an

act

of

the

human

will."

"That's

why

it's

so

hard

for

anyone

to

take

the

Gangean

experiments

seriously."

"The

Gangean

experiments

were

careful

and

honest."

"But

no

one

else

ever

got

the

same

results."

"No

one

else

ever

took

them

seriously

enough

to

perform

the

same

experiments.

Does

that

surprise

you?"

"Yes,"

said

Valentine.

But

then

she

remembered

how

the

idea

had

been

ridiculed

in

the

scientific

press,

while

it

was

immediately

picked

up

by

the

lunatic

fringe

and

incorporated

into

dozens

of

fringe

religions.

Once

that

happened,

how

could

a

scientist

hope

to

get

funding

for

such

a

project?

How

could

a

scientist

expect

to

have

a

career

if

others

came

to

think

of

him

as

a

proponent

of

a

metaphysical

religion?

"No,

I

suppose

it

doesn't."

The

Miro-image

nodded.

"If

the

philotic

ray

twines

in

response

to

the

human

will,

why

couldn't

we

suppose

that

all

philotic

twining

is

willed?

Every

particle,

all

of

matter

and

energy,

why

couldn't

every

observable

phenomenon

in

the

universe

be

the

willing

behavior

of

individuals?"

"Now

we're

beyond

Gangean

Hinduism,"

said

Valentine.

"How

seriously

am

I

supposed

to

take

this?

What

you're

talking

about

is

Animism.

The

most

primitive

kind

of

religion.

Everything's

alive.

Stones

and

oceans

and--"

"No,"

said

Miro.

"Life

is

life."

"Life

is

life,"

said

the

computer

program.

"Life

is

when

a

single

philote

has

the

strength

of

will

to

bind

together

the

molecules

of

a

single

cell,

to

entwine

their

rays

into

one.

A

stronger

philote

can

bind

together

many

cells

into

a

single

organism.

The

strongest

of

all

are

the

intelligent

beings.

We

can

bestow

our

philotic

connections

where

we

will.

The

philotic

basis

of

intelligent

life

is

even

clearer

in

the

other

known

sentient

species.

When

a

pequenino

dies

and

passes

into

the

third

life,

it's

his

strong-willed

philote

that

preserves

his

identity

and

passes

it

from

the

mammaloid

corpse

to

the

living

tree."

"Reincarnation,"

said

Jakt.

"The

philote

is

the

soul."

"It

happens

with

the

piggies,

anyway,"

said

Miro.

"The

hive

queen

as

well,"

said

the

Miro-image.

"The

reason

we

discovered

philotic

connections

in

the

first

place

was

because

we

saw

how

the

buggers

communicated

with

each

other

faster

than

light--

that's

what

showed

us

it

was

possible.

The

individual

buggers

are

all

part

of

the

hive

queen;

they're

like

her

hands

and

feet,

and

she's

their

mind,

one

vast

organism

with

thousands

or

millions

of

bodies.

And

the

only

connection

between

them

is

the

twining

of

their

philotic

rays."

It

was

a

picture

of

the

universe

that

Valentine

had

never

conceived

of

before.

Of

course,

as

a

historian

and

biographer

she

usually

conceived

of

things

in

terms

of

peoples

and

societies;

while

she

wasn't

ignorant

of

physics,

neither

was

she

deeply

trained

in

it.

Perhaps

a

physicist

would

know

at

once

why

this

whole

idea

was

absurd.

But

then,

perhaps

a

physicist

would

be

so

locked

into

the

consensus

of

his

scientific

community

that

it

would

be

harder

for

him

to

accept

an

idea

that

transformed

the

meaning

of

everything

he

knew.

Even

if

it

were

true.

And

she

liked

the

idea

well

enough

to

wish

it

were

true.

Of

the

trillion

lovers

who

had

whispered

to

each

other,

We

are

one,

could

it

be

that

some

of

them

really

were?

Of

the

billions

of

families

who

had

bonded

together

so

closely

they

felt

like

a

single

soul,

wouldn't

it

be

lovely

to

think

that

at

the

most

basic

level

of

reality

it

was

so?

Jakt,

however,

was

not

so

caught

up

in

the

idea.

"I

thought

we

weren't

supposed

to

talk

about

the

existence

of

the

hive

queen,"

he

said.

"I

thought

that

was

Ender's

secret."

"It's

all

right,"

said

Valentine.

"Everyone

in

this

room

knows."

Jakt

gave

her

his

impatient

look.

"I

thought

we

were

coming

to

Lusitania

to

help

in

the

struggle

against

Starways

Congress.

What

does

any

of

this

have

to

do

with

the

real

world?"

"Maybe

nothing,"

said

Valentine.

"Maybe

everything."

Jakt

buried

his

face

in

his

hands

for

a

moment,

then

looked

back

up

at

her

with

a

smile

that

wasn't

really

a

smile.

"I

haven't

heard

you

say

anything

so

transcendental

since

your

brother

left

Trondheim."

That

stung

her,

particularly

because

she

knew

it

was

meant

to.

After

all

these

years,

was

Jakt

still

jealous

of

her

connection

with

Ender?

Did

he

still

resent

the

fact

that

she

could

care

about

things

that

meant

nothing

to

him?

"When

he

went,"

said

Valentine,

"I

stayed."

She

was

really

saying,

I

passed

the

only

test

that

mattered.

Why

should

you

doubt

me

now?

Jakt

was

abashed.

It

was

one

of

the

best

things

about

him,

that

when

he

realized

he

was

wrong

he

backed

down

at

once.

"And

when

you

went,"

said

Jakt,

"I

came

with

you."

Which

she

took

to

mean,

I'm

with

you,

I'm

really

not

jealous

of

Ender

anymore,

and

I'm

sorry

for

sniping

at

you.

Later,

when

they

were

alone,

they'd

say

these

things

again

openly.

It

wouldn't

do

to

reach

Lusitania

with

suspicions

and

jealousy

on

either's

part.

Miro,

of

course,

was

oblivious

to

the

fact

that

Jakt

and

Valentine

had

already

declared

a

truce.

He

was

only

aware

of

the

tension

between

them,

and

thought

he

was

the

cause

of

it.

"I'm

sorry,"

said

Miro.

"I

didn't

mean

to..."

"It's

all

right,"

said

Jakt.

"I

was

out

of

line."

"There

is

no

line,"

said

Valentine,

with

a

smile

at

her

husband.

Jakt

smiled

back.

That

was

what

Miro

needed

to

see;

he

visibly

relaxed.

"Go

on,"

said

Valentine.

"Take

all

that

as

a

given,"

said

the

Miro-image.

Valentine

couldn't

help

it--

she

laughed

out

loud.

Partly

she

laughed

because

this

mystical

Gangean

philote-as-soul

business

was

such

an

absurdly

large

premise

to

swallow.

Partly

she

laughed

to

release

the

tension

between

her

and

Jakt.

"I'm

sorry,"

she

said.

"That's

an

awfully

big

'given.'

If

that's

the

preamble,

I

can't

wait

to

hear

the

conclusion."

Miro,

understanding

her

laughter

now,

smiled

back.

"I've

had

a

lot

of

time

to

think,"

he

said.

"That

really

was

my

speculation

on

what

life

is.

That

everything

in

the

universe

is

behavior.

But

there's

something

else

we

want

to

tell

you

about.

And

ask

you

about,

too,

I

guess."

He

turned

to

Jakt.

"And

it

has

a

lot

to

do

with

stopping

the

Lusitania

Fleet."

Jakt

smiled

and

nodded.

"I

appreciate

being

tossed

a

bone

now

and

then."

Valentine

smiled

her

most

charming

smile.

"So--

later

you'll

be

glad

when

I

break

a

few

bones."

Jakt

laughed

again.

"Go

on,

Miro,"

said

Valentine.

It

was

the

image-Miro

that

responded.

"If

all

of

reality

is

the

behavior

of

philotes,

then

obviously

most

philotes

are

only

smart

enough

or

strong

enough

to

act

as

a

meson

or

hold

together

a

neutron.

A

very

few

of

them

have

the

strength

of

will

to

be

alive--

to

govern

an

organism.

And

a

tiny,

tiny

fraction

of

them

are

powerful

enough

to

control--

no,

to

be--

a

sentient

organism.

But

still,

the

most

complex

and

intelligent

being--

the

hive

queen,

for

instance--

is,

at

core,

just

a

philote,

like

all

the

others.

It

gains

its

identity

and

life

from

the

particular

role

it

happens

to

fulfill,

but

what

it

is

is

a

philote."

"My

self--

my

will--

is

a

subatomic

particle?"

asked

Valentine.

Jakt

smiled,

nodded.

"A

fun

idea,"

he

said.

"My

shoe

and

I

are

brothers."

Miro

smiled

wanly.

The

Miro-image,

however,

answered.

"If

a

star

and

a

hydrogen

atom

are

brothers,

then

yes,

there

is

a

kinship

between

you

and

the

philotes

that

make

up

common

objects

like

your

shoe."

Valentine

noticed

that

Miro

had

not

subvocalized

anything

just

before

the

Miro-image

answered.

How

had

the

software

producing

the

Miro-image

come

up

with

the

analogy

with

stars

and

hydrogen

atoms,

if

Miro

didn't

provide

it

on

the

spot?

Valentine

had

never

heard

of

a

computer

program

capable

of

producing

such

involved

yet

appropriate

conversation

on

its

own.

"And

maybe

there

are

other

kinships

in

the

universe

that

you

know

nothing

of

till

now,"

said

the

Miroimage.

"Maybe

there's

a

kind

of

life

you

haven't

met."

Valentine,

watching

Miro,

saw

that

he

seemed

worried.

Agitated.

As

if

he

didn't

like

what

the

Miro-image

was

doing

now.

"What

kind

of

life

are

you

talking

about?"

asked

Jakt.

"There's

a

physical

phenomenon

in

the

universe,

a

very

common

one,

that

is

completely

unexplained,

and

yet

everyone

takes

it

for

granted

and

no

one

has

seriously

investigated

why

and

how

it

happens.

This

is

it:

None

of

the

ansible

connections

has

ever

broken."

"Nonsense,"

said

Jakt.

"One

of

the

ansibles

on

Trondheim

was

out

of

service

for

six

months

last

year--

it

doesn't

happen

often,

but

it

happens."

Again

Miro's

lips

and

jaw

were

motionless;

again

the

image

answered

immediately.

Clearly

he

was

not

controlling

it

now.

"I

didn't

say

that

the

ansibles

never

break

down.

I

said

that

the

connections--

the

philotic

twining

between

the

parts

of

a

split

meson--

have

never

broken.

The

machinery

of

the

ansible

can

break

down,

the

software

can

get

corrupted,

but

never

has

a

meson

fragment

within

an

ansible

made

the

shift

to

allow

its

philotic

ray

to

entwine

with

another

local

meson

or

even

with

the

nearby

planet."

"The

magnetic

field

suspends

the

fragment,

of

course,"

said

Jakt.

"Split

mesons

don't

endure

long

enough

in

nature

for

us

to

know

how

they

naturally

act,"

said

Valentine.

"I

know

all

the

standard

answers,"

said

the

image.

"All

nonsense.

All

the

kind

of

answers

parents

give

their

children

when

they

don't

know

the

truth

and

don't

want

to

bother

finding

out.

People

still

treat

the

ansibles

like

magic.

Everybody's

glad

enough

that

the

ansibles

keep

on

working;

if

they

tried

to

figure

out

why,

the

magic

might

go

out

of

it

and

then

the

ansibles

would

stop."

"Nobody

feels

that

way,"

said

Valentine.

"They

all

do,"

said

the

image.

"Even

if

it

took

hundreds

of

years,

or

a

thousand

years,

or

three

thousand

years,

one

of

those

connections

should

have

broken

by

now.

One

of

those

meson

fragments

should

have

shifted

its

philotic

ray--

but

they

never

have."

"Why?"

asked

Miro.

Valentine

assumed

at

first

that

Miro

was

asking

a

rhetorical

question.

But

no--

he

was

looking

at

the

image

just

like

the

rest

of

them,

asking

it

to

tell

him

why.

"I

thought

this

program

was

reporting

your

speculations,"

said

Valentine.

"It

was,"

said

Miro.

"But

not

now."

"What

if

there's

a

being

who

lives

among

the

philotic

connections

between

ansibles?"

asked

the

image.

"Are

you

sure

you

want

to

do

this?"

asked

Miro.

Again

he

was

speaking

to

the

image

on

the

screen.

And

the

image

on

the

screen

changed,

to

the

face

of

a

young

woman,

one

that

Valentine

had

never

seen

before.

"What

if

there's

a

being

who

dwells

in

the

web

of

philotic

rays

connecting

the

ansibles

on

every

world

and

every

starship

in

the

human

universe?

What

if

she

is

composed

of

those

philotic

connections?

What

if

her

thoughts

take

place

in

the

spin

and

vibration

of

the

split

pairs?

What

if

her

memories

are

stored

in

the

computers

of

every

world

and

every

ship?"

"Who

are

you?"

asked

Valentine,

speaking

directly

to

the

image.

"Maybe

I'm

the

one

who

keeps

all

those

philotic

connections

alive,

ansible

to

ansible.

Maybe

I'm

a

new

kind

of

organism,

one

that

doesn't

twine

rays

together,

but

instead

keeps

them

twined

to

each

other

so

that

they

never

break

apart.

And

if

that's

true,

then

if

those

connections

ever

broke,

if

the

ansibles

ever

stopped

moving--

if

the

ansibles

ever

fell

silent,

then

I

would

die."

"Who

are

you?"

asked

Valentine

again.

"Valentine,

I'd

like

you

to

meet

Jane,"

said

Miro.

"Ender's

friend.

And

mine."

"Jane."

So

Jane

wasn't

the

code

name

of

a

subversive

group

within

the

Starways

Congress

bureaucracy.

Jane

was

a

computer

program,

a

piece

of

software.

No.

If

what

she

had

just

suggested

was

true,

then

Jane

was

more

than

a

program.

She

was

a

being

who

dwelt

in

the

web

of

philotic

rays,

who

stored

her

memories

in

the

computers

of

every

world.

If

she

was

right,

then

the

philotic

web--

the

network

of

crisscrossing

philotic

rays

that

connected

ansible

to

ansible

on

every

world--

was

her

body,

her

substance.

And

the

philotic

links

continued

working

with

never

a

breakdown

because

she

willed

it

so.

"So

now

I

ask

the

great

Demosthenes,"

said

Jane.

"Am

I

raman

or

varelse?

Am

I

alive

at

all?

I

need

your

answer,

because

I

think

I

can

stop

the

Lusitania

Fleet.

But

before

I

do

it,

I

have

to

know:

Is

it

a

cause

worth

dying

for?"

Jane's

words

cut

Miro

to

the

heart.

She

could

stop

the

fleet--

he

could

see

that

at

once.

Congress

had

sent

the

M.D.

Device

with

several

ships

of

the

fleet,

but

they

had

not

yet

sent

the

order

to

use

it.

They

couldn't

send

the

order

without

Jane

knowing

it

beforehand,

and

with

her

complete

penetration

of

all

the

ansible

communications,

she

could

intercept

the

order

before

it

was

sent.

The

trouble

was

that

she

couldn't

do

it

without

Congress

realizing

that

she

existed--

or

at

least

that

something

was

wrong.

If

the

fleet

didn't

confirm

the

order,

it

would

simply

be

sent

again,

and

again,

and

again.

The

more

she

blocked

the

messages,

the

clearer

it

would

be

to

Congress

that

someone

had

an

impossible

degree

of

control

over

the

ansible

computers.

She

might

avoid

this

by

sending

a

counterfeit

confirmation,

but

then

she

would

have

to

monitor

all

the

communications

between

the

ships

of

the

fleet,

and

between

the

fleet

and

all

planetside

stations,

in

order

to

keep

up

the

pretense

that

the

fleet

knew

something

about

the

kill

order.

Despite

Jane's

enormous

abilities,

this

would

soon

be

beyond

her--

she

could

pay

some

degree

of

attention

to

hundreds,

even

thousands

of

things

at

a

time,

but

it

didn't

take

Miro

long

to

realize

that

there

was

no

way

she

could

handle

all

the

monitoring

and

alterations

this

would

take,

even

if

she

did

nothing

else.

One

way

or

another,

the

secret

would

be

out.

And

as

Jane

explained

her

plan,

Miro

knew

that

she

was

right--

her

best

option,

the

one

with

the

least

chance

of

revealing

her

existence,

was

simply

to

cut

off

all

ansible

communications

between

the

fleet

and

the

planetside

stations,

and

between

the

ships

of

the

fleet.

Let

each

ship

remain

isolated,

the

crew

wondering

what

had

happened,

and

they

would

have

no

choice

but

to

abort

their

mission

or

continue

to

obey

their

original

orders.

Either

they

would

go

away

or

they

would

arrive

at

Lusitania

without

the

authority

to

use

the

Little

Doctor.

In

the

meantime,

however,

Congress

would

know

that

something

had

happened.

It

was

possible

that

with

Congress's

normal

bureaucratic

inefficiency,

no

one

would

ever

figure

out

what

happened.

But

eventually

somebody

would

realize

that

there

was

no

natural

or

human

explanation

of

what

happened.

Someone

would

realize

that

Jane--

or

something

like

her--

must

exist,

and

that

cutting

off

ansible

communications

would

destroy

her.

Once

they

knew

this,

she

would

surely

die.

"Maybe

not,"

Miro

insisted.

"Maybe

you

can

keep

them

from

acting.

Interfere

with

interplanetary

communications,

so

they

can't

give

the

order

to

shut

down

communications."

No

one

answered.

He

knew

why:

she

couldn't

interfere

with

ansible

communications

forever.

Eventually

the

government

on

each

planet

would

reach

the

conclusion

on

its

own.

She

might

live

on

in

constant

warfare

for

years,

decades,

generations.

But

the

more

power

she

used,

the

more

humankind

would

hate

and

fear

her.

Eventually

she

would

be

killed.

"A

book,

then,"

said

Miro.

"Like

the

Hive

Queen

and

the

Hegemon.

Like

the

Life

of

Human.

The

Speaker

for

the

Dead

could

write

it.

To

persuade

them

not

to

do

it."

"Maybe,"

said

Valentine.

"She

can't

die,"

said

Miro.

"I

know

that

we

can't

ask

her

to

take

that

chance,"

said

Valentine.

"But

if

it's

the

only

way

to

save

the

hive

queen

and

the

pequeninos--"

Miro

was

furious.

"You

can

talk

about

her

dying!

What

is

Jane

to

you?

A

program,

a

piece

of

software.

But

she's

not,

she's

real,

she's

as

real

as

the

hive

queen,

she's

as

real

as

any

of

the

piggies--"

"More

real

to

you,

I

think,"

said

Valentine.

"As

real,"

said

Miro.

"You

forget--

I

know

the

piggies

like

my

own

brothers--"

"But

you're

able

to

contemplate

the

possibility

that

destroying

them

may

be

morally

necessary."

"Don't

twist

my

words."

"I'm

untwisting

them,"

said

Valentine.

"You

can

contemplate

losing

them,

because

they're

already

lost

to

you.

Losing

Jane,

though--"

"Because

she's

my

friend,

does

that

mean

I

can't

plead

for

her?

Can

life-and-death

decisions

only

be

made

by

strangers?"

Jakt's

voice,

quiet

and

deep,

interrupted

the

argument.

"Calm

down,

both

of

you.

It

isn't

your

decision.

It's

Jane's.

She

has

the

right

to

determine

the

value

of

her

own

life.

I'm

no

philosopher,

but

I

know

that."

"Well

said,"

Valentine

answered.

Miro

knew

that

Jakt

was

right,

that

it

was

Jane's

choice.

But

he

couldn't

bear

that,

because

he

also

knew

what

she

would

decide.

Leaving

the

choice

up

to

Jane

was

identical

to

asking

her

to

do

it.

And

yet,

in

the

end,

the

choice

would

be

up

to

her

anyway.

He

didn't

even

have

to

ask

her

what

she

would

decide.

Time

passed

so

quickly

for

her,

especially

since

they

were

already

traveling

at

near-lightspeed,

that

she

had

probably

decided

already.

It

was

too

much

to

bear.

To

lose

Jane

now

would

be

unbearable;

just

thinking

of

it

threatened

Miro's

composure.

He

didn't

want

to

show

such

weakness

in

front

of

these

people.

Good

people,

they

were

good

people,

but

he

didn't

want

them

to

see

him

lose

control

of

himself.

So

Miro

leaned

forward,

found

his

balance,

and

precariously

lifted

himself

from

his

seat.

It

was

hard,

since

only

a

few

of

his

muscles

responded

to

his

will,

and

it

took

all

his

concentration

just

to

walk

from

the

bridge

to

his

compartment.

No

one

followed

him

or

even

spoke

to

him.

He

was

glad

of

that.

Alone

in

his

room,

he

lay

down

on

his

bunk

and

called

to

her.

But

not

aloud.

He

subvocalized,

because

that

was

his

custom

when

he

talked

to

her.

Even

though

the

others

on

this

ship

now

knew

of

her

existence,

he

had

no

intention

of

losing

the

habits

that

had

kept

her

concealed

till

now.

"Jane,"

he

said

silently.

"Yes,"

said

the

voice

in

his

ear.

He

imagined,

as

always,

that

her

soft

voice

came

from

a

woman

just

out

of

sight,

but

close,

very

close.

He

shut

his

eyes,

so

he

could

imagine

her

better.

Her

breath

on

his

cheek.

Her

hair

dangling

over

his

face

as

she

spoke

to

him

softly,

as

he

answered

in

silence.

"Talk

to

Ender

before

you

decide,"

he

said.

"I

already

did.

Just

now,

while

you

were

thinking

about

this."

"What

did

he

say?"

"To

do

nothing.

To

decide

nothing,

until

the

order

is

actually

sent."

"That's

right.

Maybe

they

won't

do

it."

"Maybe.

Maybe

a

new

group

with

different

policies

will

come

into

power.

Maybe

this

group

will

change

its

mind.

Maybe

Valentine's

propaganda

will

succeed.

Maybe

there'll

be

a

mutiny

on

the

fleet."

This

last

was

so

unlikely

that

Miro

realized

Jane

absolutely

believed

that

the

order

would

be

sent.

"How

soon?"

asked

Miro.

"The

fleet

should

arrive

in

about

fifteen

years.

A

year

or

less

after

these

two

ships

get

there.

That's

how

I

timed

your

voyage.

The

order

will

be

sent

sometime

before.

Maybe

six

months

before

arrival--

which

would

be

aboul

eight

hours

ship's

time

before

the

fleet

drops

out

of

lightspeed

and

staggerss

down

to

normal

speeds."

"Don't

do

it,"

said

Miro.

"I

haven't

decided."

"Yes

you

have.

You've

decided

to

do

it."

She

said

nothing.

"Don't

leave

me,"

he

said.

"I

don't

leave

my

friends

if

I

don't

have

to,"

she

said.

"Some

people

do,

but

I

don't."

"Just

don't,"

he

said

again.

He

was

crying.

Could

she

see

that,

sense

it

somehow

through

the

jewel

in

his

ear?

"I'll

try."

"Find

another

way.

Find

another

way

to

stop

them.

Find

some

way

to

put

yourself

outside

the

philotic

net

so

they

can't

kill

you."

"That's

what

Ender

said."

"Then

do

it!"

"I

can

search

for

such

a

way,

but

who

knows

if

it

exists?"

"It

has

to."

"This

is

why

I

wonder

sometimes

whether

I'm

alive

or

not.

You

living

creatures,

you

think

that

because

you

want

something

very

much,

it

has

to

happen.

That

wishing

something

with

all

your

heart

will

make

it

so."

"How

can

you

search

for

something

if

you

don't

believe

that

it

exists?"

"Either

I

search

or

I

don't,"

said

Jane.

"I

don't

get

distracted

or

bored

like

humans

do.

I'll

try

to

think

of

something

else."

"Think

of

this,

too,"

said

Miro.

"Think

of

who

you

are.

Of

how

your

mind

works.

You

can't

possibly

find

a

way

of

saving

your

life

until

you

understand

how

you

came

to

life

in

the

first

place.

And

once

you

understand

yourself--"

"Then

maybe

I

can

make

a

copy

and

store

it

somewhere."

"Maybe."

"Maybe,"

she

echoed.

But

he

knew

she

didn't

believe

it,

and

neither

did

he.

She

existed

in

the

philotic

network

of

the

ansibles;

she

could

store

her

memories

in

the

network

of

computers

on

every

world

and

every

ship

in

space,

but

there

was

nowhere

that

she

could

put

her

self,

not

if

it

required

a

network

of

philotic

links.

Unless.

"What

about

the

fathertrees

on

Lusitania?

They

communicate

philotically,

don't

they?"

"It's

not

the

same

thing,"

said

Jane.

"It

isn't

digital.

It

isn't

coded

the

way

the

ansibles

are."

"It

may

not

be

digital,

but

the

information

gets

transferred

somehow,

it

works

philotically.

And

the

hive

queen,

too--

she

communicates

with

the

buggers

that

way."

"No

chance

of

that,"

said

Jane.

"The

structure's

too

simple.

Her

communication

with

them

isn't

a

network.

They're

all

connected

only

to

her."

"How

do

you

know

it

won't

work,

when

you

don't

even

know

for

sure

how

you

function?"

"All

right.

I'll

think

about

it."

"Think

hard,"

he

said.

"I

only

know

one

way

to

think,"

said

Jane.

"I

mean,

pay

attention

to

it."

She

could

follow

many

trains

of

thought

at

once,

but

her

thoughts

were

prioritized,

with

many

different

levels

of

attention.

Miro

didn't

want

her

relegating

her

self-investigation

to

some

low

order

of

attention.

"I'll

pay

attention,"

she

said.

"Then

you'll

think

of

something,"

he

said.

"You

will."

She

didn't

answer

for

a

while.

He

thought

this

meant

that

the

conversation

was

over.

His

thoughts

began

to

wander.

To

try

to

imagine

what

life

would

be

like,

still

in

this

body,

only

without

Jane.

It

could

happen

before

he

even

arrived

on

Lusitania.

And

if

it

did,

this

voyage

would

have

been

the

most

terrible

mistake

of

his

life.

By

traveling

at

lightspeed,

he

was

skipping

thirty

years

of

realtime.

Thirty

years

that

might

have

been

spent

with

Jane.

He

might

be

able

to

deal

with

losing

her

then.

But

losing

her

now,

only

a

few

weeks

into

knowing

her--

he

knew

that

his

tears

arose

from

self-pity,

but

he

shed

them

all

the

same.

"Miro,"

she

said.

"What?"

he

asked.

"How

can

I

think

of

something

that's

never

been

thought

of

before?"

For

a

moment

he

didn't

understand.

"Miro,

how

can

I

figure

out

something

that

isn't

just

the

logical

conclusion

of

things

that

human

beings

have

already

figured

out

and

written

somewhere?"

"You

think

of

things

all

the

time,"

said

Miro.

"I'm

trying

to

conceive

of

something

inconceivable.

I'm

trying

to

find

answers

to

questions

that

human

beings

have

never

even

tried

to

ask."

"Can't

you

do

that?"

"If

I

can't

think

original

thoughts,

does

that

mean

that

I'm

nothing

but

a

computer

program

that

got

out

of

hand?"

"Hell,

Jane,

most

people

never

have

an

original

thought

in

their

lives."

He

laughed

softly.

"Does

that

mean

they're

just

ground-dwelling

apes

that

got

out

of

hand?"

"You

were

crying,"

she

said.

"Yes."

"You

don't

think

I

can

think

of

a

way

out

of

this.

You

think

I'm

going

to

die."

"I

believe

you

can

think

of

a

way.

I

really

do.

But

that

doesn't

stop

me

from

being

afraid."

"Afraid

that

I'll

die."

"Afraid

that

I'll

lose

you."

"Would

that

be

so

terrible?

To

lose

me?"

"Oh

God,"

he

whispered.

"Would

you

miss

me

for

an

hour?"

she

insisted.

"For

a

day?

For

a

year?"

What

did

she

want

from

him?

Assurance

that

when

she

was

gone

she'd

be

remembered?

That

someone

would

yearn

for

her?

Why

would

she

doubt

that?

Didn't

she

know

him

yet?

Maybe

she

was

human

enough

that

she

simply

needed

reassurance

of

things

she

already

knew.

"Forever,"

he

said.

It

was

her

turn

to

laugh.

Playfully.

"You

won't

live

that

long,"

she

said.

"Now

you

tell

me,"

he

said.

This

time

when

she

fell

silent,

she

didn't

come

back,

and

Miro

was

left

alone

with

his

thoughts.

Valentine,

Jakt,

and

Plikt

had

remained

together

on

the

bridge,

talking

through

the

things

they

had

learned,

trying

to

decide

what

they

might

mean,

what

might

happen.

The

only

conclusion

they

reached

was

that

while

the

future

couldn't

be

known,

it

would

probably

be

a

good

deal

better

than

their

worst

fears

and

nowhere

near

as

good

as

their

best

hopes.

Wasn't

that

how

the

world

always

worked?

"Yes,"

said

Plikt.

"Except

for

the

exceptions."

That

was

Plikt's

way.

Except

when

she

was

teaching,

she

said

little,

but

when

she

did

speak,

it

had

a

way

of

ending

the

conversation.

Plikt

got

up

to

leave

the

bridge,

headed

for

her

miserably

uncomfortable

bed;

as

usual,

Valentine

tried

to

persuade

her

to

go

back

to

the

other

starship.

"Varsam

and

Ro

don't

want

me

in

their

room,"

said

Plikt.

"They

don't

mind

a

bit."

"Valentine,"

said

Jakt,

"Plikt

doesn't

want

to

go

back

to

the

other

ship

because

she

doesn't

want

to

miss

anything."

"Oh,"

said

Valentine.

Plikt

grinned.

"Good

night."

Soon

after,

Jakt

also

left

the

bridge.

His

hand

rested

on

Valentine's

shoulder

for

a

moment

as

he

left.

"I'll

be

there

soon,"

she

said.

And

she

meant

it

at

the

moment,

meant

to

follow

him

almost

at

once.

Instead

she

remained

on

the

bridge,

thinking,

brooding,

trying

to

make

sense

of

a

universe

that

would

put

all

the

nonhuman

species

ever

known

to

man

at

risk

of

extinction,

all

at

once.

The

hive

queen,

the

pequeninos,

and

now

Jane,

the

only

one

of

her

kind,

perhaps

the

only

one

that

ever

could

exist.

A

veritable

profusion

of

intelligent

life,

and

yet

known

only

to

a

few.

And

all

of

them

in

line

to

be

snuffed

out.

At

least

Ender

will

realize

at

last

that

this

is

the

natural

order

of

things,

that

he

might

not

be

as

responsible

for

the

destruction

of

the

buggers

three

thousand

years

ago

as

he

had

always

thought.

Xenocide

must

be

built

into

the

universe.

No

mercy,

not

even

for

the

greatest

players

in

the

game.

How

could

she

have

ever

thought

otherwise?

Why

should

intelligent

species

be

immune

to

the

threat

of

extinction

that

looms

over

every

species

that

ever

came

to

be?

It

must

have

been

an

hour

after

Jakt

left

the

bridge

before

Valentine

finally

turned

off

her

terminal

and

stood

up

to

go

to

bed.

On

a

whim,

though,

she

paused

before

leaving

and

spoke

into

the

air.

"Jane?"

she

said.

"Jane?"

No

answer.

There

was

no

reason

for

her

to

expect

one.

It

was

Miro

who

wore

the

jewel

in

his

ear.

Miro

and

Ender

both.

How

many

people

did

she

think

Jane

could

monitor

at

one

time?

Maybe

two

was

the

most

she

could

handle.

Or

maybe

two

thousand.

Or

two

million.

What

did

Valentine

know

of

the

limitations

of

a

being

who

existed

as

a

phantom

in

the

philotic

web?

Even

if

Jane

heard

her,

Valentine

had

no

right

to

expect

that

she

would

answer

her

call.

Valentine

stopped

in

the

corridor,

directly

between

Miro's

door

and

the

door

to

the

room

she

shared

with

Jakt.

The

doors

were

not

soundproof.

She

could

hear

Jakt's

soft

snoring

inside

their

compartment.

She

also

heard

another

sound.

Miro's

breath.

He

wasn't

sleeping.

He

might

be

crying.

She

hadn't

raised

three

children

without

being

able

to

recognize

that

ragged,

heavy

breathing.

He's

not

my

child.

I

shouldn't

meddle.

She

pushed

open

the

door;

it

was

noiseless,

but

it

cast

a

shaft

of

light

across

the

bed.

Miro's

crying

stopped

immediately,

but

he

looked

at

her

through

swollen

eyes.

"What

do

you

want?"

he

said.

She

stepped

into

the

room

and

sat

on

the

floor

beside

his

bunk,

so

their

faces

were

only

a

few

inches

apart.

"You've

never

cried

for

yourself,

have

you?"

she

said.

"A

few

times."

"But

tonight

you're

crying

for

her."

"Myself

as

much

as

her."

Valentine

leaned

closer,

put

her

arm

around

him,

pulled

his

head

onto

her

shoulder.

"No,"

he

said.

But

he

didn't

pull

away.

And

after

a

few

moments,

his

arm

swung

awkwardly

around

to

embrace

her.

He

didn't

cry

anymore,

but

he

did

let

her

hold

him

for

a

minute

or

two.

Maybe

it

helped.

Valentine

had

no

way

of

knowing.

Then

he

was

done.

He

pulled

away,

rolled

onto

his

back.

"I'm

sorry,"

he

said.

"You're

welcome,"

she

said.

She

believed

in

answering

what

people

meant,

not

what

they

said.

"Don't

tell

Jakt,"

he

whispered.

"Nothing

to

tell,"

she

said.

"We

had

a

good

talk."

She

got

up

and

left,

closing

his

door

behind

her.

He

was

a

good

boy.

She

liked

the

fact

that

he

could

admit

caring

what

Jakt

thought

about

him.

And

what

did

it

matter

if

his

tears

tonight

had

self-pity

in

them?

She

had

shed

a

few

like

that

herself.

Grief,

she

reminded

herself,

is

almost

always

for

the

mourner's

loss.

Chapter

5

--

THE

LUSITANIA

FLEET

<Ender

says

that

when

the

war

fleet

from

Starways

Congress

reaches

us,

they

plan

to

destroy

this

world.>

<Interesting.>

<You

don't

fear

death?>

<We

don't

intend

to

be

here

when

they

arrive.>

Qing-jao

was

no

longer

the

little

girl

whose

hands

had

bled

in

secret.

Her

life

had

been

transformed

from

the

moment

she

was

proved

to

be

godspoken,

and

in

the

ten

years

since

that

day

she

had

come

to

accept

the

voice

of

the

gods

in

her

life

and

the

role

this

gave

her

in

society.

She

learned

to

accept

the

privileges

and

honors

given

to

her

as

gifts

actually

meant

for

the

gods;

as

her

father

taught

her,

she

did

not

take

on

airs,

but

instead

grew

more

humble

as

the

gods

and

the

people

laid

ever-heavier

burdens

on

her.

She

took

her

duties

seriously,

and

found

joy

in

them.

For

the

past

ten

years

she

had

passed

through

a

rigorous,

exhilarating

course

of

studies.

Her

body

was

shaped

and

trained

in

the

company

of

other

children-

-

running,

swimming,

riding,

combat-with-swords,

combat-with-sticks,

combat-with-bones.

Along

with

other

children,

her

memory

was

filled

with

languages--

Stark,

the

common

speech

of

the

stars,

which

was

typed

into

computers;

Old

Chinese,

which

was

sung

in

the

throat

and

drawn

in

beautiful

ideograms

on

rice

paper

or

in

fine

sand;

and

New

Chinese,

which

was

merely

spoken

at

the

mouth

and

jotted

down

with

a

common

alphabet

on

ordinary

paper

or

in

dirt.

No

one

was

surprised

except

Qing-jao

herself

that

she

learned

all

these

languages

much

more

quickly

and

easily

and

thoroughly

than

any

of

the

other

children.

Other

teachers

came

to

her

alone.

This

was

how

she

learned

sciences

and

history,

mathematics

and

music.

And

every

week

she

would

go

to

her

father

and

spend

half

a

day

with

him,

showing

him

all

that

she

had

learned

and

listening

to

what

he

said

in

response.

His

praise

made

her

dance

all

the

way

back

to

her

room;

his

mildest

rebuke

made

her

spend

hours

tracing

woodgrain

lines

in

her

schoolroom,

until

she

felt

worthy

to

return

to

studying.

Another

part

of

her

schooling

was

utterly

private.

She

had

seen

for

herself

how

Father

was

so

strong

that

he

could

postpone

his

obedience

to

the

gods.

She

knew

that

when

the

gods

demanded

a

ritual

of

purification,

the

hunger,

the

need

to

obey

them

was

so

exquisite

it

could

not

be

denied.

And

yet

Father

somehow

denied

it--

long

enough,

at

least,

that

his

rituals

were

always

in

private.

Qing-jao

longed

for

such

strength

herself,

and

so

she

began

to

discipline

herself

to

delay.

When

the

gods

made

her

feel

her

oppressive

unworthiness,

and

her

eyes

began

to

search

for

woodgrain

lines

or

her

hands

began

to

feel

unbearably

filthy,

she

would

wait,

trying

to

concentrate

on

what

was

happening

at

the

moment

and

put

off

obedience

as

long

as

she

could.

At

first

it

was

a

triumph

if

she

managed

to

postpone

her

purification

for

a

full

minute--

and

when

her

resistance

broke,

the

gods

punished

her

for

it

by

making

the

ritual

more

onerous

and

difficult

than

usual.

But

she

refused

to

give

up.

She

was

Han

Fei-tzu's

daughter,

wasn't

she?

And

in

time,

over

the

years,

she

learned

what

her

father

had

learned:

that

one

could

live

with

the

hunger,

contain

it,

often

for

hours,

like

a

bright

fire

encased

in

a

box

of

translucent

jade,

a

dangerous,

terrible

fire

from

the

gods,

burning

within

her

heart.

Then,

when

she

was

alone,

she

could

open

that

box

and

let

the

fire

out,

not

in

a

single,

terrible

eruption,

but

slowly,

gradually,

filling

her

with

light

as

she

bowed

her

head

and

traced

the

lines

on

the

floor,

or

bent

over

the

sacred

laver

of

her

holy

washings,

quietly

and

methodically

rubbing

her

hands

with

pumice,

lye,

and

aloe.

Thus

she

converted

the

raging

voice

of

the

gods

into

a

private,

disciplined

worship.

Only

at

rare

moments

of

sudden

distress

did

she

lose

control

and

fling

herself

to

the

floor

in

front

of

a

teacher

or

visitor.

She

accepted

these

humiliations

as

the

gods'

way

of

reminding

her

that

their

power

over

her

was

absolute,

that

her

usual

self-control

was

only

permitted

for

their

amusement.

She

was

content

with

this

imperfect

discipline.

After

all,

it

would

be

presumptuous

of

her

to

equal

her

father's

perfect

self-control.

His

extraordinary

nobility

came

because

the

gods

honored

him,

and

so

did

not

require

his

public

humiliation;

she

had

done

nothing

to

earn

such

honor.

Last

of

all,

her

schooling

included

one

day

each

week

helping

with

the

righteous

labor

of

the

common

people.

Righteous

labor,

of

course,

was

not

the

work

the

common

people

did

every

day

in

their

offices

and

factories.

Righteous

labor

meant

the

backbreaking

work

of

the

rice

paddies.

Every

man

and

woman

and

child

on

Path

had

to

perform

this

labor,

bending

and

stooping

in

shin-deep

water

to

plant

and

harvest

the

rice--

or

forfeit

citizenship.

"This

is

how

we

honor

our

ancestors,"

Father

explained

to

her

when

she

was

little.

"We

show

them

that

none

of

us

will

ever

rise

above

doing

their

labor."

The

rice

that

was

grown

by

righteous

labor

was

considered

holy;

it

was

offered

in

the

temples

and

eaten

on

holy

days;

it

was

placed

in

small

bowls

as

offerings

to

the

household

gods.

Once,

when

Qing-jao

was

twelve,

the

day

was

terribly

hot

and

she

was

eager

to

finish

her

work

on

a

research

project.

"Don't

make

me

go

to

the

rice

paddies

today,"

she

said

to

her

teacher.

"What

I'm

doing

here

is

so

much

more

important."

The

teacher

bowed

and

went

away,

but

soon

Father

came

into

her

room.

He

carried

a

heavy

sword,

and

she

screamed

in

terror

when

he

raised

it

over

his

head.

Did

he

mean

to

kill

her

for

having

spoken

so

sacrilegiously?

But

he

did

not

hurt

her--

how

could

she

have

imagined

that

he

might?

Instead

the

sword

came

down

on

her

computer

terminal.

The

metal

parts

twisted;

the

plastic

shattered

and

flew.

The

machine

was

destroyed.

Father

did

not

raise

his

voice.

It

was

in

the

faintest

whisper

that

he

said,

"First

the

gods.

Second

the

ancestors.

Third

the

people.

Fourth

the

rulers.

Last

the

self."

It

was

the

clearest

expression

of

the

Path.

It

was

the

reason

this

world

was

settled

in

the

first

place.

She

had

forgotten:

If

she

was

too

busy

to

perform

righteous

labor,

she

was

not

on

the

Path.

She

would

never

forget

again.

And,

in

time,

she

learned

to

love

the

sun

beating

down

on

her

back,

the

water

cool

and

murky

around

her

legs

and

hands,

the

stalks

of

the

rice

plants

like

fingers

reaching

up

from

the

mud

to

intertwine

with

her

fingers.

Covered

with

muck

in

the

rice

paddies,

she

never

felt

unclean,

because

she

knew

that

she

was

filthy

in

the

service

of

the

gods.

Finally,

at

the

age

of

sixteen,

her

schooling

was

finished.

She

had

only

to

prove

herself

in

a

grown

woman's

task--

one

that

was

difficult

and

important

enough

that

it

could

be

entrusted

only

to

one

who

was

godspoken.

She

came

before

the

great

Han

Fei-tzu

in

his

room.

Like

hers,

it

was

a

large

open

space;

like

hers,

the

sleeping

accommodation

was

simple,

a

mat

on

the

floor;

like

hers,

the

room

was

dominated

by

a

table

with

a

computer

terminal

on

it.

She

had

never

entered

her

father's

room

without

seeing

something

floating

in

the

display

above

the

terminal--

diagrams,

threedimensional

models,

realtime

simulations,

words.

Most

commonly

words.

Letters

or

ideographs

floating

in

the

air

on

simulated

pages,

moving

back

and

forward,

side

to

side

as

Father

needed

to

compare

them.

In

Qing-jao's

room,

all

the

rest

of

the

space

was

empty.

Since

Father

did

not

trace

woodgrain

lines,

he

had

no

need

for

that

much

austerity.

Even

so,

his

tastes

were

simple.

One

rug--

only

rarely

one

that

had

much

decoration

to

it.

One

low

table,

with

one

sculpture

standing

on

it.

Walls

bare

except

for

one

painting.

And

because

the

room

was

so

large,

each

one

of

these

things

seemed

almost

lost,

like

the

faint

voice

of

someone

crying

out

from

very

far

away.

The

message

of

this

room

to

visitors

was

clear:

Han

Fei-tzu

chose

simplicity.

One

of

each

thing

was

enough

for

a

pure

soul.

The

message

to

Qing-jao,

however,

was

quite

different.

For

she

knew

what

no

one

outside

the

household

realized:

The

rug,

the

table,

the

sculpture,

and

the

painting

were

changed

every

day.

And

never

in

her

life

had

she

recognized

any

one

of

them.

So

the

lesson

she

learned

was

this:

A

pure

soul

must

never

grow

attached

to

any

one

thing.

A

pure

soul

must

expose

himself

to

new

things

every

day.

Because

this

was

a

formal

occasion,

she

did

not

come

and

stand

behind

him

as

he

worked,

studying

what

appeared

in

his

display,

trying

to

guess

what

he

was

doing.

This

time

she

came

to

the

middle

of

the

room

and

knelt

on

the

plain

rug,

which

was

today

the

color

of

a

robin's

egg,

with

a

small

stain

in

one

corner.

She

kept

her

eyes

down,

not

even

studying

the

stain,

until

Father

got

up

from

his

chair

and

came

to

stand

before

her.

"Han

Qing-jao,"

he

said.

"Let

me

see

the

sunrise

of

my

daughter's

face."

She

lifted

her

head,

looked

at

him,

and

smiled.

He

smiled

back.

"What

I

will

set

before

you

is

not

an

easy

task,

even

for

an

experienced

adult,"

said

Father.

Qing-jao

bowed

her

head.

She

had

expected

that

Father

would

set

a

hard

challenge

for

her,

and

she

was

ready

to

do

his

will.

"Look

at

me,

my

Qing-jao,"

said

Father.

She

lifted

her

head,

looked

into

his

eyes.

"This

is

not

going

to

be

a

school

assignment.

This

is

a

task

from

the

real

world.

A

task

that

Starways

Congress

has

given

me,

on

which

the

fate

of

nations

and

peoples

and

worlds

may

rest."

Qing-jao

had

been

tense

already,

but

now

Father

was

frightening

her.

"Then

you

must

give

this

task

to

someone

who

can

be

trusted

with

it,

not

to

an

untried

child."

"You

haven't

been

a

child

in

years,

Qing-jao.

Are

you

ready

to

hear

your

task?"

"Yes,

Father."

"What

do

you

know

about

the

Lusitania

Fleet?"

"Do

you

want

me

to

tell

you

everything

I

know

about

it?"

"I

want

you

to

tell

me

all

that

you

think

matters."

So--

this

was

a

kind

of

test,

to

see

how

well

she

could

distill

the

important

from

the

unimportant

in

her

knowledge

about

a

particular

subject.

"The

fleet

was

sent

to

subdue

a

rebellious

colony

on

Lusitania,

where

laws

concerning

noninterference

in

the

only

known

alien

species

had

been

defiantly

broken."

Was

that

enough?

No--

Father

was

still

waiting.

"There

was

controversy,

right

from

the

start,"

she

said.

"Essays

attributed

to

a

person

called

Demosthenes

stirred

up

trouble."

"What

trouble,

in

particular?"

"To

colony

worlds,

Demosthenes

gave

warning

that

the

Lusitania

Fleet

was

a

dangerous

precedent--

it

would

be

only

a

matter

of

time

before

Starways

Congress

used

force

to

compel

their

obedience,

too.

To

Catholic

worlds

and

Catholic

minorities

everywhere,

Demosthenes

charged

that

Congress

was

trying

to

punish

the

Bishop

of

Lusitania

for

sending

missionaries

to

the

pequeninos

to

save

their

souls

from

hell.

To

scientists,

Demosthenes

sent

warning

that

the

principle

of

independent

research

was

at

stake--

a

whole

world

was

under

military

attack

because

it

dared

to

prefer

the

judgment

of

the

scientists

on

the

scene

to

the

judgment

of

bureaucrats

many

light-years

away.

And

to

everyone,

Demosthenes

made

claims

that

the

Lusitania

Fleet

carried

the

Molecular

Disruption

Device.

Of

course

that

is

an

obvious

lie,

but

some

believed

it."

"How

effective

were

these

essays?"

asked

Father.

"I

don't

know."

"They

were

very

effective,"

said

Father.

"Fifteen

years

ago,

the

earliest

essays

to

the

colonies

were

so

effective

that

they

almost

caused

revolution."

A

near-rebellion

in

the

colonies?

Fifteen

years

ago?

Qing-jao

knew

of

only

one

such

event,

but

she

had

never

realized

it

had

anything

to

do

with

Demosthenes'

essays.

She

blushed.

"That

was

the

time

of

the

Colony

Charter--

your

first

great

treaty."

"The

treaty

was

not

mine,"

said

Han

Fei-tzu.

"The

treaty

belonged

equally

to

Congress

and

the

colonies.

Because

of

it

a

terrible

conflict

was

avoided.

And

the

Lusitania

Fleet

continues

on

its

great

mission."

"You

wrote

every

word

of

the

treaty,

Father."

"In

doing

so

I

only

found

expression

for

the

wishes

and

desires

already

in

the

hearts

of

the

people

on

both

sides

of

the

issue.

I

was

a

clerk."

Qing-jao

bowed

her

head.

She

knew

the

truth,

and

so

did

everyone

else.

It

had

been

the

beginning

of

Han

Fei-tzu's

greatness,

for

he

not

only

wrote

the

treaty

but

also

persuaded

both

sides

to

accept

it

almost

without

revision.

Ever

after

that,

Han

Fei-tzu

had

been

one

of

the

most

trusted

advisers

to

Congress;

messages

arrived

daily

from

the

greatest

men

and

women

of

every

world.

If

he

chose

to

call

himself

a

clerk

in

that

great

undertaking,

that

was

only

because

he

was

a

man

of

great

modesty.

Qing-jao

also

knew

that

Mother

was

already

dying

as

he

accomplished

all

this

work.

That

was

the

kind

of

man

her

father

was,

for

he

neglected

neither

his

wife

nor

his

duty.

He

could

not

save

Mother's

life,

but

he

could

save

the

lives

that

might

have

been

lost

in

war.

"Qing-jao,

why

do

you

say

that

it

is

an

obvious

lie

that

the

fleet

is

carrying

the

M.D.

Device?"

"Because--

because

that

would

be

monstrous.

It

would

be

like

Ender

the

Xenocide,

destroying

an

entire

world.

So

much

power

has

no

right

or

reason

to

exist

in

the

universe."

"Who

taught

you

this?"

"Decency

taught

me

this,"

said

Qing-jao.

"The

gods

made

the

stars

and

all

the

planets--

who

is

man

to

unmake

them?"

"But

the

gods

also

made

the

laws

of

nature

that

make

it

possible

to

destroy

them--

who

is

man

to

refuse

to

receive

what

the

gods

have

given?"

Qing-jao

was

stunned

to

silence.

She

had

never

heard

Father

speak

in

apparent

defense

of

any

aspect

of

war--

he

loathed

war

in

any

form.

"I

ask

you

again--

who

taught

you

that

so

much

power

has

no

right

or

reason

to

exist

in

the

universe?"

"It's

my

own

idea."

"But

that

sentence

is

an

exact

quotation."

"Yes.

From

Demosthenes.

But

if

I

believe

an

idea,

it

becomes

my

own.

You

taught

me

that."

"You

must

be

careful

that

you

understand

all

the

consequences

of

an

idea

before

you

believe

it."

"The

Little

Doctor

must

never

be

used

on

Lusitania,

and

therefore

it

should

not

have

been

sent."

Han

Fei-tzu

nodded

gravely.

"How

do

you

know

it

must

never

be

used?"

"Because

it

would

destroy

the

pequeninos,

a

young

and

beautiful

people

who

are

eager

to

fulfill

their

potential

as

a

sentient

species."

"Another

quotation."

"Father,

have

you

read

the

Life

of

Human?"

"I

have."

"Then

how

can

you

doubt

that

the

pequeninos

must

be

preserved?"

"I

said

I

had

read

the

Life

of

Human.

I

didn't

say

that

I

believed

it."

"You

don't

believe

it?"

"I

neither

believe

it

nor

disbelieve

it.

The

book

first

appeared

after

the

ansible

on

Lusitania

had

been

destroyed.

Therefore

it

is

probable

that

the

book

did

not

originate

there,

and

if

it

didn't

originate

there

then

it's

fiction.

That

seems

particularly

likely

because

it's

signed

'Speaker

for

the

Dead,'

which

is

the

same

name

signed

to

the

Hive

Queen

and

the

Hegemon,

which

are

thousands

of

years

old.

Someone

was

obviously

trying

to

capitalize

on

the

reverence

people

feel

toward

those

ancient

works."

"I

believe

the

Life

of

Human

is

true."

"That's

your

privilege,

Qing-jao.

But

why

do

you

believe

it?"

Because

it

sounded

true

when

she

read

it.

Could

she

say

that

to

Father?

Yes,

she

could

say

anything.

"Because

when

I

read

it

I

felt

that

it

must

be

true."

"I

see."

"Now

you

know

that

I'm

foolish."

"On

the

contrary.

I

know

that

you

are

wise.

When

you

hear

a

true

story,

there

is

a

part

of

you

that

responds

to

it

regardless

of

art,

regardless

of

evidence.

Let

it

be

clumsily

told

and

you

will

still

love

the

tale,

if

you

love

truth.

Let

it

be

the

most

obvious

fabrication

and

you

will

still

believe

whatever

truth

is

in

it,

because

you

cannot

deny

truth

no

matter

how

shabbily

it

is

dressed."

"Then

how

is

it

that

you

don't

believe

the

Life

of

Human?"

"I

spoke

unclearly.

We

are

using

two

different

meanings

of

the

words

truth

and

belief.

You

believe

that

the

story

is

true,

because

you

responded

to

it

from

that

sense

of

truth

deep

within

you.

But

that

sense

of

truth

does

not

respond

to

a

story's

factuality--

to

whether

it

literally

depicts

a

real

event

in

the

real

world.

Your

inner

sense

of

truth

responds

to

a

story's

causality--

to

whether

it

faithfully

shows

the

way

the

universe

functions,

the

way

the

gods

work

their

will

among

human

beings."

Qing-jao

thought

for

only

a

moment,

then

nodded

her

understanding.

"So

the

Life

of

Human

may

be

universally

true,

but

specifically

false."

"Yes,"

said

Han

Fei-tzu.

"You

can

read

the

book

and

gain

great

wisdom

from

it,

because

it

is

true.

But

is

that

book

an

accurate

representation

of

the

pequeninos

themselves?

One

can

hardly

believe

that--

a

mammaloid

species

that

turns

into

a

tree

when

it

dies?

Beautiful

as

poetry.

Ludicrous

as

science."

"But

can

you

know

that,

either,

Father?"

"I

can't

be

sure,

no.

Nature

has

done

many

strange

things,

and

there

is

a

chance

that

the

Life

of

Human

is

genuine

and

true.

Thus

I

neither

believe

it

nor

disbelieve

it.

I

hold

it

in

abeyance.

I

wait.

Yet

while

I'm

waiting,

I

don't

expect

Congress

to

treat

Lusitania

as

if

it

were

populated

by

the

fanciful

creatures

from

the

Life

of

Human.

For

all

we

know,

the

pequeninos

may

be

deadly

dangerous

to

us.

They

are

aliens."

"Ramen."

"In

the

story.

But

raman

or

varelse,

we

do

not

know

what

they

are.

The

fleet

carries

the

Little

Doctor

because

it

might

be

necessary

to

save

mankind

from

unspeakable

peril.

It

is

not

up

to

us

to

decide

whether

or

not

it

should

be

used--

Congress

will

decide.

It

is

not

up

to

us

to

decide

whether

it

should

have

been

sent-

-

Congress

has

sent

it.

And

it

is

certainly

not

up

to

us

to

decide

whether

it

should

exist--

the

gods

have

decreed

that

such

a

thing

is

possible

and

can

exist."

"So

Demosthenes

was

right.

The

M.D.

Device

is

with

the

fleet."

"Yes."

"And

the

government

files

that

Demosthenes

published--

they

were

genuine."

"Yes.:

"But

Father--

you

joined

many

others

in

claiming

that

they

were

forgeries."

"Just

as

the

gods

speak

only

to

a

chosen

few,

so

the

secrets

of

the

rulers

must

be

known

only

to

those

who

will

use

the

knowledge

properly.

Demosthenes

was

giving

powerful

secrets

to

people

who

were

not

fit

to

use

them

wisely,

and

so

for

the

good

of

the

people

those

secrets

had

to

be

withdrawn.

The

only

way

to

retrieve

a

secret,

once

it

is

known,

is

to

replace

it

with

a

lie;

then

the

knowledge

of

the

truth

is

once

again

your

secret."

"You're

telling

me

that

Demosthenes

is

not

a

liar,

and

Congress

is."

"I'm

telling

you

that

Demosthenes

is

the

enemy

of

the

gods.

A

wise

ruler

would

never

have

sent

the

Lusitania

Fleet

without

giving

it

the

possibility

of

responding

to

any

circumstance.

But

Demosthenes

has

used

his

knowledge

that

the

Little

Doctor

is

with

the

fleet

in

order

to

try

to

force

Congress

to

withdraw

the

fleet.

Thus

he

wishes

to

take

power

out

of

the

hands

of

those

whom

the

gods

have

ordained

to

rule

humankind.

What

would

happen

to

the

people

if

they

rejected

the

rulers

given

them

by

the

gods?"

"Chaos

and

suffering,"

said

Qing-jao.

History

was

full

of

times

of

chaos

and

suffering,

until

the

gods

sent

strong

rulers

and

institutions

to

keep

order.

"So

Demosthenes

told

the

truth

about

the

Little

Doctor.

Did

you

think

the

enemies

of

the

gods

could

never

speak

the

truth?

I

wish

it

were

so.

It

would

make

them

much

easier

to

identify."

"If

we

can

lie

in

the

service

of

the

gods,

what

other

crimes

can

we

commit?"

"What

is

a

crime?"

"An

act

that's

against

the

law."

"What

law?"

"I

see--

Congress

makes

the

law,

so

the

law

is

whatever

Congress

says.

But

Congress

is

composed

of

men

and

women,

who

may

do

good

and

evil."

"Now

you're

nearer

the

truth.

We

can't

do

crimes

in

the

service

of

Congress,

because

Congress

makes

the

laws.

But

if

Congress

ever

became

evil,

then

in

obeying

them

we

might

also

be

doing

evil.

That

is

a

matter

of

conscience.

However,

if

that

happened,

Congress

would

surely

lose

the

mandate

of

heaven.

And

we,

the

godspoken,

don't

have

to

wait

and

wonder

about

the

mandate

of

heaven,

as

others

do.

If

Congress

ever

loses

the

mandate

of

the

gods,

we

will

know

at

once."

"So

you

lied

for

Congress

because

Congress

had

the

mandate

of

heaven."

"And

therefore

I

knew

that

to

help

them

keep

their

secret

was

the

will

of

the

gods

for

the

good

of

the

people."

Qing-jao

had

never

thought

of

Congress

in

quite

this

way

before.

All

the

history

books

she

had

studied

showed

Congress

as

the

great

unifier

of

humanity,

and

according

to

the

schoolbooks,

all

its

acts

were

noble.

Now,

though,

she

understood

that

some

of

its

actions

might

not

seem

good.

Yet

that

didn't

necessarily

mean

that

they

were

not

good.

"I

must

learn

from

the

gods,

then,

whether

the

will

of

Congress

is

also

their

will,"

she

said.

"Will

you

do

that?"

asked

Han

Fei-tzu.

"Will

you

obey

the

will

of

Congress,

even

when

it

might

seem

wrong,

as

long

as

Congress

has

the

mandate

of

heaven?"

"Are

you

asking

for

my

oath?"

"I

am."

"Then

yes,

I

will

obey,

as

long

as

they

have

the

mandate

of

heaven."

"I

had

to

have

that

oath

from

you

to

satisfy

the

security

requirements

of

Congress,"

he

said.

"I

couldn't

have

given

you

your

task

without

it."

He

cleared

his

throat.

"But

now

I

ask

you

for

another

oath."

"I'll

give

it

if

I

can."

"This

oath

is

from--

it

arises

from

great

love.

Han

Qing-jao,

will

you

serve

the

gods

in

all

things,

in

all

ways,

throughout

your

life?"

"Oh,

Father,

we

need

no

oath

for

this.

Haven't

the

gods

chosen

me

already,

and

led

me

with

their

voice?"

"Nevertheless

I

ask

you

for

this

oath."

"Always,

in

all

things,

in

all

ways,

I

will

serve

the

gods."

To

her

surprise,

Father

knelt

before

her

and

took

her

hands

in

his.

Tears

streamed

down

his

cheeks.

"You

have

lifted

from

my

heart

the

heaviest

burden

that

was

ever

laid

there."

"How

did

I

do

this,

Father?"

"Before

your

mother

died,

she

asked

me

for

my

promise.

She

said

that

since

her

entire

character

was

expressed

by

her

devotion

to

the

gods,

the

only

way

I

could

help

you

to

know

her

was

to

teach

you

also

to

serve

the

gods.

All

my

life

I

have

still

been

afraid

that

I

might

fail,

that

you

might

turn

away

from

the

gods.

That

you

might

come

to

hate

them.

Or

that

you

might

not

be

worthy

of

their

voice."

This

struck

Qing-jao

to

the

heart.

She

was

always

conscious

of

her

deep

unworthiness

before

the

gods,

of

her

filthiness

in

their

sight--

even

when

they

weren't

requiring

her

to

watch

or

trace

woodgrain

lines.

Only

now

did

she

learn

what

was

at

stake:

her

mother's

love

for

her.

"All

my

fears

are

gone

now.

You

are

a

perfect

daughter,

my

Qing-jao.

You

already

serve

the

gods

well.

And

now,

with

your

oath,

I

can

be

sure

you'll

continue

forever.

This

will

cause

great

rejoicing

in

the

house

in

heaven

where

your

mother

dwells."

Will

it?

In

heaven

they

know

my

weakness.

You,

Father,

you

only

see

that

I

have

not

yet

failed

the

gods;

Mother

must

know

how

close

I've

come

so

many

times,

how

filthy

I

am

whenever

the

gods

look

upon

me.

But

he

seemed

so

full

of

joy

that

she

dared

not

show

him

how

much

she

dreaded

the

day

when

she

would

prove

her

unworthiness

for

all

to

see.

So

she

embraced

him.

Still,

she

couldn't

help

asking

him,

"Father,

do

you

really

think

Mother

heard

me

make

that

oath?"

"I

hope

so,"

said

Han

Fei-tzu.

"If

she

didn't,

the

gods

will

surely

save

the

echo

of

it

and

put

it

in

a

seashell

and

let

her

listen

to

it

whenever

she

puts

it

to

her

ear."

This

sort

of

fanciful

storytelling

was

a

game

they

had

played

together

as

children.

Qing-jao

set

aside

her

dread

and

quickly

came

up

with

an

answer.

"No,

the

gods

will

save

the

touch

of

our

embrace

and

weave

it

into

a

shawl,

which

she

can

wear

around

her

shoulders

when

winter

comes

to

heaven."

She

was

relieved,

anyway,

that

Father

had

not

said

yes.

He

only

hoped

that

Mother

had

heard

the

oath

she

made.

Perhaps

she

hadn't--

band

so

she

wouldn't

be

so

disappointed

when

her

daughter

failed.

Father

kissed

her,

then

stood

up.

"Now

you

are

ready

to

hear

your

task,"

he

said.

He

took

her

by

the

hand

and

led

her

to

his

table.

She

stood

beside

him

when

he

sat

on

his

chair;

she

was

not

much

taller,

standing,

than

he

was

sitting

down.

Probably

she

had

not

yet

reached

her

adult

height,

but

she

hoped

she

wouldn't

grow

much

more.

She

didn't

want

to

become

one

of

those

large,

hulking

women

who

carried

heavy

burdens

in

the

fields.

Better

to

be

a

mouse

than

a

hog,

that's

what

Mu-pao

had

told

her

years

ago.

Father

brought

a

starmap

up

into

the

display.

She

recognized

the

area

immediately.

It

centered

on

the

Lusitania

star

system,

though

the

scale

was

too

small

for

individual

planets

to

be

visible.

"Lusitania

is

in

the

center,"

she

said.

Father

nodded.

He

typed

a

few

more

commands.

"Now

watch

this,"

he

said.

"Not

the

display,

my

fingers.

This,

plus

your

voice

identification,

is

the

password

that

will

allow

you

to

access

the

information

you'll

need."

She

watched

him

type:

4Gang.

She

recognized

the

reference

at

once.

Her

mother's

ancestor-of-the-heart

had

been

Jiang-qing,

the

widow

of

the

first

Communist

Emperor,

Mao

Ze-dong.

When

Jiang-qing

and

her

allies

were

driven

from

power,

the

Conspiracy

of

Cowards

vilified

them

under

the

name

"Gang

of

Four."

Qing-jao's

mother

had

been

a

true

daughter-of-the-heart

to

that

great

martyred

woman

of

the

past.

And

now

Qing-jao

would

be

able

to

do

further

honor

to

her

mother's

ancestor-of-the-heart

every

time

she

typed

the

access

code.

It

was

a

gracious

thing

for

her

father

to

arrange.

In

the

display

there

appeared

many

green

dots.

She

quickly

counted,

almost

without

thinking:

there

were

nineteen

of

them,

clustered

at

some

distance

from

Lusitania,

but

surrounding

it

in

most

directions.

"Is

that

the

Lusitania

Fleet?"

"Those

were

their

positions

five

months

ago."

He

typed

again.

The

green

dots

all

disappeared.

"And

those

are

their

positions

today."

She

looked

for

them.

She

couldn't

find

a

green

dot

anywhere.

Yet

Father

clearly

expected

her

to

see

something.

"Are

they

already

at

Lusitania?"

"The

ships

are

where

you

see

them,"

said

Father.

"Five

months

ago

the

fleet

disappeared."

"Where

did

it

go?"

"No

one

knows."

"Was

it

a

mutiny?"

"No

one

knows."

"The

whole

fleet?"

"Every

ship."

"When

you

say

they

disappeared,

what

do

you

mean?"

Father

glanced

at

her

with

a

smile.

"Well

done,

Qing-jao.

You've

asked

the

right

question.

No

one

saw

them--

they

were

all

in

deep

space.

So

they

didn't

physically

disappear.

As

far

as

we

know,

they

may

be

moving

along,

still

on

course.

They

only

disappeared

in

the

sense

that

we

lost

all

contact

with

them.

"

"The

ansibles?"

"Silent.

All

within

the

same

three-minute

period.

No

transmissions

were

interrupted.

One

would

end,

and

then

the

next

one--

never

came."

"Every

ship's

connection

with

every

planetside

ansible

everywhere?

That's

impossible.

Even

an

explosion--

if

there

could

be

one

so

large--

but

it

couldn't

be

a

single

event,

anyway,

because

they

were

so

widely

distributed

around

Lusitania.

"

"Well,

it

could

be,

Qing-jao.

If

you

can

imagine

an

event

so

cataclysmic--

it

could

be

that

Lusitania's

star

became

a

supernova.

It

would

be

decades

before

we

saw

the

flash

even

on

the

closest

worlds.

The

trouble

is

that

it

would

be

the

most

unlikely

supernova

in

history.

Not

impossible,

but

unlikely."

"And

there

would

have

been

some

advance

indications.

Some

changes

in

the

star's

condition.

Didn't

the

ships'

instruments

detect

something?"

"No.

That's

why

we

don't

think

it

was

any

known

astronomical

phenomenon.

Scientists

can't

think

of

anything

to

explain

it.

So

we've

tried

investigating

it

as

sabotage.

We've

searched

for

penetrations

of

the

ansible

computers.

We've

raked

over

all

the

personnel

files

from

every

ship,

searching

for

some

possible

conspiracy

among

the

shipboard

crews.

There's

been

cryptoanalysis

of

every

communication

by

every

ship,

searching

for

some

kind

of

messages

among

conspirators.

The

military

and

the

government

have

analyzed

everything

they

can

think

of

to

analyze.

The

police

on

every

planet

have

conducted

inquiries--

we've

checked

the

background

on

every

ansible

operator."

"Even

though

no

messages

are

being

sent,

are

the

ansibles

still

connected?"

"What

do

you

think?"

Qing-jao

blushed.

"Of

course

they

would

be,

even

if

an

M.D.

Device

had

been

used

against

the

fleet,

because

the

ansibles

are

linked

by

fragments

of

subatomic

particles.

They'd

still

be

there

even

if

the

whole

starship

were

blown

to

dust."

"Don't

be

embarrassed,

Qing-jao.

The

wise

are

not

wise

because

they

make

no

mistakes.

They

are

wise

because

they

correct

their

mistakes

as

soon

as

they

recognize

them."

However,

Qing-jao

was

blushing

now

for

another

reason.

The

hot

blood

was

pounding

in

her

head

because

it

had

only

now

dawned

on

her

what

Father's

assignment

for

her

was

going

to

be.

But

that

was

impossible.

He

couldn't

give

to

her

a

task

that

thousands

of

wiser,

older

people

had

already

failed

at.

"Father,"

she

whispered.

"What

is

my

task?"

She

still

hoped

that

it

was

some

minor

problem

involved

with

the

disappearance

of

the

fleet.

But

she

knew

that

her

hope

was

in

vain

even

before

he

spoke.

"You

must

discover

every

possible

explanation

for

the

disappearance

of

the

fleet,"

he

said,

"and

calculate

the

likelihood

of

each

one.

Starways

Congress

must

be

able

to

tell

how

this

happened

and

how

to

make

sure

it

will

never

happen

again."

"But

Father,"

said

Qing-jao,

"I'm

only

sixteen.

Aren't

there

many

others

who

are

wiser

than

I

am?"

"Perhaps

they're

all

too

wise

to

attept

the

task,"

he

said.

"But

you

are

young

enough

not

to

fancy

yourself

wise.

You're

young

enough

to

think

of

impossible

things

and

discover

why

they

might

be

possible.

Above

all,

gods

speak

to

you

with

extraordinary

clarity,

my

brilliant

child,

my

Gloriously

Bright."

That

was

what

she

was

afraid

of--

that

Father

expected

her

to

succeed

because

of

the

favor

of

the

gods.

He

didn't

understand

how

unworthy

the

gods

found

her,

how

little

they

liked

her.

And

there

was

another

problem.

"What

if

I

succeed?

What

if

I

find

out

where

the

Lusitania

Fleet

is,

and

restore

communications?

Wouldn't

it

then

be

my

fault

if

the

fleet

destroyed

Lusitania?"

"It's

good

that

your

first

thought

is

compassion

for

the

people

of

Lusitania.

I

assure

you

that

Starways

Congress

has

promised

not

to

use

the

M.D.

Device

unless

it

proves

absolutely

unavoidable,

and

that

is

so

unlikely

that

I

can't

believe

it

would

happen.

Even

if

it

did,

though,

it's

Congress

that

must

decide.

As

my

ancestor-of-the-heart

said,

'Though

the

wise

man's

punishments

may

be

light,

this

is

not

due

to

his

compassion;

though

his

penalties

may

be

severe,

this

is

not

because

he

is

cruel;

he

simply

follows

the

custom

appropriate

to

the

time.

Circumstances

change

according

to

the

age,

and

ways

of

dealing

with

them

change

with

the

circumstances.'

You

may

be

sure

that

Starways

Congress

will

deal

with

Lusitania,

not

according

to

kindness

or

cruelty,

but

according

to

what

is

necessary

for

the

good

of

all

humanity.

That

is

why

we

serve

the

rulers:

because

they

serve

the

people,

who

serve

the

ancestors,

who

serve

the

gods."

"Father,

I

was

unworthy

even

to

think

otherwise,"

said

Qing-jao.

She

felt

her

filthiness

now,

instead

of

just

knowing

it

in

her

mind.

She

needed

to

wash

her

hands.

She

needed

to

trace

a

line.

But

she

contained

it.

She

would

wait.

Whatever

I

do,

she

thought,

there

will

be

a

terrible

consequence.

If

I

fail,

then

Father

will

lose

honor

before

Congress

and

therefore

before

all

the

world

of

Path.

That

would

prove

to

many

that

Father

isn't

worthy

to

be

chosen

god

of

Path

when

he

dies.

Yet

if

I

succeed,

the

result

might

be

xenocide.

Even

though

the

choice

belongs

to

Congress,

I

would

still

know

that

I

made

such

a

thing

possible.

The

responsibility

would

be

partly

mine.

No

matter

what

I

do,

I

will

be

covered

with

failure

and

smeared

with

unworthiness.

Then

Father

spoke

to

her

as

if

the

gods

had

shown

him

her

heart.

"Yes,

you

were

unworthy,"

he

said,

"and

you

continue

to

be

unworthy

in

your

thoughts

even

now."

Qing-jao

blushed

and

bowed

her

head,

ashamed,

not

that

her

thoughts

had

been

so

plainly

visible

to

her

father,

but

that

she

had

had

such

disobedient

thoughts

at

all.

Father

touched

her

shoulder

gently

with

his

hand.

"But

I

believe

the

gods

will

make

you

worthy,"

said

Father.

"Starways

Congress

has

the

mandate

of

heaven,

but

you

are

also

chosen

to

walk

your

own

path.

You

can

succeed

in

this

great

work.

Will

you

try?"

"I

will

try."

I

will

also

fail,

but

that

will

surprise

no

one,

least

of

all

the

gods,

who

know

my

unworthiness.

"All

the

pertinent

archives

have

been

opened

up

to

your

searching,

when

you

speak

your

name

and

type

the

password.

If

you

need

help,

let

me

know."

She

left

Father's

room

with

dignity,

and

forced

herself

to

walk

slowly

up

the

stairs

to

her

room.

Only

when

she

was

inside

with

the

door

closed

did

she

throw

herself

to

her

knees

and

creep

along

the

floor.

She

traced

woodgrain

lines

until

she

could

hardly

see.

Her

unworthiness

was

so

great

that

even

then

she

didn't

quite

feel

clean;

she

went

to

the

lavatory

and

scrubbed

her

hands

until

she

knew

the

gods

were

satisfied.

Twice

the

servants

tried

to

interrupt

her

with

meals

or

messages--

she

cared

little

which--

but

when

they

saw

that

she

was

communing

with

the

gods

they

bowed

and

quietly

slipped

away.

It

was

not

the

washing

of

her

hands,

though,

that

finally

made

her

clean.

It

was

the

moment

when

she

drove

the

last

vestige

of

uncertainty

from

her

heart.

Starways

Congress

had

the

mandate

of

heaven.

She

must

purge

herself

of

all

doubt.

Whatever

they

meant

to

do

with

the

Lusitania

Fleet,

it

was

surely

the

will

of

the

gods

that

it

be

accomplished.

Therefore

it

was

her

duty

to

help

them

accomplish

it.

And

if

she

was

in

fact

doing

the

will

of

the

gods,

then

they

would

open

a

way

for

her

to

solve

the

problem

that

had

been

set

before

her.

Anytime

she

thought

otherwise,

anytime

the

words

of

Demosthenes

returned

to

her

mind,

she

would

have

to

blot

them

out

by

remembering

that

she

would

obey

the

rulers

who

have

the

mandate

of

heaven.

By

the

time

her

mind

was

calm,

her

palms

were

raw

and

dotted

with

blood

seeping

up

from

the

layers

of

living

skin

that

were

now

so

close

to

the

surface.

This

is

how

my

understanding

of

the

truth

arises,

she

told

herself.

If

I

wash

away

enough

of

my

mortality,

then

the

truth

of

the

gods

will

seep

upward

into

the

light.

She

was

clean

at

last.

The

hour

was

late

and

her

eyes

were

tired.

Nevertheless,

she

sat

down

before

her

terminal

and

began

the

work.

"Show

me

summaries

of

all

the

research

that

has

been

conducted

so

far

on

the

disappearance

of

the

Lusitania

Fleet,"

she

said,

"starting

with

the

most

recent."

Almost

at

once

words

started

appearing

in

the

air

above

her

terminal,

page

upon

page

lined

up

like

soldiers

marching

to

the

front.

She

would

read

one,

then

scroll

it

out

of

the

way,

only

to

have

the

page

behind

it

move

to

the

front

for

her

to

read

it.

Seven

hours

she

read

until

she

could

read

no

more;

then

she

fell

asleep

before

the

terminal.

***

Jane

watches

everything.

She

can

do

a

million

jobs

and

pay

attention

to

a

thousand

things

at

once.

Neither

of

these

capacities

is

infinite,

but

they're

so

much

greater

than

our

pathetic

ability

to

think

about

one

thing

while

doing

another

that

they

might

as

well

be.

She

does

have

a

sensory

limitation

that

we

don't

have,

however;

or,

rather,

we

are

her

greatest

limitation.

She

can't

see

or

know

anything

that

hasn't

been

entered

as

data

in

a

computer

that

is

tied

to

the

great

interworld

network.

That's

less

of

a

limitation

than

you

might

think.

She

has

almost

immediate

access

to

the

raw

inputs

of

every

starship,

every

satellite,

every

traffic

control

system,

and

almost

every

electronically-monitored

spy

device

in

the

human

universe.

But

it

does

mean

that

she

almost

never

witnesses

lovers'

quarrels,

bedtime

stories,

classroom

arguments,

supper-table

gossip,

or

bitter

tears

privately

shed.

She

only

knows

that

aspect

of

our

lives

that

we

represent

as

digital

information.

If

you

asked

her

the

exact

number

of

human

beings

in

the

settled

worlds,

she

would

quickly

give

you

a

number

based

on

census

figures

combined

with

birth-and-death

probabilities

in

all

our

population

groups.

In

most

cases,

she

could

match

numbers

with

names,

though

no

human

could

live

long

enough

to

read

the

list.

And

if

you

took

a

name

you

just

happened

to

think

of--

Han

Qing-jao,

for

instance--

and

you

asked

Jane,

"Who

is

this

person?"

she'd

almost

immediately

give

you

the

vital

statistics--

birth

date,

citizenship,

parentage,

height

and

weight

at

last

medical

checkup,

grades

in

school.

But

that

is

all

gratuitous

information,

background

noise

to

her;

she

knows

it's

there,

but

it

means

nothing.

To

ask

her

about

Han

Qing-jao

would

be

something

like

asking

her

a

question

about

a

certain

molecule

of

water

vapor

in

a

distant

cloud.

The

molecule

is

certainly

there,

but

there's

nothing

special

to

differentiate

it

from

the

million

others

in

its

immediate

vicinity.

That

was

true

until

the

moment

that

Han

Qing-jao

began

to

use

her

computer

to

access

all

the

reports

dealing

with

the

disappearance

of

the

Lusitania

Fleet.

Then

Qing-jao's

name

moved

many

levels

upward

in

Jane's

attention.

Jane

began

to

keep

a

log

of

everything

that

Qing-jao

did

with

her

computer.

And

it

quickly

became

clear

to

her

that

Han

Qing-jao,

though

she

was

only

sixteen,

meant

to

make

serious

trouble

for

Jane.

Because

Han

Qing-jao,

unconnected

as

she

was

to

any

particular

bureaucracy,

having

no

ideological

axe

to

grind

or

vested

interest

to

protect,

was

taking

a

broader

and

therefore

more

dangerous

look

at

all

the

information

that

had

been

collected

by

every

human

agency.

Why

was

it

dangerous?

Had

Jane

left

clues

behind

that

Qing-jao

would

find?

No,

of

course

not.

Jane

left

no

clues.

She

had

thought

of

leaving

some,

of

trying

to

make

the

disappearance

of

the

Lusitania

Fleet

look

like

sabotage

or

mechanical

failure

or

some

natural

disaster.

She

had

to

give

up

on

that

idea,

because

she

couldn't

work

up

any

physical

clues.

All

she

could

do

was

leave

misleading

data

in

computer

memories.

None

of

it

would

ever

have

any

physical

analogue

in

the

real

world,

and

therefore

any

halfway-intelligent

researcher

would

quickly

realize

that

the

clues

were

all

faked-up

data.

Then

he

would

conclude

that

the

disappearance

of

the

Lusitania

Fleet

had

to

have

been

caused

by

some

agency

that

had

unimaginably

detailed

access

to

the

computer

systems

that

had

the

false

data.

Surely

that

would

lead

people

to

discover

her

far

more

quickly

than

if

she

left

no

evidence

at

all.

Leaving

no

evidence

was

the

best

course,

definitely;

and

until

Han

Qing-jao

began

her

investigation,

it

had

worked

very

well.

Each

investigating

agency

looked

only

in

the

places

they

usually

looked.

The

police

on

many

planets

checked

out

all

the

known

dissident

groups

(and,

in

some

places,

tortured

various

dissidents

until

they

made

useless

confessions,

at

which

point

the

interrogators

filed

final

reports

and

pronounced

the

issue

closed).

The

military

looked

for

evidence

of

military

opposition--

especially

alien

starships,

since

the

military

had

keen

memories

of

the

invasion

of

the

buggers

three

thousand

years

before.

Scientists

looked

for

evidence

of

some

unexpected

invisible

astronomical

phenomenon

that

could

account

for

either

the

destruction

of

the

fleet

or

the

selective

breakdown

of

ansible

communication.

The

politicians

looked

for

somebody

else

to

blame.

Nobody

imagined

Jane,

and

therefore

nobody

found

her.

But

Han

Qing-jao

was

putting

everything

together,

carefully,

systematically,

running

precise

searches

on

the

data.

She

would

inevitably

turn

up

the

evidence

that

could

eventually

prove--

and

end--

Jane's

existence.

That

evidence

was,

simply

put,

the

lack

of

evidence.

Nobody

else

could

see

it,

because

nobody

had

ever

brought

an

unbiased

methodical

mind

to

the

investigation.

What

Jane

couldn't

know

was

that

Qing-jao's

seemingly

inhuman

patience,

her

meticulous

attention

to

detail,

her

constant

rephrasing

and

reprogramming

of

computer

searches,

that

all

of

these

were

the

result

of

endless

hours

kneeling

hunched

over

on

a

wooden

floor,

carefully

following

a

grain

in

the

wood

from

one

end

of

a

board

to

the

other,

from

one

side

of

a

room

to

the

other.

Jane

couldn't

begin

to

guess

that

it

was

the

great

lesson

taught

her

by

the

gods

that

made

Qing-jao

her

most

formidable

opponent.

All

Jane

knew

was

that

at

some

point,

this

searcher

named

Qing-jao

would

probably

realize

what

no

one

else

really

understood:

that

every

conceivable

explanation

for

the

disappearance

of

the

Lusitania

Fleet

had

already

been

completely

eliminated.

At

that

point

only

one

conclusion

would

remain:

that

some

force

not

yet

encountered

anywhere

in

the

history

of

humankind

had

the

power

either

to

make

a

widely

scattered

fleet

of

starships

disappear

simultaneously,

or--

just

as

unlikely--

to

make

that

fleet's

ansibles

all

stop

functioning

at

once.

And

if

that

same

methodical

mind

then

started

listing

possible

forces

that

might

have

such

power,

eventually

it

was

bound

to

name

the

one

that

was

true:

an

independent

entity

that

dwelt

among--

no,

that

was

composed

of--

the

philotic

rays

connecting

all

ansibles

together.

Because

this

idea

was

true,

no

amount

of

logical

scrutiny

or

research

would

eliminate

it.

Eventually

this

idea

would

be

left

standing

alone.

And

at

that

point,

somebody

would

surely

act

on

Qing-jao's

discovery

and

set

out

to

destroy

Jane.

So

Jane

watched

Qing-jao's

research

with

more

and

more

fascination.

This

sixteen-year-old

daughter

of

Han

Fei-tzu,

who

weighed

39

kilograms

and

stood

160

centimeters

tall

and

was

in

the

uppermost

social

and

intellectual

class

on

the

Taoist

Chinese

world

of

Path,

was

the

first

human

being

Jane

had

ever

found

who

approached

the

thoroughness

and

precision

of

a

computer

and,

therefore,

of

Jane

herself.

And

though

Jane

could

conduct

in

an

hour

the

search

that

was

taking

Qing-jao

weeks

and

months

to

complete,

the

dangerous

truth

was

that

Qing-jao

was

performing

almost

exactly

the

search

Jane

herself

would

have

conducted;

and

therefore

there

was

no

reason

for

Jane

to

suppose

that

Qing-jao

would

not

reach

the

conclusion

that

Jane

herself

would

reach.

Qing-jao

was

therefore

Jane's

most

dangerous

enemy,

and

Jane

was

helpless

to

stop

her--

at

least

physically.

Trying

to

block

Qing-jao's

access

to

information

would

only

mean

leading

her

more

quickly

to

the

knowledge

of

Jane's

existence.

So

instead

of

open

opposition,

Jane

searched

for

another

way

to

stop

her

eney.

She

did

not

understand

all

of

human

nature,

but

Ender

had

taught

her

this:

to

stop

a

human

being

from

doing

something,

you

must

find

a

way

to

make

the

person

stop

wanting

to

do

it.

Chapter

6

--

VARELSE

<How

are

you

able

to

speak

directly

into

Ender's

mind?>

<Now

that

we

know

where

he

is,

it's

as

natural

as

eating.>

<How

did

you

find

him?

I've

never

been

able

to

speak

into

the

mind

of

anyone

who

hasn't

passed

into

the

third

life.>

<We

found

him

through

the

ansibles,

and

the

electronics

connected

to

them--

found

where

his

body

was

in

space.

To

reach

his

mind,

we

had

to

reach

into

chaos

and

form

a

bridge.>

<Bridge?>

<A

transitional

entity,

which

partly

resembled

his

mind

and

partly

ours.>

<If

you

could

reach

his

mind,

why

didn't

you

stop

him

from

destroying

you?>

<The

human

brain

is

very

strange.

Before

we

could

make

sense

of

what

we

found

there,

before

we

could

learn

how

to

speak

into

that

twisted

space,

all

my

sisters

and

mothers

were

gone.

We

continued

to

study

his

mind

during

all

the

years

we

waited,

cocooned,

until

he

found

us;

when

he

come,

then

we

could

speak

directly

to

him.>

<What

happened

to

the

bridge

you

made?>

<We

never

thought

about

it.

It's

probably

still

out

there

somewhere.>

The

new

strain

of

potatoes

was

dying.

Ender

saw

the

telltale

brown

circles

in

the

leaves,

the

plants

broken

off

where

the

stems

had

turned

so

brittle

that

the

slightest

breeze

bent

them

till

they

snapped.

This

morning

they

had

all

been

healthy.

The

onset

of

this

disease

was

so

sudden,

its

effect

so

devastating,

that

it

could

only

be

the

descolada

virus.

Ela

and

Novinha

would

be

disappointed--

they

had

had

such

hopes

for

this

strain

of

potato.

Ela,

Ender's

stepdaughter,

had

been

working

on

a

gene

that

would

cause

every

cell

in

an

organism

to

produce

three

different

chemicals

that

were

known

to

inhibit

or

kill

the

descolada

virus.

Novinha,

Ender's

wife,

had

been

working

on

a

gene

that

would

cause

cell

nuclei

to

be

impermeable

to

any

molecule

larger

than

one-tenth

the

size

of

the

descolada.

With

this

strain

of

potato,

they

had

spliced

in

both

genes

and,

when

early

tests

showed

that

both

traits

had

taken

hold,

Ender

had

brought

the

seedlings

to

the

experimental

farm

and

planted

them.

He

and

his

assistants

had

nurtured

them

for

the

past

six

weeks.

All

had

seemed

to

be

going

well.

If

the

technique

had

worked,

it

could

have

been

adapted

to

all

the

plants

and

animals

that

the

humans

of

Lusitania

depended

on

for

food.

But

the

descolada

virus

was

too

clever

by

half--

it

saw

through

all

their

stratagems,

eventually.

Still,

six

weeks

was

better

than

the

normal

two

or

three

days.

Maybe

they

were

on

the

right

track.

Or

maybe

things

had

already

gone

too

far.

Back

when

Ender

first

arrived

on

Lusitania,

new

strains

of

Earthborn

plants

and

animals

could

last

as

long

as

twenty

years

in

the

field

before

the

descolada

decoded

their

genetic

molecules

and

tore

them

apart.

But

in

recent

years

the

descolada

virus

had

apparently

made

a

breakthrough

that

allowed

it

to

decode

any

genetic

molecule

from

Earth

in

days

or

even

hours.

These

days

the

only

thing

that

allowed

the

human

colonists

to

grow

their

plants

and

raise

their

animals

was

a

spray

that

was

immediately

fatal

to

the

descolada

virus.

There

were

human

colonists

who

wanted

to

spray

the

whole

planet

and

wipe

out

the

descolada

virus

once

and

for

all.

Spraying

a

whole

planet

was

impractical,

but

not

impossible;

there

were

other

reasons

for

rejecting

that

option.

Every

form

of

native

life

absolutely

depended

on

the

descolada

in

order

to

reproduce.

That

included

the

piggies--

the

pequeninos,

the

intelligent

natives

of

this

world--

whose

reproductive

cycle

was

inextricably

bound

up

with

the

only

native

species

of

tree.

If

the

descolada

virus

were

ever

destroyed,

this

generation

of

pequeninos

would

be

the

last.

It

would

be

xenocide.

So

far,

the

idea

of

doing

anything

that

would

wipe

out

the

piggies

would

be

immediately

rejected

by

most

of

the

people

of

Milagre,

the

village

of

humans.

So

far.

But

Ender

knew

that

many

minds

would

change

if

a

few

more

facts

were

widely

known.

For

instance,

only

a

handful

of

people

knew

that

twice

already

the

descolada

had

adapted

itself

to

the

chemical

they

were

using

to

kill

it.

Ela

and

Novinha

had

already

developed

several

new

versions

of

the

chemical,

so

that

the

next

time

the

descolada

adapted

to

one

viricide

they

could

switch

immediately

to

another.

Likewise,

they

had

once

had

to

change

the

descolada

inhibitor

that

kept

human

beings

from

dying

of

the

descolada

viruses

that

dwelt

in

every

human

in

the

colony.

The

inhibitor

was

added

to

all

the

colony's

food,

so

that

every

human

being

ingested

it

with

every

meal.

However,

all

the

inhibitors

and

viricides

worked

on

the

same

basic

principles.

Someday,

just

as

the

descolada

virus

had

learned

how

to

adapt

to

Earthborn

genes

in

general,

it

would

also

learn

how

to

handle

each

class

of

chemicals,

and

then

it

wouldn't

matter

how

many

new

versions

they

had--

the

descolada

would

exhaust

their

resources

in

days.

Only

a

few

people

knew

how

precarious

Milagre's

survival

really

was.

Only

a

few

people

understood

how

much

was

riding

on

the

work

that

Ela

and

Novinha,

as

Lusitania's

xenobiologists,

were

doing;

how

close

their

contest

was

with

the

descolada;

how

devastating

the

consequences

would

be

if

they

ever

fell

behind.

Just

as

well.

If

the

colonists

did

understand,

there

would

be

many

who

would

say,

If

it's

inevitable

that

someday

the

descolada

will

overwhelm

us,

then

let's

wipe

it

out

now.

If

that

kills

all

the

piggies

then

we're

sorry,

but

if

it's

us

or

them,

we

choose

us.

It

was

fine

for

Ender

to

take

the

long

view,

the

philosophical

perspective,

and

say,

Better

for

one

small

human

colony

to

perish

than

to

wipe

out

an

entire

sentient

species.

He

knew

this

argument

would

carry

no

water

with

the

humans

of

Lusitania.

Their

own

lives

were

at

stake

here,

and

the

lives

of

their

children;

it

would

be

absurd

to

expect

them

to

be

willing

to

die

for

the

sake

of

another

species

that

they

didn't

understand

and

that

few

of

them

even

liked.

It

would

make

no

sense

genetically--

evolution

encourages

only

creatures

who

are

serious

about

protecting

their

own

genes.

Even

if

the

Bishop

himself

declared

it

to

be

the

will

of

God

that

the

human

beings

of

Lusitania

lay

down

their

lives

for

the

piggies,

there

would

be

precious

few

who

would

obey.

I'm

not

sure

I

could

make

such

a

sacrifice

myself,

thought

Ender.

Even

though

I

have

no

children

of

my

own.

Even

though

I

have

already

lived

through

the

destruction

of

a

sentient

species--

even

though

I

triggered

that

destruction

myself,

and

I

know

what

a

terrible

moral

burden

that

is

to

bear--

I'm

not

sure

I

could

let

my

fellow

human

beings

die,

either

by

starvation

because

their

food

crops

have

been

destroyed,

or

far

more

painfully

by

the

return

of

the

descolada

as

a

disease

with

the

power

to

consume

the

human

body

in

days.

And

yet...

could

I

consent

to

the

destruction

of

the

pequeninos?

Could

I

permit

another

xenocide?

He

picked

up

one

of

the

broken

potato

stems

with

its

blotchy

leaves.

He

would

have

to

take

this

to

Novinha,

of

course.

Novinha

would

examine

it,

or

Ela

would,

and

they'd

confirm

what

was

already

obvious.

Another

failure.

He

put

the

potato

stem

into

a

sterile

pouch.

"Speaker."

It

was

Planter,

Ender's

assistant

and

his

closest

friend

among

the

piggies.

Planter

was

a

son

of

the

pequenino

named

Human,

whom

Ender

had

taken

into

the

"third

life,"

the

tree

stage

of

the

pequenino

life

cycle.

Ender

held

up

the

transparent

plastic

pouch

for

Planter

to

see

the

leaves

inside.

"Very

dead

indeed,

Speaker,"

said

Planter,

with

no

discernible

emotion.

That

had

been

the

most

disconcerting

thing

about

working

with

pequeninos

at

first--

they

didn't

show

emotions

in

ways

that

humans

could

easily,

habitually

interpret.

It

was

one

of

the

greatest

barriers

to

their

acceptance

by

most

of

the

colonists.

The

piggies

weren't

cute

or

cuddly;

they

were

merely

strange.

"We'll

try

again,"

said

Ender.

"I

think

we're

getting

closer."

"Your

wife

wants

you,"

said

Planter.

The

word

wife,

even

translated

into

a

human

language

like

Stark,

was

so

loaded

with

tension

for

a

pequenino

that

it

was

difficult

to

speak

the

word

naturally--

Planter

almost

screeched

it.

Yet

the

idea

of

wifeness

was

so

powerful

to

the

pequeninos

that,

while

they

could

call

Novinha

by

her

name

when

they

spoke

to

her

directly,

when

they

were

speaking

to

Novinha's

husband

they

could

only

refer

to

her

by

her

title.

"I

was

just

about

to

go

see

her

anyway,"

said

Ender.

"Would

you

measure

and

record

these

potatoes,

please?"

Planter

leaped

straight

up--

like

a

popcorn,

Ender

thought.

Though

his

face

remained,

to

human

eyes,

expressionless,

the

vertical

jump

showed

his

delight.

Planter

loved

working

with

the

electronic

equipment,

both

because

machines

fascinated

him

and

because

it

added

greatly

to

his

status

among

the

other

pequenino

males.

Planter

immediately

began

unpacking

the

camera

and

its

computer

from

the

bag

he

always

carried

with

him.

"When

you're

done,

please

prepare

this

isolated

section

for

flash

burning,"

said

Ender.

"Yes

yes,"

said

Planter.

"Yes

yes

yes."

Ender

sighed.

Pequeninos

got

so

annoyed

when

humans

told

them

things

that

they

already

knew.

Planter

certainly

knew

the

routine

when

the

descolada

had

adapted

to

a

new

crop--

the

"educated"

virus

had

to

be

destroyed

while

it

was

still

in

isolation.

No

point

in

letting

the

whole

community

of

descolada

viruses

profit

from

what

one

strain

had

learned.

So

Ender

shouldn't

have

reminded

him.

And

yet

that

was

how

human

beings

satisfied

their

sense

of

responsibility--

checking

again

even

when

they

knew

it

was

unnecessary.

Planter

was

so

busy

he

hardly

noticed

that

Ender

was

leaving

the

field.

When

Ender

was

inside

the

isolation

shed

at

the

townward

end

of

the

field,

he

stripped,

put

his

clothes

in

the

purification

box,

and

then

did

the

purification

dance--

hands

up

high,

arms

rotating

at

the

shoulder,

turning

in

a

circle,

squatting

and

standing

again,

so

that

no

part

of

his

body

was

missed

by

the

combination

of

radiation

and

gases

that

filled

the

shed.

He

breathed

deeply

through

mouth

and

nose,

then

coughed--

as

always--

because

the

gases

were

barely

within

the

limits

of

human

tolerance.

Three

full

minutes

with

burning

eyes

and

wheezing

lungs,

while

waving

his

arms

and

squatting

and

standing:

our

ritual

of

obeisance

to

the

almighty

descolada.

Thus

we

humiliate

ourselves

before

the

undisputed

master

of

life

on

this

planet.

Finally

it

was

done;

I've

been

roasted

to

a

turn,

he

thought.

As

fresh

air

finally

rushed

into

the

shed,

he

took

his

clothes

out

of

the

box

and

put

them

on,

still

hot.

As

soon

as

he

left

the

shed,

it

would

be

heated

so

that

every

surface

was

far

over

the

proven

heat

tolerance

of

the

descolada

virus.

Nothing

could

live

in

that

shed

during

this

final

step

of

purification.

Next

time

someone

came

to

the

shed

it

would

be

absolutely

sterile.

Yet

Ender

couldn't

help

but

think

that

somehow

the

descolada

virus

would

find

a

way

through--

if

not

through

the

shed,

then

through

the

mild

disruption

barrier

that

surrounded

the

experimental

crop

area

like

an

invisible

fortress

wall.

Officially,

no

molecule

larger

than

a

hundred

atoms

could

pass

through

that

barrier

without

being

broken

up.

Fences

on

either

side

of

the

barrier

kept

humans

and

piggies

from

straying

into

the

fatal

area--

but

Ender

had

often

imagined

what

it

would

be

like

for

someone

to

pass

through

the

disruption

field.

Every

cell

in

the

body

would

be

killed

instantly

as

the

nucleic

acids

broke

apart.

Perhaps

the

body

would

hold

together

physically.

But

in

Ender's

imagination

he

always

saw

the

body

crumbling

into

dust

on

the

other

side

of

the

barrier,

the

breeze

carrying

it

away

like

smoke

before

it

could

hit

the

ground.

What

made

Ender

most

uncomfortable

about

the

disruption

barrier

was

that

it

was

based

on

the

same

principle

as

the

Molecular

Disruption

Device.

Designed

to

be

used

against

starships

and

missiles,

it

was

Ender

who

turned

it

against

the

home

planet

of

the

buggers

when

he

commanded

the

human

warfleet

three

thousand

years

ago.

And

it

was

the

same

weapon

that

was

now

on

its

way

from

Starways

Congress

to

Lusitania.

According

to

Jane,

Starways

Congress

had

already

attempted

to

send

the

order

to

use

it.

She

had

blocked

that

by

cutting

off

ansible

communications

between

the

fleet

and

the

rest

of

humanity,

but

there

was

no

telling

whether

some

overwrought

ship's

captain,

panicked

because

his

ansible

wasn't

working,

might

still

use

it

on

Lusitania

when

he

got

here.

It

was

unthinkable,

but

they

had

done

it--

Congress

had

sent

the

order

to

destroy

a

world.

To

commit

xenocide.

Had

Ender

written

the

Hive

Queen

in

vain?

Had

they

already

forgotten?

But

it

wasn't

"already"

to

them.

It

was

three

thousand

years

to

most

people.

And

even

though

Ender

had

written

the

Life

of

Human,

it

wasn't

believed

widely

enough

yet.

It

hadn't

been

embraced

by

the

people

to

such

a

degree

that

Congress

wouldn't

dare

to

act

against

the

pequeninos.

Why

had

they

decided

to

do

it?

Probably

for

exactly

the

same

purpose

as

the

xenobiologists'

disruption

barrier:

to

isolate

a

dangerous

infection

so

it

couldn't

spread

into

the

wider

population.

Congress

was

probably

worried

about

containing

the

plague

of

planetary

revolt.

But

when

the

fleet

reached

here,

with

or

without

orders,

they

might

be

as

likely

to

use

the

Little

Doctor

as

the

final

solution

to

the

descolada

problem:

If

there

were

no

planet

Lusitania,

there

would

be

no

self-mutating

half-intelligent

virus

itching

for

a

chance

to

wipe

out

humanity

and

all

its

works.

It

wasn't

that

long

a

walk

from

the

experimental

fields

to

the

new

xenobiology

station.

The

path

wound

over

a

low

hill,

skirting

the

edge

of

the

wood

that

provided

father,

mother,

and

living

cemetery

to

this

tribe

of

pequeninos,

and

then

on

to

the

north

gate

in

the

fence

that

surrounded

the

human

colony.

The

fence

was

a

sore

point

with

Ender.

There

was

no

reason

for

it

to

exist

anymore,

now

that

the

policy

of

minimal

contact

between

humans

and

pequeninos

had

broken

down,

and

both

species

passed

freely

through

the

gate.

When

Ender

arrived

on

Lusitania,

the

fence

was

charged

with

a

field

that

caused

any

person

entering

it

to

suffer

excruciating

pain.

During

the

struggle

to

win

the

right

to

communicate

freely

with

the

pequeninos,

Ender's

oldest

stepson,

Miro,

was

trapped

in

the

field

for

several

minutes,

causing

irreversible

brain

damage.

Yet

Miro's

experience

was

only

the

most

painful

and

immediate

expression

of

what

the

fence

did

to

the

souls

of

the

humans

enclosed

within

it.

The

psychobarrier

had

been

shut

off

thirty

years

ago.

In

all

that

time,

there

had

been

no

reason

to

have

any

barrier

between

humans

and

pequeninos--

yet

the

fence

remained.

The

human

colonists

of

Lusitania

wanted

it

that

way.

They

wanted

the

boundary

between

human

and

pequenino

to

remain

unbreached.

That

was

why

the

xenobiology

labs

had

been

moved

from

their

old

location

down

by

the

river.

If

pequeninos

were

to

take

part

in

the

research,

the

lab

had

to

be

close

to

the

fence,

and

all

the

experimental

fields

outside

it,

so

that

humans

and

pequeninos

wouldn't

have

occasion

to

confront

each

other

unexpectedly.

When

Miro

left

to

meet

Valentine,

Ender

had

thought

he

would

return

to

be

astonished

by

the

great

changes

in

the

world

of

Lusitania.

He

had

thought

that

Miro

would

see

humans

and

pequeninos

living

side

by

side,

two

species

living

in

harmony.

Instead,

Miro

would

find

the

colony

nearly

unchanged.

With

rare

exceptions,

the

human

beings

of

Lusitania

did

not

long

for

the

close

company

of

another

species.

It

was

a

good

thing

that

Ender

had

helped

the

hive

queen

restore

the

race

of

buggers

so

far

from

Milagre.

Ender

had

planned

to

help

buggers

and

humans

gradually

come

to

know

each

other.

Instead,

he

and

Novinha

and

their

family

had

been

forced

to

keep

the

existence

of

the

buggers

on

Lusitania

a

close-held

secret.

If

the

human

colonists

couldn't

deal

with

the

mammal-like

pequeninos,

it

was

certain

that

knowing

about

the

insect-like

buggers

would

provoke

violent

xenophobia

almost

at

once.

I

have

too

many

secrets,

thought

Ender.

For

all

these

years

I've

been

a

speaker

for

the

dead,

uncovering

secrets

and

helping

people

to

live

in

the

light

of

truth.

Now

I

no

longer

tell

anyone

half

of

what

I

know,

because

if

I

told

the

whole

truth

there

would

be

fear,

hatred,

brutality,

murder,

war.

Not

far

from

the

gate,

but

outside

it,

stood

two

fathertrees,

the

one

named

Rooter,

the

other

named

Human,

planted

so

that

from

the

gate

it

would

seem

that

Rooter

was

on

the

left

hand,

Human

on

the

right.

Human

was

the

pequenino

whom

Ender

had

been

required

to

ritually

kill

with

his

own

hands,

in

order

to

seal

the

treaty

between

humans

and

pequeninos.

Then

Human

was

reborn

in

cellulose

and

chlorophyll,

finally

a

mature

adult

male,

able

to

sire

children.

At

present

Human

still

had

enormous

prestige,

not

only

among

the

piggies

of

this

tribe,

but

in

many

other

tribes

as

well.

Ender

knew

that

he

was

alive;

yet,

seeing

the

tree,

it

was

impossible

for

him

to

forget

how

Human

had

died.

Ender

had

no

trouble

dealing

with

Human

as

a

person,

for

he

had

spoken

with

this

fathertree

many

times.

What

he

could

not

manage

was

to

think

of

this

tree

as

the

same

person

he

had

known

as

the

pequenino

named

Human.

Ender

might

understand

intellectually

that

it

was

will

and

memory

that

made

up

a

person's

identity,

and

that

will

and

memory

had

passed

intact

from

the

pequenino

into

the

fathertree.

But

intellectual

understanding

did

not

always

bring

visceral

belief.

Human

was

so

alien

now.

Yet

still

he

was

Human,

and

he

was

still

Ender's

friend;

Ender

touched

the

bark

of

the

tree

as

he

passed.

Then,

taking

a

few

steps

out

of

his

way,

Ender

walked

to

the

older

fathertree

named

Rooter,

and

touched

his

bark

also.

He

had

never

known

Rooter

as

a

pequenino--

Rooter

had

been

killed

by

other

hands,

and

his

tree

was

already

tall

and

well-spread

before

Ender

arrived

on

Lusitania.

There

was

no

sense

of

loss

to

trouble

him

when

Ender

talked

to

Rooter.

At

Rooter's

base,

among

the

roots,

lay

many

sticks.

Some

had

been

brought

here;

some

were

shed

from

Rooter's

own

branches.

They

were

talking

sticks.

Pequeninos

used

them

to

beat

a

rhythm

on

the

trunk

of

a

fathertree;

the

fathertree

would

shape

and

reshape

the

hollow

areas

inside

his

own

trunk

to

change

the

sound,

to

make

a

slow

kind

of

speech.

Ender

could

beat

the

rhythm--

clumsily,

but

well

enough

to

get

words

from

the

trees.

Today,

though,

Ender

wanted

no

conversation.

Let

Planter

tell

the

fathertrees

that

another

experiment

had

failed.

Ender

would

talk

to

Rooter

and

Human

later.

He

would

talk

to

the

hive

queen.

He

would

talk

to

Jane.

He

would

talk

to

everybody.

And

after

all

the

talking,

they

would

be

no

closer

to

solving

any

of

the

problems

that

darkened

Lusitania's

future.

Because

the

solution

to

their

problems

now

did

not

depend

on

talk.

It

depended

on

knowledge

and

action--

knowledge

that

only

other

people

could

learn,

actions

that

only

other

people

could

perform.

There

was

nothing

that

Ender

could

do

himself

to

solve

anything.

All

he

could

do,

all

he

had

ever

done

since

his

final

battle

as

a

child

warrior,

was

listen

and

talk.

At

other

times,

in

other

places,

that

had

been

enough.

Not

now.

Many

different

kinds

of

destruction

loomed

over

Lusitania,

some

of

them

set

in

motion

by

Ender

himself,

and

yet

not

one

of

them

could

now

be

solved

by

any

act

or

word

or

thought

of

Andrew

Wiggin.

Like

all

the

other

citizens

of

Lusitania,

his

future

was

in

the

hands

of

other

people.

The

difference

between

him

and

them

was

that

Ender

knew

all

the

danger,

all

the

possible

consequences

of

every

failure

or

mistake.

Who

was

more

cursed,

the

one

who

died,

unknowing

until

the

very

moment

of

his

death,

or

the

one

who

watched

his

destruction

as

it

approached,

step

by

step,

for

days

and

weeks

and

years?

Ender

left

the

fathertrees

and

walked

on

down

the

well-beaten

path

toward

the

human

colony.

Through

the

gate,

through

the

door

of

the

xenobiology

lab.

The

pequenino

who

served

as

Ela's

most

trusted

assistant-

-

named

Deaf,

though

he

was

definitely

not

hard

of

hearing--

led

him

at

once

to

Novinha's

office,

where

Ela,

Novinha,

Quara,

and

Grego

were

already

waiting.

Ender

held

up

the

pouch

containing

the

fragment

of

potato

plant.

Ela

shook

her

head;

Novinha

sighed.

But

they

didn't

seem

half

as

disappointed

as

Ender

had

expected.

Clearly

there

was

something

else

on

their

minds.

"I

guess

we

expected

that,"

said

Novinha.

"We

still

had

to

try,"

said

Ela.

"Why

did

we

have

to

try?"

demanded

Grego.

Novinha's

youngest

son--

and

therefore

Ender's

stepson--

was

in

his

mid-thirties

now,

a

brilliant

scientist

in

his

own

right;

but

he

did

seem

to

relish

his

role

as

devil's

advocate

in

all

the

family's

discussions,

whether

they

dealt

with

xenobiology

or

the

color

to

paint

the

walls.

"All

we're

doing

by

introducing

these

new

strains

is

teaching

the

descolada

how

to

get

around

every

strategy

we

have

for

killing

it.

If

we

don't

wipe

it

out

soon,

it'll

wipe

us

out.

And

once

the

descolada

is

gone,

we

can

grow

regular

old

potatoes

without

any

of

this

nonsense."

"We

can't!"

shouted

Quara.

Her

vehemence

surprised

Ender.

Quara

was

reluctant

to

speak

out

at

the

best

of

times;

for

her

to

speak

so

loudly

now

was

out

of

character.

"I

tell

you

that

the

descolada

is

alive."

"And

I

tell

you

that

a

virus

is

a

virus,"

said

Grego.

It

bothered

Ender

that

Grego

was

calling

for

the

extermination

of

the

descolada--

it

wasn't

like

him

to

so

easily

call

for

something

that

would

destroy

the

pequeninos.

Grego

had

practically

grown

up

among

the

pequenino

males--

he

knew

them

better,

spoke

their

language

better,

than

anyone.

"Children,

be

quiet

and

let

me

explain

this

to

Andrew,"

said

Novinha.

"We

were

discussing

what

to

do

if

the

potatoes

failed,

Ela

and

I,

and

she

told

me--

no,

you

explain

it,

Ela."

"It's

an

easy

enough

concept.

Instead

of

trying

to

grow

plants

that

inhibit

the

growth

of

the

descolada

virus,

we

need

to

go

after

the

virus

itself."

"Right,"

said

Grego.

"Shut

up,"

said

Quara.

"As

a

kindness

to

us

all,

Grego,

please

do

as

your

sister

has

so

kindly

asked,"

said

Novinha.

Ela

sighed

and

went

on.

"We

can't

just

kill

it

because

that

would

kill

all

the

other

native

life

on

Lusitania.

So

what

I

propose

is

trying

to

develop

a

new

strain

of

descolada

that

continues

to

act

as

the

present

virus

acts

in

the

reproductive

cycles

of

all

the

Lusitanian

life

forms,

but

without

the

ability

to

adapt

to

new

species."

"You

can

eliminate

that

part

of

the

virus?"

asked

Ender.

"You

can

find

it?"

"Not

likely.

But

I

think

I

can

find

all

the

parts

of

the

virus

that

are

active

in

the

piggies

and

in

all

the

other

plant-animal

pairs,

keep

those,

and

discard

everything

else.

Then

we'd

add

a

rudimentary

reproductive

ability

and

set

up

some

receptors

so

it'll

respond

properly

to

the

appropriate

changes

in

the

host

bodies,

put

the

whole

thing

in

a

little

organelle,

and

there

we

have

it--

a

substitute

for

the

descolada

so

that

the

pequeninos

and

all

the

other

native

species

are

safe,

while

we

can

live

without

worry."

"Then

you'll

spray

all

the

original

descolada

virus

to

wipe

them

out?"

asked

Ender.

"What

if

there's

already

a

resistant

strain?"

"No,

we

don't

spray

them,

because

spraying

wouldn't

wipe

out

the

viruses

that

are

already

incorporated

into

the

bodies

of

every

Lusitanian

creature.

This

is

the

really

tricky

part--"

"As

if

the

rest

were

easy,"

said

Novinha,

"making

a

new

organelle

out

of

nothing--"

"We

can't

just

inject

these

organelles

into

a

few

piggies

or

even

into

all

of

them,

because

we'd

also

have

to

inject

them

into

every

other

native

animal

and

tree

and

blade

of

grass."

"Can't

be

done,"

said

Ender.

"So

we

have

to

develop

a

mechanism

to

deliver

the

organelles

universally,

and

at

the

same

time

destroy

the

old

descolada

viruses

once

and

for

all."

"Xenocide,"

said

Quara.

"That's

the

argument,"

said

Ela.

"Quara

says

the

descolada

is

sentient."

Ender

looked

at

his

youngest

stepdaughter.

"A

sentient

molecule?"

"They

have

language,

Andrew."

"When

did

this

happen?"

asked

Ender.

He

was

trying

to

imagine

how

a

genetic

molecule--

even

one

as

long

and

complex

as

the

descolada

virus--

could

possibly

speak.

"I've

suspected

it

for

a

long

time.

I

wasn't

going

to

say

anything

until

I

was

sure,

but--"

"Which

means

she

isn't

sure,"

said

Grego

triumphantly.

"But

I'm

almost

sure

now,

and

you

can't

go

destroying

a

whole

species

until

we

know."

"How

do

they

speak?"

asked

Ender.

"Not

like

us,

of

course,"

said

Quara.

"They

pass

information

back

and

forth

to

each

other

at

a

molecular

level.

I

first

noticed

it

as

I

was

working

on

the

question

of

how

the

new

resistant

strains

of

the

descolada

spread

so

quickly

and

replaced

all

the

old

viruses

in

such

a

short

time.

I

couldn't

solve

that

problem

because

I

was

asking

the

wrong

question.

They

don't

replace

the

old

ones.

They

simply

pass

messages."

"They

throw

darts,"

said

Grego.

"That

was

my

own

word

for

it,"

said

Quara.

"I

didn't

understand

that

it

was

speech."

"Because

it

wasn't

speech,"

said

Grego.

"That

was

five

years

ago,"

said

Ender.

"You

said

the

darts

they

send

out

carry

the

needed

genes

and

then

all

the

viruses

that

receive

the

darts

revise

their

own

structure

to

include

the

new

gene.

That's

hardly

language."

"But

that

isn't

the

only

time

they

send

darts,"

said

Quara.

"Those

messenger

molecules

are

moving

in

and

out

all

the

time,

and

most

of

the

time

they

aren't

incorporated

into

the

body

at

all.

They

get

read

by

several

parts

of

the

descolada

and

then

they're

passed

on

to

another

one."

"This

is

language?"

asked

Grego.

"Not

yet,"

said

Quara.

"But

sometimes

after

a

virus

reads

one

of

these

darts,

it

makes

a

new

dart

and

sends

it

out.

Here's

the

part

that

tells

me

it's

a

language:

The

front

part

of

the

new

dart

always

begins

with

a

molecular

sequence

similar

to

the

back

tag

of

the

dart

that

it's

answering.

It

holds

the

thread

of

the

conversation

together."

"Conversation,"

said

Grego

scornfully.

"Be

quiet

or

die,"

said

Ela.

Even

after

all

these

years,

Ender

realized,

Ela's

voice

still

had

the

power

to

curb

Grego's

snottiness--

sometimes,

at

least.

"I've

tracked

some

of

these

conversations

for

as

many

as

a

hundred

statements

and

answers.

Most

of

them

die

out

much

sooner

than

that.

A

few

of

them

are

incorporated

into

the

main

body

of

the

virus.

But

here's

the

most

interesting

thing--

it's

completely

voluntary.

Sometimes

one

virus

will

pick

up

that

dart

and

keep

it,

while

most

of

the

others

don't.

Sometimes

most

of

the

viruses

will

keep

a

particular

dart.

But

the

area

where

they

incorporate

these

message

darts

is

exactly

that

area

that

has

been

hardest

to

map.

It's

hardest

to

map

because

it

isn't

part

of

their

structure,

it's

their

memory,

and

individuals

are

all

different

from

each

other.

They

also

tend

to

weed

out

a

few

memory

fragments

when

they've

taken

on

too

many

darts."

"This

is

all

fascinating,"

said

Grego,

"but

it

isn't

science.

There

are

plenty

of

explanations

for

these

darts

and

the

random

bonding

and

shedding--"

"Not

random!"

said

Quara.

"None

of

this

is

language,"

said

Grego.

Ender

ignored

the

argument,

because

Jane

was

whispering

in

his

ear

through

the

jewel-like

transceiver

he

wore

there.

She

spoke

to

him

more

rarely

now

than

in

years

past.

He

listened

carefully,

taking

nothing

for

granted.

"She's

on

to

something,"

Jane

said.

"I've

looked

at

her

research

and

there's

something

going

on

here

that

doesn't

happen

with

any

other

subcellular

creature.

I've

run

many

different

analyses

on

the

data,

and

the

more

I

simulate

and

test

this

particular

behavior

of

the

descolada,

the

less

it

looks

like

genetic

coding

and

the

more

it

looks

like

language.

At

the

moment

we

can't

rule

out

the

possibility

that

it

is

voluntary."

When

Ender

turned

his

attention

back

to

the

argument,

Grego

was

speaking.

"Why

do

we

have

to

turn

everything

we

haven't

figured

out

yet

into

some

kind

of

mystical

experience?"

Grego

closed

his

eyes

and

intoned,

"I

have

found

new

life!

I

have

found

new

life!"

"Stop

it!"

shouted

Quara.

"This

is

getting

out

of

hand,"

said

Novinha.

"Grego,

try

to

keep

this

at

the

level

of

rational

discussion."

"It's

hard

to,

when

the

whole

thing

is

so

irrational.

At‚

agora

quem

ja

imaginou

microbiologista

que

se

torna

namorada

de

uma

mol‚cula?"

Who

ever

heard

of

a

microbiologist

getting

a

crush

on

a

molecule?

"Enough!"

said

Novinha

sharply.

"Quara

is

as

much

a

scientist

as

you

are,

and--"

"She

was,"

muttered

Grego.

"And--

if

you'll

kindly

shut

up

long

enough

to

hear

me

out--

she

has

a

right

to

be

heard."

Novinha

was

quite

angry

now,

but,

as

usual,

Grego

seemed

unimpressed.

"You

should

know

by

now,

Grego,

that

it's

often

the

ideas

that

sound

most

absurd

and

counterintuitive

at

first

that

later

cause

fundamental

shifts

in

the

way

we

see

the

world."

"Do

you

really

think

this

is

one

of

those

basic

discoveries?"

asked

Grego,

looking

them

in

the

eye,

each

in

turn.

"A

talking

virus?

Se

Quara

sabe

tanto,

porque

ela

nao

diz

o

que

e

que

aqueles

bichos

dizem?"

If

she

knows

so

much

about

it,

why

doesn't

she

tell

us

what

these

little

beasts

are

saying?

It

was

a

sign

that

the

discussion

was

getting

out

of

hand,

that

he

broke

into

Portuguese

instead

of

speaking

in

Stark,

the

language

of

science--

and

diplomacy.

"Does

it

matter?"

asked

Ender.

"Matter!"

said

Quara.

Ela

looked

at

Ender

with

consternation.

"It's

only

the

difference

between

curing

a

dangerous

disease

and

destroying

an

entire

sentient

species.

I

think

it

matters."

"I

meant,"

said

Ender

patiently,

"does

it

matter

whether

we

know

what

they're

saying."

"No,"

said

Quara.

"We'll

probably

never

understand

their

language,

but

that

doesn't

change

the

fact

that

they're

sentient.

What

do

viruses

and

human

beings

have

to

say

to

each

other,

anyway?"

"How

about,

'Please

stop

trying

to

kill

us'?"

said

Grego.

"If

you

can

figure

out

how

to

say

that

in

virus

language,

then

this

might

be

useful."

"But

Grego,"

said

Quara,

with

mock

sweetness,

"do

we

say

that

to

them,

or

do

they

say

that

to

us?"

"We

don't

have

to

decide

today,"

said

Ender.

"We

can

afford

to

wait

awhile."

"How

do

you

know?"

said

Grego.

"How

do

you

know

that

tomorrow

afternoon

we

won't

all

wake

up

itching

and

hurting

and

puking

and

burning

up

with

fever

and

finally

dying

because

overnight

the

descolada

virus

figured

out

how

to

wipe

us

out

once

and

for

all?

It's

us

or

them."

"I

think

Grego

just

showed

us

why

we

have

to

wait,"

said

Ender.

"Did

you

hear

how

he

talked

about

the

descolada?

It

figures

out

how

to

wipe

us

out.

Even

he

thinks

the

descolada

has

a

will

and

makes

decisions."

"That's

just

a

figure

of

speech,"

said

Grego.

"We've

all

been

talking

that

way,"

said

Ender.

"And

thinking

that

way,

too.

Because

we

all

feel

it--

that

we're

at

war

with

the

descolada.

That

it's

more

than

just

fighting

off

a

disease--

it's

like

we

have

an

intelligent,

resourceful

enemy

who

keeps

countering

all

our

moves.

In

all

the

history

of

medical

research,

no

one

has

ever

fought

a

disease

that

had

so

many

ways

to

defeat

the

strategies

used

against

it."

"Only

because

nobody's

been

fighting

a

germ

with

such

an

oversized

and

complex

genetic

molecule,"

said

Grego.

"Exactly,"

said

Ender.

"This

is

a

one-of-a-kind

virus,

and

so

it

may

have

abilities

we've

never

imagined

in

any

species

less

structurally

complex

than

a

vertebrate."

For

a

moment

Ender's

words

hung

in

the

air,

answered

by

silence;

for

a

moment,

Ender

imagined

that

he

might

have

served

a

useful

function

in

this

meeting

after

all,

that

as

a

mere

talker

he

might

have

won

some

kind

of

agreement.

Grego

soon

disabused

him

of

this

idea.

"Even

if

Quara's

right,

even

if

she's

dead

on

and

the

descolada

viruses

all

have

doctorates

of

philosophy

and

keep

publishing

dissertations

on

screwing-up-humans-tillthey're-dead,

what

then?

Do

we

all

roll

over

and

play

dead

because

the

virus

that's

trying

to

kill

us

all

is

so

damn

smart?"

Novinha

answered

calmly.

"I

think

Quara

needs

to

continue

with

her

research--

and

we

need

to

give

her

more

resources

to

do

it--

while

Ela

continues

with

hers."

It

was

Quara

who

objected

this

time.

"Why

should

I

bother

trying

to

understand

them

if

the

rest

of

you

are

still

working

on

ways

to

kill

them?"

"That's

a

good

question,

Quara,"

said

Novinha.

"On

the

other

hand,

why

should

you

bother

trying

to

understand

them

if

they

suddenly

figure

out

a

way

to

get

past

all

our

chemical

barriers

and

kill

us

all?"

"Us

or

them,"

muttered

Grego.

Novinha

had

made

a

good

decision,

Ender

knew--

keep

both

lines

of

research

open,

and

decide

later

when

they

knew

more.

In

the

meantime,

Quara

and

Grego

were

both

missing

the

point,

both

assuming

that

everything

hinged

on

whether

or

not

the

descolada

was

sentient.

"Even

if

they're

sentient,"

said

Ender,

"that

doesn't

mean

they're

sacrosanct.

It

all

depends

whether

they're

raman

or

varelse.

If

they're

raman--

if

we

can

understand

them

and

they

can

understand

us

well

enough

to

work

out

a

way

of

living

together--

then

fine.

We'll

be

safe,

they'll

be

safe."

"The

great

peacemaker

plans

to

sign

a

treaty

with

a

molecule?"

asked

Grego.

Ender

ignored

his

mocking

tone.

"On

the

other

hand,

if

they're

trying

to

destroy

us,

and

we

can't

find

a

way

to

communicate

with

them,

then

they're

varelse--

sentient

aliens,

but

implacably

hostile

and

dangerous.

Varelse

are

aliens

we

can't

live

with.

Varelse

are

aliens

with

whom

we

are

naturally

and

permanently

engaged

in

a

war

to

the

death,

and

at

that

time

our

only

moral

choice

is

to

do

all

that's

necessary

to

win."

"Right,"

said

Grego.

Despite

her

brother's

triumphant

tone,

Quara

had

listened

to

Ender's

words,

weighed

them,

and

now

gave

a

tentative

nod.

"As

long

as

we

don't

start

from

the

assumption

that

they're

varelse,"

said

Quara.

"And

even

then,

maybe

there's

a

middle

way,"

said

Ender.

"Maybe

Ela

can

find

a

way

to

replace

all

the

descolada

viruses

without

destroying

this

memory-and-language

thing."

"No!"

said

Quara,

once

again

fervent.

"You

can't--

you

don't

even

have

the

right

to

leave

them

their

memories

and

take

away

their

ability

to

adapt.

That

would

be

like

them

giving

all

of

us

frontal

lobotomies.

If

it's

war,

then

it's

war.

Kill

them,

but

don't

leave

them

their

memories

while

stealing

their

will."

"It

doesn't

matter,"

said

Ela.

"It

can't

be

done.

As

it

is,

I

think

I've

set

myself

an

impossible

task.

Operating

on

the

descolada

isn't

easy.

Not

like

examining

and

operating

on

an

animal.

How

do

I

anesthetize

the

molecule

so

that

it

doesn't

heal

itself

while

I'm

halfway

through

the

amputation?

Maybe

the

descolada

isn't

much

on

physics,

but

it's

a

hell

of

a

lot

better

than

I

am

at

molecular

surgery."

"So

far,"

said

Ender.

"So

far

we

don't

know

anything,"

said

Grego.

"Except

that

the

descolada

is

trying

as

hard

as

it

can

to

kill

us

all,

while

we're

still

trying

to

figure

out

whether

we

ought

to

fight

back.

I'll

sit

tight

for

a

while

longer,

but

not

forever.

"

"What

about

the

piggies?"

asked

Quara.

"Don't

they

have

a

right

to

vote

on

whether

we

transform

the

molecule

that

not

only

allows

them

to

reproduce,

but

probably

created

them

as

a

sentient

species

in

the

first

place?"

"This

thing

is

trying

to

kill

us,"

said

Ender.

"As

long

as

the

solution

Ela

comes

up

with

can

wipe

out

the

virus

without

interfering

with

the

reproductive

cycle

of

the

piggies,

then

I

don't

think

they

have

any

right

to

object."

"Maybe

they'd

feel

different

about

that."

"Then

maybe

they'd

better

not

find

out

what

we're

doing,"

said

Grego.

"We

don't

tell

people--

human

or

pequenino--

about

the

research

we're

doing

here,"

said

Novinha

sharply.

"It

could

cause

terrible

misunderstandings

that

could

lead

to

violence

and

death."

"So

we

humans

are

the

judges

of

all

other

creatures,"

said

Quara.

"No,

Quara.

We

scientists

are

gathering

information,"

said

Novinha.

"Until

we've

gathered

enough,

nobody

can

judge

anything.

So

the

secrecy

rule

goes

for

everybody

here.

Quara

and

Grego

both.

You

tell

no

one

until

I

say

so,

and

I

won't

say

so

until

we

know

more."

"Until

you

say

so,"

asked

Grego

impudently,

"or

until

the

Speaker

for

the

Dead

says

so?"

"I'm

the

head

xenobiologist,"

said

Novinha.

"The

decision

on

when

we

know

enough

is

mine

alone.

Is

that

understood?"

She

waited

for

everyone

there

to

assent.

They

all

did.

Novinha

stood

up.

The

meeting

was

over.

Quara

and

Grego

left

almost

immediately;

Novinha

gave

Ender

a

kiss

on

the

cheek

and

then

ushered

him

and

Ela

out

of

her

office.

Ender

lingered

in

the

lab

to

talk

to

Ela.

"Is

there

a

way

to

spread

your

replacement

virus

throughout

the

entire

population

of

every

native

species

on

Lusitania?"

"I

don't

know,"

said

Ela.

"That's

less

of

a

problem

than

how

to

get

it

to

every

cell

of

an

individual

organism

fast

enough

that

the

descolada

can't

adapt

or

escape.

I'll

have

to

create

some

kind

of

carrier

virus,

and

I'll

probably

have

to

model

it

partly

on

the

descolada

itself--

the

descolada

is

the

only

parasite

I've

seen

that

invades

a

host

as

quickly

and

thoroughly

as

I

need

the

carrier

virus

to

do

it.

Ironic--

I'll

learn

how

to

replace

the

descolada

by

stealing

techniques

from

the

virus

itself."

"It's

not

ironic,"

said

Ender,

"it's

the

way

the

world

works.

Someone

once

told

me

that

the

only

teacher

who's

worth

anything

to

you

is

your

enemy."

"Then

Quara

and

Grego

must

be

giving

each

other

advanced

degrees,"

said

Ela.

"Their

argument

is

healthy,"

said

Ender.

"It

forces

us

to

weigh

every

aspect

of

what

we're

doing."

"It'll

stop

being

healthy

if

one

of

them

decides

to

bring

it

up

outside

the

family,"

said

Ela.

"This

family

doesn't

tell

its

business

to

strangers,"

said

Ender.

"I

of

all

people

should

know

that."

"On

the

contrary,

Ender.

You

of

all

people

should

know

how

eager

we

are

to

talk

to

a

stranger--

when

we

think

our

need

is

great

enough

to

justify

it."

Ender

had

to

admit

that

she

was

right.

Getting

Quara

and

Grego,

Miro

and

Quim

and

Olhado

to

trust

him

enough

to

speak

to

him,

that

had

been

hard

when

Ender

first

came

to

Lusitania.

But

Ela

had

spoken

to

him

from

the

start,

and

so

had

all

of

Novinha's

other

children.

So,

in

the

end,

had

Novinha

herself.

The

family

was

intensely

loyal,

but

they

were

also

strong-willed

and

opinionated

and

there

wasn't

a

one

of

them

who

didn't

trust

his

own

judgment

above

anyone

else's.

Grego

or

Quara,

either

one

of

them,

might

well

decide

that

telling

somebody

else

was

in

the

best

interests

of

Lusitania

or

humanity

or

science,

and

there

would

go

the

rule

of

secrecy.

Just

the

way

the

rule

of

noninterference

with

the

piggies

had

been

broken

before

Ender

ever

got

here.

How

nice,

thought

Ender.

One

more

possible

source

of

disaster

that

is

completely

out

of

my

power

to

control.

Leaving

the

lab,

Ender

wished,

as

he

had

many

times

before,

that

Valentine

were

here.

She

was

the

one

who

was

good

at

sorting

out

ethical

dilemmas.

She'd

be

here

soon--

but

soon

enough?

Ender

understood

and

mostly

agreed

with

the

viewpoints

put

forward

by

Quara

and

Grego

both.

What

stung

most

was

the

need

for

such

secrecy

that

Ender

couldn't

even

speak

to

the

pequeninos,

not

even

Human

himself,

about

a

decision

that

would