XENOCIDE
by
Orson
Scott
Card
(c)
1991
Orson
Scott
Card
Chapter
1
--
A
PARTING
<Today
one
of
the
brothers
asked
me:
Is
it
a
terrible
prison,
not
to
be
able
to
move
from
the
place
where
you're
standing?>
<You
answered
...>
<I
told
him
that
I
am
now
more
free
than
he
is.
The
inability
to
move
frees
me
from
the
obligation
to
act.>
<You
who
speak
languages,
you
are
such
liars.>
Han
Fei-tzu
sat
in
lotus
position
on
the
bare
wooden
floor
beside
his
wife's
sickbed.
Until
a
moment
ago
he
might
have
been
sleeping;
he
wasn't
sure.
But
now
he
was
aware
of
the
slight
change
in
her
breathing,
a
change
as
subtle
as
the
wind
from
a
butterfly's
passing.
Jiang-qing,
for
her
part,
must
also
have
detected
some
change
in
him,
for
she
had
not
spoken
before
and
now
she
did
speak.
Her
voice
was
very
soft.
But
Han
Fei-tzu
could
hear
her
clearly,
for
the
house
was
silent.
He
had
asked
his
friends
and
servants
for
stillness
during
the
dusk
of
Jiang-qing's
life.
Time
enough
for
careless
noise
during
the
long
night
that
was
to
come,
when
there
would
be
no
hushed
words
from
her
lips.
"Still
not
dead,"
she
said.
She
had
greeted
him
with
these
words
each
time
she
woke
during
the
past
few
days.
At
first
the
words
had
seemed
whimsical
or
ironic
to
him,
but
now
he
knew
that
she
spoke
with
disappointment.
She
longed
for
death
now,
not
because
she
hadn't
loved
life,
but
because
death
was
now
unavoidable,
and
what
cannot
be
shunned
must
be
embraced.
That
was
the
Path.
Jiang-qing
had
never
taken
a
step
away
from
the
Path
in
her
life.
"Then
the
gods
are
kind
to
me,"
said
Han
Fei-tzu.
"To
you,"
she
breathed.
"What
do
we
contemplate?"
It
was
her
way
of
asking
him
to
share
his
private
thoughts
with
her.
When
others
asked
his
private
thoughts,
he
felt
spied
upon.
But
Jiang-qing
asked
only
so
that
she
could
also
think
the
same
thought;
it
was
part
of
their
having
become
a
single
soul.
"We
are
contemplating
the
nature
of
desire,"
said
Han
Fei-tzu.
"Whose
desire?"
she
asked.
"And
for
what?"
My
desire
for
your
bones
to
heal
and
become
strong,
so
that
they
don't
snap
at
the
slightest
pressure.
So
that
you
could
stand
again,
or
even
raise
an
arm
without
your
own
muscles
tearing
away
chunks
of
bone
or
causing
the
bone
to
break
under
the
tension.
So
that
I
wouldn't
have
to
watch
you
wither
away
until
now
you
weigh
only
eighteen
kilograms.
I
never
knew
how
perfectly
happy
we
were
until
I
learned
that
we
could
not
stay
together.
"My
desire,"
he
answered.
"For
you."
"'You
only
covet
what
you
do
not
have.'
Who
said
that?"
"You
did,"
said
Han
Fei-tzu.
"Some
say,
'what
you
cannot
have.'
Others
say,
'what
you
should
not
have.'
I
say,
'You
can
truly
covet
only
what
you
will
always
hunger
for.'"
"You
have
me
forever."
"I
will
lose
you
tonight.
Or
tomorrow.
Or
next
week."
"Let
us
contemplate
the
nature
of
desire,"
said
Jiang-qing.
As
before,
she
was
using
philosophy
to
pull
him
out
of
his
brooding
melancholy.
He
resisted
her,
but
only
playfully.
"You
are
a
harsh
ruler,"
said
Han
Feitzu.
"Like
your
ancestor-of-theheart,
you
make
no
allowance
for
other
people's
frailty."
Jiang-qing
was
named
for
a
revolutionary
leader
of
the
ancient
past,
who
had
tried
to
lead
the
people
onto
a
new
Path
but
was
overthrown
by
weak-hearted
cowards.
It
was
not
right,
thought
Han
Fei-tzu,
for
his
wife
to
die
before
him:
her
ancestor-of-the-heart
had
outlived
her
husband.
Besides,
wives
should
live
longer
than
husbands.
Women
were
more
complete
inside
themselves.
They
were
also
better
at
living
in
their
children.
They
were
never
as
solitary
as
a
man
alone.
Jiang-qing
refused
to
let
him
return
to
brooding.
"When
a
man's
wife
is
dead,
what
does
he
long
for?"
Rebelliously,
Han
Fei-tzu
gave
her
the
most
false
answer
to
her
question.
"To
lie
with
her,"
he
said.
"The
desire
of
the
body,"
said
Jiang-qing.
Since
she
was
determined
to
have
this
conversation,
Han
Fei-tzu
took
up
the
catalogue
for
her.
"The
desire
of
the
body
is
to
act.
It
includes
all
touches,
casual
and
intimate,
and
all
customary
movements.
Thus
he
sees
a
movement
out
of
the
corner
of
his
eye,
and
thinks
he
has
seen
his
dead
wife
moving
across
the
doorway,
and
he
cannot
be
content
until
he
has
walked
to
the
door
and
seen
that
it
was
not
his
wife.
Thus
he
wakes
up
from
a
dream
in
which
he
heard
her
voice,
and
finds
himself
speaking
his
answer
aloud
as
if
she
could
hear
him."
"What
else?"
asked
Jiang-qing.
"I'm
tired
of
philosophy,"
said
Han
Fei-tzu.
"Maybe
the
Greeks
found
comfort
in
it,
but
not
me."
"The
desire
of
the
spirit,"
said
Jiang-qing,
insisting.
"Because
the
spirit
is
of
the
earth,
it
is
that
part
which
makes
new
things
out
of
old
ones.
The
husband
longs
for
all
the
unfinished
things
that
he
and
his
wife
were
making
when
she
died,
and
all
the
unstarted
dreams
of
what
they
would
have
made
if
she
had
lived.
Thus
a
man
grows
angry
at
his
children
for
being
too
much
like
him
and
not
enough
like
his
dead
wife.
Thus
a
man
hates
the
house
they
lived
in
together,
because
either
he
does
not
change
it,
so
that
it
is
as
dead
as
his
wife,
or
because
he
does
change
it,
so
that
it
is
no
longer
half
of
her
making."
"You
don't
have
to
be
angry
at
our
little
Qing-jao,"
said
Jiang-qing.
"Why?"
asked
Han
Fei-tzu.
"Will
you
stay,
then,
and
help
me
teach
her
to
be
a
woman?
All
I
can
teach
her
is
to
be
what
I
am--
cold
and
hard,
sharp
and
strong,
like
obsidian.
If
she
grows
like
that,
while
she
looks
so
much
like
you,
how
can
I
help
but
be
angry?"
"Because
you
can
teach
her
everything
that
I
am,
too,"
said
Jiang-qing.
"If
I
had
any
part
of
you
in
me,"
said
Han
Fei-tzu,
"I
would
not
have
needed
to
marry
you
to
become
a
complete
person."
Now
he
teased
her
by
using
philosophy
to
turn
the
conversation
away
from
pain.
"That
is
the
desire
of
the
soul.
Because
the
soul
is
made
of
light
and
dwells
in
air,
it
is
that
part
which
conceives
and
keeps
ideas,
especially
the
idea
of
the
self.
The
husband
longs
for
his
whole
self,
which
was
made
of
the
husband
and
wife
together.
Thus
he
never
believes
any
of
his
own
thoughts,
because
there
is
always
a
question
in
his
mind
to
which
his
wife's
thoughts
were
the
only
possible
answer.
Thus
the
whole
world
seems
dead
to
him
because
he
cannot
trust
anything
to
keep
its
meaning
before
the
onslaught
of
this
unanswerable
question."
"Very
deep,"
said
Jiang-qing.
"If
I
were
Japanese
I
would
commit
seppuku,
spilling
my
bowel
into
the
jar
of
your
ashes."
"Very
wet
and
messy,"
she
said.
He
smiled.
"Then
I
should
be
an
ancient
Hindu,
and
burn
myself
on
your
pyre."
But
she
was
through
with
joking.
"Qing-jao,"
she
whispered.
She
was
reminding
him
he
could
do
nothing
so
flamboyant
as
to
die
with
her.
There
was
little
Qing-jao
to
care
for.
So
Han
Fei-tzu
answered
her
seriously.
"How
can
I
teach
her
to
be
what
you
are?"
"All
that
is
good
in
me,"
said
Jiang-qing,
"comes
from
the
Path.
If
you
teach
her
to
obey
the
gods,
honor
the
ancestors,
love
the
people,
and
serve
the
rulers,
I
will
be
in
her
as
much
as
you
are."
"I
would
teach
her
the
Path
as
part
of
myself,"
said
Han
Fei-tzu.
"Not
so,"
said
Jiang-qing.
"The
Path
is
not
a
natural
part
of
you,
my
husband.
Even
with
the
gods
speaking
to
you
every
day,
you
insist
on
believing
in
a
world
where
everything
can
be
explained
by
natural
causes."
"I
obey
the
gods."
He
thought,
bitterly,
that
he
had
no
choice;
that
even
to
delay
obedience
was
torture.
"But
you
don't
know
them.
You
don't
love
their
works."
"The
Path
is
to
love
the
people.
The
gods
we
only
obey."
How
can
I
love
gods
who
humiliate
me
and
torment
me
at
every
opportunity?
"We
love
the
people
because
they
are
creatures
of
the
gods."
"Don't
preach
to
me."
She
sighed.
Her
sadness
stung
him
like
a
spider.
"I
wish
you
would
preach
to
me
forever,"
said
Han
Fei-tzu.
"You
married
me
because
you
knew
I
loved
the
gods,
and
that
love
for
them
was
completely
missing
from
yourself.
That
was
how
I
completed
you."
How
could
he
argue
with
her,
when
he
knew
that
even
now
he
hated
the
gods
for
everything
they
had
ever
done
to
him,
everything
they
had
ever
made
him
do,
everything
they
had
stolen
from
him
in
his
life.
"Promise
me,"
said
Jiang-qing.
He
knew
what
these
words
meant.
She
felt
death
upon
her;
she
was
laying
the
burden
of
her
life
upon
him.
A
burden
he
would
gladly
bear.
It
was
losing
her
company
on
the
Path
that
he
had
dreaded
for
so
long.
"Promise
that
you
will
teach
Qing-jao
to
love
the
gods
and
walk
always
on
the
Path.
Promise
that
you
will
make
her
as
much
my
daughter
as
yours."
"Even
if
she
never
hears
the
voice
of
the
gods?"
"The
Path
is
for
everyone,
not
just
the
godspoken."
Perhaps,
thought
Han
Fei-tzu,
but
it
was
much
easier
for
the
godspoken
to
follow
the
Path,
because
to
them
the
price
for
straying
from
it
was
so
terrible.
The
common
people
were
free;
they
could
leave
the
Path
and
not
feel
the
pain
of
it
for
years.
The
godspoken
couldn't
leave
the
Path
for
an
hour.
"Promise
me."
I
will.
I
promise.
But
he
couldn't
say
the
words
out
loud.
He
did
not
know
why,
but
his
reluctance
was
deep.
In
the
silence,
as
she
waited
for
his
vow,
they
heard
the
sound
of
running
feet
on
the
gravel
outside
the
front
door
of
the
house.
It
could
only
be
Qing-jao,
home
from
the
garden
of
Sun
Cao-pi.
Only
Qing-jao
was
allowed
to
run
and
make
noise
during
this
time
of
hush,
They
waited,
knowing
that
she
would
come
straight
to
her
mother's
room.
The
door
slid
open
almost
noiselessly.
Even
Qing-jao
had
caught
enough
of
the
hush
to
walk
softly
when
she
was
actually
in
the
presence
of
her
mother.
Though
she
walked
on
tiptoe,
she
could
hardly
keep
from
dancing,
almost
galloping
across
the
floor.
But
she
did
not
fling
her
arms
around
her
mother's
neck;
she
remembered
that
lesson
even
though
the
terrible
bruise
had
faded
from
Jiang-qing's
face,
where
Qing-jao's
eager
embrace
had
broken
her
jaw
three
months
ago.
"I
counted
twenty-three
white
carp
in
the
garden
stream,"
said
Qing-jao.
"So
many,"
said
Jiang-qing.
"I
think
they
were
showing
themselves
to
me,"
said
Qing-jao.
"So
I
could
count
them.
None
of
them
wanted
to
be
left
out."
"Love
you,"
whispered
Jiang-qing.
Han
Fei-tzu
heard
a
new
sound
in
her
breathy
voice--
a
popping
sound,
like
bubbles
bursting
with
her
words.
"Do
you
think
that
seeing
so
many
carp
means
that
I
will
be
godspoken?"
asked
Qing-jao.
"I
will
ask
the
gods
to
speak
to
you,"
said
Jiang-qing.
Suddenly
Jiang-qing's
breathing
became
quick
and
harsh.
Han
Fei-tzu
immediately
knelt
and
looked
at
his
wife.
Her
eyes
were
wide
and
frightened.
The
moment
had
come.
Her
lips
moved.
Promise
me,
she
said,
though
her
breath
could
make
no
sound
but
gasping.
"I
promise,"
said
Han
Fei-tzu.
Then
her
breathing
stopped.
"What
do
the
gods
say
when
they
talk
to
you?"
asked
Qing-jao.
"Your
mother
is
very
tired,"
said
Han
Fei-tzu.
"You
should
go
out
now."
"But
she
didn't
answer
me.
What
do
the
gods
say?"
"They
tell
secrets,"
said
Han
Fei-tzu.
"No
one
who
hears
will
repeat
them."
Qing-jao
nodded
wisely.
She
took
a
step
back,
as
if
to
leave,
but
stopped.
"May
I
kiss
you,
Mama?"
"Lightly
on
the
cheek,"
said
Han
Fei-tzu.
Qing-jao,
being
small
for
a
four-year-old,
did
not
have
to
bend
very
far
at
all
to
kiss
her
mother's
cheek.
"I
love
you,
Mama."
"You'd
better
leave
now,
Qing-jao,"
said
Han
Fei-tzu.
"But
Mama
didn't
say
she
loved
me
too."
"She
did.
She
said
it
before.
Remember?
But
she's
very
tired
and
weak.
Go
now."
He
put
just
enough
sternness
in
his
voice
that
Qing-jao
left
without
further
questions.
Only
when
she
was
gone
did
Han
Fei-tzu
let
himself
feel
anything
but
care
for
her.
He
knelt
over
Jiang-qing's
body
and
tried
to
imagine
what
was
happening
to
her
now.
Her
soul
had
flown
and
was
now
already
in
heaven.
Her
spirit
would
linger
much
longer;
perhaps
her
spirit
would
dwell
in
this
house,
if
it
had
truly
been
a
place
of
happiness
for
her.
Superstitious
people
believed
that
all
spirits
of
the
dead
were
dangerous,
and
put
up
signs
and
wards
to
fend
them
off.
But
those
who
followed
the
Path
knew
that
the
spirit
of
a
good
person
was
never
harmful
or
destructive,
for
their
goodness
in
life
had
come
from
the
spirit's
love
of
making
things.
Jiang-qing's
spirit
would
be
a
blessing
in
the
house
for
many
years
to
come,
if
she
chose
to
stay.
Yet
even
as
he
tried
to
imagine
her
soul
and
spirit,
according
to
the
teachings
of
the
Path,
there
was
a
cold
place
in
his
heart
that
was
certain
that
all
that
was
left
of
Jiang-qing
was
this
brittle,
dried-up
body.
Tonight
it
would
burn
as
quickly
as
paper,
and
then
she
would
be
gone
except
for
the
memories
in
his
heart.
Jiang-qing
was
right.
Without
her
to
complete
his
soul,
he
was
already
doubting
the
gods.
And
the
gods
had
noticed--
they
always
did.
At
once
he
felt
the
unbearable
pressure
to
do
the
ritual
of
cleansing,
until
he
was
rid
of
his
unworthy
thoughts.
Even
now
they
could
not
leave
him
unpunished.
Even
now,
with
his
wife
lying
dead
before
him,
the
gods
insisted
that
he
do
obeisance
to
them
before
he
could
shed
a
single
tear
of
grief
for
her.
At
first
he
meant
to
delay,
to
put
off
obedience.
He
had
schooled
himself
to
be
able
to
postpone
the
ritual
for
as
long
as
a
whole
day,
while
hiding
all
outward
signs
of
his
inner
torment.
He
could
do
that
now--
but
only
by
keeping
his
heart
utterly
cold.
There
was
no
point
in
that.
Proper
grief
could
come
only
when
he
had
satisfied
the
gods.
So,
kneeling
there,
he
began
the
ritual.
He
was
still
twisting
and
gyrating
with
the
ritual
when
a
servant
peered
in.
Though
the
servant
said
nothing,
Han
Fei-tzu
heard
the
faint
sliding
of
the
door
and
knew
what
the
servant
would
assume:
Jiangqing
was
dead,
and
Han
Fei-tzu
was
so
righteous
that
he
was
communing
with
the
gods
even
before
he
announced
her
death
to
the
household.
No
doubt
some
would
even
suppose
that
the
gods
had
come
to
take
Jiang-qing,
since
she
was
known
for
her
extraordinary
holiness.
No
one
would
guess
that
even
as
Han
Feitzu
worshiped,
his
heart
was
full
of
bitterness
that
the
gods
would
dare
demand
this
of
him
even
now.
O
Gods,
he
thought,
if
I
knew
that
by
cutting
off
an
arm
or
cutting
out
my
liver
I
could
be
rid
of
you
forever,
I
would
seize
the
knife
and
relish
the
pain
and
loss,
all
for
the
sake
of
freedom.
That
thought,
too,
was
unworthy,
and
required
even
more
cleansing.
It
was
hours
before
the
gods
at
last
released
him,
and
by
then
he
was
too
tired,
too
sick
at
heart
to
grieve.
He
got
up
and
fetched
the
women
to
prepare
Jiang-qing's
body
for
the
burning.
At
midnight
he
was
the
last
to
come
to
the
pyre,
carrying
a
sleepy
Qing-jao
in
his
arms.
She
clutched
in
her
hands
the
three
papers
she
had
written
for
her
mother
in
her
childish
scrawl.
"Fish,"
she
had
written,
and
"book"
and
"secrets."
These
were
the
things
that
Qing-jao
was
giving
to
her
mother
to
carry
with
her
into
heaven.
Han
Fei-tzu
had
tried
to
guess
at
the
thoughts
in
Qing-jao's
mind
as
she
wrote
those
words.
Fish
because
of
the
carp
in
the
garden
stream
today,
no
doubt.
And
book--
that
was
easy
enough
to
understand,
because
reading
aloud
was
one
of
the
last
things
Jiang-qing
could
do
with
her
daughter.
But
why
secrets?
What
secrets
did
Qing-jao
have
for
her
mother?
He
could
not
ask.
One
did
not
discuss
the
paper
offerings
to
the
dead.
Han
Fei-tzu
set
Qing-jao
on
her
feet;
she
had
not
been
deeply
asleep,
and
so
she
woke
at
once
and
stood
there,
blinking
slowly.
Han
Fei-tzu
whispered
to
her
and
she
rolled
her
papers
and
tucked
them
into
her
mother's
sleeve.
She
didn't
seem
to
mind
touching
her
mother's
cold
flesh--
she
was
too
young
to
have
learned
to
shudder
at
the
touch
of
death.
Nor
did
Han
Fei-tzu
mind
the
touch
of
his
wife's
flesh
as
he
tucked
his
own
three
papers
into
her
other
sleeve.
What
was
there
to
fear
from
death
now,
when
it
had
already
done
its
worst?
No
one
knew
what
was
written
on
his
papers,
or
they
would
have
been
horrified,
for
he
had
written,
"My
body,"
"My
spirit,"
and
"My
soul."
Thus
it
was
that
he
burned
himself
on
Jiang-qing's
funeral
pyre,
and
sent
himself
with
her
wherever
it
was
she
was
going.
Then
Jiang-qing's
secret
maid,
Mu-pao,
laid
the
torch
onto
the
sacred
wood
and
the
pyre
burst
into
flames.
The
heat
of
the
fire
was
painful,
and
Qing-jao
hid
herself
behind
her
father,
only
peeking
around
him
now
and
then
to
watch
her
mother
leave
on
her
endless
journey.
Han
Fei-tzu,
though,
welcomed
the
dry
heat
that
seared
his
skin
and
made
brittle
the
silk
of
his
robe.
Her
body
had
not
been
as
dry
as
it
seemed;
long
after
the
papers
had
crisped
into
ash
and
blown
upward
into
the
smoke
of
the
fire,
her
body
still
sizzled,
and
the
heavy
incense
burning
all
around
the
fire
could
not
conceal
from
him
the
smell
of
burning
flesh.
That
is
what
we're
burning
here:
meat,
fish,
carrion,
nothing.
Not
my
Jiang-qing.
Only
the
costume
she
wore
into
this
life.
That
which
made
that
body
into
the
woman
that
I
loved
is
still
alive,
must
still
live.
And
for
a
moment
he
thought
he
could
see,
or
hear,
or
somehow
feel
the
passage
of
Jiang-qing.
Into
the
air,
into
the
earth,
into
the
fire.
I
am
with
you.
Chapter
2
--
A
MEETING
<The
strangest
thing
about
humans
is
the
way
they
pair
up,
males
and
females.
Constantly
at
war
with
each
other,
never
content
to
leave
each
other
alone.
They
never
seem
to
grasp
the
idea
that
males
and
females
are
separate
species
with
completely
different
needs
and
desires,
forced
to
come
together
only
to
reproduce.>
<Of
course
you
feel
that
way.
Your
mates
are
nothing
but
mindless
drones,
extensions
of
yourself,
without
their
own
identity.>
<We
know
our
lovers
with
perfect
understanding.
Humans
invent
an
imaginary
lover
and
put
that
mask
over
the
face
of
the
body
in
their
bed.>
<That
is
the
tragedy
of
language,
my
friend.
Those
who
know
each
other
only
through
symbolic
representations
are
forced
to
imagine
each
other.
And
because
their
imagination
is
imperfect,
they
are
often
wrong.>
<That
is
the
source
of
their
misery.>
<And
some
of
their
strength,
I
think.
Your
people
and
mine,
each
for
our
own
evolutionary
reasons,
mate
with
vastly
unequal
partners.
Our
mates
are
always,
hopelessly,
our
intellectual
inferiors.
Humans
mate
with
beings
who
challenge
their
supremacy.
They
have
conflict
between
mates,
not
because
their
communication
is
inferior
to
ours,
but
because
they
commune
with
each
other
at
all.>
Valentine
Wiggin
read
over
her
essay,
making
a
few
corrections
here
and
there.
When
she
was
done,
the
words
stood
in
the
air
over
her
computer
terminal.
She
was
feeling
pleased
with
herself
for
having
written
such
a
deft
ironic
dismemberment
of
the
personal
character
of
Rymus
Ojman,
the
chairman
of
the
cabinet
of
Starways
Congress.
"Have
we
finished
another
attack
on
the
masters
of
the
Hundred
Worlds?"
Valentine
did
not
turn
to
face
her
husband;
she
knew
from
his
voice
exactly
what
expression
would
be
on
his
face,
and
so
she
smiled
back
at
him
without
turning
around.
After
twenty-five
years
of
marriage,
they
could
see
each
other
clearly
without
having
to
look.
"We
have
made
Rymus
Ojman
look
ridiculous."
Jakt
leaned
into
her
tiny
office,
his
face
so
close
to
hers
that
she
could
hear
his
soft
breathing
as
he
read
the
opening
paragraphs.
He
wasn't
young
anymore;
the
exertion
of
leaning
into
her
office,
bracing
his
hands
on
the
doorframe,
was
making
him
breathe
more
rapidly
than
she
liked
to
hear.
Then
he
spoke,
but
with
his
face
so
close
to
hers
that
she
felt
his
lips
brush
her
cheek,
tickling
her
with
every
word.
"From
now
on
even
his
mother
will
laugh
behind
her
hand
whenever
she
sees
the
poor
bastard."
"It
was
hard
to
make
it
funny,"
said
Valentine.
"I
caught
myself
denouncing
him
again
and
again."
"This
is
better."
"Oh,
I
know.
If
I
had
let
my
outrage
show,
if
I
had
accused
him
of
all
his
crimes,
it
would
have
made
him
seem
more
formidable
and
frightening
and
the
Rule-of-law
Faction
would
have
loved
him
all
the
more,
while
the
cowards
on
every
world
would
have
bowed
to
him
even
lower."
"If
they
bow
any
lower
they'll
have
to
buy
thinner
carpets,"
said
Jakt.
She
laughed,
but
it
was
as
much
because
the
tickling
of
his
lips
on
her
cheek
was
becoming
unbearable.
It
was
also
beginning,
just
a
little,
to
tantalize
her
with
desires
that
simply
could
not
be
satisfied
on
this
voyage.
The
starship
was
too
small
and
cramped,
with
all
their
family
aboard,
for
any
real
privacy.
"Jakt,
we're
almost
at
the
midpoint.
We've
abstained
longer
than
this
during
the
mishmish
run
every
year
of
our
lives."
"We
could
put
a
do-not-enter
sign
on
the
door."
"Then
you
might
just
as
well
put
out
a
sign
that
says,
'naked
elderly
couple
reliving
old
memories
inside.'"
"I'm
not
elderly."
"You're
over
sixty."
"If
the
old
soldier
can
still
stand
up
and
salute,
I
say
let
him
march
in
the
parade."
"No
parades
till
the
voyage
is
over.
It's
only
a
couple
of
weeks
more.
We
only
have
to
complete
this
rendezvous
with
Ender's
stepson
and
then
we're
back
on
course
to
Lusitania."
Jakt
drew
away
from
her,
pulled
himself
out
of
her
doorway
and
stood
upright
in
the
corridor--
one
of
the
few
places
on
the
starship
where
he
could
actually
do
that.
He
groaned
as
he
did
it,
though.
"You
creak
like
an
old
rusty
door,"
said
Valentine.
"I've
heard
you
make
the
same
sounds
when
you
get
up
from
your
desk
here.
I'm
not
the
only
senile,
decrepit,
miserable
old
coot
in
our
family."
"Go
away
and
let
me
transmit
this."
"I'm
used
to
having
work
to
do
on
a
voyage,"
said
Jakt.
"The
computers
do
everything
here,
and
this
ship
never
rolls
or
pitches
in
the
sea."
"Read
a
book."
"I
worry
about
you.
All
work
and
no
play
makes
Val
a
mean-tempered
old
hag."
"Every
minute
that
we
talk
here
is
eight
and
a
half
hours
in
real
time."
"Our
time
here
on
this
starship
is
just
as
real
as
their
time
out
there,"
said
Jakt.
"Sometimes
I
wish
Ender's
friends
hadn't
figured
out
a
way
for
our
starship
to
keep
up
a
landside
link."
"It
takes
up
a
huge
amount
of
computer
time,"
said
Val.
"Until
now,
only
the
military
could
communicate
with
starships
during
near-lightspeed
flight.
If
Ender's
friends
can
achieve
it,
then
I
owe
it
to
them
to
use
it."
"You're
not
doing
all
this
because
you
owe
it
to
somebody."
That
was
true
enough.
"If
I
write
an
essay
every
hour,
Jakt,
it
means
that
to
the
rest
of
humanity
Demosthenes
is
publishing
something
only
once
every
three
weeks."
"You
can't
possibly
write
an
essay
every
hour.
You
sleep,
you
eat."
"You
talk,
I
listen.
Go
away,
Jakt."
"If
I'd
known
that
saving
a
planet
from
destruction
would
mean
my
returning
to
a
state
of
virginity,
I'd
never
have
agreed
to
it."
He
was
only
half
teasing.
Leaving
Trondheim
was
a
hard
decision
for
all
her
family--
even
for
her,
even
knowing
that
she
was
going
to
see
Ender
again.
The
children
were
all
adults
now,
or
nearly
so;
they
saw
this
voyage
as
a
great
adventure.
Their
visions
of
the
future
were
not
so
tied
to
a
particular
place.
None
of
them
had
become
a
sailor,
like
their
father;
all
of
them
were
becoming
scholars
or
scientists,
living
the
life
of
public
discourse
and
private
contemplation,
like
their
mother.
They
could
live
their
lives,
substantially
unchanged,
anywhere,
on
any
world.
Jakt
was
proud
of
them,
but
disappointed
that
the
chain
of
family
reaching
back
for
seven
generations
on
the
seas
of
Trondheim
would
end
with
him.
And
now,
for
her
sake,
he
had
given
up
the
sea
himself.
Giving
up
Trondheim
was
the
hardest
thing
she
could
ever
have
asked
of
Jakt,
and
he
had
said
yes
without
hesitation.
Perhaps
he
would
go
back
someday,
and,
if
he
did,
the
oceans,
the
ice,
the
storms,
the
fish,
the
desperately
sweet
green
meadows
of
summer
would
still
be
there.
But
his
crews
would
be
gone,
were
already
gone.
The
men
he
had
known
better
than
his
own
children,
better
than
his
wife--
those
men
were
already
fifteen
years
older,
and
when
he
returned,
if
he
returned,
another
forty
years
would
have
passed.
Their
grandsons
would
be
working
the
boats
then.
They
wouldn't
know
the
name
of
Jakt.
He'd
be
a
foreign
shipowner,
come
from
the
sky,
not
a
sailor,
not
a
man
with
the
stink
and
yellowy
blood
of
skrika
on
his
hands.
He
would
not
be
one
of
them.
So
when
he
complained
that
she
was
ignoring
him,
when
he
teased
about
their
lack
of
intimacy
during
the
voyage,
there
was
more
to
it
than
an
aging
husband's
playful
desire.
Whether
he
knew
he
was
saying
it
or
not,
she
understood
the
true
meaning
of
his
overtures:
After
what
I've
given
up
for
you,
have
you
nothing
to
give
to
me?
And
he
was
right--
she
was
pushing
herself
harder
than
she
needed
to.
She
was
making
more
sacrifices
than
needed
to
be
made--
requiring
overmuch
from
him
as
well.
It
wasn't
the
sheer
number
of
subversive
essays
that
Demosthenes
published
during
this
voyage
that
would
make
the
difference.
What
mattered
was
how
many
people
read
and
believed
what
she
wrote,
and
how
many
then
thought
and
spoke
and
acted
as
enemies
of
Starways
Congress.
Perhaps
more
important
was
the
hope
that
some
within
the
bureaucracy
of
Congress
itself
would
be
moved
to
feel
a
higher
allegiance
to
humanity
and
break
their
maddening
institutional
solidarity.
Some
would
surely
be
changed
by
what
she
wrote.
Not
many,
but
maybe
enough.
And
maybe
it
would
happen
in
time
to
stop
them
from
destroying
the
planet
Lusitania.
If
not,
she
and
Jakt
and
those
who
had
given
up
so
much
to
come
with
them
on
this
voyage
from
Trondheim
would
reach
Lusitania
just
in
time
to
turn
around
and
flee--
or
be
destroyed
along
with
all
the
others
of
that
world.
It
was
not
unreasonable
for
Jakt
to
be
tense,
to
want
to
spend
more
time
with
her.
It
was
unreasonable
for
her
to
be
so
single-minded,
to
use
every
waking
moment
writing
propaganda.
"You
make
the
sign
for
the
door,
and
I'll
make
sure
you
aren't
alone
in
the
room."
"Woman,
you
make
my
heart
go
flip-flop
like
a
dying
flounder,"
said
Jakt.
"You
are
so
romantic
when
you
talk
like
a
fisherman,"
said
Valentine.
"The
children
will
have
a
good
laugh,
knowing
you
couldn't
keep
your
hands
off
me
even
for
the
three
weeks
of
this
voyage."
"They
have
our
genes.
They
should
be
rooting
for
us
to
stay
randy
till
we're
well
into
our
second
century."
"I'm
well
into
my
fourth
millennium."
"When
oh
when
can
I
expect
you
in
my
stateroom,
Ancient
One?"
"When
I've
transmitted
this
essay."
"And
how
long
will
that
be?"
"Sometime
after
you
go
away
and
leave
me
alone."
With
a
deep
sigh
that
was
more
theatre
than
genuine
misery,
he
padded
off
down
the
carpeted
corridor.
After
a
moment
there
came
a
clanging
sound
and
she
heard
him
yelp
in
pain.
In
mock
pain,
of
course;
he
had
accidentally
hit
the
metal
beam
with
his
head
on
the
first
day
of
the
voyage,
but
ever
since
then
his
collisions
had
been
deliberate,
for
comic
effect.
No
one
ever
laughed
out
loud,
of
course--
that
was
a
family
tradition,
not
to
laugh
when
Jakt
pulled
one
of
his
physical
gags--
but
then
Jakt
was
not
the
sort
of
man
who
needed
overt
encouragement
from
others.
He
was
his
own
best
audience;
a
man
couldn't
be
a
sailor
and
a
leader
of
men
all
his
life
without
being
quite
self-contained.
As
far
as
Valentine
knew,
she
and
the
children
were
the
only
people
he
had
ever
allowed
himself
to
need.
Even
then,
he
had
not
needed
them
so
much
that
he
couldn't
go
on
with
his
life
as
a
sailor
and
fisherman,
away
from
home
for
days,
often
weeks,
sometimes
months
at
a
time.
Valentine
went
with
him
sometimes
at
first,
when
they
were
still
so
hungry
for
each
other
that
they
could
never
be
satisfied.
But
within
a
few
years
their
hunger
had
given
way
to
patience
and
trust;
when
he
was
away,
she
did
her
research
and
wrote
her
books,
and
then
gave
her
entire
attention
to
him
and
the
children
when
he
returned.
The
children
used
to
complain,
"I
wish
Father
would
get
home,
so
Mother
would
come
out
of
her
room
and
talk
to
us
again."
I
was
not
a
very
good
mother,
Valentine
thought.
It's
pure
luck
that
the
children
turned
out
so
well.
The
essay
remained
in
the
air
over
the
terminal.
Only
a
final
touch
remained
to
be
given.
At
the
bottom,
she
centered
the
cursor
and
typed
the
name
under
which
all
her
writings
were
published:
DEMOSTHENES
It
was
a
name
given
to
her
by
her
older
brother,
Peter,
when
they
were
children
together
fifty--
no,
three
thousand
years
ago.
The
mere
thought
of
Peter
still
had
the
power
to
upset
her,
to
make
her
go
hot
and
cold
inside.
Peter,
the
cruel
one,
the
violent
one,
the
one
whose
mind
was
so
subtle
and
dangerous
that
he
was
manipulating
her
by
the
age
of
two
and
the
world
by
the
age
of
twenty.
When
they
were
still
children
on
Earth
in
the
twentysecond
century,
he
studied
the
political
writings
of
great
men
and
women,
living
and
dead,
not
to
learn
their
ideas--
those
he
grasped
instantly--
but
to
learn
how
they
said
them.
To
learn,
in
practical
terms,
how
to
sound
like
an
adult.
When
he
had
mastered
it,
he
taught
Valentine,
and
forced
her
to
write
low
political
demagoguery
under
the
name
Demosthenes
while
he
wrote
elevated
statesmanlike
essays
under
the
name
Locke.
Then
they
submitted
them
to
the
computer
networks
and
within
a
few
years
were
at
the
heart
of
the
greatest
political
issues
of
the
day.
What
galled
Valentine
then--
and
still
stung
a
bit
today,
since
it
had
never
been
resolved
before
Peter
died-
-
was
that
he,
consumed
by
the
lust
for
power,
had
forced
her
to
write
the
sort
of
thing
that
expressed
his
character,
while
he
got
to
write
the
peace-loving,
elevated
sentiments
that
were
hers
by
nature.
In
those
days
the
name
"Demosthenes"
had
felt
like
a
terrible
burden
to
her.
Everything
she
wrote
under
that
name
was
a
lie;
and
not
even
her
lie--
Peter's
lie.
A
lie
within
a
lie.
Not
now.
Not
for
three
thousand
years.
I've
made
the
name
my
own.
I've
written
histories
and
biographies
that
have
shaped
the
thinking
of
millions
of
scholars
on
the
Hundred
Worlds
and
helped
to
shape
the
identities
of
dozens
of
nations.
So
much
for
you,
Peter.
So
much
for
what
you
tried
to
make
of
me.
Except
that
now,
looking
at
the
essay
she
had
just
written,
she
realized
that
even
though
she
had
freed
herself
from
Peter's
suzerainty,
she
was
still
his
pupil.
All
she
knew
of
rhetoric,
polemic--
yes,
of
demagoguery--
she
had
learned
from
him
or
because
of
his
insistence.
And
now,
though
she
was
using
it
in
a
noble
cause,
she
was
nevertheless
doing
exactly
the
sort
of
political
manipulation
that
Peter
had
loved
so
much.
Peter
had
gone
on
to
become
Hegemon,
ruler
of
all
humanity
for
sixty
years
at
the
beginning
of
the
Great
Expansion.
He
was
the
one
who
united
all
the
quarreling
communities
of
man
for
the
vast
effort
that
flung
starships
out
to
every
world
where
the
buggers
had
once
dwelt,
and
then
on
to
discover
more
habitable
worlds
until,
by
the
time
he
died,
all
the
Hundred
Worlds
had
either
been
settled
or
had
colony
ships
on
the
way.
It
was
almost
a
thousand
years
after
that,
of
course,
before
Starways
Congress
once
again
united
all
of
humankind
under
one
government--
but
the
memory
of
the
first
true
Hegemon--
*the*
Hegemon--
was
at
the
heart
of
the
story
that
made
human
unity
possible.
Out
of
a
moral
wasteland
like
Peter's
soul
came
harmony
and
unity
and
peace.
While
Ender's
legacy,
as
far
as
humanity
remembered,
was
murder,
slaughter,
xenocide.
Ender,
Valentine's
younger
brother,
the
man
she
and
her
family
were
voyaging
to
see--
he
was
the
tender
one,
the
brother
she
loved
and,
in
the
earliest
years,
tried
to
protect.
He
was
the
good
one.
Oh,
yes,
he
had
a
streak
of
ruthlessness
that
rivaled
Peter's,
but
he
had
the
decency
to
be
appalled
by
his
own
brutality.
She
had
loved
him
as
fervently
as
she
had
loathed
Peter;
and
when
Peter
exiled
his
younger
brother
from
the
Earth
that
Peter
was
determined
to
rule,
Valentine
went
with
Ender--
her
final
repudiation
of
Peter's
personal
hegemony
over
her.
And
here
I
am
again,
thought
Valentine,
back
in
the
business
of
politics.
She
spoke
sharply,
in
the
clipped
voice
that
told
her
terminal
that
she
was
giving
it
a
command.
"Transmit,"
she
said.
The
word
transmitting
appeared
in
the
air
above
her
essay.
Ordinarily,
back
when
she
was
writing
scholarly
works,
she
would
have
had
to
specify
a
destination--
submit
the
essay
to
a
publisher
through
some
roundabout
pathway
so
that
it
could
not
readily
be
traced
to
Valentine
Wiggin.
Now,
though,
a
subversive
friend
of
Ender's,
working
under
the
obvious
code
name
of
"Jane,"
was
taking
care
of
all
that
for
her--
managing
the
tricky
business
of
translating
an
ansible
message
from
a
ship
going
at
near-light
speed
to
a
message
readable
by
a
planetbound
ansible
for
which
time
was
passing
more
than
five
hundred
times
faster.
Since
communicating
with
a
starship
ate
up
huge
amounts
of
planetside
ansible
time,
it
was
usually
done
only
to
convey
navigational
information
and
instructions.
The
only
people
permitted
to
send
extended
text
messages
were
high
officials
in
the
government
or
the
military.
Valentine
could
not
begin
to
understand
how
"Jane"
managed
to
get
so
much
ansible
time
for
these
text
transmissions--
and
at
the
same
time
keep
anyone
from
discovering
where
these
subversive
documents
were
coming
from.
Furthermore,
"Jane"
used
even
more
ansible
time
transmitting
back
to
her
the
published
responses
to
her
writings,
reporting
to
her
on
all
the
arguments
and
strategies
the
government
was
using
to
counter
Valentine's
propaganda.
Whoever
"Jane"
was--
and
Valentine
suspected
that
"Jane"
was
simply
the
name
for
a
clandestine
organization
that
had
penetrated
the
highest
reaches
of
government--
she
was
extraordinarily
good.
And
extraordinarily
foolhardy.
Still,
if
Jane
was
willing
to
expose
herself--
themselves--
to
such
risks,
Valentine
owed
it
to
her--
them--
to
produce
as
many
tracts
as
she
could,
and
as
powerful
and
dangerous
as
she
could
make
them.
If
words
can
be
lethal
weapons,
I
must
provide
them
with
an
arsenal.
But
she
was
still
a
woman;
even
revolutionaries
are
allowed
to
have
a
life,
aren't
they?
Moments
of
joy--
or
pleasure,
or
perhaps
only
relief--
stolen
here
and
there.
She
got
up
from
her
seat,
ignoring
the
pain
that
came
from
moving
after
sitting
so
long,
and
twisted
her
way
out
of
the
door
of
her
tiny
office--
a
storage
bin,
really,
before
they
converted
the
starship
to
their
own
use.
She
was
a
little
ashamed
of
how
eager
she
was
to
get
to
the
room
where
Jakt
would
be
waiting.
Most
of
the
great
revolutionary
propagandists
in
history
would
have
been
able
to
endure
at
least
three
weeks
of
physical
abstinence.
Or
would
they?
She
wondered
if
anyone
had
done
a
study
of
that
particular
question.
She
was
still
imagining
how
a
researcher
would
go
about
writing
a
grant
proposal
for
such
a
project
when
she
got
to
the
four-bunk
compartment
they
shared
with
Syfte
and
her
husband,
Lars,
who
had
proposed
to
her
only
a
few
days
before
they
left,
as
soon
as
he
realized
that
Syfte
really
meant
to
leave
Trondheim.
It
was
hard
to
share
a
cabin
with
newlyweds--
Valentine
always
felt
like
such
an
intruder,
using
the
same
room.
But
there
was
no
choice.
Though
this
starship
was
a
luxury
yacht,
with
all
the
amenities
they
could
hope
for,
it
simply
hadn't
been
meant
to
hold
so
many
bodies.
It
had
been
the
only
starship
near
Trondheim
that
was
remotely
suitable,
so
it
had
to
do.
Their
twenty-year-old
daughter,
Ro,
and
Varsam,
their
sixteen-year-old
son,
shared
another
compartment
with
Plikt,
who
had
been
their
lifelong
tutor
and
dearest
family
friend.
The
members
of
the
yacht's
staff
and
crew
who
had
chosen
to
make
this
voyage
with
them--
it
would
have
been
wrong
to
dismiss
them
all
and
strand
them
on
Trondheim--
used
the
other
two.
The
bridge,
the
dining
room,
the
galley,
the
salon,
the
sleeping
compartments--
all
were
filled
with
people
doing
their
best
not
to
let
their
annoyance
at
the
close
quarters
get
out
of
hand.
None
of
them
were
in
the
corridor
now,
however,
and
Jakt
had
already
taped
a
sign
to
their
door:
STAY
OUT
OR
DIE.
It
was
signed,
"The
proprietor."
Valentine
opened
the
door.
Jakt
was
leaning
against
the
wall
so
close
to
the
door
that
she
was
startled
and
gave
a
little
gasp.
"Nice
to
know
that
the
sight
of
me
can
make
you
cry
out
in
pleasure."
"In
shock."
"Come
in,
my
sweet
seditionist."
"Technically,
you
know,
I'm
the
proprietor
of
this
starship."
"What's
yours
is
mine.
I
married
you
for
your
property."
She
was
inside
the
compartment
now.
He
closed
the
door
and
sealed
it.
"That's
all
I
am
to
you?"
she
asked.
"Real
estate?"
"A
little
plot
of
ground
where
I
can
plow
and
plant
and
harvest,
all
in
their
proper
season."
He
reached
out
to
her;
she
stepped
into
his
arms.
His
hands
slid
lightly
up
her
back,
cradled
her
shoulders.
She
felt
contained
in
his
embrace,
never
confined.
"It's
late
in
the
autumn,"
she
said.
"Getting
on
toward
winter."
"Time
to
harrow,
perhaps,"
said
Jakt.
"Or
perhaps
it's
already
time
to
kindle
up
the
fire
and
keep
the
old
hut
warm
before
the
snow
comes."
He
kissed
her
and
it
felt
like
the
first
time.
"If
you
asked
me
to
marry
you
all
over
again
today,
I'd
say
yes,"
said
Valentine.
"And
if
I
had
only
met
you
for
the
first
time
today,
I'd
ask."
They
had
said
the
same
words
many,
many
times
before.
Yet
they
still
smiled
to
hear
them,
because
they
were
still
true.
***
The
two
starships
had
almost
completed
their
vast
ballet,
dancing
through
space
in
great
leaps
and
delicate
turns
until
at
last
they
could
meet
and
touch.
Miro
Ribeira
had
watched
the
whole
process
from
the
bridge
of
his
starship,
his
shoulders
hunched,
his
head
leaned
back
on
the
headrest
of
the
seat.
To
others
this
posture
always
looked
awkward.
Back
on
Lusitania,
whenever
Mother
caught
him
sitting
that
way
she
would
come
and
fuss
over
him,
insist
on
bringing
him
a
pillow
so
he
could
be
comfortable.
She
never
seemed
to
grasp
the
idea
that
it
was
only
in
that
hunched,
awkward-seeming
posture
that
his
head
would
remain
upright
without
any
conscious
effort
on
his
part.
He
would
endure
her
ministrations
because
it
wasn't
worth
the
effort
to
argue
with
her.
Mother
was
always
moving
and
thinking
so
quickly,
it
was
almost
impossible
for
her
to
slow
down
enough
to
listen
to
him.
Since
the
brain
damage
he
had
suffered
passing
through
the
disruptor
field
that
separated
the
human
colony
and
the
piggies'
forest,
his
speech
had
been
unbearably
slow,
painful
to
produce
and
difficult
to
understand.
Miro's
brother
Quim,
the
religious
one,
had
told
him
that
he
should
be
grateful
to
God
that
he
was
able
to
speak
at
all--
the
first
few
days
he
had
been
incapable
of
communicating
except
through
alphabetic
scanning,
spelling
out
messages
letter
by
letter.
In
some
ways,
though,
spelling
things
out
had
been
better.
At
least
then
Miro
had
been
silent;
he
hadn't
had
to
listen
to
his
own
voice.
The
thick,
awkward
sound,
the
agonizing
slowness
of
it.
Who
in
his
family
had
the
patience
to
listen
to
him?
Even
the
ones
who
tried--
his
next-younger
sister,
Ela;
his
friend
and
stepfather,
Andrew
Wiggin,
the
Speaker
for
the
Dead;
and
Quim,
of
course--
he
could
feel
their
impatience.
They
tended
to
finish
his
sentences
for
him.
They
needed
to
hurry
things.
So
even
though
they
said
they
wanted
to
talk
with
him,
even
though
they
actually
sat
and
listened
as
he
spoke,
he
still
couldn't
speak
freely
to
them.
He
couldn't
talk
about
ideas;
he
couldn't
speak
in
long,
involved
sentences,
because
by
the
time
he
got
to
the
end
his
listeners
would
have
lost
track
of
the
beginning.
The
human
brain,
Miro
had
concluded,
just
like
a
computer,
can
only
receive
data
at
certain
speeds.
If
you
get
too
slow,
the
listener's
attention
wanders
and
the
information
is
lost.
Not
just
the
listeners,
either.
Miro
had
to
be
fair--
he
was
as
impatient
with
himself
as
they
were.
When
he
thought
of
the
sheer
effort
involved
in
explaining
a
complicated
idea,
when
he
anticipated
trying
to
form
the
words
with
lips
and
tongue
and
jaws
that
wouldn't
obey
him,
when
he
thought
of
how
long
it
would
all
take,
he
usually
felt
too
weary
to
speak.
His
mind
raced
on
and
on,
as
fast
as
ever,
thinking
so
many
thoughts
that
at
times
Miro
wanted
his
brain
to
shut
down,
to
be
silent
and
give
him
peace.
But
his
thoughts
remained
his
own,
unshared.
Except
with
Jane.
He
could
speak
to
Jane.
She
had
come
to
him
first
on
his
terminal
at
home,
her
face
taking
form
on
the
screen.
"I'm
a
friend
of
the
Speaker
for
the
Dead,"
she
had
told
him.
"I
think
we
can
get
this
computer
to
be
a
little
more
responsive."
From
then
on,
Miro
had
found
that
Jane
was
the
only
person
he
could
talk
to
easily.
For
one
thing,
she
was
infinitely
patient.
She
never
finished
his
sentences.
She
could
wait
for
him
to
finish
them
himself,
so
that
he
never
felt
rushed,
never
felt
that
he
was
boring
her.
Perhaps
even
more
important,
he
didn't
have
to
form
his
words
as
fully
for
her
as
he
did
for
human
listeners.
Andrew
had
given
him
a
personal
terminal--
a
computer
transceiver
encased
in
a
jewel
like
the
one
Andrew
wore
in
his
own
ear.
From
that
vantage
point,
using
the
jewel's
sensors,
Jane
could
detect
every
sound
he
made,
every
motion
of
the
muscles
in
his
head.
He
didn't
have
to
complete
each
sound,
he
had
only
to
begin
it
and
she
would
understand.
So
he
could
be
lazy.
He
could
speak
more
quickly
and
be
understood.
And
he
could
also
speak
silently.
He
could
subvocalize--
he
didn't
have
to
use
that
awkward,
barking,
yowling
voice
that
was
all
his
throat
could
produce
now.
So
that
when
he
was
talking
to
Jane,
he
could
speak
quickly,
naturally,
without
any
reminder
that
he
was
crippled.
With
Jane
he
could
feel
like
himself.
Now
he
sat
on
the
bridge
of
the
cargo
ship
that
had
brought
the
Speaker
for
the
Dead
to
Lusitania
only
a
few
months
ago.
He
dreaded
the
rendezvous
with
Valentine's
ship.
If
he
could
have
thought
of
somewhere
else
to
go,
he
might
have
gone
there--
he
had
no
desire
to
meet
Andrew's
sister
Valentine
or
anybody
else.
If
he
could
have
stayed
alone
in
the
starship
forever,
speaking
only
to
Jane,
he
would
have
been
content.
No
he
wouldn't.
He
would
never
be
content
again.
At
least
this
Valentine
and
her
family
would
be
somebody
new.
On
Lusitania
he
knew
everybody,
or
at
least
everybody
that
he
valued--
all
the
scientific
community
there,
the
people
of
education
and
understanding.
He
knew
them
all
so
well
that
he
could
not
help
but
see
their
pity,
their
grief,
their
frustration
at
what
had
become
of
him.
When
they
looked
at
him
all
they
could
see
was
the
difference
between
what
he
was
before
and
what
he
was
now.
All
they
could
see
was
loss.
There
was
a
chance
that
new
people--
Valentine
and
her
family--
would
be
able
to
look
at
him
and
see
something
else.
Even
that
was
unlikely,
though.
Strangers
would
look
at
him
and
see
less,
not
more,
than
those
who
had
known
him
before
he
was
crippled.
At
least
Mother
and
Andrew
and
Ela
and
Ouanda
and
all
the
others
knew
that
he
had
a
mind,
knew
that
he
was
capable
of
understanding
ideas.
What
will
new
people
think
when
they
see
me?
They'll
see
a
body
that's
already
atrophying,
hunched
over;
they'll
see
me
walk
with
a
shuffling
gait;
they'll
watch
me
use
my
hands
like
paws,
clutching
a
spoon
like
a
three-year-old;
they'll
hear
my
thick,
half-intelligible
speech;
and
they'll
assume,
they'll
know,
that
such
a
person
cannot
possibly
understand
anything
complicated
or
difficult.
Why
did
I
come?
I
didn't
come.
I
went.
I
wasn't
coming
here,
to
meet
these
people.
I
was
leaving
there.
Getting
away.
Only
I
tricked
myself.
I
thought
of
leaving
on
a
thirty-year
voyage,
which
is
only
how
it
will
seem
to
them.
To
me
I've
been
gone
only
a
week
and
a
half.
No
time
at
all.
And
already
my
time
of
solitude
is
over.
My
time
of
being
alone
with
Jane,
who
listens
to
me
as
if
I
were
still
a
human
being,
is
done.
Almost.
Almost
he
said
the
words
that
would
have
aborted
the
rendezvous.
He
could
have
stolen
Andrew's
starship
and
taken
off
on
a
voyage
that
would
last
forever
without
having
to
face
another
living
soul.
But
such
a
nihilistic
act
was
not
in
him,
not
yet.
He
had
not
yet
despaired,
he
decided.
There
might
yet
be
something
he
could
do
that
might
justify
his
continuing
to
live
in
this
body.
And
perhaps
it
would
begin
with
meeting
Andrew's
sister.
The
ships
were
now
joining,
the
umbilicals
snaking
outward
and
searching,
groping
till
they
met
each
other.
Miro
watched
on
the
monitors
and
listened
to
the
computer
reports
of
each
successful
linkage.
The
ships
were
joining
in
every
possible
way
so
that
they
could
make
the
rest
of
the
voyage
to
Lusitania
in
perfect
tandem.
All
resources
would
be
shared.
Since
Miro's
ship
was
a
cargo
vessel,
it
couldn't
take
on
more
than
a
handful
of
people,
but
it
could
take
some
of
the
other
ship's
life-support
supplies;
together,
the
two
ship's
computers
were
figuring
out
a
perfect
balance.
Once
they
had
calculated
the
load,
they
worked
out
exactly
how
fast
each
ship
should
accelerate
as
they
made
the
park
shift
to
get
them
both
back
to
near-lightspeed
at
exactly
the
same
pace.
It
was
an
extremely
delicate
and
complicated
negotiation
between
two
computers
that
had
to
know
almost
perfectly
what
their
ships
carried
and
how
they
could
perform.
It
was
finished
before
the
passage
tube
between
the
ships
was
fully
connected.
Miro
heard
the
footsteps
scuffing
along
the
corridor
from
the
tube.
He
turned
his
chair--
slowly,
because
he
did
everything
slowly--
and
saw
her
coming
toward
him.
Stooped
over,
but
not
very
much,
because
she
wasn't
that
tall
to
begin
with.
Hair
mostly
white,
with
a
few
strands
of
mousy
brown.
When
she
stood
he
looked
at
her
face
and
judged
her.
Old
but
not
elderly.
If
she
was
nervous
about
this
meeting
it
didn't
show.
But
then,
from
what
Andrew
and
Jane
had
told
him
about
her,
she
had
met
a
lot
of
people
who
were
a
good
deal
more
fearsome
than
a
twenty-year-old
cripple.
"Miro?"
she
asked.
"Who
else?"
he
said.
It
took
a
moment,
just
a
heartbeat,
for
her
to
process
the
strange
sounds
that
came
out
of
his
mouth
and
recognize
the
words.
He
was
used
to
that
pause
now,
but
he
still
hated
it.
"I'm
Valentine,"
she
said.
"I
know,"
he
answered.
He
wasn't
making
this
any
easier,
with
his
laconic
replies,
but
what
else
was
there
to
say?
This
wasn't
exactly
a
meeting
between
heads
of
state
with
a
list
of
vital
decisions
to
make.
But
he
had
to
make
some
effort,
if
only
not
to
seem
hostile.
"Your
name,
Miro--
it
means
'I
look,'
doesn't
it?"
"'I
look
closely.'
Maybe
'I
pay
attention.'"
"It's
really
not
that
hard
to
understand
you,"
said
Valentine.
He
was
startled
that
she
addressed
the
matter
so
openly.
"I
think
I'm
having
more
problems
with
your
Portuguese
accent
than
with
the
brain
damage."
For
a
moment
it
felt
like
a
hammer
in
his
heart--
she
was
speaking
more
frankly
about
his
situation
than
anyone
except
Andrew.
But
then
she
was
Andrew's
sister,
wasn't
she?
He
should
have
expected
her
to
be
plainspoken.
"Or
do
you
prefer
that
we
pretend
that
it
isn't
a
barrier
between
you
and
other
people?"
Apparently
she
had
sensed
his
shock.
But
that
was
over,
and
now
it
occurred
to
him
that
he
probably
shouldn't
be
annoyed,
that
he
should
probably
be
glad
that
they
wouldn't
have
to
sidestep
the
issue.
Yet
he
was
annoyed,
and
it
took
him
a
moment
to
think
why.
Then
he
knew.
"My
brain
damage
isn't
your
problem,"
he
said.
"If
it
makes
it
hard
for
me
to
understand
you,
then
it's
a
problem
I
have
to
deal
with.
Don't
get
prickly
with
me
already,
young
man.
I
have
only
begun
to
bother
you,
and
you
have
only
begun
to
bother
me.
So
don't
get
steamed
up
because
I
happened
to
mention
your
brain
damage
as
being
somehow
my
problem.
I
have
no
intention
of
watching
every
word
I
say
for
fear
I'll
offend
an
oversensitive
young
man
who
thinks
the
whole
world
revolves
around
his
disappointments."
Miro
was
furious
that
she
had
judged
him
already,
and
so
harshly.
It
was
unfair--
not
at
all
what
the
author
of
Demosthenes'
hierarchy
ought
to
be
like.
"I
don't
think
the
whole
world
revolves
around
my
disappointments!
But
don't
you
think
you
can
come
in
here
and
run
things
on
my
ship!"
That's
what
annoyed
him,
not
her
words.
She
was
right--
her
words
were
nothing.
It
was
her
attitude,
her
complete
selfconfidence.
He
wasn't
used
to
people
looking
at
him
without
shock
or
pity.
She
sat
down
in
the
seat
next
to
him.
He
swiveled
to
face
her.
She,
for
her
part,
did
not
look
away.
Indeed,
she
pointedly
scanned
his
body,
head
to
toe,
looking
him
over
with
an
air
of
cool
appraisal.
"He
said
you
were
tough.
He
said
you
had
been
twisted
but
not
broken."
"Are
you
supposed
to
be
my
therapist?"
"Are
you
supposed
to
be
my
enemy?"
"Should
I
be?"
asked
Miro.
"No
more
than
I
should
be
your
therapist.
Andrew
didn't
have
us
meet
so
I
could
heal
you.
He
had
us
meet
so
you
could
help
me.
If
you're
not
going
to,
fine.
If
you
are,
fine.
Just
let
me
make
a
few
things
clear.
I'm
spending
every
waking
moment
writing
subversive
propaganda
to
try
to
arouse
public
sentiment
on
the
Hundred
Worlds
and
in
the
colonies.
I'm
trying
to
turn
the
people
against
the
fleet
that
Starways
Congress
has
sent
to
subdue
Lusitania.
Your
world,
not
mine,
I
might
add."
"Your
brother's
there."
He
was
not
about
to
let
her
claim
complete
altruism.
"Yes,
we
both
have
family
there.
And
we
both
are
concerned
about
keeping
the
pequeninos
from
destruction.
And
we
both
know
that
Ender
has
restored
the
hive
queen
on
your
world,
so
that
there
are
two
alien
species
that
will
be
destroyed
if
Starways
Congress
gets
its
way.
There's
a
great
deal
at
stake,
and
I
am
already
doing
all
that
I
can
possibly
do
to
try
to
stop
that
fleet.
Now,
if
spending
a
few
hours
with
you
can
help
me
do
it
better,
it's
worth
taking
time
away
from
my
writing
in
order
to
talk
with
you.
But
I
have
no
intention
of
wasting
my
time
worrying
about
whether
I'm
going
to
offend
you
or
not.
So
if
you're
going
to
be
my
adversary,
you
can
sit
up
here
all
by
yourself
and
I'll
get
back
to
my
work."
"Andrew
said
you
were
the
best
person
he
ever
knew."
"He
reached
that
conclusion
before
he
saw
me
raise
three
barbarian
children
to
adulthood.
I
understand
your
mother
has
six."
"Right."
"And
you're
the
oldest."
"Yes."
"That's
too
bad.
Parents
always
make
their
worst
mistakes
with
the
oldest
children.
That's
when
parents
know
the
least
and
care
the
most,
so
they're
more
likely
to
be
wrong
and
also
more
likely
to
insist
that
they're
right."
Miro
didn't
like
hearing
this
woman
leap
to
conclusions
about
his
mother.
"She's
nothing
like
you."
"Of
course
not."
She
leaned
forward
in
her
seat.
"Well,
have
you
decided?"
"Decided
what?"
"Are
we
working
together
or
did
you
just
unplug
yourself
from
thirty
years
of
human
history
for
nothing?"
"What
do
you
want
from
me?"
"Stories,
of
course.
Facts
I
can
get
from
the
computer."
"Stories
about
what?"
"You.
The
piggies.
You
and
the
piggies.
This
whole
business
with
the
Lusitania
Fleet
began
with
you
and
the
piggies,
after
all.
It
was
because
you
interfered
with
them
that--"
"We
helped
them!"
"Oh,
did
I
use
the
wrong
word
again?"
Miro
glared
at
her.
But
even
as
he
did,
he
knew
that
she
was
right--
he
was
being
oversensitive.
The
word
interfered,
when
used
in
a
scientific
context,
was
almost
value-neutral.
It
merely
meant
that
he
had
introduced
change
into
the
culture
he
was
studying.
And
if
it
did
have
a
negative
connotation,
it
was
that
he
had
lost
his
scientific
perspective--
he
had
stopped
studying
the
pequeninos
and
started
treating
them
as
friends.
Of
that
he
was
surely
guilty.
No,
not
guilty--
he
was
proud
of
having
made
that
transition.
"Go
on,"
he
said.
"All
this
began
because
you
broke
the
law
and
piggies
started
growing
amaranth."
"Not
anymore."
"Yes,
that's
ironic,
isn't
it?
The
descolada
virus
has
gotten
in
and
killed
every
strain
of
amaranth
that
your
sister
developed
for
them.
So
your
interference
was
in
vain."
"No
it
wasn't,"
said
Miro.
"They're
learning."
"Yes,
I
know.
More
to
the
point,
they're
choosing.
What
to
learn,
what
to
do.
You
brought
them
freedom.
I
approve
wholeheartedly
of
what
you
decided
to
do.
But
my
job
is
to
write
about
you
to
the
people
out
there
in
the
Hundred
Worlds
and
the
colonies,
and
they
won't
necessarily
see
things
that
way.
So
what
I
need
from
you
is
the
story
of
how
and
why
you
broke
the
law
and
interfered
with
the
piggies,
and
why
the
government
and
people
of
Lusitania
rebelled
against
Congress
rather
than
send
you
off
to
be
tried
and
punished
for
your
crimes."
"Andrew
already
told
you
that
story."
"And
I've
already
written
about
it,
in
larger
terms.
Now
I
need
the
personal
things.
I
want
to
be
able
to
let
other
people
know
these
so-called
piggies
as
people.
And
you,
too.
I
have
to
let
them
know
you
as
a
person.
If
it's
possible,
it
would
be
nice
if
I
could
bring
them
to
like
you.
Then
the
Lusitania
Fleet
will
look
like
what
it
is--
a
monstrous
overreaction
to
a
threat
that
never
existed."
"The
fleet
is
xenocide."
"So
I've
said
in
my
propaganda,"
said
Valentine.
He
couldn't
bear
her
self-certainty.
He
couldn't
bear
her
unshakable
faith
in
herself.
So
he
had
to
contradict
her,
and
the
only
way
he
could
was
to
blurt
out
ideas
that
he
had
not
yet
thought
out
completely.
Ideas
that
were
still
only
half-formed
doubts
in
his
mind.
"The
fleet
is
also
self-defense."
It
had
the
desired
effect--
it
stopped
her
lecture
and
even
made
her
raise
her
eyebrows,
questioning
him.
The
trouble
was,
now
he
had
to
explain
what
he
meant.
"The
descolada,"
he
said.
"It's
the
most
dangerous
form
of
life
anywhere."
"The
answer
to
that
is
quarantine.
Not
sending
a
fleet
armed
with
the
M.D.
Device,
so
they
have
the
capacity
to
turn
Lusitania
and
everybody
on
it
into
microscopic
interstellar
dust."
"You're
so
sure
you're
right?"
"I'm
sure
that
it's
wrong
for
Starways
Congress
even
to
contemplate
obliterating
another
sentient
species."
"The
piggies
can't
live
without
the
descolada,"
said
Miro,
"and
if
the
descolada
ever
spreads
to
another
planet,
it
will
destroy
all
life
there.
It
will."
It
was
a
pleasure
to
see
that
Valentine
was
capable
of
looking
puzzled.
"But
I
thought
the
virus
was
contained.
It
was
your
grandparents
who
found
a
way
to
stop
it,
to
make
it
dormant
in
human
beings."
"The
descolada
adapts,"
said
Miro.
"Jane
told
me
that
it's
already
changed
itself
a
couple
of
times.
My
mother
and
my
sister
Ela
are
working
on
it--
trying
to
stay
ahead
of
the
descolada.
Sometimes
it
even
looks
like
the
descolada
is
doing
it
deliberately.
Intelligently.
Finding
strategies
to
get
around
the
chemicals
we
use
to
contain
it
and
stop
it
from
killing
people.
It's
getting
into
the
Earthborn
crops
that
humans
need
in
order
to
survive
on
Lusitania.
They
have
to
spray
them
now.
What
if
the
descolada
finds
a
way
to
get
around
all
our
barriers?"
Valentine
was
silent.
No
glib
answer
now.
She
hadn't
faced
this
question
squarely--
no
one
had,
except
Miro.
"I
haven't
even
told
this
to
Jane,"
said
Miro.
"But
what
if
the
fleet
is
right?
What
if
the
only
way
to
save
humanity
from
the
descolada
is
to
destroy
Lusitania
now?"
"No,"
said
Valentine.
"This
has
nothing
to
do
with
the
purposes
for
which
Starways
Congress
sent
out
the
fleet.
Their
reasons
all
have
to
do
with
interplanetary
politics,
with
showing
the
colonies
who's
boss.
It
has
to
do
with
a
bureaucracy
out
of
control
and
a
military
that--"
"Listen
to
me!"
said
Miro.
"You
said
you
wanted
to
hear
my
stories,
listen
to
this
one:
It
doesn't
matter
what
their
reasons
are.
It
doesn't
matter
if
they're
a
bunch
of
murderous
beasts.
I
don't
care.
What
matters
is--
should
they
blow
up
Lusitania?"
"What
kind
of
person
are
you?"
asked
Valentine.
He
could
hear
both
awe
and
loathing
in
her
voice.
"You're
the
moral
philosopher,"
said
Miro.
"You
tell
me.
Are
we
supposed
to
love
the
pequeninos
so
much
that
we
allow
the
virus
they
carry
to
destroy
all
of
humanity?"
"Of
course
not.
We
simply
have
to
find
a
way
to
neutralize
the
descolada."
"And
if
we
can't?"
"Then
we
quarantine
Lusitania.
Even
if
all
the
human
beings
on
the
planet
die--
your
family
and
mine--
we
still
don't
destroy
the
pequeninos."
"Really?"
asked
Miro.
"What
about
the
hive
queen?"
"Ender
told
me
that
she
was
reestablishing
herself,
but--"
"She
contains
within
herself
a
complete
industrialized
society.
She's
going
to
build
starships
and
get
off
the
planet."
"She
wouldn't
take
the
descolada
with
her!"
"She
has
no
choice.
The
descolada
is
in
her
already.
It's
in
me."
That
was
when
he
really
got
to
her.
He
could
see
it
in
her
eyes--
the
fear.
"It'll
be
in
you,
too.
Even
if
you
run
back
to
your
ship
and
seal
me
off
and
keep
yourself
from
infection,
once
you
land
on
Lusitania
the
descolada
will
get
into
you
and
your
husband
and
your
children.
They'll
have
to
ingest
the
chemicals
with
their
food
and
water,
every
day
of
their
lives.
And
they
can
never
go
away
from
Lusitania
again
or
they'll
carry
death
and
destruction
with
them."
"I
suppose
we
knew
that
was
a
possibility,"
said
Valentine.
"When
you
left,
it
was
only
a
possibility.
We
thought
that
the
descolada
would
soon
be
controlled.
Now
they
aren't
sure
if
it
can
ever
be
controlled.
And
that
means
that
you
can
never
leave
Lusitania
once
you
go
there."
"I
hope
we
like
the
weather."
Miro
studied
her
face,
the
way
she
was
processing
the
information
he
had
given
her.
The
initial
fear
was
gone.
She
was
herself
again--
thinking.
"Here's
what
I
think,"
said
Miro.
"I
think
that
no
matter
how
terrible
Congress
is,
no
matter
how
evil
their
plans
might
be,
that
fleet
might
be
the
salvation
of
humanity."
Valentine
answered
thoughtfully,
searching
for
words.
Miro
was
glad
to
see
that--
she
was
a
person
who
didn't
shoot
back
without
thinking.
She
was
able
to
learn.
"I
can
see
that
if
events
move
down
one
possible
path,
there
might
be
a
time
when--
but
it's
very
improbable.
First
of
all,
knowing
all
this,
the
hive
queen
is
quite
unlikely
to
build
any
starships
that
would
carry
the
descolada
away
from
Lusitania."
"Do
you
know
the
hive
queen?"
demanded
Miro.
"Do
you
understand
her?"
"Even
if
she
would
do
such
a
thing,"
said
Valentine,
"your
mother
and
sister
are
working
on
this,
aren't
they?
By
the
time
we
reach
Lusitania--
by
the
time
the
fleet
reaches
Lusitania--
they
might
have
found
a
way
to
control
the
descolada
once
and
for
all."
"And
if
they
do,"
said
Miro,
"should
they
use
it?"
"Why
shouldn't
they?"
"How
could
they
kill
all
the
descolada
virus?
The
virus
is
an
integral
part
of
the
pequenino
life
cycle.
When
the
pequenino
body-form
dies,
it's
the
descolada
virus
that
enables
the
transformation
into
the
tree-state,
what
the
piggies
call
the
third
life--
and
it's
only
in
the
third
life,
as
trees,
that
the
pequenino
males
can
fertilize
the
females.
If
the
virus
is
gone,
there
can
be
no
more
passage
into
the
third
life,
and
this
generation
of
piggies
is
the
last."
"That
doesn't
make
it
impossible,
it
only
makes
it
harder.
Your
mother
and
sister
have
to
find
a
way
to
neutralize
the
descolada
in
human
beings
and
the
crops
we
need
to
eat,
without
destroying
its
ability
to
enable
the
pequeninos
to
pass
into
adulthood."
"And
they
have
less
than
fifteen
years
to
do
it,"
said
Miro.
"Not
likely."
"But
not
impossible."
"Yes.
There's
a
chance.
And
on
the
strength
of
that
chance,
you
want
to
get
rid
of
the
fleet?"
"The
fleet
is
being
sent
to
destroy
Lusitania
whether
we
control
the
descolada
virus
or
not."
"And
I
say
it
again--
the
motive
of
the
senders
is
irrelevant.
No
matter
what
the
reason,
the
destruction
of
Lusitania
may
be
the
only
sure
protection
for
all
the
rest
of
humanity."
"And
I
say
you're
wrong."
"You're
Demosthenes,
aren't
you?
Andrew
said
you
were."
"Yes."
"So
you
thought
up
the
Hierarchy
of
Foreignness.
Utlannings
are
strangers
from
our
own
world.
Framlings
are
strangers
of
our
own
species,
but
from
another
world.
Ramen
are
strangers
of
another
species,
but
capable
of
communication
with
us,
capable
of
co-existence
with
humanity.
Last
are
varelse--
and
what
are
they?"
"The
pequeninos
are
not
varelse.
Neither
is
the
hive
queen."
"But
the
descolada
is.
Varelse.
An
alien
life
form
that's
capable
of
destroying
all
of
humanity
..."
"Unless
we
can
tame
it..."
"...
Yet
which
we
cannot
possibly
communicate
with,
an
alien
species
that
we
cannot
live
with.
You're
the
one
who
said
that
in
that
case
war
is
unavoidable.
If
an
alien
species
seems
bent
on
destroying
us
and
we
can't
communicate
with
them,
can't
understand
them,
if
there's
no
possibility
of
turning
them
away
from
their
course
peacefully,
then
we
are
justified
in
any
action
necessary
to
save
ourselves,
including
the
complete
destruction
of
the
other
species."
"Yes,"
said
Valentine.
"But
what
if
we
must
destroy
the
descolada,
and
yet
we
can't
destroy
the
descolada
without
also
destroying
every
living
pequenino,
the
hive
queen,
and
every
human
being
on
Lusitania?"
To
Miro's
surprise,
Valentine's
eyes
were
awash
with
tears.
"So
this
is
what
you
have
become."
Miro
was
confused.
"When
did
this
conversation
become
a
discussion
of
me?"
"You've
done
all
this
thinking,
you've
seen
all
the
possibilities
for
the
future--
good
ones
and
bad
ones
alike--
and
yet
the
only
one
that
you're
willing
to
believe
in,
the
imagined
future
that
you
seize
upon
as
the
foundation
for
all
your
moral
judgments,
is
the
only
future
in
which
everyone
that
you
and
I
have
ever
loved
and
everything
we've
ever
hoped
for
must
be
obliterated."
"I
didn't
say
I
liked
that
future--"
"I
didn't
say
you
liked
it
either,"
said
Valentine.
"I
said
that's
the
future
you
choose
to
prepare
for.
But
I
don't.
I
choose
to
live
in
a
universe
that
has
some
hope
in
it.
I
choose
to
live
in
a
universe
where
your
mother
and
sister
will
find
a
way
to
contain
the
descolada,
a
universe
in
which
Starways
Congress
can
be
reformed
or
replaced,
a
universe
in
which
there
is
neither
the
power
nor
the
will
to
destroy
an
entire
species."
"What
if
you're
wrong?"
"Then
I'll
still
have
plenty
of
time
to
despair
before
I
die.
But
you--
do
you
seek
out
every
opportunity
to
despair?
I
can
understand
the
impulse
that
might
lead
to
that.
Andrew
tells
me
you
were
a
handsome
man--
you
still
are,
you
know--
and
that
losing
the
full
use
of
your
body
has
hurt
you
deeply.
But
other
people
have
lost
more
than
you
have
without
getting
such
a
black-hearted
vision
of
the
world."
"This
is
your
analysis
of
me?"
asked
Miro.
"We've
known
each
other
half
an
hour,
and
now
you
understand
everything
about
me?"
"I
know
that
this
is
the
most
depressing
conversation
I've
ever
had
in
my
life."
"And
so
you
assume
that
it's
because
I
am
crippled.
Well,
let
me
tell
you
something,
Valentine
Wiggin.
I
hope
the
same
things
you
hope.
I
even
hope
that
someday
I'll
get
more
of
my
body
back
again.
If
I
didn't
have
hope
I'd
be
dead.
The
things
I
told
you
just
now
aren't
because
I
despair.
I
said
all
that
because
these
things
are
possible.
And
because
they're
possible
we
have
to
think
of
them
so
they
don't
surprise
us
later.
We
have
to
think
of
them
so
that
if
the
worst
does
come,
we'll
already
know
how
to
live
in
that
universe."
Valentine
seemed
to
be
studying
his
face;
he
felt
her
gaze
on
him
as
an
almost
palpable
thing,
like
a
faint
tickling
under
the
skin,
inside
his
brain.
"Yes,"
she
said.
"Yes
what?"
"Yes,
my
husband
and
I
will
move
over
here
and
live
on
your
ship."
She
got
up
from
her
seat
and
started
toward
the
corridor
leading
back
to
the
tube.
"Why
did
you
decide
that?"
"Because
it's
too
crowded
on
our
ship.
And
because
you
are
definitely
worth
talking
to.
And
not
just
to
get
material
for
the
essays
I
have
to
write."
"Oh,
so
I
passed
your
test?"
"Yes,
you
did,"
she
said.
"Did
I
pass
yours?"
"I
wasn't
testing
you."
"Like
hell,"
she
said.
"But
in
case
you
didn't
notice,
I'll
tell
you--
I
did
pass.
Or
you
wouldn't
have
said
to
me
all
the
things
you
said."
She
was
gone.
He
could
hear
her
shuffling
down
the
corridor,
and
then
the
computer
reported
that
she
was
passing
through
the
tube
between
ships.
He
already
missed
her.
Because
she
was
right.
She
had
passed
his
test.
She
had
listened
to
him
the
way
no
one
else
did--
without
impatience,
without
finishing
his
sentences,
without
letting
her
gaze
waver
from
his
face.
He
had
spoken
to
her,
not
with
careful
precision,
but
with
great
emotion.
Much
of
the
time
his
words
must
surely
have
been
almost
unintelligible.
Yet
she
had
listened
so
carefully
and
well
that
she
had
understood
all
his
arguments
and
never
once
asked
him
to
repeat
something.
He
could
talk
to
this
woman
as
naturally
as
he
ever
talked
to
anyone
before
his
brain
was
injured.
Yes,
she
was
opinionated,
headstrong,
bossy,
and
quick
to
reach
conclusions.
But
she
could
also
listen
to
an
opposing
view,
change
her
mind
when
she
needed
to.
She
could
listen,
and
so
he
could
speak.
Perhaps
with
her
he
could
still
be
Miro.
Chapter
3
--
CLEAN
HANDS
<The
most
unpleasant
thing
about
human
beings
is
that
they
don't
metamorphose.
Your
people
and
mine
are
born
as
grubs,
but
we
transform
ourselves
into
a
higher
form
before
we
reproduce.
Human
beings
remain
grubs
all
their
lives.>
<Human
beings
do
metamorphose.
They
change
their
identity
constantly.
However,
each
new
identity
thrives
on
the
delusion
that
it
was
always
in
possession
of
the
body
it
has
just
conquered.>
<Such
changes
are
superficial.
The
nature
of
the
organism
remains
the
same.
Humans
are
very
proud
of
their
changes,
but
every
imagined
transformation
turns
out
to
be
a
new
set
of
excuses
for
behaving
exactly
as
the
individual
has
always
behaved.>
<You
are
too
different
from
humans
ever
to
understand
them.>
<You
are
too
similar
to
humans
for
you
ever
to
be
able
to
see
them
clearly.>
The
gods
first
spoke
to
Han
Qing-jao
when
she
was
seven
years
old.
She
didn't
realize
for
a
while
that
she
was
hearing
the
voice
of
a
god.
All
she
knew
was
that
her
hands
were
filthy,
covered
with
some
loathsome
invisible
slime,
and
she
had
to
purify
them.
The
first
few
times,
a
simple
washing
was
enough,
and
she
felt
better
for
days.
But
as
time
passed,
the
feeling
of
filthiness
returned
sooner
each
time,
and
it
took
more
and
more
scrubbing
to
remove
the
dirt,
until
she
was
washing
several
times
a
day,
using
a
hard-bristled
brush
to
stab
at
her
hands
until
they
bled.
Only
when
the
pain
was
unbearable
did
she
feel
clean,
and
then
only
for
a
few
hours
at
a
time.
She
told
no
one;
she
kriew
instinctively
that
the
filthiness
of
her
hands
had
to
be
kept
secret.
Everyone
knew
that
handwashing
was
one
of
the
first
signs
that
the
gods
were
speaking
to
a
child,
and
most
parents
in
the
whole
world
of
Path
watched
their
children
hopefully
for
signs
of
excessive
concern
with
cleanliness.
But
what
these
people
did
not
understand
was
the
terrible
self-knowledge
that
led
to
the
washing:
The
first
message
from
the
gods
was
of
the
unspeakable
filthiness
of
the
one
they
spoke
to.
Qing-jao
hid
her
handwashing,
not
because
she
was
ashamed
that
the
gods
spoke
to
her,
but
because
she
was
sure
that
if
anyone
knew
how
vile
she
was,
they
would
despise
her.
The
gods
conspired
with
her
in
concealment.
They
allowed
her
to
confine
her
savage
scrubbing
to
the
palms
of
her
hands.
This
meant
that
when
her
hands
were
badly
hurt,
she
could
clench
them
into
fists,
or
tuck
them
into
the
folds
of
her
skirt
as
she
walked,
or
lay
them
in
her
lap
very
meekly
when
she
sat,
and
no
one
would
notice
them.
They
saw
only
a
very
well-behaved
little
girl.
If
her
mother
had
been
alive,
Qing-jao's
secret
would
have
been
discovered
much
sooner.
As
it
was,
it
took
months
for
a
servant
to
notice.
Fat
old
Mu-pao
happened
to
notice
a
bloody
stain
on
the
small
tablecloth
from
Qing-jao's
breakfast
table.
Mu-pao
knew
at
once
what
it
meant--
weren't
bloody
hands
well
known
to
be
an
early
sign
of
the
gods'
attention?
That
was
why
many
an
ambitious
mother
and
father
forced
a
particularly
promising
child
to
wash
and
wash.
Throughout
the
world
of
Path,
ostentatious
handwashing
was
called
"inviting
the
gods."
Mu-pao
went
at
once
to
Qing-jao's
father,
the
noble
Han
Fei-tzu,
rumored
to
be
the
greatest
of
the
godspoken,
one
of
the
few
so
powerful
in
the
eyes
of
the
gods
that
he
could
meet
with
framlings--
offworlders--
and
never
betray
a
hint
of
the
voices
of
the
gods
within
him,
thus
preserving
the
divine
secret
of
the
world
of
Path.
He
would
be
grateful
to
hear
the
news,
and
Mu-pao
would
be
honored
for
having
been
the
first
to
see
the
gods
in
Qing-jao.
Within
an
hour,
Han
Fei-tzu
had
gathered
up
his
beloved
little
Qing-jao
and
together
they
rode
in
a
sedan
chair
to
the
temple
at
Rockfall.
Qing-jao
didn't
like
riding
in
such
chairs--
she
felt
bad
for
the
men
who
had
to
carry
their
weight.
"They
don't
suffer,"
Father
told
her
the
first
time
she
mentioned
this
idea.
"They
feel
greatly
honored.
It's
one
of
the
ways
the
people
show
honor
to
the
gods--
when
one
of
the
godspoken
goes
to
a
temple,
he
does
it
on
the
shoulders
of
the
people
of
Path.
"
"But
I'm
getting
bigger
every
day,"
Qing-jao
answered.
"When
you're
too
big,
either
you'll
walk
on
your
own
feet
or
you'll
ride
in
your
own
chair,"
said
Father.
He
did
not
need
to
explain
that
she
would
have
her
own
chair
only
if
she
grew
up
to
be
godspoken
herself.
"And
we
try
to
show
our
humility
by
remaining
very
thin
and
light
so
we
aren't
a
heavy
burden
to
the
people."
This
was
a
joke,
of
course,
since
Father's
belly,
while
not
immense,
was
copious.
But
the
lesson
behind
the
joke
was
true:
The
godspoken
must
never
be
a
burden
to
the
common
people
of
Path.
The
people
must
always
be
grateful,
never
resentful,
that
the
gods
had
chosen
their
world
of
all
worlds
to
hear
their
voices.
Now,
though,
Qing-jao
was
more
concerned
with
the
ordeal
that
lay
before
her.
She
knew
that
she
was
being
taken
for
testing.
"Many
children
are
taught
to
pretend
that
the
gods
speak
to
them,"
Father
explained.
"We
must
find
out
if
the
gods
have
truly
chosen
you."
"I
want
them
to
stop
choosing
me,"
said
Qing-jao.
"And
you
will
want
it
even
more
during
the
test,"
said
Father.
His
voice
was
filled
with
pity.
It
made
Qingjao
even
more
afraid.
"The
folk
see
only
our
powers
and
privileges,
and
envy
us.
They
don't
know
the
great
suffering
of
those
who
hear
the
voices
of
the
gods.
If
the
gods
truly
speak
to
you,
my
Qing-jao,
you
will
learn
to
bear
the
suffering
the
way
jade
bears
the
carver's
knife,
the
polisher's
rough
cloth.
It
will
make
you
shine.
Why
else
do
you
think
I
named
you
Qing-jao?"
Qing-jao--
Gloriously
Bright
was
what
the
name
meant.
It
was
also
the
name
of
a
great
poet
from
ancient
times
in
Old
China.
A
woman
poet
in
an
age
when
only
men
were
given
respect,
and
yet
she
was
honored
as
the
greatest
of
poets
in
her
day.
"Thin
fog
and
thick
cloud,
gloom
all
day."
It
was
the
opening
of
Li
Qingjao's
song
"The
Double
Ninth."
That
was
how
Qing-jao
felt
now.
And
how
did
the
poem
end?
"Now
my
curtain's
lifted
only
by
the
western
wind.
I've
grown
thinner
than
this
golden
blossom."
Would
this
be
her
ending
also?
Was
her
ancestor-of-the-heart
telling
her
in
this
poem
that
the
darkness
failing
over
her
now
would
be
lifted
only
when
the
gods
came
out
of
the
west
to
lift
her
thin,
light,
golden
soul
out
of
her
body?
It
was
too
terrible,
to
think
of
death
now,
when
she
was
only
seven
years
old;
and
yet
the
thought
came
to
her:
If
I
die
soon,
then
soon
I'll
see
Mother,
and
even
the
great
Li
Qing-jao
herself.
But
the
test
had
nothing
to
do
with
death,
or
at
least
it
was
not
supposed
to.
It
was
quite
simple,
really.
Father
led
her
into
a
large
room
where
three
old
men
knelt.
Or
they
seemed
like
men--
they
could
have
been
women.
They
were
so
old
that
all
distinctions
had
disappeared.
They
had
only
the
tiniest
wisps
of
white
hair
and
no
beards
at
all,
and
they
dressed
in
shapeless
sacks.
Later
Qing-jao
would
learn
that
these
were
temple
eunuchs,
survivors
of
the
old
days
before
Starways
Congress
intervened
and
forbade
even
voluntary
self-mutilation
in
the
service
of
a
religion.
Now,
though,
they
were
mysterious
ghostly
old
creatures
whose
hands
touched
her,
exploring
her
clothing.
What
were
they
searching
for?
They
found
her
ebony
chopsticks
and
took
them
away.
They
took
the
sash
from
around
her
waist.
They
took
her
slippers.
Later
she
would
learn
that
these
things
were
taken
because
other
children
had
become
so
desperate
during
their
testing
that
they
had
killed
themselves.
One
of
them
had
inserted
her
chopsticks
into
her
nostrils
and
then
flung
herself
to
the
floor,
jamming
the
sticks
into
her
brain.
Another
had
hanged
herself
with
her
sash.
Another
had
forced
her
slippers
into
her
mouth
and
down
her
throat,
choking
herself
to
death.
Successful
suicide
attempts
were
rare,
but
they
seemed
to
happen
with
the
brightest
of
the
children,
and
most
commonly
with
girls.
So
they
took
away
from
Qing-jao
all
the
known
ways
of
committing
suicide.
The
old
ones
left.
Father
knelt
beside
Qing-jao
and
spoke
to
her
face
to
face.
"You
must
understand,
Qingjao,
that
we
are
not
really
testing
you.
Nothing
that
you
do
of
your
own
free
will
can
make
the
slightest
difference
in
what
happens
here.
We
are
really
testing
the
gods,
to
see
if
they
are
determined
to
speak
to
you.
If
they
are,
they'll
find
a
way,
and
we'll
see
it,
and
you'll
come
out
of
this
room
as
one
of
the
godspoken.
If
they
aren't,
then
you'll
come
out
of
here
free
of
their
voices
for
all
time.
I
can't
tell
you
which
outcome
I
pray
for,
since
I
don't
know
myself."
"Father,"
said
Qing-jao,
"what
if
you're
ashamed
of
me?"
The
very
thought
made
her
feel
a
tingling
in
her
hands,
as
if
there
were
dirt
on
them,
as
if
she
needed
to
wash
them.
"I
will
not
be
ashamed
of
you
either
way."
Then
he
clapped
his
hands.
One
of
the
old
ones
came
back
in,
bearing
a
heavy
basin.
He
set
it
down
before
Qing-jao.
"Thrust
in
your
hands,"
said
Father.
The
basin
was
filled
with
thick
black
grease.
Qing-jao
shuddered.
"I
can't
put
my
hands
in
there."
Father
reached
out,
took
her
by
the
forearms,
and
forced
her
hands
down
into
the
muck.
Qing-jao
cried
out--
her
father
had
never
used
force
with
her
before.
And
when
he
let
go
of
her
arms,
her
hands
were
covered
with
clammy
slime.
She
gasped
at
the
filthiness
of
her
hands;
it
was
hard
to
breathe,
looking
at
them
like
that,
smelling
them.
The
old
one
picked
up
the
basin
and
carried
it
out.
"Where
can
I
wash,
Father?"
Qing-jao
whimpered.
"You
can't
wash,"
said
Father.
"You
can
never
wash
again."
And
because
Qing-jao
was
a
child,
she
believed
him,
not
guessing
that
his
words
were
part
of
the
test.
She
watched
Father
leave
the
room.
She
heard
the
door
latch
behind
him.
She
was
alone.
At
first
she
simply
held
her
hands
out
in
front
of
her,
making
sure
they
didn't
touch
any
part
of
her
clothing.
She
searched
desperately
for
somewhere
to
wash,
but
there
was
no
water,
nor
even
a
cloth.
The
room
was
far
from
bare--
there
were
chairs,
tables,
statues,
large
stone
jars--
but
all
the
surfaces
were
hard
and
well-polished
and
so
clean
that
she
couldn't
bear
to
touch
them.
Yet
the
filthiness
of
her
hands
was
unendurable.
She
had
to
get
them
clean.
"Father!"
she
called
out.
"Come
and
wash
my
hands!"
Surely
he
could
hear
her.
Surely
he
was
somewhere
near,
waiting
for
the
outcome
of
her
test.
He
must
hear
her--
but
he
didn't
come.
The
only
cloth
in
the
room
was
the
gown
she
was
wearing.
She
could
wipe
on
that,
only
then
she
would
be
wearing
the
grease;
it
might
get
on
other
parts
of
her
body.
The
solution,
of
course,
was
to
take
it
off--
but
how
could
she
do
that
without
touching
her
filthy
hands
to
some
other
part
of
herself?
She
tried.
First
she
carefully
scraped
off
as
much
of
the
grease
as
she
could
on
the
smooth
arms
of
a
statue.
Forgive
me,
she
said
to
the
statue,
in
case
it
belonged
to
a
god.
I
will
come
and
clean
you
after;
I'll
clean
you
with
my
own
gown.
Then
she
reached
back
over
her
shoulders
and
gathered
the
cloth
on
her
back,
pulling
up
on
the
gown
to
draw
it
over
her
head.
Her
greasy
fingers
slipped
on
the
silk;
she
could
feel
the
slime
cold
on
her
bare
back
as
it
penetrated
the
silk.
I'll
clean
it
after,
she
thought.
At
last
she
got
a
firm
enough
grasp
of
the
fabric
that
she
could
pull
off
the
gown.
It
slid
over
her
head,
but
even
before
it
was
completely
off,
she
knew
that
things
were
worse
than
ever,
for
some
of
the
grease
was
in
her
long
hair,
and
that
hair
had
fallen
onto
her
face,
and
now
she
had
filth
not
just
on
her
hands
but
also
on
her
back,
in
her
hair,
on
her
face.
Still
she
tried.
She
got
the
gown
the
rest
of
the
way
off,
then
carefully
wiped
her
hands
on
one
small
part
of
the
fabric.
Then
she
wiped
her
face
on
another.
But
it
was
no
good.
Some
of
the
grease
clung
to
her
no
matter
what
she
did.
Her
face
felt
as
if
the
silk
of
her
gown
had
only
smeared
the
grease
around
instead
of
lifting
it
away.
She
had
never
been
so
hopelessly
grimy
in
her
life.
It
was
unbearable,
and
yet
she
couldn't
get
rid
of
it.
"Father!
Come
take
me
away!
I
don't
want
to
be
godspoken!"
He
didn't
come.
She
began
to
cry.
The
trouble
with
crying
was
that
it
didn't
work.
The
more
she
cried,
the
filthier
she
felt.
The
desperate
need
to
be
clean
overpowered
even
her
weeping.
So
with
tears
streaming
down
her
face,
she
began
to
search
desperately
for
some
way
to
get
the
grease
off
her
hands.
Again
she
tried
the
silk
of
her
gown,
but
within
a
little
while
she
was
wiping
her
hands
on
the
walls,
sidling
around
the
room,
smearing
them
with
grease.
She
rubbed
her
palms
on
the
wall
so
rapidly
that
heat
built
up
and
the
grease
melted.
She
did
it
again
and
again
until
her
hands
were
red,
until
some
of
the
softened
scabs
on
her
palms
had
worn
away
or
been
torn
off
by
invisible
snags
in
the
wooden
walls.
When
her
palms
and
fingers
hurt
badly
enough
that
she
couldn't
feel
the
slime
on
them,
she
wiped
her
face
with
them,
gouged
at
her
face
with
her
fingernails
to
scrape
away
the
grease
there.
Then,
hands
dirty
again,
she
once
more
rubbed
them
on
the
walls.
Finally,
exhausted,
she
fell
to
the
floor
and
wept
at
the
pain
in
her
hands,
at
her
helplessness
to
get
clean.
Her
eyes
were
shut
with
weeping.
Tears
streaked
down
her
cheeks.
She
rubbed
at
her
eyes,
at
her
cheeks--
and
felt
how
slimy
the
tears
made
her
skin,
how
filthy
she
was.
She
knew
what
this
surely
meant:
The
gods
had
judged
her
and
found
her
unclean.
She
wasn't
worthy
to
live.
If
she
couldn't
get
clean,
she
had
to
blot
herself
out.
That
would
satisfy
them.
That
would
ease
the
agony
of
it.
All
she
had
to
do
was
find
a
way
to
die.
To
stop
breathing.
Father
would
be
sorry
he
didn't
come
when
she
called
to
him,
but
she
couldn't
help
that.
She
was
under
the
power
of
the
gods
now,
and
they
had
judged
her
unworthy
to
be
among
the
living.
After
all,
what
right
did
she
have
to
breathe
when
the
gate
of
Mother's
lips
had
stopped
letting
the
air
pass
through,
in
or
out,
for
all
these
many
years?
She
first
thought
of
using
her
gown,
thought
of
stuffing
it
into
her
mouth
to
block
her
breath,
or
tying
it
around
her
throat
to
choke
herself--
but
it
was
too
filthy
to
handle,
too
covered
with
grease.
She
would
have
to
find
another
way.
Qing-jao
walked
to
the
wall,
pressed
against
it.
Sturdy
wood.
She
leaned
back
and
flung
her
head
against
the
wood.
Pain
flashed
through
her
head
when
it
struck;
stunned,
she
dropped
to
a
sitting
position
on
the
floor.
Her
head
ached
inside.
The
room
swung
slowly
around
and
around
her.
For
a
moment
she
forgot
the
filthiness
of
her
hands.
But
the
relief
didn't
last
long.
She
could
see
on
the
wall
a
slightly
duller
place
where
the
grease
from
her
forehead
broke
up
the
shiny
polished
surface.
The
gods
spoke
inside
her,
insisted
she
was
as
filthy
as
ever.
A
little
pain
wouldn't
make
up
for
her
unworthiness.
Again
she
struck
her
head
against
the
wall.
This
time,
however,
there
was
nowhere
near
as
much
pain.
Again,
again--
and
now
she
realized
that
against
her
will,
her
body
was
recoiling
from
the
blow,
refusing
to
inflict
so
much
pain
on
herself.
This
helped
her
understand
why
the
gods
found
her
so
unworthy--
she
was
too
weak
to
make
her
body
obey.
Well,
she
wasn't
helpless.
She
could
fool
her
body
into
submission.
She
selected
the
tallest
of
the
statues,
which
stood
perhaps
three
meters
high.
It
was
a
bronze
casting
of
a
man
in
mid-stride,
holding
a
sword
above
his
head.
There
were
enough
angles
and
bends
and
projections
that
she
could
climb.
Her
hands
kept
slipping,
but
she
persevered
until
she
balanced
on
the
statue's
shoulders,
holding
onto
its
headdress
with
one
hand
and
the
sword
with
the
other.
For
a
moment,
touching
the
sword,
she
thought
of
trying
to
cut
her
throat
on
it--
that
would
stop
her
breath,
wouldn't
it?
But
the
blade
was
only
a
pretend
blade.
It
wasn't
sharp,
and
she
couldn't
get
her
neck
to
it
at
the
right
angle.
So
she
went
back
to
her
original
plan.
She
took
several
deep
breaths,
then
clasped
her
hands
behind
her
back
and
toppled
forward.
She
would
land
on
her
head;
that
would
end
her
filthiness.
As
the
floor
rushed
upward,
however,
she
lost
control
of
herself.
She
screamed;
she
felt
her
hands
tear
free
of
each
other
behind
her
back
and
rush
forward
to
try
to
break
her
fall.
Too
late,
she
thought
with
grim
satisfaction,
and
then
her
head
struck
the
floor
and
everything
went
black.
***
Qing-jao
awoke
with
a
dull
ache
in
her
arm
and
a
sharp
pain
in
her
head
whenever
she
moved--
but
she
was
alive.
When
she
could
bear
to
open
her
eyes
she
saw
that
the
room
was
darker.
Was
it
night
outside?
How
long
had
she
slept?
She
couldn't
bear
to
move
her
left
arm,
the
one
with
the
pain;
she
could
see
an
ugly
red
bruise
at
the
elbow
and
she
thought
she
must
have
broken
it
inside
when
she
fell.
She
also
saw
that
her
hands
were
still
smeared
with
grease,
and
felt
her
unbearable
dirtiness:
the
gods'
judgment
against
her.
She
shouldn't
have
tried
to
kill
herself
after
all.
The
gods
wouldn't
allow
her
to
escape
their
judgment
so
easily.
What
can
I
do?
she
pleaded.
How
can
I
be
clean
before
you,
O
Gods?
Li
Qing-jao,
my
ancestor-of-theheart,
show
me
how
to
make
myself
worthy
to
receive
the
kind
judgment
of
the
gods!
What
came
at
once
to
her
mind
was
Li
Qing-jao's
love
song
"Separation."
It
was
one
of
the
first
that
Father
had
given
her
to
memorize
when
she
was
only
three
years
old,
only
a
short
time
before
he
and
Mother
told
her
that
Mother
was
going
to
die.
It
was
exactly
appropriate
now,
too,
for
wasn't
she
separated
from
the
goodwill
of
the
gods?
Didn't
she
need
to
be
reconciled
with
them
so
they
could
receive
her
as
one
of
the
truly
godspoken
ones?
someone's
sent
a
loving
note
in
lines
of
returning
geese
and
as
the
moon
fills
my
western
chamber
as
petals
dance
over
the
flowing
stream
again
I
think
of
you
the
two
of
us
living
a
sadness
apart
a
hurt
that
can't
be
removed
yet
when
my
gaze
comes
down
my
heart
stays
up
The
moon
filling
the
western
chamber
told
her
that
it
was
really
a
god,
not
an
ordinary
man-lover
who
was
being
pined
for
in
this
poem--
references
to
the
west
always
meant
that
the
gods
were
involved.
Li
Qing-Jao
had
answered
the
prayer
of
little
Han
Qing-jao,
and
sent
this
poem
to
tell
her
how
to
cure
the
hurt
that
couldn't
be
removed--
the
filthiness
of
her
flesh.
What
is
the
loving
note?
thought
Qing-jao.
Lines
of
returning
geese--
but
there
are
no
geese
in
this
room.
Petals
dancing
over
a
flowing
stream--
but
there
are
no
petals,
there
is
no
stream
here.
"Yet
when
my
gaze
comes
down,
my
heart
stays
up."
That
was
the
clue,
that
was
the
answer,
she
knew
it.
Slowly,
carefully
Qing-jao
rolled
over
onto
her
belly.
Once
when
she
tried
to
put
weight
on
her
left
hand,
her
elbow
buckled
and
an
exquisite
pain
almost
made
her
lose
consciousness
again.
At
last
she
knelt,
her
head
bowed,
leaning
on
her
right
hand.
Gazing
down.
The
poem
promised
that
this
would
let
her
heart
stay
up.
She
felt
no
better--
still
filthy,
still
in
pain.
Looking
down
showed
her
nothing
but
the
polished
boards
of
the
floor,
the
grain
of
the
wood
making
rippling
lines
reaching
from
between
her
knees
outward
to
the
very
edge
of
the
room.
Lines.
Lines
of
woodgrain,
lines
of
geese.
And
couldn't
the
woodgrain
also
be
seen
as
a
flowing
stream?
She
must
follow
these
lines
like
the
geese;
she
must
dance
over
these
flowing
streams
like
a
petal.
That
was
what
the
promise
meant:
When
her
gaze
came
down,
her
heart
would
stay
up.
She
found
one
particular
line
in
the
woodgrain,
a
line
of
darkness
like
a
river
rippling
through
the
lighter
wood
around
it,
and
knew
at
once
that
this
was
the
stream
she
was
supposed
to
follow.
She
dared
not
touch
it
with
her
finger--
filthy,
unworthy
finger.
It
had
to
be
followed
lightly,
the
way
a
goose
touched
the
air,
the
way
a
petal
touched
the
stream.
Only
her
eyes
could
follow
the
line.
So
she
began
to
trace
the
line,
follow
it
carefully
to
the
wall.
A
couple
of
times
she
moved
so
quickly
that
she
lost
the
line,
forgot
which
one
it
was;
but
soon
she
found
it
again,
or
thought
she
did,
and
followed
it
to
the
wall.
Was
it
good
enough?
Were
the
gods
satisfied?
Almost,
but
not
quite--
she
couldn't
be
sure
that
when
her
gaze
slipped
from
the
line
she
had
returned
to
the
right
one.
Petals
didn't
skip
from
stream
to
stream.
She
had
to
follow
the
right
one,
along
its
entire
length.
This
time
she
started
at
the
wall
and
bowed
very
low,
so
her
eyes
wouldn't
be
distracted
even
by
the
movement
of
her
own
right
hand.
She
inched
her
way
along,
never
letting
herself
so
much
as
blink,
even
when
her
eyes
burned.
She
knew
that
if
she
lost
the
grain
she
was
following
she'd
have
to
go
back
and
start
over.
It
had
to
be
done
perfectly
or
it
would
lose
all
its
power
to
cleanse
her.
It
took
forever.
She
did
blink,
but
not
haphazardly,
by
accident.
When
her
eyes
burned
too
much,
she
would
bow
down
until
her
left
eye
was
directly
over
the
grain.
Then
she
would
close
the
other
eye
for
a
moment.
Her
right
eye
relieved,
she
would
open
it,
then
put
that
eye
directly
over
the
line
in
the
wood
and
close
the
left.
This
way
she
was
able
to
make
it
halfway
across
the
room
until
the
board
ended,
butting
up
against
another.
She
wasn't
sure
whether
that
was
good
enough,
whether
it
was
enough
to
finish
the
board
or
if
she
needed
to
find
another
woodgrain
line
to
follow.
She
made
as
if
to
get
up,
testing
the
gods,
to
see
if
they
were
satisfied.
She
half-rose,
felt
nothing;
she
stood,
and
still
she
was
at
ease.
Ah!
They
were
satisfied,
they
were
pleased
with
her.
Now
the
grease
on
her
skin
felt
like
nothing
more
than
a
little
oil.
There
was
no
need
for
washing,
not
at
this
moment,
for
she
had
found
another
way
to
cleanse
herself,
another
way
for
the
gods
to
discipline
her.
Slowly
she
lay
back
on
the
floor,
smiling,
weeping
softly
in
joy.
Li
Qing-jao,
my
ancestor-of-the-heart,
thank
you
for
showing
me
the
way.
Now
I
have
been
joined
to
the
gods;
the
separation
is
over.
Mother,
I
am
again
connected
to
you,
clean
and
worthy.
White
Tiger
of
the
West,
I
am
now
pure
enough
to
touch
your
fur
and
leave
no
mark
of
filthiness.
Then
hands
touched
her--
Father's
hands,
picking
her
up.
Drops
of
water
fell
onto
her
face,
the
bare
skin
of
her
body--
Father's
tears.
"You're
alive,"
he
said.
"My
godspoken
one,
my
beloved,
my
daughter,
my
life,
Gloriously
Bright,
you
shine
on."
Later
she
would
learn
that
Father
had
had
to
be
tied
and
gagged
during
her
test,
that
when
she
climbed
the
statue
and
made
as
if
to
press
her
throat
against
the
sword,
he
flung
himself
forward
with
such
force
that
his
chair
fell
and
his
head
struck
the
floor.
This
was
regarded
as
a
great
mercy,
since
it
meant
he
didn't
see
her
terrible
fall
from
the
statue.
He
wept
for
her
all
the
time
she
lay
unconscious.
And
then,
when
she
rose
to
her
knees
and
began
to
trace
the
woodgrains
on
the
floor,
he
was
the
one
who
realized
what
it
meant.
"Look,"
he
whispered.
"The
gods
have
given
her
a
task.
The
gods
are
speaking
to
her."
The
others
were
slow
to
recognize
it,
because
they
had
never
seen
anyone
trace
woodgrain
lines
before.
It
wasn't
in
the
Catalogue
of
Voices
of
the
Gods:
Door-Waiting,
Counting-to-Multiples-of-Five,
ObjectCounting,
Checking-for-Accidental-Murders,
Fingernail-Tearing,
Skin-Scraping,
Pulling-Out-of-Hair,
Gnawing-at-Stone,
Bugging-Out-of-Eyes--
all
these
were
known
to
be
penances
that
the
gods
demanded,
rituals
of
obedience
that
cleansed
the
soul
of
the
godspoken
so
that
the
gods
could
fill
their
minds
with
wisdom.
No
one
had
ever
seen
Woodgrain-Tracing.
Yet
Father
saw
what
she
was
doing,
named
the
ritual,
and
added
it
to
the
Catalogue
of
Voices.
It
would
forever
bear
her
name,
Han
Qing-jao,
as
the
first
to
be
commanded
by
the
gods
to
perform
this
rite.
It
made
her
very
special.
So
did
her
unusual
resourcefulness
in
trying
to
find
ways
to
cleanse
her
hands
and,
later,
kill
herself.
Many
had
tried
scraping
their
hands
on
walls,
of
course,
and
most
attempted
to
wipe
on
clothes.
But
rubbing
her
hands
to
build
up
the
heat
of
friction,
that
was
regarded
as
rare
and
clever.
And
while
head-beating
was
common,
climbing
a
statue
and
jumping
off
and
landing
on
her
head
was
very
rare.
And
none
who
had
done
it
before
had
been
strong
enough
to
keep
their
hands
behind
their
back
so
long.
The
temple
was
all
abuzz
with
it,
and
word
soon
spread
to
all
the
temples
in
Path.
It
was
a
great
honor
to
Han
Fei-tzu,
of
course,
that
his
daughter
was
so
powerfully
possessed
by
the
gods.
And
the
story
of
his
near-madness
when
she
was
trying
to
destroy
herself
spread
just
as
quickly
and
touched
many
hearts.
"He
may
be
the
greatest
of
the
godspoken,"
they
said
of
him,
"but
he
loves
his
daughter
more
than
life."
This
made
them
love
him
as
much
as
they
already
revered
him.
It
was
then
that
people
began
whispering
about
the
possible
godhood
of
Han
Fei-tzu.
"He
is
great
and
strong
enough
that
the
gods
will
listen
to
him,"
said
the
people
who
favored
him.
"Yet
he
is
so
affectionate
that
he
will
always
love
the
people
of
the
planet
Path,
and
try
to
do
good
for
us.
Isn't
this
what
the
god
of
a
world
ought
to
be?"
Of
course
it
was
impossible
to
decide
now--
a
man
could
not
be
chosen
to
be
god
of
a
village,
let
alone
of
a
whole
world,
until
he
died.
How
could
you
judge
what
sort
of
god
he'd
be,
until
his
whole
life,
from
beginning
to
end,
was
known?
These
whispers
came
to
Qing-jao's
ears
many
times
as
she
grew
older,
and
the
knowledge
that
her
father
might
well
be
chosen
god
of
Path
became
one
of
the
beacons
of
her
life.
But
at
the
time,
and
forever
in
her
memory,
she
remembered
that
his
hands
were
the
ones
that
carried
her
bruised
and
twisted
body
to
the
bed
of
healing,
his
eyes
were
the
ones
that
dropped
warm
tears
on
to
her
cold
skin,
his
voice
was
the
one
that
whispered
in
the
beautiful
passionate
tones
of
the
old
language,
"My
beloved,
my
Gloriously
Bright,
never
take
your
light
from
my
life.
Whatever
happens,
never
harm
yourself
or
I
will
surely
die."
Chapter
4
--
JANE
<So
many
of
your
people
are
becoming
Christians.
Believing
in
the
god
these
humans
brought
with
them.>
<You
don't
believe
in
God?>
<The
question
never
come
up.
We
have
always
remembered
how
we
began.>
<You
evolved.
We
were
created.>
<By
a
virus.>
<By
a
virus
that
God
created
in
order
to
create
us.>
<So
you,
too,
are
a
believer.>
<I
understand
belief.>
<No--
you
desire
belief.>
<I
desire
it
enough
to
act
as
if
I
believed.
Maybe
that's
what
faith
is.>
<Or
deliberate
insanity>
It
turned
out
not
to
be
just
Valentine
and
Jakt
who
came
over
to
Miro's
ship.
Plikt
also
came,
without
invitation,
and
installed
herself
in
a
miserable
little
cubicle
where
there
wasn't
even
room
to
stretch
out
completely.
She
was
the
anomaly
on
the
voyage--
not
family,
not
crew,
but
a
friend.
Plikt
had
been
a
student
of
Ender's
when
he
was
on
Trondheim
as
a
speaker
for
the
dead.
She
had
figured
out,
quite
independently,
that
Andrew
Wiggin
was
the
Speaker
for
the
Dead
and
that
he
was
also
the
Ender
Wiggin.
Why
this
brilliant
young
woman
should
have
become
so
fixed
on
Ender
Wiggin,
Valentine
could
not
really
understand.
At
times
she
thought,
Perhaps
this
is
how
some
religions
start.
The
founder
doesn't
ask
for
disciples;
they
come
and
force
themselves
upon
him.
In
any
event,
Plikt
had
stayed
with
Valentine
and
her
family
for
all
the
years
since
Ender
left
Trondheim,
tutoring
the
children
and
helping
in
Valentine's
research,
always
waiting
for
the
day
that
the
family
journeyed
to
be
with
Ender--
a
day
that
only
Plikt
had
known
would
come.
So
during
the
last
half
of
the
voyage
to
Lusitania,
it
was
the
four
of
them
who
traveled
in
Miro's
ship:
Valentine,
Miro,
Jakt,
and
Plikt.
Or
so
Valentine
thought
at
first.
It
was
on
the
third
day
since
the
rendezvous
that
she
learned
of
the
fifth
traveler
who
had
been
with
them
all
along.
That
day,
as
always,
the
four
of
them
were
gathered
on
the
bridge.
There
was
nowhere
else
to
go.
This
was
a
cargo
ship--
besides
the
bridge
and
the
sleeping
quarters,
there
was
only
a
tiny
galley
and
the
toilet.
All
the
other
space
was
designed
to
hold
cargo,
not
people--
not
in
any
kind
of
reasonable
comfort.
Valentine
didn't
mind
the
loss
of
privacy,
though.
She
was
slacking
off
now
on
her
output
of
subversive
essays;
it
was
more
important,
she
felt,
to
get
to
know
Miro--
and,
through
him,
Lusitania.
The
people
there,
the
pequeninos,
and,
most
particularly,
Miro's
family--
for
Ender
had
married
Novinha,
Mira's
mother.
Valentine
did
glean
much
of
that
kind
of
information,
of
course--
she
couldn't
have
been
a
historian
and
biographer
for
all
these
years
without
learning
how
to
extrapolate
much
from
scant
bits
of
evidence.
The
real
prize
for
her
had
turned
out
to
be
Miro
himself.
He
was
bitter,
angry,
frustrated,
and
filled
with
loathing
for
his
crippled
body,
but
all
that
was
understandable--
his
loss
had
happened
only
a
few
months
before,
and
he
was
still
trying
to
redefine
himself.
Valentine
didn't
worry
about
his
future--
she
could
see
that
he
was
very
strong-willed,
the
kind
of
man
who
didn't
easily
fall
apart.
He
would
adapt
and
thrive.
What
interested
her
most
was
his
thought.
It
was
as
if
the
confinement
of
his
body
had
freed
his
mind.
When
he
had
first
been
injured
his
paralysis
was
almost
total.
He
had
had
nothing
to
do
but
lie
in
one
place
and
think.
Of
course,
much
of
his
time
had
been
spent
brooding
about
his
losses,
his
mistakes,
the
future
he
couldn't
have.
But
he
had
also
spent
many
hours
thinking
about
the
issues
that
busy
people
almost
never
think
about.
And
on
that
third
day
together,
that's
what
Valentine
was
trying
to
draw
out
of
him.
"Most
people
don't
think
about
it,
not
seriously,
and
you
have,"
said
Valentine.
"Just
because
I
think
about
it
doesn't
mean
I
know
anything,"
said
Miro.
She
really
was
used
to
his
voice
now,
though
sometimes
his
speech
was
maddeningly
slow.
It
took
a
real
effort
of
will
at
times
to
keep
from
showing
any
sign
of
inattention.
"The
nature
of
the
universe,"
said
Jakt.
"The
sources
of
life,"
said
Valentine.
"You
said
you
had
thought
about
what
it
means
to
be
alive,
and
I
want
to
know
what
you
thought."
"How
the
universe
works
and
why
we
all
are
in
it."
Miro
laughed.
"It's
pretty
crazy
stuff."
"I've
been
trapped
alone
in
an
ice
floe
in
a
fishing
boat
for
two
weeks
in
a
blizzard
with
no
heat,"
said
Jakt.
"I
doubt
you've
come
up
with
anything
that'll
sound
crazy
to
me."
Valentine
smiled.
Jakt
was
no
scholar,
and
his
philosophy
was
generally
confined
to
holding
his
crew
together
and
catching
a
lot
of
fish.
But
he
knew
that
Valentine
wanted
to
draw
Miro
out,
and
so
he
helped
put
the
young
man
at
ease,
helped
him
know
that
he'd
be
taken
seriously.
And
it
was
important
for
Jakt
to
be
the
one
who
did
that--
because
Valentine
had
seen,
and
so
had
Jakt,
how
Miro
watched
him.
Jakt
might
be
old,
but
his
arms
and
legs
and
back
were
still
those
of
a
fisherman,
and
every
movement
revealed
the
suppleness
of
his
body.
Miro
even
commented
on
it
once,
obliquely,
admiringly:
"You've
got
the
build
of
a
twenty-year-old."
Valentine
heard
the
ironic
corollary
that
must
have
been
in
Miro's
mind:
While
I,
who
am
young,
have
the
body
of
an
arthritic
ninety-year-old.
So
Jakt
meant
something
to
Miro--
he
represented
the
future
that
Miro
could
never
have.
Admiration
and
resentment;
it
would
have
been
hard
for
Miro
to
speak
openly
in
front
of
Jakt,
if
Jakt
had
not
taken
care
to
make
sure
Miro
heard
nothing
but
respect
and
interest
from
him.
Plikt,
of
course,
sat
in
her
place,
silent,
withdrawn,
effectively
invisible.
"All
right,"
said
Miro.
"Speculations
on
the
nature
of
reality
and
the
soul."
"Theology
or
metaphysics?"
asked
Valentine.
"Metaphysics,
mostly,"
said
Miro.
"And
physics.
Neither
one
is
my
specialty.
And
this
isn't
the
kind
of
story
you
said
you
needed
me
for."
"I
don't
always
know
exactly
what
I'll
need."
"All
right,"
said
Miro.
He
took
a
couple
of
breaths,
as
if
he
were
trying
to
decide
where
to
begin.
"You
know
about
philotic
twining."
"I
know
what
everybody
knows,"
said
Valentine.
"And
I
know
that
it
hasn't
led
anywhere
in
the
last
twentyfive
hundred
years
because
it
can't
really
be
experimented
with."
It
was
an
old
discovery,
from
the
days
when
scientists
were
struggling
to
catch
up
with
technology.
Teenage
physics
students
memorized
a
few
wise
sayings:
"Philotes
are
the
fundamental
building
blocks
of
all
matter
and
energy.
Philotes
have
neither
mass
nor
inertia.
Philotes
have
only
location,
duration,
and
connection."
And
everybody
knew
that
it
was
philotic
connections--
the
twining
of
philotic
rays--
that
made
ansibles
work,
allowing
instantaneous
communication
between
worlds
and
starships
many
light-years
apart.
But
no
one
knew
why
it
worked,
and
because
philotes
could
not
be
"handled,"
it
was
almost
impossible
to
experiment
with
them.
They
could
only
be
observed,
and
then
only
through
their
connections.
"Philotics,"
said
Jakt.
"Ansibles?"
"A
by-product,"
said
Miro.
"What
does
it
have
to
do
with
the
soul?"
asked
Valentine.
Miro
was
about
to
answer,
but
he
grew
frustrated,
apparently
at
the
thought
of
trying
to
give
a
long
speech
through
his
sluggish,
resisting
mouth.
His
jaw
was
working,
his
lips
moving
slightly.
Then
he
said
aloud,
"I
can't
do
it."
"We'll
listen,"
said
Valentine.
She
understood
his
reluctance
to
try
extended
discourse
with
the
limitations
of
his
speech,
but
she
also
knew
he
had
to
do
it
anyway.
"No,"
said
Miro.
Valentine
would
have
tried
further
persuasion,
but
she
saw
his
lips
were
still
moving,
though
little
sound
came
out.
Was
he
muttering?
Cursing?
No--
she
knew
it
wasn't
that
at
all.
It
took
a
moment
for
her
to
realize
why
she
was
so
sure.
It
was
because
she
had
seen
Ender
do
exactly
the
same
thing,
moving
his
lips
and
jaw,
when
he
was
issuing
subvocalized
commands
to
the
computer
terminal
built
into
the
jewel
he
wore
in
his
ear.
Of
course:
Miro
has
the
same
computer
hookup
Ender
has,
so
he'll
speak
to
it
the
same
way.
In
a
moment
it
became
clear
what
command
Miro
had
given
to
his
jewel.
It
must
have
been
tied
in
to
the
ship's
computer,
because
immediately
afterward
one
of
the
display
screens
cleared
and
then
showed
Miro's
face.
Only
there
was
none
of
the
slackness
that
marred
his
face
in
person.
Valentine
realized:
It
was
Miro's
face
as
it
used
to
be.
And
when
the
computer
image
spoke,
the
sound
coming
from
the
speakers
was
surely
Miro's
voice
as
it
used
to
be--
clear.
Forceful.
Intelligent.
Quick.
"You
know
that
when
philotes
combine
to
make
a
durable
structure--
a
meson,
a
neutron,
an
atom,
a
molecule,
an
organism,
a
planet--
they
twine
up."
"What
is
this?"
demanded
Jakt.
He
hadn't
yet
figured
out
why
the
computer
was
doing
the
talking.
The
computer
image
of
Miro
froze
on
the
screen
and
fell
silent.
Miro
himself
answered.
"I've
been
playing
with
this,"
he
said.
"I
tell
it
things,
and
it
remembers
and
speaks
for
me."
Valentine
tried
to
imagine
Miro
experimenting
until
the
computer
program
got
his
face
and
voice
just
right.
How
exhilarating
it
must
have
been,
to
re-create
himself
as
he
ought
to
be.
And
also
how
agonizing,
to
see
what
he
could
have
been
and
know
that
it
could
never
be
real.
"What
a
clever
idea,"
said
Valentine.
"Sort
of
a
prosthesis
for
the
personality."
Miro
laughed--
a
single
"Ha!"
"Go
ahead,"
said
Valentine.
"Whether
you
speak
for
yourself
or
the
computer
speaks
for
you,
we'll
listen."
The
computer
image
came
back
to
life,
and
spoke
again
in
Miro's
strong,
imaginary
voice.
"Philotes
are
the
smallest
building
blocks
of
matter
and
energy.
They
have
no
mass
or
dimension.
Each
philote
connects
itself
to
the
rest
of
the
universe
along
a
single
ray,
a
one-dimensional
line
that
connects
it
to
all
the
other
philotes
in
its
smallest
immediate
structure--
a
meson.
All
those
strands
from
the
philotes
in
that
structure
are
twined
into
a
single
philotic
thread
that
connects
the
meson
to
the
next
larger
structure--
a
neutron,
for
instance.
The
threads
in
the
neutron
twine
into
a
yarn
connecting
it
to
all
the
other
particles
of
the
atom,
and
then
the
yarns
of
the
atom
twine
into
the
rope
of
the
molecule.
This
has
nothing
to
do
with
nuclear
forces
or
gravity,
nothing
to
do
with
chemical
bonds.
As
far
as
we
can
tell,
the
philotic
connections
don't
do
anything.
They're
just
there."
"But
the
individual
rays
are
always
there,
present
in
the
twines,"
said
Valentine.
"Yes,
each
ray
goes
on
forever,"
answered
the
screen.
It
surprised
her--
and
Jakt,
too,
judging
from
the
way
his
eyes
widened--
that
the
computer
was
able
to
respond
immediately
to
what
Valentine
said.
It
wasn't
just
a
preset
lecture.
This
had
to
be
a
sophisticated
program
anyway,
to
simulate
Miro's
face
and
voice
so
well;
but
now
to
have
it
responding
as
if
it
were
simulating
Miro's
personality
...
Or
had
Miro
given
some
cue
to
the
program?
Had
he
subvocalized
the
response?
Valentine
didn't
know--
she
had
been
watching
the
screen.
She
would
stop
doing
that
now--
she
would
watch
Miro
himself.
"We
don't
know
if
the
ray
is
infinite,"
said
Valentine.
"We
only
know
that
we
haven't
found
where
the
ray
ends."
"They
twine
together,
a
whole
planetful,
and
each
planet's
philotic
twine
reaches
to
its
star,
and
each
star
to
the
center
of
the
galaxy--"
"And
where
does
the
galactic
twine
go?"
said
Jakt.
It
was
an
old
question--
schoolchildren
asked
it
when
they
first
got
into
philotics
in
high
school.
Like
the
old
speculation
that
maybe
galaxies
were
really
neutrons
or
mesons
inside
a
far
vaster
universe,
or
the
old
question,
If
the
universe
isn't
infinite,
what
is
beyond
the
edge?
"Yes,
yes,"
said
Miro.
This
time,
though,
he
spoke
from
his
own
mouth.
"But
that's
not
where
I'm
going.
I
want
to
talk
about
life."
The
computerized
voice--
the
voice
of
the
brilliant
young
man--
took
over.
"The
philotic
twines
from
substances
like
rock
or
sand
all
connect
directly
from
each
molecule
to
the
center
of
the
planet.
But
when
a
molecule
is
incorporated
into
a
living
organism,
its
ray
shifts.
Instead
of
reaching
to
the
planet,
it
gets
twined
in
with
the
individual
cell,
and
the
rays
from
the
cells
are
all
twined
together
so
that
each
organism
sends
a
single
fiber
of
philotic
connections
to
twine
up
with
the
central
philotic
rope
of
the
planet."
"Which
shows
that
individual
lives
have
some
meaning
at
the
level
of
physics,"
said
Valentine.
She
had
written
an
essay
about
it
once,
trying
to
dispel
some
of
the
mysticism
that
had
grown
up
about
philotics
while
at
the
same
time
using
it
to
suggest
a
view
of
community
formation.
"But
there's
no
practical
effect
from
it,
Miro.
Nothing
you
can
do
with
it.
The
philotic
twining
of
living
organisms
simply
is.
Every
philote
is
connected
to
something,
and
through
that
to
something
else,
and
through
that
to
something
else--
living
cells
and
organisms
are
simply
two
of
the
leels
where
those
connections
can
be
made."
"Yes,"
said
Miro.
"That
which
lives,
twines."
Valentine
shrugged,
nodded.
It
probably
couldn't
be
proven,
but
if
Miro
wanted
that
as
a
premise
in
his
speculations,
that
was
fine.
The
computer-Miro
took
over
again.
"What
I've
been
thinking
about
is
the
endurance
of
the
twining.
When
a
twined
structure
is
broken--
as
when
a
molecule
breaks
apart--
the
old
philotic
twining
remains
for
a
time.
Fragments
that
are
no
longer
physically
joined
remain
philotically
connected
for
a
while.
And
the
smaller
the
particle,
the
longer
that
connection
lasts
after
the
breakup
of
the
original
structure,
and
the
more
slowly
the
fragments
shift
to
new
twinings."
Jakt:
frowned.
"I
thought
the
smaller
things
were,
the
faster
things
happened."
"It
is
counterintuitive,"
said
Valentine.
"After
nuclear
fission
it
takes
hours
for
the
philotic
rays
to
sort
themselves
back
out
again,"
said
the
computer-Miro.
"Split
a
smaller
particle
than
an
atom,
and
the
philotic
connection
between
the
fragments
will
last
much
longer
than
that."
"Which
is
how
the
ansible
works,"
said
Miro.
Valentine
looked
at
him
closely.
Why
was
he
talking
sometimes
in
his
own
voice,
sometimes
through
the
computer?
Was
the
program
under
his
control
or
wasn't
it?
"The
principle
of
the
ansible
is
that
if
you
suspend
a
meson
in
a
powerful
magnetic
field,"
said
computerMiro,
"split
it,
and
carry
the
two
parts
as
far
away
as
you
want,
the
philotic
twining
will
still
connect
them.
And
the
connection
is
instantaneous.
If
one
fragment
spins
or
vibrates,
the
ray
between
them
spins
and
vibrates,
and
the
movement
is
detectable
at
the
other
end
at
exactly
the
same
moment.
It
takes
no
time
whatsoever
for
the
movement
to
be
transmitted
along
the
entire
length
of
the
ray,
even
if
the
two
fragments
are
carried
light-years
away
from
each
other.
Nobody
knows
why
it
works,
but
we're
glad
it
does.
Without
the
ansible,
there'd
be
no
possibility
of
meaningful
communication
between
human
worlds."
"Hell,
there's
no
meaningful
communication
now,"
said
Jakt.
"And
if
it
wasn't
for
the
ansibles,
there'd
be
no
warfleet
heading
for
Lusitania
right
now."
Valentine
wasn't
listening
to
Jakt,
though.
She
was
watching
Miro.
This
time
Valentine
saw
when
he
moved
his
lips
and
jaw,
slightly,
silently.
Sure
enough,
after
he
subvocalized,
the
computer
image
of
Miro
spoke
again.
He
was
giving
commands.
It
had
been
absurd
for
her
to
think
otherwise--
who
else
could
be
controlling
the
computer?
"It's
a
hierarchy,"
said
the
image.
"The
more
complex
the
structure,
the
faster
the
response
to
change.
It's
as
if
the
smaller
the
particle
is,
the
stupider
it
is,
so
it's
slower
to
pick
up
on
the
fact
that
it's
now
part
of
a
different
structure."
"Now
you're
anthropomorphizing,"
said
Valentine.
"Maybe,"
said
Miro.
"Maybe
not."
"Human
beings
are
organisms,"
said
the
image.
"But
human
philotic
twinings
go
way
beyond
those
of
any
other
life
form."
"Now
you're
talking
about
that
stuff
that
came
from
Ganges
a
thousand
years
ago,"
said
Valentine.
"Nobody's
been
able
to
get
consistent
results
from
those
experiments."
The
researchers--
Hindus
all,
and
devout
ones--
claimed
that
they
had
shown
that
human
philotic
twinings,
unlike
those
of
other
organisms,
did
not
always
reach
directly
down
into
the
planet's
core
to
twine
with
all
other
life
and
matter.
Rather,
they
claimed,
the
philotic
rays
from
human
beings
often
twined
with
those
of
other
human
beings,
most
often
with
families,
but
sometimes
between
teachers
and
students,
and
sometimes
between
close
co-workers--
including
the
researchers
themselves.
The
Gangeans
had
concluded
that
this
distinction
between
humans
and
other
plant
and
animal
life
proved
that
the
souls
of
some
humans
were
literally
lifted
to
a
higher
plane,
nearer
to
perfection.
They
believed
that
the
Perfecting
Ones
had
become
one
with
each
other
the
way
that
all
of
life
was
one
with
the
world.
"It's
all
very
pleasingly
mystical,
but
nobody
except
Gangean
Hindus
takes
it
seriously
anymore."
"I
do,"
said
Miro.
"To
each
his
own,"
said
Jakt.
"Not
as
a
religion,"
said
Miro.
"As
science."
"You
mean
metaphysics,
don't
you?"
said
Valentine.
It
was
the
Miro-image
that
answered.
"The
philotic
connections
between
people
change
fastest
of
all,
and
what
the
Gangeans
proved
is
that
they
respond
to
human
will.
If
you
have
strong
feelings
binding
you
to
your
family,
then
your
philotic
rays
will
twine
and
you
will
be
one,
in
exactly
the
same
way
that
the
different
atoms
in
a
molecule
are
one."
It
was
a
sweet
idea--
she
had
thought
so
when
she
first
heard
it,
perhaps
two
thousand
years
ago,
when
Ender
was
speaking
for
a
murdered
revolutionary
on
Mindanao.
She
and
Ender
had
speculated
then
on
whether
the
Gangean
tests
would
show
that
they
were
twined,
as
brother
and
sister.
They
wondered
whether
there
had
been
such
a
connection
between
them
as
children,
and
if
it
had
persisted
when
Ender
was
taken
off
to
Battle
School
and
they
were
separated
for
six
years.
Ender
had
liked
that
idea
very
much,
and
so
had
Valentine,
but
after
that
one
conversation
the
subject
never
came
up
again.
The
notion
of
philotic
connections
between
people
had
remained
in
the
pretty-idea
category
in
her
memory.
"It's
nice
to
think
that
the
metaphor
of
human
unity
might
have
a
physical
analogue,"
said
Valentine.
"Listen!"
said
Miro.
Apparently
he
didn't
want
her
to
dismiss
the
idea
as
"nice."
Again
his
image
spoke
for
him.
"If
the
Gangeans
are
right,
then
when
a
human
being
chooses
to
bond
with
another
person,
when
he
makes
a
commitment
to
a
community,
it
is
not
just
a
social
phenomenon.
It's
a
physical
event
as
well.
The
philote,
the
smallest
conceivable
physical
particle--
if
we
can
call
something
with
no
mass
or
inertia
physical
at
all--
responds
to
an
act
of
the
human
will."
"That's
why
it's
so
hard
for
anyone
to
take
the
Gangean
experiments
seriously."
"The
Gangean
experiments
were
careful
and
honest."
"But
no
one
else
ever
got
the
same
results."
"No
one
else
ever
took
them
seriously
enough
to
perform
the
same
experiments.
Does
that
surprise
you?"
"Yes,"
said
Valentine.
But
then
she
remembered
how
the
idea
had
been
ridiculed
in
the
scientific
press,
while
it
was
immediately
picked
up
by
the
lunatic
fringe
and
incorporated
into
dozens
of
fringe
religions.
Once
that
happened,
how
could
a
scientist
hope
to
get
funding
for
such
a
project?
How
could
a
scientist
expect
to
have
a
career
if
others
came
to
think
of
him
as
a
proponent
of
a
metaphysical
religion?
"No,
I
suppose
it
doesn't."
The
Miro-image
nodded.
"If
the
philotic
ray
twines
in
response
to
the
human
will,
why
couldn't
we
suppose
that
all
philotic
twining
is
willed?
Every
particle,
all
of
matter
and
energy,
why
couldn't
every
observable
phenomenon
in
the
universe
be
the
willing
behavior
of
individuals?"
"Now
we're
beyond
Gangean
Hinduism,"
said
Valentine.
"How
seriously
am
I
supposed
to
take
this?
What
you're
talking
about
is
Animism.
The
most
primitive
kind
of
religion.
Everything's
alive.
Stones
and
oceans
and--"
"No,"
said
Miro.
"Life
is
life."
"Life
is
life,"
said
the
computer
program.
"Life
is
when
a
single
philote
has
the
strength
of
will
to
bind
together
the
molecules
of
a
single
cell,
to
entwine
their
rays
into
one.
A
stronger
philote
can
bind
together
many
cells
into
a
single
organism.
The
strongest
of
all
are
the
intelligent
beings.
We
can
bestow
our
philotic
connections
where
we
will.
The
philotic
basis
of
intelligent
life
is
even
clearer
in
the
other
known
sentient
species.
When
a
pequenino
dies
and
passes
into
the
third
life,
it's
his
strong-willed
philote
that
preserves
his
identity
and
passes
it
from
the
mammaloid
corpse
to
the
living
tree."
"Reincarnation,"
said
Jakt.
"The
philote
is
the
soul."
"It
happens
with
the
piggies,
anyway,"
said
Miro.
"The
hive
queen
as
well,"
said
the
Miro-image.
"The
reason
we
discovered
philotic
connections
in
the
first
place
was
because
we
saw
how
the
buggers
communicated
with
each
other
faster
than
light--
that's
what
showed
us
it
was
possible.
The
individual
buggers
are
all
part
of
the
hive
queen;
they're
like
her
hands
and
feet,
and
she's
their
mind,
one
vast
organism
with
thousands
or
millions
of
bodies.
And
the
only
connection
between
them
is
the
twining
of
their
philotic
rays."
It
was
a
picture
of
the
universe
that
Valentine
had
never
conceived
of
before.
Of
course,
as
a
historian
and
biographer
she
usually
conceived
of
things
in
terms
of
peoples
and
societies;
while
she
wasn't
ignorant
of
physics,
neither
was
she
deeply
trained
in
it.
Perhaps
a
physicist
would
know
at
once
why
this
whole
idea
was
absurd.
But
then,
perhaps
a
physicist
would
be
so
locked
into
the
consensus
of
his
scientific
community
that
it
would
be
harder
for
him
to
accept
an
idea
that
transformed
the
meaning
of
everything
he
knew.
Even
if
it
were
true.
And
she
liked
the
idea
well
enough
to
wish
it
were
true.
Of
the
trillion
lovers
who
had
whispered
to
each
other,
We
are
one,
could
it
be
that
some
of
them
really
were?
Of
the
billions
of
families
who
had
bonded
together
so
closely
they
felt
like
a
single
soul,
wouldn't
it
be
lovely
to
think
that
at
the
most
basic
level
of
reality
it
was
so?
Jakt,
however,
was
not
so
caught
up
in
the
idea.
"I
thought
we
weren't
supposed
to
talk
about
the
existence
of
the
hive
queen,"
he
said.
"I
thought
that
was
Ender's
secret."
"It's
all
right,"
said
Valentine.
"Everyone
in
this
room
knows."
Jakt
gave
her
his
impatient
look.
"I
thought
we
were
coming
to
Lusitania
to
help
in
the
struggle
against
Starways
Congress.
What
does
any
of
this
have
to
do
with
the
real
world?"
"Maybe
nothing,"
said
Valentine.
"Maybe
everything."
Jakt
buried
his
face
in
his
hands
for
a
moment,
then
looked
back
up
at
her
with
a
smile
that
wasn't
really
a
smile.
"I
haven't
heard
you
say
anything
so
transcendental
since
your
brother
left
Trondheim."
That
stung
her,
particularly
because
she
knew
it
was
meant
to.
After
all
these
years,
was
Jakt
still
jealous
of
her
connection
with
Ender?
Did
he
still
resent
the
fact
that
she
could
care
about
things
that
meant
nothing
to
him?
"When
he
went,"
said
Valentine,
"I
stayed."
She
was
really
saying,
I
passed
the
only
test
that
mattered.
Why
should
you
doubt
me
now?
Jakt
was
abashed.
It
was
one
of
the
best
things
about
him,
that
when
he
realized
he
was
wrong
he
backed
down
at
once.
"And
when
you
went,"
said
Jakt,
"I
came
with
you."
Which
she
took
to
mean,
I'm
with
you,
I'm
really
not
jealous
of
Ender
anymore,
and
I'm
sorry
for
sniping
at
you.
Later,
when
they
were
alone,
they'd
say
these
things
again
openly.
It
wouldn't
do
to
reach
Lusitania
with
suspicions
and
jealousy
on
either's
part.
Miro,
of
course,
was
oblivious
to
the
fact
that
Jakt
and
Valentine
had
already
declared
a
truce.
He
was
only
aware
of
the
tension
between
them,
and
thought
he
was
the
cause
of
it.
"I'm
sorry,"
said
Miro.
"I
didn't
mean
to..."
"It's
all
right,"
said
Jakt.
"I
was
out
of
line."
"There
is
no
line,"
said
Valentine,
with
a
smile
at
her
husband.
Jakt
smiled
back.
That
was
what
Miro
needed
to
see;
he
visibly
relaxed.
"Go
on,"
said
Valentine.
"Take
all
that
as
a
given,"
said
the
Miro-image.
Valentine
couldn't
help
it--
she
laughed
out
loud.
Partly
she
laughed
because
this
mystical
Gangean
philote-as-soul
business
was
such
an
absurdly
large
premise
to
swallow.
Partly
she
laughed
to
release
the
tension
between
her
and
Jakt.
"I'm
sorry,"
she
said.
"That's
an
awfully
big
'given.'
If
that's
the
preamble,
I
can't
wait
to
hear
the
conclusion."
Miro,
understanding
her
laughter
now,
smiled
back.
"I've
had
a
lot
of
time
to
think,"
he
said.
"That
really
was
my
speculation
on
what
life
is.
That
everything
in
the
universe
is
behavior.
But
there's
something
else
we
want
to
tell
you
about.
And
ask
you
about,
too,
I
guess."
He
turned
to
Jakt.
"And
it
has
a
lot
to
do
with
stopping
the
Lusitania
Fleet."
Jakt
smiled
and
nodded.
"I
appreciate
being
tossed
a
bone
now
and
then."
Valentine
smiled
her
most
charming
smile.
"So--
later
you'll
be
glad
when
I
break
a
few
bones."
Jakt
laughed
again.
"Go
on,
Miro,"
said
Valentine.
It
was
the
image-Miro
that
responded.
"If
all
of
reality
is
the
behavior
of
philotes,
then
obviously
most
philotes
are
only
smart
enough
or
strong
enough
to
act
as
a
meson
or
hold
together
a
neutron.
A
very
few
of
them
have
the
strength
of
will
to
be
alive--
to
govern
an
organism.
And
a
tiny,
tiny
fraction
of
them
are
powerful
enough
to
control--
no,
to
be--
a
sentient
organism.
But
still,
the
most
complex
and
intelligent
being--
the
hive
queen,
for
instance--
is,
at
core,
just
a
philote,
like
all
the
others.
It
gains
its
identity
and
life
from
the
particular
role
it
happens
to
fulfill,
but
what
it
is
is
a
philote."
"My
self--
my
will--
is
a
subatomic
particle?"
asked
Valentine.
Jakt
smiled,
nodded.
"A
fun
idea,"
he
said.
"My
shoe
and
I
are
brothers."
Miro
smiled
wanly.
The
Miro-image,
however,
answered.
"If
a
star
and
a
hydrogen
atom
are
brothers,
then
yes,
there
is
a
kinship
between
you
and
the
philotes
that
make
up
common
objects
like
your
shoe."
Valentine
noticed
that
Miro
had
not
subvocalized
anything
just
before
the
Miro-image
answered.
How
had
the
software
producing
the
Miro-image
come
up
with
the
analogy
with
stars
and
hydrogen
atoms,
if
Miro
didn't
provide
it
on
the
spot?
Valentine
had
never
heard
of
a
computer
program
capable
of
producing
such
involved
yet
appropriate
conversation
on
its
own.
"And
maybe
there
are
other
kinships
in
the
universe
that
you
know
nothing
of
till
now,"
said
the
Miroimage.
"Maybe
there's
a
kind
of
life
you
haven't
met."
Valentine,
watching
Miro,
saw
that
he
seemed
worried.
Agitated.
As
if
he
didn't
like
what
the
Miro-image
was
doing
now.
"What
kind
of
life
are
you
talking
about?"
asked
Jakt.
"There's
a
physical
phenomenon
in
the
universe,
a
very
common
one,
that
is
completely
unexplained,
and
yet
everyone
takes
it
for
granted
and
no
one
has
seriously
investigated
why
and
how
it
happens.
This
is
it:
None
of
the
ansible
connections
has
ever
broken."
"Nonsense,"
said
Jakt.
"One
of
the
ansibles
on
Trondheim
was
out
of
service
for
six
months
last
year--
it
doesn't
happen
often,
but
it
happens."
Again
Miro's
lips
and
jaw
were
motionless;
again
the
image
answered
immediately.
Clearly
he
was
not
controlling
it
now.
"I
didn't
say
that
the
ansibles
never
break
down.
I
said
that
the
connections--
the
philotic
twining
between
the
parts
of
a
split
meson--
have
never
broken.
The
machinery
of
the
ansible
can
break
down,
the
software
can
get
corrupted,
but
never
has
a
meson
fragment
within
an
ansible
made
the
shift
to
allow
its
philotic
ray
to
entwine
with
another
local
meson
or
even
with
the
nearby
planet."
"The
magnetic
field
suspends
the
fragment,
of
course,"
said
Jakt.
"Split
mesons
don't
endure
long
enough
in
nature
for
us
to
know
how
they
naturally
act,"
said
Valentine.
"I
know
all
the
standard
answers,"
said
the
image.
"All
nonsense.
All
the
kind
of
answers
parents
give
their
children
when
they
don't
know
the
truth
and
don't
want
to
bother
finding
out.
People
still
treat
the
ansibles
like
magic.
Everybody's
glad
enough
that
the
ansibles
keep
on
working;
if
they
tried
to
figure
out
why,
the
magic
might
go
out
of
it
and
then
the
ansibles
would
stop."
"Nobody
feels
that
way,"
said
Valentine.
"They
all
do,"
said
the
image.
"Even
if
it
took
hundreds
of
years,
or
a
thousand
years,
or
three
thousand
years,
one
of
those
connections
should
have
broken
by
now.
One
of
those
meson
fragments
should
have
shifted
its
philotic
ray--
but
they
never
have."
"Why?"
asked
Miro.
Valentine
assumed
at
first
that
Miro
was
asking
a
rhetorical
question.
But
no--
he
was
looking
at
the
image
just
like
the
rest
of
them,
asking
it
to
tell
him
why.
"I
thought
this
program
was
reporting
your
speculations,"
said
Valentine.
"It
was,"
said
Miro.
"But
not
now."
"What
if
there's
a
being
who
lives
among
the
philotic
connections
between
ansibles?"
asked
the
image.
"Are
you
sure
you
want
to
do
this?"
asked
Miro.
Again
he
was
speaking
to
the
image
on
the
screen.
And
the
image
on
the
screen
changed,
to
the
face
of
a
young
woman,
one
that
Valentine
had
never
seen
before.
"What
if
there's
a
being
who
dwells
in
the
web
of
philotic
rays
connecting
the
ansibles
on
every
world
and
every
starship
in
the
human
universe?
What
if
she
is
composed
of
those
philotic
connections?
What
if
her
thoughts
take
place
in
the
spin
and
vibration
of
the
split
pairs?
What
if
her
memories
are
stored
in
the
computers
of
every
world
and
every
ship?"
"Who
are
you?"
asked
Valentine,
speaking
directly
to
the
image.
"Maybe
I'm
the
one
who
keeps
all
those
philotic
connections
alive,
ansible
to
ansible.
Maybe
I'm
a
new
kind
of
organism,
one
that
doesn't
twine
rays
together,
but
instead
keeps
them
twined
to
each
other
so
that
they
never
break
apart.
And
if
that's
true,
then
if
those
connections
ever
broke,
if
the
ansibles
ever
stopped
moving--
if
the
ansibles
ever
fell
silent,
then
I
would
die."
"Who
are
you?"
asked
Valentine
again.
"Valentine,
I'd
like
you
to
meet
Jane,"
said
Miro.
"Ender's
friend.
And
mine."
"Jane."
So
Jane
wasn't
the
code
name
of
a
subversive
group
within
the
Starways
Congress
bureaucracy.
Jane
was
a
computer
program,
a
piece
of
software.
No.
If
what
she
had
just
suggested
was
true,
then
Jane
was
more
than
a
program.
She
was
a
being
who
dwelt
in
the
web
of
philotic
rays,
who
stored
her
memories
in
the
computers
of
every
world.
If
she
was
right,
then
the
philotic
web--
the
network
of
crisscrossing
philotic
rays
that
connected
ansible
to
ansible
on
every
world--
was
her
body,
her
substance.
And
the
philotic
links
continued
working
with
never
a
breakdown
because
she
willed
it
so.
"So
now
I
ask
the
great
Demosthenes,"
said
Jane.
"Am
I
raman
or
varelse?
Am
I
alive
at
all?
I
need
your
answer,
because
I
think
I
can
stop
the
Lusitania
Fleet.
But
before
I
do
it,
I
have
to
know:
Is
it
a
cause
worth
dying
for?"
Jane's
words
cut
Miro
to
the
heart.
She
could
stop
the
fleet--
he
could
see
that
at
once.
Congress
had
sent
the
M.D.
Device
with
several
ships
of
the
fleet,
but
they
had
not
yet
sent
the
order
to
use
it.
They
couldn't
send
the
order
without
Jane
knowing
it
beforehand,
and
with
her
complete
penetration
of
all
the
ansible
communications,
she
could
intercept
the
order
before
it
was
sent.
The
trouble
was
that
she
couldn't
do
it
without
Congress
realizing
that
she
existed--
or
at
least
that
something
was
wrong.
If
the
fleet
didn't
confirm
the
order,
it
would
simply
be
sent
again,
and
again,
and
again.
The
more
she
blocked
the
messages,
the
clearer
it
would
be
to
Congress
that
someone
had
an
impossible
degree
of
control
over
the
ansible
computers.
She
might
avoid
this
by
sending
a
counterfeit
confirmation,
but
then
she
would
have
to
monitor
all
the
communications
between
the
ships
of
the
fleet,
and
between
the
fleet
and
all
planetside
stations,
in
order
to
keep
up
the
pretense
that
the
fleet
knew
something
about
the
kill
order.
Despite
Jane's
enormous
abilities,
this
would
soon
be
beyond
her--
she
could
pay
some
degree
of
attention
to
hundreds,
even
thousands
of
things
at
a
time,
but
it
didn't
take
Miro
long
to
realize
that
there
was
no
way
she
could
handle
all
the
monitoring
and
alterations
this
would
take,
even
if
she
did
nothing
else.
One
way
or
another,
the
secret
would
be
out.
And
as
Jane
explained
her
plan,
Miro
knew
that
she
was
right--
her
best
option,
the
one
with
the
least
chance
of
revealing
her
existence,
was
simply
to
cut
off
all
ansible
communications
between
the
fleet
and
the
planetside
stations,
and
between
the
ships
of
the
fleet.
Let
each
ship
remain
isolated,
the
crew
wondering
what
had
happened,
and
they
would
have
no
choice
but
to
abort
their
mission
or
continue
to
obey
their
original
orders.
Either
they
would
go
away
or
they
would
arrive
at
Lusitania
without
the
authority
to
use
the
Little
Doctor.
In
the
meantime,
however,
Congress
would
know
that
something
had
happened.
It
was
possible
that
with
Congress's
normal
bureaucratic
inefficiency,
no
one
would
ever
figure
out
what
happened.
But
eventually
somebody
would
realize
that
there
was
no
natural
or
human
explanation
of
what
happened.
Someone
would
realize
that
Jane--
or
something
like
her--
must
exist,
and
that
cutting
off
ansible
communications
would
destroy
her.
Once
they
knew
this,
she
would
surely
die.
"Maybe
not,"
Miro
insisted.
"Maybe
you
can
keep
them
from
acting.
Interfere
with
interplanetary
communications,
so
they
can't
give
the
order
to
shut
down
communications."
No
one
answered.
He
knew
why:
she
couldn't
interfere
with
ansible
communications
forever.
Eventually
the
government
on
each
planet
would
reach
the
conclusion
on
its
own.
She
might
live
on
in
constant
warfare
for
years,
decades,
generations.
But
the
more
power
she
used,
the
more
humankind
would
hate
and
fear
her.
Eventually
she
would
be
killed.
"A
book,
then,"
said
Miro.
"Like
the
Hive
Queen
and
the
Hegemon.
Like
the
Life
of
Human.
The
Speaker
for
the
Dead
could
write
it.
To
persuade
them
not
to
do
it."
"Maybe,"
said
Valentine.
"She
can't
die,"
said
Miro.
"I
know
that
we
can't
ask
her
to
take
that
chance,"
said
Valentine.
"But
if
it's
the
only
way
to
save
the
hive
queen
and
the
pequeninos--"
Miro
was
furious.
"You
can
talk
about
her
dying!
What
is
Jane
to
you?
A
program,
a
piece
of
software.
But
she's
not,
she's
real,
she's
as
real
as
the
hive
queen,
she's
as
real
as
any
of
the
piggies--"
"More
real
to
you,
I
think,"
said
Valentine.
"As
real,"
said
Miro.
"You
forget--
I
know
the
piggies
like
my
own
brothers--"
"But
you're
able
to
contemplate
the
possibility
that
destroying
them
may
be
morally
necessary."
"Don't
twist
my
words."
"I'm
untwisting
them,"
said
Valentine.
"You
can
contemplate
losing
them,
because
they're
already
lost
to
you.
Losing
Jane,
though--"
"Because
she's
my
friend,
does
that
mean
I
can't
plead
for
her?
Can
life-and-death
decisions
only
be
made
by
strangers?"
Jakt's
voice,
quiet
and
deep,
interrupted
the
argument.
"Calm
down,
both
of
you.
It
isn't
your
decision.
It's
Jane's.
She
has
the
right
to
determine
the
value
of
her
own
life.
I'm
no
philosopher,
but
I
know
that."
"Well
said,"
Valentine
answered.
Miro
knew
that
Jakt
was
right,
that
it
was
Jane's
choice.
But
he
couldn't
bear
that,
because
he
also
knew
what
she
would
decide.
Leaving
the
choice
up
to
Jane
was
identical
to
asking
her
to
do
it.
And
yet,
in
the
end,
the
choice
would
be
up
to
her
anyway.
He
didn't
even
have
to
ask
her
what
she
would
decide.
Time
passed
so
quickly
for
her,
especially
since
they
were
already
traveling
at
near-lightspeed,
that
she
had
probably
decided
already.
It
was
too
much
to
bear.
To
lose
Jane
now
would
be
unbearable;
just
thinking
of
it
threatened
Miro's
composure.
He
didn't
want
to
show
such
weakness
in
front
of
these
people.
Good
people,
they
were
good
people,
but
he
didn't
want
them
to
see
him
lose
control
of
himself.
So
Miro
leaned
forward,
found
his
balance,
and
precariously
lifted
himself
from
his
seat.
It
was
hard,
since
only
a
few
of
his
muscles
responded
to
his
will,
and
it
took
all
his
concentration
just
to
walk
from
the
bridge
to
his
compartment.
No
one
followed
him
or
even
spoke
to
him.
He
was
glad
of
that.
Alone
in
his
room,
he
lay
down
on
his
bunk
and
called
to
her.
But
not
aloud.
He
subvocalized,
because
that
was
his
custom
when
he
talked
to
her.
Even
though
the
others
on
this
ship
now
knew
of
her
existence,
he
had
no
intention
of
losing
the
habits
that
had
kept
her
concealed
till
now.
"Jane,"
he
said
silently.
"Yes,"
said
the
voice
in
his
ear.
He
imagined,
as
always,
that
her
soft
voice
came
from
a
woman
just
out
of
sight,
but
close,
very
close.
He
shut
his
eyes,
so
he
could
imagine
her
better.
Her
breath
on
his
cheek.
Her
hair
dangling
over
his
face
as
she
spoke
to
him
softly,
as
he
answered
in
silence.
"Talk
to
Ender
before
you
decide,"
he
said.
"I
already
did.
Just
now,
while
you
were
thinking
about
this."
"What
did
he
say?"
"To
do
nothing.
To
decide
nothing,
until
the
order
is
actually
sent."
"That's
right.
Maybe
they
won't
do
it."
"Maybe.
Maybe
a
new
group
with
different
policies
will
come
into
power.
Maybe
this
group
will
change
its
mind.
Maybe
Valentine's
propaganda
will
succeed.
Maybe
there'll
be
a
mutiny
on
the
fleet."
This
last
was
so
unlikely
that
Miro
realized
Jane
absolutely
believed
that
the
order
would
be
sent.
"How
soon?"
asked
Miro.
"The
fleet
should
arrive
in
about
fifteen
years.
A
year
or
less
after
these
two
ships
get
there.
That's
how
I
timed
your
voyage.
The
order
will
be
sent
sometime
before.
Maybe
six
months
before
arrival--
which
would
be
aboul
eight
hours
ship's
time
before
the
fleet
drops
out
of
lightspeed
and
staggerss
down
to
normal
speeds."
"Don't
do
it,"
said
Miro.
"I
haven't
decided."
"Yes
you
have.
You've
decided
to
do
it."
She
said
nothing.
"Don't
leave
me,"
he
said.
"I
don't
leave
my
friends
if
I
don't
have
to,"
she
said.
"Some
people
do,
but
I
don't."
"Just
don't,"
he
said
again.
He
was
crying.
Could
she
see
that,
sense
it
somehow
through
the
jewel
in
his
ear?
"I'll
try."
"Find
another
way.
Find
another
way
to
stop
them.
Find
some
way
to
put
yourself
outside
the
philotic
net
so
they
can't
kill
you."
"That's
what
Ender
said."
"Then
do
it!"
"I
can
search
for
such
a
way,
but
who
knows
if
it
exists?"
"It
has
to."
"This
is
why
I
wonder
sometimes
whether
I'm
alive
or
not.
You
living
creatures,
you
think
that
because
you
want
something
very
much,
it
has
to
happen.
That
wishing
something
with
all
your
heart
will
make
it
so."
"How
can
you
search
for
something
if
you
don't
believe
that
it
exists?"
"Either
I
search
or
I
don't,"
said
Jane.
"I
don't
get
distracted
or
bored
like
humans
do.
I'll
try
to
think
of
something
else."
"Think
of
this,
too,"
said
Miro.
"Think
of
who
you
are.
Of
how
your
mind
works.
You
can't
possibly
find
a
way
of
saving
your
life
until
you
understand
how
you
came
to
life
in
the
first
place.
And
once
you
understand
yourself--"
"Then
maybe
I
can
make
a
copy
and
store
it
somewhere."
"Maybe."
"Maybe,"
she
echoed.
But
he
knew
she
didn't
believe
it,
and
neither
did
he.
She
existed
in
the
philotic
network
of
the
ansibles;
she
could
store
her
memories
in
the
network
of
computers
on
every
world
and
every
ship
in
space,
but
there
was
nowhere
that
she
could
put
her
self,
not
if
it
required
a
network
of
philotic
links.
Unless.
"What
about
the
fathertrees
on
Lusitania?
They
communicate
philotically,
don't
they?"
"It's
not
the
same
thing,"
said
Jane.
"It
isn't
digital.
It
isn't
coded
the
way
the
ansibles
are."
"It
may
not
be
digital,
but
the
information
gets
transferred
somehow,
it
works
philotically.
And
the
hive
queen,
too--
she
communicates
with
the
buggers
that
way."
"No
chance
of
that,"
said
Jane.
"The
structure's
too
simple.
Her
communication
with
them
isn't
a
network.
They're
all
connected
only
to
her."
"How
do
you
know
it
won't
work,
when
you
don't
even
know
for
sure
how
you
function?"
"All
right.
I'll
think
about
it."
"Think
hard,"
he
said.
"I
only
know
one
way
to
think,"
said
Jane.
"I
mean,
pay
attention
to
it."
She
could
follow
many
trains
of
thought
at
once,
but
her
thoughts
were
prioritized,
with
many
different
levels
of
attention.
Miro
didn't
want
her
relegating
her
self-investigation
to
some
low
order
of
attention.
"I'll
pay
attention,"
she
said.
"Then
you'll
think
of
something,"
he
said.
"You
will."
She
didn't
answer
for
a
while.
He
thought
this
meant
that
the
conversation
was
over.
His
thoughts
began
to
wander.
To
try
to
imagine
what
life
would
be
like,
still
in
this
body,
only
without
Jane.
It
could
happen
before
he
even
arrived
on
Lusitania.
And
if
it
did,
this
voyage
would
have
been
the
most
terrible
mistake
of
his
life.
By
traveling
at
lightspeed,
he
was
skipping
thirty
years
of
realtime.
Thirty
years
that
might
have
been
spent
with
Jane.
He
might
be
able
to
deal
with
losing
her
then.
But
losing
her
now,
only
a
few
weeks
into
knowing
her--
he
knew
that
his
tears
arose
from
self-pity,
but
he
shed
them
all
the
same.
"Miro,"
she
said.
"What?"
he
asked.
"How
can
I
think
of
something
that's
never
been
thought
of
before?"
For
a
moment
he
didn't
understand.
"Miro,
how
can
I
figure
out
something
that
isn't
just
the
logical
conclusion
of
things
that
human
beings
have
already
figured
out
and
written
somewhere?"
"You
think
of
things
all
the
time,"
said
Miro.
"I'm
trying
to
conceive
of
something
inconceivable.
I'm
trying
to
find
answers
to
questions
that
human
beings
have
never
even
tried
to
ask."
"Can't
you
do
that?"
"If
I
can't
think
original
thoughts,
does
that
mean
that
I'm
nothing
but
a
computer
program
that
got
out
of
hand?"
"Hell,
Jane,
most
people
never
have
an
original
thought
in
their
lives."
He
laughed
softly.
"Does
that
mean
they're
just
ground-dwelling
apes
that
got
out
of
hand?"
"You
were
crying,"
she
said.
"Yes."
"You
don't
think
I
can
think
of
a
way
out
of
this.
You
think
I'm
going
to
die."
"I
believe
you
can
think
of
a
way.
I
really
do.
But
that
doesn't
stop
me
from
being
afraid."
"Afraid
that
I'll
die."
"Afraid
that
I'll
lose
you."
"Would
that
be
so
terrible?
To
lose
me?"
"Oh
God,"
he
whispered.
"Would
you
miss
me
for
an
hour?"
she
insisted.
"For
a
day?
For
a
year?"
What
did
she
want
from
him?
Assurance
that
when
she
was
gone
she'd
be
remembered?
That
someone
would
yearn
for
her?
Why
would
she
doubt
that?
Didn't
she
know
him
yet?
Maybe
she
was
human
enough
that
she
simply
needed
reassurance
of
things
she
already
knew.
"Forever,"
he
said.
It
was
her
turn
to
laugh.
Playfully.
"You
won't
live
that
long,"
she
said.
"Now
you
tell
me,"
he
said.
This
time
when
she
fell
silent,
she
didn't
come
back,
and
Miro
was
left
alone
with
his
thoughts.
Valentine,
Jakt,
and
Plikt
had
remained
together
on
the
bridge,
talking
through
the
things
they
had
learned,
trying
to
decide
what
they
might
mean,
what
might
happen.
The
only
conclusion
they
reached
was
that
while
the
future
couldn't
be
known,
it
would
probably
be
a
good
deal
better
than
their
worst
fears
and
nowhere
near
as
good
as
their
best
hopes.
Wasn't
that
how
the
world
always
worked?
"Yes,"
said
Plikt.
"Except
for
the
exceptions."
That
was
Plikt's
way.
Except
when
she
was
teaching,
she
said
little,
but
when
she
did
speak,
it
had
a
way
of
ending
the
conversation.
Plikt
got
up
to
leave
the
bridge,
headed
for
her
miserably
uncomfortable
bed;
as
usual,
Valentine
tried
to
persuade
her
to
go
back
to
the
other
starship.
"Varsam
and
Ro
don't
want
me
in
their
room,"
said
Plikt.
"They
don't
mind
a
bit."
"Valentine,"
said
Jakt,
"Plikt
doesn't
want
to
go
back
to
the
other
ship
because
she
doesn't
want
to
miss
anything."
"Oh,"
said
Valentine.
Plikt
grinned.
"Good
night."
Soon
after,
Jakt
also
left
the
bridge.
His
hand
rested
on
Valentine's
shoulder
for
a
moment
as
he
left.
"I'll
be
there
soon,"
she
said.
And
she
meant
it
at
the
moment,
meant
to
follow
him
almost
at
once.
Instead
she
remained
on
the
bridge,
thinking,
brooding,
trying
to
make
sense
of
a
universe
that
would
put
all
the
nonhuman
species
ever
known
to
man
at
risk
of
extinction,
all
at
once.
The
hive
queen,
the
pequeninos,
and
now
Jane,
the
only
one
of
her
kind,
perhaps
the
only
one
that
ever
could
exist.
A
veritable
profusion
of
intelligent
life,
and
yet
known
only
to
a
few.
And
all
of
them
in
line
to
be
snuffed
out.
At
least
Ender
will
realize
at
last
that
this
is
the
natural
order
of
things,
that
he
might
not
be
as
responsible
for
the
destruction
of
the
buggers
three
thousand
years
ago
as
he
had
always
thought.
Xenocide
must
be
built
into
the
universe.
No
mercy,
not
even
for
the
greatest
players
in
the
game.
How
could
she
have
ever
thought
otherwise?
Why
should
intelligent
species
be
immune
to
the
threat
of
extinction
that
looms
over
every
species
that
ever
came
to
be?
It
must
have
been
an
hour
after
Jakt
left
the
bridge
before
Valentine
finally
turned
off
her
terminal
and
stood
up
to
go
to
bed.
On
a
whim,
though,
she
paused
before
leaving
and
spoke
into
the
air.
"Jane?"
she
said.
"Jane?"
No
answer.
There
was
no
reason
for
her
to
expect
one.
It
was
Miro
who
wore
the
jewel
in
his
ear.
Miro
and
Ender
both.
How
many
people
did
she
think
Jane
could
monitor
at
one
time?
Maybe
two
was
the
most
she
could
handle.
Or
maybe
two
thousand.
Or
two
million.
What
did
Valentine
know
of
the
limitations
of
a
being
who
existed
as
a
phantom
in
the
philotic
web?
Even
if
Jane
heard
her,
Valentine
had
no
right
to
expect
that
she
would
answer
her
call.
Valentine
stopped
in
the
corridor,
directly
between
Miro's
door
and
the
door
to
the
room
she
shared
with
Jakt.
The
doors
were
not
soundproof.
She
could
hear
Jakt's
soft
snoring
inside
their
compartment.
She
also
heard
another
sound.
Miro's
breath.
He
wasn't
sleeping.
He
might
be
crying.
She
hadn't
raised
three
children
without
being
able
to
recognize
that
ragged,
heavy
breathing.
He's
not
my
child.
I
shouldn't
meddle.
She
pushed
open
the
door;
it
was
noiseless,
but
it
cast
a
shaft
of
light
across
the
bed.
Miro's
crying
stopped
immediately,
but
he
looked
at
her
through
swollen
eyes.
"What
do
you
want?"
he
said.
She
stepped
into
the
room
and
sat
on
the
floor
beside
his
bunk,
so
their
faces
were
only
a
few
inches
apart.
"You've
never
cried
for
yourself,
have
you?"
she
said.
"A
few
times."
"But
tonight
you're
crying
for
her."
"Myself
as
much
as
her."
Valentine
leaned
closer,
put
her
arm
around
him,
pulled
his
head
onto
her
shoulder.
"No,"
he
said.
But
he
didn't
pull
away.
And
after
a
few
moments,
his
arm
swung
awkwardly
around
to
embrace
her.
He
didn't
cry
anymore,
but
he
did
let
her
hold
him
for
a
minute
or
two.
Maybe
it
helped.
Valentine
had
no
way
of
knowing.
Then
he
was
done.
He
pulled
away,
rolled
onto
his
back.
"I'm
sorry,"
he
said.
"You're
welcome,"
she
said.
She
believed
in
answering
what
people
meant,
not
what
they
said.
"Don't
tell
Jakt,"
he
whispered.
"Nothing
to
tell,"
she
said.
"We
had
a
good
talk."
She
got
up
and
left,
closing
his
door
behind
her.
He
was
a
good
boy.
She
liked
the
fact
that
he
could
admit
caring
what
Jakt
thought
about
him.
And
what
did
it
matter
if
his
tears
tonight
had
self-pity
in
them?
She
had
shed
a
few
like
that
herself.
Grief,
she
reminded
herself,
is
almost
always
for
the
mourner's
loss.
Chapter
5
--
THE
LUSITANIA
FLEET
<Ender
says
that
when
the
war
fleet
from
Starways
Congress
reaches
us,
they
plan
to
destroy
this
world.>
<Interesting.>
<You
don't
fear
death?>
<We
don't
intend
to
be
here
when
they
arrive.>
Qing-jao
was
no
longer
the
little
girl
whose
hands
had
bled
in
secret.
Her
life
had
been
transformed
from
the
moment
she
was
proved
to
be
godspoken,
and
in
the
ten
years
since
that
day
she
had
come
to
accept
the
voice
of
the
gods
in
her
life
and
the
role
this
gave
her
in
society.
She
learned
to
accept
the
privileges
and
honors
given
to
her
as
gifts
actually
meant
for
the
gods;
as
her
father
taught
her,
she
did
not
take
on
airs,
but
instead
grew
more
humble
as
the
gods
and
the
people
laid
ever-heavier
burdens
on
her.
She
took
her
duties
seriously,
and
found
joy
in
them.
For
the
past
ten
years
she
had
passed
through
a
rigorous,
exhilarating
course
of
studies.
Her
body
was
shaped
and
trained
in
the
company
of
other
children-
-
running,
swimming,
riding,
combat-with-swords,
combat-with-sticks,
combat-with-bones.
Along
with
other
children,
her
memory
was
filled
with
languages--
Stark,
the
common
speech
of
the
stars,
which
was
typed
into
computers;
Old
Chinese,
which
was
sung
in
the
throat
and
drawn
in
beautiful
ideograms
on
rice
paper
or
in
fine
sand;
and
New
Chinese,
which
was
merely
spoken
at
the
mouth
and
jotted
down
with
a
common
alphabet
on
ordinary
paper
or
in
dirt.
No
one
was
surprised
except
Qing-jao
herself
that
she
learned
all
these
languages
much
more
quickly
and
easily
and
thoroughly
than
any
of
the
other
children.
Other
teachers
came
to
her
alone.
This
was
how
she
learned
sciences
and
history,
mathematics
and
music.
And
every
week
she
would
go
to
her
father
and
spend
half
a
day
with
him,
showing
him
all
that
she
had
learned
and
listening
to
what
he
said
in
response.
His
praise
made
her
dance
all
the
way
back
to
her
room;
his
mildest
rebuke
made
her
spend
hours
tracing
woodgrain
lines
in
her
schoolroom,
until
she
felt
worthy
to
return
to
studying.
Another
part
of
her
schooling
was
utterly
private.
She
had
seen
for
herself
how
Father
was
so
strong
that
he
could
postpone
his
obedience
to
the
gods.
She
knew
that
when
the
gods
demanded
a
ritual
of
purification,
the
hunger,
the
need
to
obey
them
was
so
exquisite
it
could
not
be
denied.
And
yet
Father
somehow
denied
it--
long
enough,
at
least,
that
his
rituals
were
always
in
private.
Qing-jao
longed
for
such
strength
herself,
and
so
she
began
to
discipline
herself
to
delay.
When
the
gods
made
her
feel
her
oppressive
unworthiness,
and
her
eyes
began
to
search
for
woodgrain
lines
or
her
hands
began
to
feel
unbearably
filthy,
she
would
wait,
trying
to
concentrate
on
what
was
happening
at
the
moment
and
put
off
obedience
as
long
as
she
could.
At
first
it
was
a
triumph
if
she
managed
to
postpone
her
purification
for
a
full
minute--
and
when
her
resistance
broke,
the
gods
punished
her
for
it
by
making
the
ritual
more
onerous
and
difficult
than
usual.
But
she
refused
to
give
up.
She
was
Han
Fei-tzu's
daughter,
wasn't
she?
And
in
time,
over
the
years,
she
learned
what
her
father
had
learned:
that
one
could
live
with
the
hunger,
contain
it,
often
for
hours,
like
a
bright
fire
encased
in
a
box
of
translucent
jade,
a
dangerous,
terrible
fire
from
the
gods,
burning
within
her
heart.
Then,
when
she
was
alone,
she
could
open
that
box
and
let
the
fire
out,
not
in
a
single,
terrible
eruption,
but
slowly,
gradually,
filling
her
with
light
as
she
bowed
her
head
and
traced
the
lines
on
the
floor,
or
bent
over
the
sacred
laver
of
her
holy
washings,
quietly
and
methodically
rubbing
her
hands
with
pumice,
lye,
and
aloe.
Thus
she
converted
the
raging
voice
of
the
gods
into
a
private,
disciplined
worship.
Only
at
rare
moments
of
sudden
distress
did
she
lose
control
and
fling
herself
to
the
floor
in
front
of
a
teacher
or
visitor.
She
accepted
these
humiliations
as
the
gods'
way
of
reminding
her
that
their
power
over
her
was
absolute,
that
her
usual
self-control
was
only
permitted
for
their
amusement.
She
was
content
with
this
imperfect
discipline.
After
all,
it
would
be
presumptuous
of
her
to
equal
her
father's
perfect
self-control.
His
extraordinary
nobility
came
because
the
gods
honored
him,
and
so
did
not
require
his
public
humiliation;
she
had
done
nothing
to
earn
such
honor.
Last
of
all,
her
schooling
included
one
day
each
week
helping
with
the
righteous
labor
of
the
common
people.
Righteous
labor,
of
course,
was
not
the
work
the
common
people
did
every
day
in
their
offices
and
factories.
Righteous
labor
meant
the
backbreaking
work
of
the
rice
paddies.
Every
man
and
woman
and
child
on
Path
had
to
perform
this
labor,
bending
and
stooping
in
shin-deep
water
to
plant
and
harvest
the
rice--
or
forfeit
citizenship.
"This
is
how
we
honor
our
ancestors,"
Father
explained
to
her
when
she
was
little.
"We
show
them
that
none
of
us
will
ever
rise
above
doing
their
labor."
The
rice
that
was
grown
by
righteous
labor
was
considered
holy;
it
was
offered
in
the
temples
and
eaten
on
holy
days;
it
was
placed
in
small
bowls
as
offerings
to
the
household
gods.
Once,
when
Qing-jao
was
twelve,
the
day
was
terribly
hot
and
she
was
eager
to
finish
her
work
on
a
research
project.
"Don't
make
me
go
to
the
rice
paddies
today,"
she
said
to
her
teacher.
"What
I'm
doing
here
is
so
much
more
important."
The
teacher
bowed
and
went
away,
but
soon
Father
came
into
her
room.
He
carried
a
heavy
sword,
and
she
screamed
in
terror
when
he
raised
it
over
his
head.
Did
he
mean
to
kill
her
for
having
spoken
so
sacrilegiously?
But
he
did
not
hurt
her--
how
could
she
have
imagined
that
he
might?
Instead
the
sword
came
down
on
her
computer
terminal.
The
metal
parts
twisted;
the
plastic
shattered
and
flew.
The
machine
was
destroyed.
Father
did
not
raise
his
voice.
It
was
in
the
faintest
whisper
that
he
said,
"First
the
gods.
Second
the
ancestors.
Third
the
people.
Fourth
the
rulers.
Last
the
self."
It
was
the
clearest
expression
of
the
Path.
It
was
the
reason
this
world
was
settled
in
the
first
place.
She
had
forgotten:
If
she
was
too
busy
to
perform
righteous
labor,
she
was
not
on
the
Path.
She
would
never
forget
again.
And,
in
time,
she
learned
to
love
the
sun
beating
down
on
her
back,
the
water
cool
and
murky
around
her
legs
and
hands,
the
stalks
of
the
rice
plants
like
fingers
reaching
up
from
the
mud
to
intertwine
with
her
fingers.
Covered
with
muck
in
the
rice
paddies,
she
never
felt
unclean,
because
she
knew
that
she
was
filthy
in
the
service
of
the
gods.
Finally,
at
the
age
of
sixteen,
her
schooling
was
finished.
She
had
only
to
prove
herself
in
a
grown
woman's
task--
one
that
was
difficult
and
important
enough
that
it
could
be
entrusted
only
to
one
who
was
godspoken.
She
came
before
the
great
Han
Fei-tzu
in
his
room.
Like
hers,
it
was
a
large
open
space;
like
hers,
the
sleeping
accommodation
was
simple,
a
mat
on
the
floor;
like
hers,
the
room
was
dominated
by
a
table
with
a
computer
terminal
on
it.
She
had
never
entered
her
father's
room
without
seeing
something
floating
in
the
display
above
the
terminal--
diagrams,
threedimensional
models,
realtime
simulations,
words.
Most
commonly
words.
Letters
or
ideographs
floating
in
the
air
on
simulated
pages,
moving
back
and
forward,
side
to
side
as
Father
needed
to
compare
them.
In
Qing-jao's
room,
all
the
rest
of
the
space
was
empty.
Since
Father
did
not
trace
woodgrain
lines,
he
had
no
need
for
that
much
austerity.
Even
so,
his
tastes
were
simple.
One
rug--
only
rarely
one
that
had
much
decoration
to
it.
One
low
table,
with
one
sculpture
standing
on
it.
Walls
bare
except
for
one
painting.
And
because
the
room
was
so
large,
each
one
of
these
things
seemed
almost
lost,
like
the
faint
voice
of
someone
crying
out
from
very
far
away.
The
message
of
this
room
to
visitors
was
clear:
Han
Fei-tzu
chose
simplicity.
One
of
each
thing
was
enough
for
a
pure
soul.
The
message
to
Qing-jao,
however,
was
quite
different.
For
she
knew
what
no
one
outside
the
household
realized:
The
rug,
the
table,
the
sculpture,
and
the
painting
were
changed
every
day.
And
never
in
her
life
had
she
recognized
any
one
of
them.
So
the
lesson
she
learned
was
this:
A
pure
soul
must
never
grow
attached
to
any
one
thing.
A
pure
soul
must
expose
himself
to
new
things
every
day.
Because
this
was
a
formal
occasion,
she
did
not
come
and
stand
behind
him
as
he
worked,
studying
what
appeared
in
his
display,
trying
to
guess
what
he
was
doing.
This
time
she
came
to
the
middle
of
the
room
and
knelt
on
the
plain
rug,
which
was
today
the
color
of
a
robin's
egg,
with
a
small
stain
in
one
corner.
She
kept
her
eyes
down,
not
even
studying
the
stain,
until
Father
got
up
from
his
chair
and
came
to
stand
before
her.
"Han
Qing-jao,"
he
said.
"Let
me
see
the
sunrise
of
my
daughter's
face."
She
lifted
her
head,
looked
at
him,
and
smiled.
He
smiled
back.
"What
I
will
set
before
you
is
not
an
easy
task,
even
for
an
experienced
adult,"
said
Father.
Qing-jao
bowed
her
head.
She
had
expected
that
Father
would
set
a
hard
challenge
for
her,
and
she
was
ready
to
do
his
will.
"Look
at
me,
my
Qing-jao,"
said
Father.
She
lifted
her
head,
looked
into
his
eyes.
"This
is
not
going
to
be
a
school
assignment.
This
is
a
task
from
the
real
world.
A
task
that
Starways
Congress
has
given
me,
on
which
the
fate
of
nations
and
peoples
and
worlds
may
rest."
Qing-jao
had
been
tense
already,
but
now
Father
was
frightening
her.
"Then
you
must
give
this
task
to
someone
who
can
be
trusted
with
it,
not
to
an
untried
child."
"You
haven't
been
a
child
in
years,
Qing-jao.
Are
you
ready
to
hear
your
task?"
"Yes,
Father."
"What
do
you
know
about
the
Lusitania
Fleet?"
"Do
you
want
me
to
tell
you
everything
I
know
about
it?"
"I
want
you
to
tell
me
all
that
you
think
matters."
So--
this
was
a
kind
of
test,
to
see
how
well
she
could
distill
the
important
from
the
unimportant
in
her
knowledge
about
a
particular
subject.
"The
fleet
was
sent
to
subdue
a
rebellious
colony
on
Lusitania,
where
laws
concerning
noninterference
in
the
only
known
alien
species
had
been
defiantly
broken."
Was
that
enough?
No--
Father
was
still
waiting.
"There
was
controversy,
right
from
the
start,"
she
said.
"Essays
attributed
to
a
person
called
Demosthenes
stirred
up
trouble."
"What
trouble,
in
particular?"
"To
colony
worlds,
Demosthenes
gave
warning
that
the
Lusitania
Fleet
was
a
dangerous
precedent--
it
would
be
only
a
matter
of
time
before
Starways
Congress
used
force
to
compel
their
obedience,
too.
To
Catholic
worlds
and
Catholic
minorities
everywhere,
Demosthenes
charged
that
Congress
was
trying
to
punish
the
Bishop
of
Lusitania
for
sending
missionaries
to
the
pequeninos
to
save
their
souls
from
hell.
To
scientists,
Demosthenes
sent
warning
that
the
principle
of
independent
research
was
at
stake--
a
whole
world
was
under
military
attack
because
it
dared
to
prefer
the
judgment
of
the
scientists
on
the
scene
to
the
judgment
of
bureaucrats
many
light-years
away.
And
to
everyone,
Demosthenes
made
claims
that
the
Lusitania
Fleet
carried
the
Molecular
Disruption
Device.
Of
course
that
is
an
obvious
lie,
but
some
believed
it."
"How
effective
were
these
essays?"
asked
Father.
"I
don't
know."
"They
were
very
effective,"
said
Father.
"Fifteen
years
ago,
the
earliest
essays
to
the
colonies
were
so
effective
that
they
almost
caused
revolution."
A
near-rebellion
in
the
colonies?
Fifteen
years
ago?
Qing-jao
knew
of
only
one
such
event,
but
she
had
never
realized
it
had
anything
to
do
with
Demosthenes'
essays.
She
blushed.
"That
was
the
time
of
the
Colony
Charter--
your
first
great
treaty."
"The
treaty
was
not
mine,"
said
Han
Fei-tzu.
"The
treaty
belonged
equally
to
Congress
and
the
colonies.
Because
of
it
a
terrible
conflict
was
avoided.
And
the
Lusitania
Fleet
continues
on
its
great
mission."
"You
wrote
every
word
of
the
treaty,
Father."
"In
doing
so
I
only
found
expression
for
the
wishes
and
desires
already
in
the
hearts
of
the
people
on
both
sides
of
the
issue.
I
was
a
clerk."
Qing-jao
bowed
her
head.
She
knew
the
truth,
and
so
did
everyone
else.
It
had
been
the
beginning
of
Han
Fei-tzu's
greatness,
for
he
not
only
wrote
the
treaty
but
also
persuaded
both
sides
to
accept
it
almost
without
revision.
Ever
after
that,
Han
Fei-tzu
had
been
one
of
the
most
trusted
advisers
to
Congress;
messages
arrived
daily
from
the
greatest
men
and
women
of
every
world.
If
he
chose
to
call
himself
a
clerk
in
that
great
undertaking,
that
was
only
because
he
was
a
man
of
great
modesty.
Qing-jao
also
knew
that
Mother
was
already
dying
as
he
accomplished
all
this
work.
That
was
the
kind
of
man
her
father
was,
for
he
neglected
neither
his
wife
nor
his
duty.
He
could
not
save
Mother's
life,
but
he
could
save
the
lives
that
might
have
been
lost
in
war.
"Qing-jao,
why
do
you
say
that
it
is
an
obvious
lie
that
the
fleet
is
carrying
the
M.D.
Device?"
"Because--
because
that
would
be
monstrous.
It
would
be
like
Ender
the
Xenocide,
destroying
an
entire
world.
So
much
power
has
no
right
or
reason
to
exist
in
the
universe."
"Who
taught
you
this?"
"Decency
taught
me
this,"
said
Qing-jao.
"The
gods
made
the
stars
and
all
the
planets--
who
is
man
to
unmake
them?"
"But
the
gods
also
made
the
laws
of
nature
that
make
it
possible
to
destroy
them--
who
is
man
to
refuse
to
receive
what
the
gods
have
given?"
Qing-jao
was
stunned
to
silence.
She
had
never
heard
Father
speak
in
apparent
defense
of
any
aspect
of
war--
he
loathed
war
in
any
form.
"I
ask
you
again--
who
taught
you
that
so
much
power
has
no
right
or
reason
to
exist
in
the
universe?"
"It's
my
own
idea."
"But
that
sentence
is
an
exact
quotation."
"Yes.
From
Demosthenes.
But
if
I
believe
an
idea,
it
becomes
my
own.
You
taught
me
that."
"You
must
be
careful
that
you
understand
all
the
consequences
of
an
idea
before
you
believe
it."
"The
Little
Doctor
must
never
be
used
on
Lusitania,
and
therefore
it
should
not
have
been
sent."
Han
Fei-tzu
nodded
gravely.
"How
do
you
know
it
must
never
be
used?"
"Because
it
would
destroy
the
pequeninos,
a
young
and
beautiful
people
who
are
eager
to
fulfill
their
potential
as
a
sentient
species."
"Another
quotation."
"Father,
have
you
read
the
Life
of
Human?"
"I
have."
"Then
how
can
you
doubt
that
the
pequeninos
must
be
preserved?"
"I
said
I
had
read
the
Life
of
Human.
I
didn't
say
that
I
believed
it."
"You
don't
believe
it?"
"I
neither
believe
it
nor
disbelieve
it.
The
book
first
appeared
after
the
ansible
on
Lusitania
had
been
destroyed.
Therefore
it
is
probable
that
the
book
did
not
originate
there,
and
if
it
didn't
originate
there
then
it's
fiction.
That
seems
particularly
likely
because
it's
signed
'Speaker
for
the
Dead,'
which
is
the
same
name
signed
to
the
Hive
Queen
and
the
Hegemon,
which
are
thousands
of
years
old.
Someone
was
obviously
trying
to
capitalize
on
the
reverence
people
feel
toward
those
ancient
works."
"I
believe
the
Life
of
Human
is
true."
"That's
your
privilege,
Qing-jao.
But
why
do
you
believe
it?"
Because
it
sounded
true
when
she
read
it.
Could
she
say
that
to
Father?
Yes,
she
could
say
anything.
"Because
when
I
read
it
I
felt
that
it
must
be
true."
"I
see."
"Now
you
know
that
I'm
foolish."
"On
the
contrary.
I
know
that
you
are
wise.
When
you
hear
a
true
story,
there
is
a
part
of
you
that
responds
to
it
regardless
of
art,
regardless
of
evidence.
Let
it
be
clumsily
told
and
you
will
still
love
the
tale,
if
you
love
truth.
Let
it
be
the
most
obvious
fabrication
and
you
will
still
believe
whatever
truth
is
in
it,
because
you
cannot
deny
truth
no
matter
how
shabbily
it
is
dressed."
"Then
how
is
it
that
you
don't
believe
the
Life
of
Human?"
"I
spoke
unclearly.
We
are
using
two
different
meanings
of
the
words
truth
and
belief.
You
believe
that
the
story
is
true,
because
you
responded
to
it
from
that
sense
of
truth
deep
within
you.
But
that
sense
of
truth
does
not
respond
to
a
story's
factuality--
to
whether
it
literally
depicts
a
real
event
in
the
real
world.
Your
inner
sense
of
truth
responds
to
a
story's
causality--
to
whether
it
faithfully
shows
the
way
the
universe
functions,
the
way
the
gods
work
their
will
among
human
beings."
Qing-jao
thought
for
only
a
moment,
then
nodded
her
understanding.
"So
the
Life
of
Human
may
be
universally
true,
but
specifically
false."
"Yes,"
said
Han
Fei-tzu.
"You
can
read
the
book
and
gain
great
wisdom
from
it,
because
it
is
true.
But
is
that
book
an
accurate
representation
of
the
pequeninos
themselves?
One
can
hardly
believe
that--
a
mammaloid
species
that
turns
into
a
tree
when
it
dies?
Beautiful
as
poetry.
Ludicrous
as
science."
"But
can
you
know
that,
either,
Father?"
"I
can't
be
sure,
no.
Nature
has
done
many
strange
things,
and
there
is
a
chance
that
the
Life
of
Human
is
genuine
and
true.
Thus
I
neither
believe
it
nor
disbelieve
it.
I
hold
it
in
abeyance.
I
wait.
Yet
while
I'm
waiting,
I
don't
expect
Congress
to
treat
Lusitania
as
if
it
were
populated
by
the
fanciful
creatures
from
the
Life
of
Human.
For
all
we
know,
the
pequeninos
may
be
deadly
dangerous
to
us.
They
are
aliens."
"Ramen."
"In
the
story.
But
raman
or
varelse,
we
do
not
know
what
they
are.
The
fleet
carries
the
Little
Doctor
because
it
might
be
necessary
to
save
mankind
from
unspeakable
peril.
It
is
not
up
to
us
to
decide
whether
or
not
it
should
be
used--
Congress
will
decide.
It
is
not
up
to
us
to
decide
whether
it
should
have
been
sent-
-
Congress
has
sent
it.
And
it
is
certainly
not
up
to
us
to
decide
whether
it
should
exist--
the
gods
have
decreed
that
such
a
thing
is
possible
and
can
exist."
"So
Demosthenes
was
right.
The
M.D.
Device
is
with
the
fleet."
"Yes."
"And
the
government
files
that
Demosthenes
published--
they
were
genuine."
"Yes.:
"But
Father--
you
joined
many
others
in
claiming
that
they
were
forgeries."
"Just
as
the
gods
speak
only
to
a
chosen
few,
so
the
secrets
of
the
rulers
must
be
known
only
to
those
who
will
use
the
knowledge
properly.
Demosthenes
was
giving
powerful
secrets
to
people
who
were
not
fit
to
use
them
wisely,
and
so
for
the
good
of
the
people
those
secrets
had
to
be
withdrawn.
The
only
way
to
retrieve
a
secret,
once
it
is
known,
is
to
replace
it
with
a
lie;
then
the
knowledge
of
the
truth
is
once
again
your
secret."
"You're
telling
me
that
Demosthenes
is
not
a
liar,
and
Congress
is."
"I'm
telling
you
that
Demosthenes
is
the
enemy
of
the
gods.
A
wise
ruler
would
never
have
sent
the
Lusitania
Fleet
without
giving
it
the
possibility
of
responding
to
any
circumstance.
But
Demosthenes
has
used
his
knowledge
that
the
Little
Doctor
is
with
the
fleet
in
order
to
try
to
force
Congress
to
withdraw
the
fleet.
Thus
he
wishes
to
take
power
out
of
the
hands
of
those
whom
the
gods
have
ordained
to
rule
humankind.
What
would
happen
to
the
people
if
they
rejected
the
rulers
given
them
by
the
gods?"
"Chaos
and
suffering,"
said
Qing-jao.
History
was
full
of
times
of
chaos
and
suffering,
until
the
gods
sent
strong
rulers
and
institutions
to
keep
order.
"So
Demosthenes
told
the
truth
about
the
Little
Doctor.
Did
you
think
the
enemies
of
the
gods
could
never
speak
the
truth?
I
wish
it
were
so.
It
would
make
them
much
easier
to
identify."
"If
we
can
lie
in
the
service
of
the
gods,
what
other
crimes
can
we
commit?"
"What
is
a
crime?"
"An
act
that's
against
the
law."
"What
law?"
"I
see--
Congress
makes
the
law,
so
the
law
is
whatever
Congress
says.
But
Congress
is
composed
of
men
and
women,
who
may
do
good
and
evil."
"Now
you're
nearer
the
truth.
We
can't
do
crimes
in
the
service
of
Congress,
because
Congress
makes
the
laws.
But
if
Congress
ever
became
evil,
then
in
obeying
them
we
might
also
be
doing
evil.
That
is
a
matter
of
conscience.
However,
if
that
happened,
Congress
would
surely
lose
the
mandate
of
heaven.
And
we,
the
godspoken,
don't
have
to
wait
and
wonder
about
the
mandate
of
heaven,
as
others
do.
If
Congress
ever
loses
the
mandate
of
the
gods,
we
will
know
at
once."
"So
you
lied
for
Congress
because
Congress
had
the
mandate
of
heaven."
"And
therefore
I
knew
that
to
help
them
keep
their
secret
was
the
will
of
the
gods
for
the
good
of
the
people."
Qing-jao
had
never
thought
of
Congress
in
quite
this
way
before.
All
the
history
books
she
had
studied
showed
Congress
as
the
great
unifier
of
humanity,
and
according
to
the
schoolbooks,
all
its
acts
were
noble.
Now,
though,
she
understood
that
some
of
its
actions
might
not
seem
good.
Yet
that
didn't
necessarily
mean
that
they
were
not
good.
"I
must
learn
from
the
gods,
then,
whether
the
will
of
Congress
is
also
their
will,"
she
said.
"Will
you
do
that?"
asked
Han
Fei-tzu.
"Will
you
obey
the
will
of
Congress,
even
when
it
might
seem
wrong,
as
long
as
Congress
has
the
mandate
of
heaven?"
"Are
you
asking
for
my
oath?"
"I
am."
"Then
yes,
I
will
obey,
as
long
as
they
have
the
mandate
of
heaven."
"I
had
to
have
that
oath
from
you
to
satisfy
the
security
requirements
of
Congress,"
he
said.
"I
couldn't
have
given
you
your
task
without
it."
He
cleared
his
throat.
"But
now
I
ask
you
for
another
oath."
"I'll
give
it
if
I
can."
"This
oath
is
from--
it
arises
from
great
love.
Han
Qing-jao,
will
you
serve
the
gods
in
all
things,
in
all
ways,
throughout
your
life?"
"Oh,
Father,
we
need
no
oath
for
this.
Haven't
the
gods
chosen
me
already,
and
led
me
with
their
voice?"
"Nevertheless
I
ask
you
for
this
oath."
"Always,
in
all
things,
in
all
ways,
I
will
serve
the
gods."
To
her
surprise,
Father
knelt
before
her
and
took
her
hands
in
his.
Tears
streamed
down
his
cheeks.
"You
have
lifted
from
my
heart
the
heaviest
burden
that
was
ever
laid
there."
"How
did
I
do
this,
Father?"
"Before
your
mother
died,
she
asked
me
for
my
promise.
She
said
that
since
her
entire
character
was
expressed
by
her
devotion
to
the
gods,
the
only
way
I
could
help
you
to
know
her
was
to
teach
you
also
to
serve
the
gods.
All
my
life
I
have
still
been
afraid
that
I
might
fail,
that
you
might
turn
away
from
the
gods.
That
you
might
come
to
hate
them.
Or
that
you
might
not
be
worthy
of
their
voice."
This
struck
Qing-jao
to
the
heart.
She
was
always
conscious
of
her
deep
unworthiness
before
the
gods,
of
her
filthiness
in
their
sight--
even
when
they
weren't
requiring
her
to
watch
or
trace
woodgrain
lines.
Only
now
did
she
learn
what
was
at
stake:
her
mother's
love
for
her.
"All
my
fears
are
gone
now.
You
are
a
perfect
daughter,
my
Qing-jao.
You
already
serve
the
gods
well.
And
now,
with
your
oath,
I
can
be
sure
you'll
continue
forever.
This
will
cause
great
rejoicing
in
the
house
in
heaven
where
your
mother
dwells."
Will
it?
In
heaven
they
know
my
weakness.
You,
Father,
you
only
see
that
I
have
not
yet
failed
the
gods;
Mother
must
know
how
close
I've
come
so
many
times,
how
filthy
I
am
whenever
the
gods
look
upon
me.
But
he
seemed
so
full
of
joy
that
she
dared
not
show
him
how
much
she
dreaded
the
day
when
she
would
prove
her
unworthiness
for
all
to
see.
So
she
embraced
him.
Still,
she
couldn't
help
asking
him,
"Father,
do
you
really
think
Mother
heard
me
make
that
oath?"
"I
hope
so,"
said
Han
Fei-tzu.
"If
she
didn't,
the
gods
will
surely
save
the
echo
of
it
and
put
it
in
a
seashell
and
let
her
listen
to
it
whenever
she
puts
it
to
her
ear."
This
sort
of
fanciful
storytelling
was
a
game
they
had
played
together
as
children.
Qing-jao
set
aside
her
dread
and
quickly
came
up
with
an
answer.
"No,
the
gods
will
save
the
touch
of
our
embrace
and
weave
it
into
a
shawl,
which
she
can
wear
around
her
shoulders
when
winter
comes
to
heaven."
She
was
relieved,
anyway,
that
Father
had
not
said
yes.
He
only
hoped
that
Mother
had
heard
the
oath
she
made.
Perhaps
she
hadn't--
band
so
she
wouldn't
be
so
disappointed
when
her
daughter
failed.
Father
kissed
her,
then
stood
up.
"Now
you
are
ready
to
hear
your
task,"
he
said.
He
took
her
by
the
hand
and
led
her
to
his
table.
She
stood
beside
him
when
he
sat
on
his
chair;
she
was
not
much
taller,
standing,
than
he
was
sitting
down.
Probably
she
had
not
yet
reached
her
adult
height,
but
she
hoped
she
wouldn't
grow
much
more.
She
didn't
want
to
become
one
of
those
large,
hulking
women
who
carried
heavy
burdens
in
the
fields.
Better
to
be
a
mouse
than
a
hog,
that's
what
Mu-pao
had
told
her
years
ago.
Father
brought
a
starmap
up
into
the
display.
She
recognized
the
area
immediately.
It
centered
on
the
Lusitania
star
system,
though
the
scale
was
too
small
for
individual
planets
to
be
visible.
"Lusitania
is
in
the
center,"
she
said.
Father
nodded.
He
typed
a
few
more
commands.
"Now
watch
this,"
he
said.
"Not
the
display,
my
fingers.
This,
plus
your
voice
identification,
is
the
password
that
will
allow
you
to
access
the
information
you'll
need."
She
watched
him
type:
4Gang.
She
recognized
the
reference
at
once.
Her
mother's
ancestor-of-the-heart
had
been
Jiang-qing,
the
widow
of
the
first
Communist
Emperor,
Mao
Ze-dong.
When
Jiang-qing
and
her
allies
were
driven
from
power,
the
Conspiracy
of
Cowards
vilified
them
under
the
name
"Gang
of
Four."
Qing-jao's
mother
had
been
a
true
daughter-of-the-heart
to
that
great
martyred
woman
of
the
past.
And
now
Qing-jao
would
be
able
to
do
further
honor
to
her
mother's
ancestor-of-the-heart
every
time
she
typed
the
access
code.
It
was
a
gracious
thing
for
her
father
to
arrange.
In
the
display
there
appeared
many
green
dots.
She
quickly
counted,
almost
without
thinking:
there
were
nineteen
of
them,
clustered
at
some
distance
from
Lusitania,
but
surrounding
it
in
most
directions.
"Is
that
the
Lusitania
Fleet?"
"Those
were
their
positions
five
months
ago."
He
typed
again.
The
green
dots
all
disappeared.
"And
those
are
their
positions
today."
She
looked
for
them.
She
couldn't
find
a
green
dot
anywhere.
Yet
Father
clearly
expected
her
to
see
something.
"Are
they
already
at
Lusitania?"
"The
ships
are
where
you
see
them,"
said
Father.
"Five
months
ago
the
fleet
disappeared."
"Where
did
it
go?"
"No
one
knows."
"Was
it
a
mutiny?"
"No
one
knows."
"The
whole
fleet?"
"Every
ship."
"When
you
say
they
disappeared,
what
do
you
mean?"
Father
glanced
at
her
with
a
smile.
"Well
done,
Qing-jao.
You've
asked
the
right
question.
No
one
saw
them--
they
were
all
in
deep
space.
So
they
didn't
physically
disappear.
As
far
as
we
know,
they
may
be
moving
along,
still
on
course.
They
only
disappeared
in
the
sense
that
we
lost
all
contact
with
them.
"
"The
ansibles?"
"Silent.
All
within
the
same
three-minute
period.
No
transmissions
were
interrupted.
One
would
end,
and
then
the
next
one--
never
came."
"Every
ship's
connection
with
every
planetside
ansible
everywhere?
That's
impossible.
Even
an
explosion--
if
there
could
be
one
so
large--
but
it
couldn't
be
a
single
event,
anyway,
because
they
were
so
widely
distributed
around
Lusitania.
"
"Well,
it
could
be,
Qing-jao.
If
you
can
imagine
an
event
so
cataclysmic--
it
could
be
that
Lusitania's
star
became
a
supernova.
It
would
be
decades
before
we
saw
the
flash
even
on
the
closest
worlds.
The
trouble
is
that
it
would
be
the
most
unlikely
supernova
in
history.
Not
impossible,
but
unlikely."
"And
there
would
have
been
some
advance
indications.
Some
changes
in
the
star's
condition.
Didn't
the
ships'
instruments
detect
something?"
"No.
That's
why
we
don't
think
it
was
any
known
astronomical
phenomenon.
Scientists
can't
think
of
anything
to
explain
it.
So
we've
tried
investigating
it
as
sabotage.
We've
searched
for
penetrations
of
the
ansible
computers.
We've
raked
over
all
the
personnel
files
from
every
ship,
searching
for
some
possible
conspiracy
among
the
shipboard
crews.
There's
been
cryptoanalysis
of
every
communication
by
every
ship,
searching
for
some
kind
of
messages
among
conspirators.
The
military
and
the
government
have
analyzed
everything
they
can
think
of
to
analyze.
The
police
on
every
planet
have
conducted
inquiries--
we've
checked
the
background
on
every
ansible
operator."
"Even
though
no
messages
are
being
sent,
are
the
ansibles
still
connected?"
"What
do
you
think?"
Qing-jao
blushed.
"Of
course
they
would
be,
even
if
an
M.D.
Device
had
been
used
against
the
fleet,
because
the
ansibles
are
linked
by
fragments
of
subatomic
particles.
They'd
still
be
there
even
if
the
whole
starship
were
blown
to
dust."
"Don't
be
embarrassed,
Qing-jao.
The
wise
are
not
wise
because
they
make
no
mistakes.
They
are
wise
because
they
correct
their
mistakes
as
soon
as
they
recognize
them."
However,
Qing-jao
was
blushing
now
for
another
reason.
The
hot
blood
was
pounding
in
her
head
because
it
had
only
now
dawned
on
her
what
Father's
assignment
for
her
was
going
to
be.
But
that
was
impossible.
He
couldn't
give
to
her
a
task
that
thousands
of
wiser,
older
people
had
already
failed
at.
"Father,"
she
whispered.
"What
is
my
task?"
She
still
hoped
that
it
was
some
minor
problem
involved
with
the
disappearance
of
the
fleet.
But
she
knew
that
her
hope
was
in
vain
even
before
he
spoke.
"You
must
discover
every
possible
explanation
for
the
disappearance
of
the
fleet,"
he
said,
"and
calculate
the
likelihood
of
each
one.
Starways
Congress
must
be
able
to
tell
how
this
happened
and
how
to
make
sure
it
will
never
happen
again."
"But
Father,"
said
Qing-jao,
"I'm
only
sixteen.
Aren't
there
many
others
who
are
wiser
than
I
am?"
"Perhaps
they're
all
too
wise
to
attept
the
task,"
he
said.
"But
you
are
young
enough
not
to
fancy
yourself
wise.
You're
young
enough
to
think
of
impossible
things
and
discover
why
they
might
be
possible.
Above
all,
gods
speak
to
you
with
extraordinary
clarity,
my
brilliant
child,
my
Gloriously
Bright."
That
was
what
she
was
afraid
of--
that
Father
expected
her
to
succeed
because
of
the
favor
of
the
gods.
He
didn't
understand
how
unworthy
the
gods
found
her,
how
little
they
liked
her.
And
there
was
another
problem.
"What
if
I
succeed?
What
if
I
find
out
where
the
Lusitania
Fleet
is,
and
restore
communications?
Wouldn't
it
then
be
my
fault
if
the
fleet
destroyed
Lusitania?"
"It's
good
that
your
first
thought
is
compassion
for
the
people
of
Lusitania.
I
assure
you
that
Starways
Congress
has
promised
not
to
use
the
M.D.
Device
unless
it
proves
absolutely
unavoidable,
and
that
is
so
unlikely
that
I
can't
believe
it
would
happen.
Even
if
it
did,
though,
it's
Congress
that
must
decide.
As
my
ancestor-of-the-heart
said,
'Though
the
wise
man's
punishments
may
be
light,
this
is
not
due
to
his
compassion;
though
his
penalties
may
be
severe,
this
is
not
because
he
is
cruel;
he
simply
follows
the
custom
appropriate
to
the
time.
Circumstances
change
according
to
the
age,
and
ways
of
dealing
with
them
change
with
the
circumstances.'
You
may
be
sure
that
Starways
Congress
will
deal
with
Lusitania,
not
according
to
kindness
or
cruelty,
but
according
to
what
is
necessary
for
the
good
of
all
humanity.
That
is
why
we
serve
the
rulers:
because
they
serve
the
people,
who
serve
the
ancestors,
who
serve
the
gods."
"Father,
I
was
unworthy
even
to
think
otherwise,"
said
Qing-jao.
She
felt
her
filthiness
now,
instead
of
just
knowing
it
in
her
mind.
She
needed
to
wash
her
hands.
She
needed
to
trace
a
line.
But
she
contained
it.
She
would
wait.
Whatever
I
do,
she
thought,
there
will
be
a
terrible
consequence.
If
I
fail,
then
Father
will
lose
honor
before
Congress
and
therefore
before
all
the
world
of
Path.
That
would
prove
to
many
that
Father
isn't
worthy
to
be
chosen
god
of
Path
when
he
dies.
Yet
if
I
succeed,
the
result
might
be
xenocide.
Even
though
the
choice
belongs
to
Congress,
I
would
still
know
that
I
made
such
a
thing
possible.
The
responsibility
would
be
partly
mine.
No
matter
what
I
do,
I
will
be
covered
with
failure
and
smeared
with
unworthiness.
Then
Father
spoke
to
her
as
if
the
gods
had
shown
him
her
heart.
"Yes,
you
were
unworthy,"
he
said,
"and
you
continue
to
be
unworthy
in
your
thoughts
even
now."
Qing-jao
blushed
and
bowed
her
head,
ashamed,
not
that
her
thoughts
had
been
so
plainly
visible
to
her
father,
but
that
she
had
had
such
disobedient
thoughts
at
all.
Father
touched
her
shoulder
gently
with
his
hand.
"But
I
believe
the
gods
will
make
you
worthy,"
said
Father.
"Starways
Congress
has
the
mandate
of
heaven,
but
you
are
also
chosen
to
walk
your
own
path.
You
can
succeed
in
this
great
work.
Will
you
try?"
"I
will
try."
I
will
also
fail,
but
that
will
surprise
no
one,
least
of
all
the
gods,
who
know
my
unworthiness.
"All
the
pertinent
archives
have
been
opened
up
to
your
searching,
when
you
speak
your
name
and
type
the
password.
If
you
need
help,
let
me
know."
She
left
Father's
room
with
dignity,
and
forced
herself
to
walk
slowly
up
the
stairs
to
her
room.
Only
when
she
was
inside
with
the
door
closed
did
she
throw
herself
to
her
knees
and
creep
along
the
floor.
She
traced
woodgrain
lines
until
she
could
hardly
see.
Her
unworthiness
was
so
great
that
even
then
she
didn't
quite
feel
clean;
she
went
to
the
lavatory
and
scrubbed
her
hands
until
she
knew
the
gods
were
satisfied.
Twice
the
servants
tried
to
interrupt
her
with
meals
or
messages--
she
cared
little
which--
but
when
they
saw
that
she
was
communing
with
the
gods
they
bowed
and
quietly
slipped
away.
It
was
not
the
washing
of
her
hands,
though,
that
finally
made
her
clean.
It
was
the
moment
when
she
drove
the
last
vestige
of
uncertainty
from
her
heart.
Starways
Congress
had
the
mandate
of
heaven.
She
must
purge
herself
of
all
doubt.
Whatever
they
meant
to
do
with
the
Lusitania
Fleet,
it
was
surely
the
will
of
the
gods
that
it
be
accomplished.
Therefore
it
was
her
duty
to
help
them
accomplish
it.
And
if
she
was
in
fact
doing
the
will
of
the
gods,
then
they
would
open
a
way
for
her
to
solve
the
problem
that
had
been
set
before
her.
Anytime
she
thought
otherwise,
anytime
the
words
of
Demosthenes
returned
to
her
mind,
she
would
have
to
blot
them
out
by
remembering
that
she
would
obey
the
rulers
who
have
the
mandate
of
heaven.
By
the
time
her
mind
was
calm,
her
palms
were
raw
and
dotted
with
blood
seeping
up
from
the
layers
of
living
skin
that
were
now
so
close
to
the
surface.
This
is
how
my
understanding
of
the
truth
arises,
she
told
herself.
If
I
wash
away
enough
of
my
mortality,
then
the
truth
of
the
gods
will
seep
upward
into
the
light.
She
was
clean
at
last.
The
hour
was
late
and
her
eyes
were
tired.
Nevertheless,
she
sat
down
before
her
terminal
and
began
the
work.
"Show
me
summaries
of
all
the
research
that
has
been
conducted
so
far
on
the
disappearance
of
the
Lusitania
Fleet,"
she
said,
"starting
with
the
most
recent."
Almost
at
once
words
started
appearing
in
the
air
above
her
terminal,
page
upon
page
lined
up
like
soldiers
marching
to
the
front.
She
would
read
one,
then
scroll
it
out
of
the
way,
only
to
have
the
page
behind
it
move
to
the
front
for
her
to
read
it.
Seven
hours
she
read
until
she
could
read
no
more;
then
she
fell
asleep
before
the
terminal.
***
Jane
watches
everything.
She
can
do
a
million
jobs
and
pay
attention
to
a
thousand
things
at
once.
Neither
of
these
capacities
is
infinite,
but
they're
so
much
greater
than
our
pathetic
ability
to
think
about
one
thing
while
doing
another
that
they
might
as
well
be.
She
does
have
a
sensory
limitation
that
we
don't
have,
however;
or,
rather,
we
are
her
greatest
limitation.
She
can't
see
or
know
anything
that
hasn't
been
entered
as
data
in
a
computer
that
is
tied
to
the
great
interworld
network.
That's
less
of
a
limitation
than
you
might
think.
She
has
almost
immediate
access
to
the
raw
inputs
of
every
starship,
every
satellite,
every
traffic
control
system,
and
almost
every
electronically-monitored
spy
device
in
the
human
universe.
But
it
does
mean
that
she
almost
never
witnesses
lovers'
quarrels,
bedtime
stories,
classroom
arguments,
supper-table
gossip,
or
bitter
tears
privately
shed.
She
only
knows
that
aspect
of
our
lives
that
we
represent
as
digital
information.
If
you
asked
her
the
exact
number
of
human
beings
in
the
settled
worlds,
she
would
quickly
give
you
a
number
based
on
census
figures
combined
with
birth-and-death
probabilities
in
all
our
population
groups.
In
most
cases,
she
could
match
numbers
with
names,
though
no
human
could
live
long
enough
to
read
the
list.
And
if
you
took
a
name
you
just
happened
to
think
of--
Han
Qing-jao,
for
instance--
and
you
asked
Jane,
"Who
is
this
person?"
she'd
almost
immediately
give
you
the
vital
statistics--
birth
date,
citizenship,
parentage,
height
and
weight
at
last
medical
checkup,
grades
in
school.
But
that
is
all
gratuitous
information,
background
noise
to
her;
she
knows
it's
there,
but
it
means
nothing.
To
ask
her
about
Han
Qing-jao
would
be
something
like
asking
her
a
question
about
a
certain
molecule
of
water
vapor
in
a
distant
cloud.
The
molecule
is
certainly
there,
but
there's
nothing
special
to
differentiate
it
from
the
million
others
in
its
immediate
vicinity.
That
was
true
until
the
moment
that
Han
Qing-jao
began
to
use
her
computer
to
access
all
the
reports
dealing
with
the
disappearance
of
the
Lusitania
Fleet.
Then
Qing-jao's
name
moved
many
levels
upward
in
Jane's
attention.
Jane
began
to
keep
a
log
of
everything
that
Qing-jao
did
with
her
computer.
And
it
quickly
became
clear
to
her
that
Han
Qing-jao,
though
she
was
only
sixteen,
meant
to
make
serious
trouble
for
Jane.
Because
Han
Qing-jao,
unconnected
as
she
was
to
any
particular
bureaucracy,
having
no
ideological
axe
to
grind
or
vested
interest
to
protect,
was
taking
a
broader
and
therefore
more
dangerous
look
at
all
the
information
that
had
been
collected
by
every
human
agency.
Why
was
it
dangerous?
Had
Jane
left
clues
behind
that
Qing-jao
would
find?
No,
of
course
not.
Jane
left
no
clues.
She
had
thought
of
leaving
some,
of
trying
to
make
the
disappearance
of
the
Lusitania
Fleet
look
like
sabotage
or
mechanical
failure
or
some
natural
disaster.
She
had
to
give
up
on
that
idea,
because
she
couldn't
work
up
any
physical
clues.
All
she
could
do
was
leave
misleading
data
in
computer
memories.
None
of
it
would
ever
have
any
physical
analogue
in
the
real
world,
and
therefore
any
halfway-intelligent
researcher
would
quickly
realize
that
the
clues
were
all
faked-up
data.
Then
he
would
conclude
that
the
disappearance
of
the
Lusitania
Fleet
had
to
have
been
caused
by
some
agency
that
had
unimaginably
detailed
access
to
the
computer
systems
that
had
the
false
data.
Surely
that
would
lead
people
to
discover
her
far
more
quickly
than
if
she
left
no
evidence
at
all.
Leaving
no
evidence
was
the
best
course,
definitely;
and
until
Han
Qing-jao
began
her
investigation,
it
had
worked
very
well.
Each
investigating
agency
looked
only
in
the
places
they
usually
looked.
The
police
on
many
planets
checked
out
all
the
known
dissident
groups
(and,
in
some
places,
tortured
various
dissidents
until
they
made
useless
confessions,
at
which
point
the
interrogators
filed
final
reports
and
pronounced
the
issue
closed).
The
military
looked
for
evidence
of
military
opposition--
especially
alien
starships,
since
the
military
had
keen
memories
of
the
invasion
of
the
buggers
three
thousand
years
before.
Scientists
looked
for
evidence
of
some
unexpected
invisible
astronomical
phenomenon
that
could
account
for
either
the
destruction
of
the
fleet
or
the
selective
breakdown
of
ansible
communication.
The
politicians
looked
for
somebody
else
to
blame.
Nobody
imagined
Jane,
and
therefore
nobody
found
her.
But
Han
Qing-jao
was
putting
everything
together,
carefully,
systematically,
running
precise
searches
on
the
data.
She
would
inevitably
turn
up
the
evidence
that
could
eventually
prove--
and
end--
Jane's
existence.
That
evidence
was,
simply
put,
the
lack
of
evidence.
Nobody
else
could
see
it,
because
nobody
had
ever
brought
an
unbiased
methodical
mind
to
the
investigation.
What
Jane
couldn't
know
was
that
Qing-jao's
seemingly
inhuman
patience,
her
meticulous
attention
to
detail,
her
constant
rephrasing
and
reprogramming
of
computer
searches,
that
all
of
these
were
the
result
of
endless
hours
kneeling
hunched
over
on
a
wooden
floor,
carefully
following
a
grain
in
the
wood
from
one
end
of
a
board
to
the
other,
from
one
side
of
a
room
to
the
other.
Jane
couldn't
begin
to
guess
that
it
was
the
great
lesson
taught
her
by
the
gods
that
made
Qing-jao
her
most
formidable
opponent.
All
Jane
knew
was
that
at
some
point,
this
searcher
named
Qing-jao
would
probably
realize
what
no
one
else
really
understood:
that
every
conceivable
explanation
for
the
disappearance
of
the
Lusitania
Fleet
had
already
been
completely
eliminated.
At
that
point
only
one
conclusion
would
remain:
that
some
force
not
yet
encountered
anywhere
in
the
history
of
humankind
had
the
power
either
to
make
a
widely
scattered
fleet
of
starships
disappear
simultaneously,
or--
just
as
unlikely--
to
make
that
fleet's
ansibles
all
stop
functioning
at
once.
And
if
that
same
methodical
mind
then
started
listing
possible
forces
that
might
have
such
power,
eventually
it
was
bound
to
name
the
one
that
was
true:
an
independent
entity
that
dwelt
among--
no,
that
was
composed
of--
the
philotic
rays
connecting
all
ansibles
together.
Because
this
idea
was
true,
no
amount
of
logical
scrutiny
or
research
would
eliminate
it.
Eventually
this
idea
would
be
left
standing
alone.
And
at
that
point,
somebody
would
surely
act
on
Qing-jao's
discovery
and
set
out
to
destroy
Jane.
So
Jane
watched
Qing-jao's
research
with
more
and
more
fascination.
This
sixteen-year-old
daughter
of
Han
Fei-tzu,
who
weighed
39
kilograms
and
stood
160
centimeters
tall
and
was
in
the
uppermost
social
and
intellectual
class
on
the
Taoist
Chinese
world
of
Path,
was
the
first
human
being
Jane
had
ever
found
who
approached
the
thoroughness
and
precision
of
a
computer
and,
therefore,
of
Jane
herself.
And
though
Jane
could
conduct
in
an
hour
the
search
that
was
taking
Qing-jao
weeks
and
months
to
complete,
the
dangerous
truth
was
that
Qing-jao
was
performing
almost
exactly
the
search
Jane
herself
would
have
conducted;
and
therefore
there
was
no
reason
for
Jane
to
suppose
that
Qing-jao
would
not
reach
the
conclusion
that
Jane
herself
would
reach.
Qing-jao
was
therefore
Jane's
most
dangerous
enemy,
and
Jane
was
helpless
to
stop
her--
at
least
physically.
Trying
to
block
Qing-jao's
access
to
information
would
only
mean
leading
her
more
quickly
to
the
knowledge
of
Jane's
existence.
So
instead
of
open
opposition,
Jane
searched
for
another
way
to
stop
her
eney.
She
did
not
understand
all
of
human
nature,
but
Ender
had
taught
her
this:
to
stop
a
human
being
from
doing
something,
you
must
find
a
way
to
make
the
person
stop
wanting
to
do
it.
Chapter
6
--
VARELSE
<How
are
you
able
to
speak
directly
into
Ender's
mind?>
<Now
that
we
know
where
he
is,
it's
as
natural
as
eating.>
<How
did
you
find
him?
I've
never
been
able
to
speak
into
the
mind
of
anyone
who
hasn't
passed
into
the
third
life.>
<We
found
him
through
the
ansibles,
and
the
electronics
connected
to
them--
found
where
his
body
was
in
space.
To
reach
his
mind,
we
had
to
reach
into
chaos
and
form
a
bridge.>
<Bridge?>
<A
transitional
entity,
which
partly
resembled
his
mind
and
partly
ours.>
<If
you
could
reach
his
mind,
why
didn't
you
stop
him
from
destroying
you?>
<The
human
brain
is
very
strange.
Before
we
could
make
sense
of
what
we
found
there,
before
we
could
learn
how
to
speak
into
that
twisted
space,
all
my
sisters
and
mothers
were
gone.
We
continued
to
study
his
mind
during
all
the
years
we
waited,
cocooned,
until
he
found
us;
when
he
come,
then
we
could
speak
directly
to
him.>
<What
happened
to
the
bridge
you
made?>
<We
never
thought
about
it.
It's
probably
still
out
there
somewhere.>
The
new
strain
of
potatoes
was
dying.
Ender
saw
the
telltale
brown
circles
in
the
leaves,
the
plants
broken
off
where
the
stems
had
turned
so
brittle
that
the
slightest
breeze
bent
them
till
they
snapped.
This
morning
they
had
all
been
healthy.
The
onset
of
this
disease
was
so
sudden,
its
effect
so
devastating,
that
it
could
only
be
the
descolada
virus.
Ela
and
Novinha
would
be
disappointed--
they
had
had
such
hopes
for
this
strain
of
potato.
Ela,
Ender's
stepdaughter,
had
been
working
on
a
gene
that
would
cause
every
cell
in
an
organism
to
produce
three
different
chemicals
that
were
known
to
inhibit
or
kill
the
descolada
virus.
Novinha,
Ender's
wife,
had
been
working
on
a
gene
that
would
cause
cell
nuclei
to
be
impermeable
to
any
molecule
larger
than
one-tenth
the
size
of
the
descolada.
With
this
strain
of
potato,
they
had
spliced
in
both
genes
and,
when
early
tests
showed
that
both
traits
had
taken
hold,
Ender
had
brought
the
seedlings
to
the
experimental
farm
and
planted
them.
He
and
his
assistants
had
nurtured
them
for
the
past
six
weeks.
All
had
seemed
to
be
going
well.
If
the
technique
had
worked,
it
could
have
been
adapted
to
all
the
plants
and
animals
that
the
humans
of
Lusitania
depended
on
for
food.
But
the
descolada
virus
was
too
clever
by
half--
it
saw
through
all
their
stratagems,
eventually.
Still,
six
weeks
was
better
than
the
normal
two
or
three
days.
Maybe
they
were
on
the
right
track.
Or
maybe
things
had
already
gone
too
far.
Back
when
Ender
first
arrived
on
Lusitania,
new
strains
of
Earthborn
plants
and
animals
could
last
as
long
as
twenty
years
in
the
field
before
the
descolada
decoded
their
genetic
molecules
and
tore
them
apart.
But
in
recent
years
the
descolada
virus
had
apparently
made
a
breakthrough
that
allowed
it
to
decode
any
genetic
molecule
from
Earth
in
days
or
even
hours.
These
days
the
only
thing
that
allowed
the
human
colonists
to
grow
their
plants
and
raise
their
animals
was
a
spray
that
was
immediately
fatal
to
the
descolada
virus.
There
were
human
colonists
who
wanted
to
spray
the
whole
planet
and
wipe
out
the
descolada
virus
once
and
for
all.
Spraying
a
whole
planet
was
impractical,
but
not
impossible;
there
were
other
reasons
for
rejecting
that
option.
Every
form
of
native
life
absolutely
depended
on
the
descolada
in
order
to
reproduce.
That
included
the
piggies--
the
pequeninos,
the
intelligent
natives
of
this
world--
whose
reproductive
cycle
was
inextricably
bound
up
with
the
only
native
species
of
tree.
If
the
descolada
virus
were
ever
destroyed,
this
generation
of
pequeninos
would
be
the
last.
It
would
be
xenocide.
So
far,
the
idea
of
doing
anything
that
would
wipe
out
the
piggies
would
be
immediately
rejected
by
most
of
the
people
of
Milagre,
the
village
of
humans.
So
far.
But
Ender
knew
that
many
minds
would
change
if
a
few
more
facts
were
widely
known.
For
instance,
only
a
handful
of
people
knew
that
twice
already
the
descolada
had
adapted
itself
to
the
chemical
they
were
using
to
kill
it.
Ela
and
Novinha
had
already
developed
several
new
versions
of
the
chemical,
so
that
the
next
time
the
descolada
adapted
to
one
viricide
they
could
switch
immediately
to
another.
Likewise,
they
had
once
had
to
change
the
descolada
inhibitor
that
kept
human
beings
from
dying
of
the
descolada
viruses
that
dwelt
in
every
human
in
the
colony.
The
inhibitor
was
added
to
all
the
colony's
food,
so
that
every
human
being
ingested
it
with
every
meal.
However,
all
the
inhibitors
and
viricides
worked
on
the
same
basic
principles.
Someday,
just
as
the
descolada
virus
had
learned
how
to
adapt
to
Earthborn
genes
in
general,
it
would
also
learn
how
to
handle
each
class
of
chemicals,
and
then
it
wouldn't
matter
how
many
new
versions
they
had--
the
descolada
would
exhaust
their
resources
in
days.
Only
a
few
people
knew
how
precarious
Milagre's
survival
really
was.
Only
a
few
people
understood
how
much
was
riding
on
the
work
that
Ela
and
Novinha,
as
Lusitania's
xenobiologists,
were
doing;
how
close
their
contest
was
with
the
descolada;
how
devastating
the
consequences
would
be
if
they
ever
fell
behind.
Just
as
well.
If
the
colonists
did
understand,
there
would
be
many
who
would
say,
If
it's
inevitable
that
someday
the
descolada
will
overwhelm
us,
then
let's
wipe
it
out
now.
If
that
kills
all
the
piggies
then
we're
sorry,
but
if
it's
us
or
them,
we
choose
us.
It
was
fine
for
Ender
to
take
the
long
view,
the
philosophical
perspective,
and
say,
Better
for
one
small
human
colony
to
perish
than
to
wipe
out
an
entire
sentient
species.
He
knew
this
argument
would
carry
no
water
with
the
humans
of
Lusitania.
Their
own
lives
were
at
stake
here,
and
the
lives
of
their
children;
it
would
be
absurd
to
expect
them
to
be
willing
to
die
for
the
sake
of
another
species
that
they
didn't
understand
and
that
few
of
them
even
liked.
It
would
make
no
sense
genetically--
evolution
encourages
only
creatures
who
are
serious
about
protecting
their
own
genes.
Even
if
the
Bishop
himself
declared
it
to
be
the
will
of
God
that
the
human
beings
of
Lusitania
lay
down
their
lives
for
the
piggies,
there
would
be
precious
few
who
would
obey.
I'm
not
sure
I
could
make
such
a
sacrifice
myself,
thought
Ender.
Even
though
I
have
no
children
of
my
own.
Even
though
I
have
already
lived
through
the
destruction
of
a
sentient
species--
even
though
I
triggered
that
destruction
myself,
and
I
know
what
a
terrible
moral
burden
that
is
to
bear--
I'm
not
sure
I
could
let
my
fellow
human
beings
die,
either
by
starvation
because
their
food
crops
have
been
destroyed,
or
far
more
painfully
by
the
return
of
the
descolada
as
a
disease
with
the
power
to
consume
the
human
body
in
days.
And
yet...
could
I
consent
to
the
destruction
of
the
pequeninos?
Could
I
permit
another
xenocide?
He
picked
up
one
of
the
broken
potato
stems
with
its
blotchy
leaves.
He
would
have
to
take
this
to
Novinha,
of
course.
Novinha
would
examine
it,
or
Ela
would,
and
they'd
confirm
what
was
already
obvious.
Another
failure.
He
put
the
potato
stem
into
a
sterile
pouch.
"Speaker."
It
was
Planter,
Ender's
assistant
and
his
closest
friend
among
the
piggies.
Planter
was
a
son
of
the
pequenino
named
Human,
whom
Ender
had
taken
into
the
"third
life,"
the
tree
stage
of
the
pequenino
life
cycle.
Ender
held
up
the
transparent
plastic
pouch
for
Planter
to
see
the
leaves
inside.
"Very
dead
indeed,
Speaker,"
said
Planter,
with
no
discernible
emotion.
That
had
been
the
most
disconcerting
thing
about
working
with
pequeninos
at
first--
they
didn't
show
emotions
in
ways
that
humans
could
easily,
habitually
interpret.
It
was
one
of
the
greatest
barriers
to
their
acceptance
by
most
of
the
colonists.
The
piggies
weren't
cute
or
cuddly;
they
were
merely
strange.
"We'll
try
again,"
said
Ender.
"I
think
we're
getting
closer."
"Your
wife
wants
you,"
said
Planter.
The
word
wife,
even
translated
into
a
human
language
like
Stark,
was
so
loaded
with
tension
for
a
pequenino
that
it
was
difficult
to
speak
the
word
naturally--
Planter
almost
screeched
it.
Yet
the
idea
of
wifeness
was
so
powerful
to
the
pequeninos
that,
while
they
could
call
Novinha
by
her
name
when
they
spoke
to
her
directly,
when
they
were
speaking
to
Novinha's
husband
they
could
only
refer
to
her
by
her
title.
"I
was
just
about
to
go
see
her
anyway,"
said
Ender.
"Would
you
measure
and
record
these
potatoes,
please?"
Planter
leaped
straight
up--
like
a
popcorn,
Ender
thought.
Though
his
face
remained,
to
human
eyes,
expressionless,
the
vertical
jump
showed
his
delight.
Planter
loved
working
with
the
electronic
equipment,
both
because
machines
fascinated
him
and
because
it
added
greatly
to
his
status
among
the
other
pequenino
males.
Planter
immediately
began
unpacking
the
camera
and
its
computer
from
the
bag
he
always
carried
with
him.
"When
you're
done,
please
prepare
this
isolated
section
for
flash
burning,"
said
Ender.
"Yes
yes,"
said
Planter.
"Yes
yes
yes."
Ender
sighed.
Pequeninos
got
so
annoyed
when
humans
told
them
things
that
they
already
knew.
Planter
certainly
knew
the
routine
when
the
descolada
had
adapted
to
a
new
crop--
the
"educated"
virus
had
to
be
destroyed
while
it
was
still
in
isolation.
No
point
in
letting
the
whole
community
of
descolada
viruses
profit
from
what
one
strain
had
learned.
So
Ender
shouldn't
have
reminded
him.
And
yet
that
was
how
human
beings
satisfied
their
sense
of
responsibility--
checking
again
even
when
they
knew
it
was
unnecessary.
Planter
was
so
busy
he
hardly
noticed
that
Ender
was
leaving
the
field.
When
Ender
was
inside
the
isolation
shed
at
the
townward
end
of
the
field,
he
stripped,
put
his
clothes
in
the
purification
box,
and
then
did
the
purification
dance--
hands
up
high,
arms
rotating
at
the
shoulder,
turning
in
a
circle,
squatting
and
standing
again,
so
that
no
part
of
his
body
was
missed
by
the
combination
of
radiation
and
gases
that
filled
the
shed.
He
breathed
deeply
through
mouth
and
nose,
then
coughed--
as
always--
because
the
gases
were
barely
within
the
limits
of
human
tolerance.
Three
full
minutes
with
burning
eyes
and
wheezing
lungs,
while
waving
his
arms
and
squatting
and
standing:
our
ritual
of
obeisance
to
the
almighty
descolada.
Thus
we
humiliate
ourselves
before
the
undisputed
master
of
life
on
this
planet.
Finally
it
was
done;
I've
been
roasted
to
a
turn,
he
thought.
As
fresh
air
finally
rushed
into
the
shed,
he
took
his
clothes
out
of
the
box
and
put
them
on,
still
hot.
As
soon
as
he
left
the
shed,
it
would
be
heated
so
that
every
surface
was
far
over
the
proven
heat
tolerance
of
the
descolada
virus.
Nothing
could
live
in
that
shed
during
this
final
step
of
purification.
Next
time
someone
came
to
the
shed
it
would
be
absolutely
sterile.
Yet
Ender
couldn't
help
but
think
that
somehow
the
descolada
virus
would
find
a
way
through--
if
not
through
the
shed,
then
through
the
mild
disruption
barrier
that
surrounded
the
experimental
crop
area
like
an
invisible
fortress
wall.
Officially,
no
molecule
larger
than
a
hundred
atoms
could
pass
through
that
barrier
without
being
broken
up.
Fences
on
either
side
of
the
barrier
kept
humans
and
piggies
from
straying
into
the
fatal
area--
but
Ender
had
often
imagined
what
it
would
be
like
for
someone
to
pass
through
the
disruption
field.
Every
cell
in
the
body
would
be
killed
instantly
as
the
nucleic
acids
broke
apart.
Perhaps
the
body
would
hold
together
physically.
But
in
Ender's
imagination
he
always
saw
the
body
crumbling
into
dust
on
the
other
side
of
the
barrier,
the
breeze
carrying
it
away
like
smoke
before
it
could
hit
the
ground.
What
made
Ender
most
uncomfortable
about
the
disruption
barrier
was
that
it
was
based
on
the
same
principle
as
the
Molecular
Disruption
Device.
Designed
to
be
used
against
starships
and
missiles,
it
was
Ender
who
turned
it
against
the
home
planet
of
the
buggers
when
he
commanded
the
human
warfleet
three
thousand
years
ago.
And
it
was
the
same
weapon
that
was
now
on
its
way
from
Starways
Congress
to
Lusitania.
According
to
Jane,
Starways
Congress
had
already
attempted
to
send
the
order
to
use
it.
She
had
blocked
that
by
cutting
off
ansible
communications
between
the
fleet
and
the
rest
of
humanity,
but
there
was
no
telling
whether
some
overwrought
ship's
captain,
panicked
because
his
ansible
wasn't
working,
might
still
use
it
on
Lusitania
when
he
got
here.
It
was
unthinkable,
but
they
had
done
it--
Congress
had
sent
the
order
to
destroy
a
world.
To
commit
xenocide.
Had
Ender
written
the
Hive
Queen
in
vain?
Had
they
already
forgotten?
But
it
wasn't
"already"
to
them.
It
was
three
thousand
years
to
most
people.
And
even
though
Ender
had
written
the
Life
of
Human,
it
wasn't
believed
widely
enough
yet.
It
hadn't
been
embraced
by
the
people
to
such
a
degree
that
Congress
wouldn't
dare
to
act
against
the
pequeninos.
Why
had
they
decided
to
do
it?
Probably
for
exactly
the
same
purpose
as
the
xenobiologists'
disruption
barrier:
to
isolate
a
dangerous
infection
so
it
couldn't
spread
into
the
wider
population.
Congress
was
probably
worried
about
containing
the
plague
of
planetary
revolt.
But
when
the
fleet
reached
here,
with
or
without
orders,
they
might
be
as
likely
to
use
the
Little
Doctor
as
the
final
solution
to
the
descolada
problem:
If
there
were
no
planet
Lusitania,
there
would
be
no
self-mutating
half-intelligent
virus
itching
for
a
chance
to
wipe
out
humanity
and
all
its
works.
It
wasn't
that
long
a
walk
from
the
experimental
fields
to
the
new
xenobiology
station.
The
path
wound
over
a
low
hill,
skirting
the
edge
of
the
wood
that
provided
father,
mother,
and
living
cemetery
to
this
tribe
of
pequeninos,
and
then
on
to
the
north
gate
in
the
fence
that
surrounded
the
human
colony.
The
fence
was
a
sore
point
with
Ender.
There
was
no
reason
for
it
to
exist
anymore,
now
that
the
policy
of
minimal
contact
between
humans
and
pequeninos
had
broken
down,
and
both
species
passed
freely
through
the
gate.
When
Ender
arrived
on
Lusitania,
the
fence
was
charged
with
a
field
that
caused
any
person
entering
it
to
suffer
excruciating
pain.
During
the
struggle
to
win
the
right
to
communicate
freely
with
the
pequeninos,
Ender's
oldest
stepson,
Miro,
was
trapped
in
the
field
for
several
minutes,
causing
irreversible
brain
damage.
Yet
Miro's
experience
was
only
the
most
painful
and
immediate
expression
of
what
the
fence
did
to
the
souls
of
the
humans
enclosed
within
it.
The
psychobarrier
had
been
shut
off
thirty
years
ago.
In
all
that
time,
there
had
been
no
reason
to
have
any
barrier
between
humans
and
pequeninos--
yet
the
fence
remained.
The
human
colonists
of
Lusitania
wanted
it
that
way.
They
wanted
the
boundary
between
human
and
pequenino
to
remain
unbreached.
That
was
why
the
xenobiology
labs
had
been
moved
from
their
old
location
down
by
the
river.
If
pequeninos
were
to
take
part
in
the
research,
the
lab
had
to
be
close
to
the
fence,
and
all
the
experimental
fields
outside
it,
so
that
humans
and
pequeninos
wouldn't
have
occasion
to
confront
each
other
unexpectedly.
When
Miro
left
to
meet
Valentine,
Ender
had
thought
he
would
return
to
be
astonished
by
the
great
changes
in
the
world
of
Lusitania.
He
had
thought
that
Miro
would
see
humans
and
pequeninos
living
side
by
side,
two
species
living
in
harmony.
Instead,
Miro
would
find
the
colony
nearly
unchanged.
With
rare
exceptions,
the
human
beings
of
Lusitania
did
not
long
for
the
close
company
of
another
species.
It
was
a
good
thing
that
Ender
had
helped
the
hive
queen
restore
the
race
of
buggers
so
far
from
Milagre.
Ender
had
planned
to
help
buggers
and
humans
gradually
come
to
know
each
other.
Instead,
he
and
Novinha
and
their
family
had
been
forced
to
keep
the
existence
of
the
buggers
on
Lusitania
a
close-held
secret.
If
the
human
colonists
couldn't
deal
with
the
mammal-like
pequeninos,
it
was
certain
that
knowing
about
the
insect-like
buggers
would
provoke
violent
xenophobia
almost
at
once.
I
have
too
many
secrets,
thought
Ender.
For
all
these
years
I've
been
a
speaker
for
the
dead,
uncovering
secrets
and
helping
people
to
live
in
the
light
of
truth.
Now
I
no
longer
tell
anyone
half
of
what
I
know,
because
if
I
told
the
whole
truth
there
would
be
fear,
hatred,
brutality,
murder,
war.
Not
far
from
the
gate,
but
outside
it,
stood
two
fathertrees,
the
one
named
Rooter,
the
other
named
Human,
planted
so
that
from
the
gate
it
would
seem
that
Rooter
was
on
the
left
hand,
Human
on
the
right.
Human
was
the
pequenino
whom
Ender
had
been
required
to
ritually
kill
with
his
own
hands,
in
order
to
seal
the
treaty
between
humans
and
pequeninos.
Then
Human
was
reborn
in
cellulose
and
chlorophyll,
finally
a
mature
adult
male,
able
to
sire
children.
At
present
Human
still
had
enormous
prestige,
not
only
among
the
piggies
of
this
tribe,
but
in
many
other
tribes
as
well.
Ender
knew
that
he
was
alive;
yet,
seeing
the
tree,
it
was
impossible
for
him
to
forget
how
Human
had
died.
Ender
had
no
trouble
dealing
with
Human
as
a
person,
for
he
had
spoken
with
this
fathertree
many
times.
What
he
could
not
manage
was
to
think
of
this
tree
as
the
same
person
he
had
known
as
the
pequenino
named
Human.
Ender
might
understand
intellectually
that
it
was
will
and
memory
that
made
up
a
person's
identity,
and
that
will
and
memory
had
passed
intact
from
the
pequenino
into
the
fathertree.
But
intellectual
understanding
did
not
always
bring
visceral
belief.
Human
was
so
alien
now.
Yet
still
he
was
Human,
and
he
was
still
Ender's
friend;
Ender
touched
the
bark
of
the
tree
as
he
passed.
Then,
taking
a
few
steps
out
of
his
way,
Ender
walked
to
the
older
fathertree
named
Rooter,
and
touched
his
bark
also.
He
had
never
known
Rooter
as
a
pequenino--
Rooter
had
been
killed
by
other
hands,
and
his
tree
was
already
tall
and
well-spread
before
Ender
arrived
on
Lusitania.
There
was
no
sense
of
loss
to
trouble
him
when
Ender
talked
to
Rooter.
At
Rooter's
base,
among
the
roots,
lay
many
sticks.
Some
had
been
brought
here;
some
were
shed
from
Rooter's
own
branches.
They
were
talking
sticks.
Pequeninos
used
them
to
beat
a
rhythm
on
the
trunk
of
a
fathertree;
the
fathertree
would
shape
and
reshape
the
hollow
areas
inside
his
own
trunk
to
change
the
sound,
to
make
a
slow
kind
of
speech.
Ender
could
beat
the
rhythm--
clumsily,
but
well
enough
to
get
words
from
the
trees.
Today,
though,
Ender
wanted
no
conversation.
Let
Planter
tell
the
fathertrees
that
another
experiment
had
failed.
Ender
would
talk
to
Rooter
and
Human
later.
He
would
talk
to
the
hive
queen.
He
would
talk
to
Jane.
He
would
talk
to
everybody.
And
after
all
the
talking,
they
would
be
no
closer
to
solving
any
of
the
problems
that
darkened
Lusitania's
future.
Because
the
solution
to
their
problems
now
did
not
depend
on
talk.
It
depended
on
knowledge
and
action--
knowledge
that
only
other
people
could
learn,
actions
that
only
other
people
could
perform.
There
was
nothing
that
Ender
could
do
himself
to
solve
anything.
All
he
could
do,
all
he
had
ever
done
since
his
final
battle
as
a
child
warrior,
was
listen
and
talk.
At
other
times,
in
other
places,
that
had
been
enough.
Not
now.
Many
different
kinds
of
destruction
loomed
over
Lusitania,
some
of
them
set
in
motion
by
Ender
himself,
and
yet
not
one
of
them
could
now
be
solved
by
any
act
or
word
or
thought
of
Andrew
Wiggin.
Like
all
the
other
citizens
of
Lusitania,
his
future
was
in
the
hands
of
other
people.
The
difference
between
him
and
them
was
that
Ender
knew
all
the
danger,
all
the
possible
consequences
of
every
failure
or
mistake.
Who
was
more
cursed,
the
one
who
died,
unknowing
until
the
very
moment
of
his
death,
or
the
one
who
watched
his
destruction
as
it
approached,
step
by
step,
for
days
and
weeks
and
years?
Ender
left
the
fathertrees
and
walked
on
down
the
well-beaten
path
toward
the
human
colony.
Through
the
gate,
through
the
door
of
the
xenobiology
lab.
The
pequenino
who
served
as
Ela's
most
trusted
assistant-
-
named
Deaf,
though
he
was
definitely
not
hard
of
hearing--
led
him
at
once
to
Novinha's
office,
where
Ela,
Novinha,
Quara,
and
Grego
were
already
waiting.
Ender
held
up
the
pouch
containing
the
fragment
of
potato
plant.
Ela
shook
her
head;
Novinha
sighed.
But
they
didn't
seem
half
as
disappointed
as
Ender
had
expected.
Clearly
there
was
something
else
on
their
minds.
"I
guess
we
expected
that,"
said
Novinha.
"We
still
had
to
try,"
said
Ela.
"Why
did
we
have
to
try?"
demanded
Grego.
Novinha's
youngest
son--
and
therefore
Ender's
stepson--
was
in
his
mid-thirties
now,
a
brilliant
scientist
in
his
own
right;
but
he
did
seem
to
relish
his
role
as
devil's
advocate
in
all
the
family's
discussions,
whether
they
dealt
with
xenobiology
or
the
color
to
paint
the
walls.
"All
we're
doing
by
introducing
these
new
strains
is
teaching
the
descolada
how
to
get
around
every
strategy
we
have
for
killing
it.
If
we
don't
wipe
it
out
soon,
it'll
wipe
us
out.
And
once
the
descolada
is
gone,
we
can
grow
regular
old
potatoes
without
any
of
this
nonsense."
"We
can't!"
shouted
Quara.
Her
vehemence
surprised
Ender.
Quara
was
reluctant
to
speak
out
at
the
best
of
times;
for
her
to
speak
so
loudly
now
was
out
of
character.
"I
tell
you
that
the
descolada
is
alive."
"And
I
tell
you
that
a
virus
is
a
virus,"
said
Grego.
It
bothered
Ender
that
Grego
was
calling
for
the
extermination
of
the
descolada--
it
wasn't
like
him
to
so
easily
call
for
something
that
would
destroy
the
pequeninos.
Grego
had
practically
grown
up
among
the
pequenino
males--
he
knew
them
better,
spoke
their
language
better,
than
anyone.
"Children,
be
quiet
and
let
me
explain
this
to
Andrew,"
said
Novinha.
"We
were
discussing
what
to
do
if
the
potatoes
failed,
Ela
and
I,
and
she
told
me--
no,
you
explain
it,
Ela."
"It's
an
easy
enough
concept.
Instead
of
trying
to
grow
plants
that
inhibit
the
growth
of
the
descolada
virus,
we
need
to
go
after
the
virus
itself."
"Right,"
said
Grego.
"Shut
up,"
said
Quara.
"As
a
kindness
to
us
all,
Grego,
please
do
as
your
sister
has
so
kindly
asked,"
said
Novinha.
Ela
sighed
and
went
on.
"We
can't
just
kill
it
because
that
would
kill
all
the
other
native
life
on
Lusitania.
So
what
I
propose
is
trying
to
develop
a
new
strain
of
descolada
that
continues
to
act
as
the
present
virus
acts
in
the
reproductive
cycles
of
all
the
Lusitanian
life
forms,
but
without
the
ability
to
adapt
to
new
species."
"You
can
eliminate
that
part
of
the
virus?"
asked
Ender.
"You
can
find
it?"
"Not
likely.
But
I
think
I
can
find
all
the
parts
of
the
virus
that
are
active
in
the
piggies
and
in
all
the
other
plant-animal
pairs,
keep
those,
and
discard
everything
else.
Then
we'd
add
a
rudimentary
reproductive
ability
and
set
up
some
receptors
so
it'll
respond
properly
to
the
appropriate
changes
in
the
host
bodies,
put
the
whole
thing
in
a
little
organelle,
and
there
we
have
it--
a
substitute
for
the
descolada
so
that
the
pequeninos
and
all
the
other
native
species
are
safe,
while
we
can
live
without
worry."
"Then
you'll
spray
all
the
original
descolada
virus
to
wipe
them
out?"
asked
Ender.
"What
if
there's
already
a
resistant
strain?"
"No,
we
don't
spray
them,
because
spraying
wouldn't
wipe
out
the
viruses
that
are
already
incorporated
into
the
bodies
of
every
Lusitanian
creature.
This
is
the
really
tricky
part--"
"As
if
the
rest
were
easy,"
said
Novinha,
"making
a
new
organelle
out
of
nothing--"
"We
can't
just
inject
these
organelles
into
a
few
piggies
or
even
into
all
of
them,
because
we'd
also
have
to
inject
them
into
every
other
native
animal
and
tree
and
blade
of
grass."
"Can't
be
done,"
said
Ender.
"So
we
have
to
develop
a
mechanism
to
deliver
the
organelles
universally,
and
at
the
same
time
destroy
the
old
descolada
viruses
once
and
for
all."
"Xenocide,"
said
Quara.
"That's
the
argument,"
said
Ela.
"Quara
says
the
descolada
is
sentient."
Ender
looked
at
his
youngest
stepdaughter.
"A
sentient
molecule?"
"They
have
language,
Andrew."
"When
did
this
happen?"
asked
Ender.
He
was
trying
to
imagine
how
a
genetic
molecule--
even
one
as
long
and
complex
as
the
descolada
virus--
could
possibly
speak.
"I've
suspected
it
for
a
long
time.
I
wasn't
going
to
say
anything
until
I
was
sure,
but--"
"Which
means
she
isn't
sure,"
said
Grego
triumphantly.
"But
I'm
almost
sure
now,
and
you
can't
go
destroying
a
whole
species
until
we
know."
"How
do
they
speak?"
asked
Ender.
"Not
like
us,
of
course,"
said
Quara.
"They
pass
information
back
and
forth
to
each
other
at
a
molecular
level.
I
first
noticed
it
as
I
was
working
on
the
question
of
how
the
new
resistant
strains
of
the
descolada
spread
so
quickly
and
replaced
all
the
old
viruses
in
such
a
short
time.
I
couldn't
solve
that
problem
because
I
was
asking
the
wrong
question.
They
don't
replace
the
old
ones.
They
simply
pass
messages."
"They
throw
darts,"
said
Grego.
"That
was
my
own
word
for
it,"
said
Quara.
"I
didn't
understand
that
it
was
speech."
"Because
it
wasn't
speech,"
said
Grego.
"That
was
five
years
ago,"
said
Ender.
"You
said
the
darts
they
send
out
carry
the
needed
genes
and
then
all
the
viruses
that
receive
the
darts
revise
their
own
structure
to
include
the
new
gene.
That's
hardly
language."
"But
that
isn't
the
only
time
they
send
darts,"
said
Quara.
"Those
messenger
molecules
are
moving
in
and
out
all
the
time,
and
most
of
the
time
they
aren't
incorporated
into
the
body
at
all.
They
get
read
by
several
parts
of
the
descolada
and
then
they're
passed
on
to
another
one."
"This
is
language?"
asked
Grego.
"Not
yet,"
said
Quara.
"But
sometimes
after
a
virus
reads
one
of
these
darts,
it
makes
a
new
dart
and
sends
it
out.
Here's
the
part
that
tells
me
it's
a
language:
The
front
part
of
the
new
dart
always
begins
with
a
molecular
sequence
similar
to
the
back
tag
of
the
dart
that
it's
answering.
It
holds
the
thread
of
the
conversation
together."
"Conversation,"
said
Grego
scornfully.
"Be
quiet
or
die,"
said
Ela.
Even
after
all
these
years,
Ender
realized,
Ela's
voice
still
had
the
power
to
curb
Grego's
snottiness--
sometimes,
at
least.
"I've
tracked
some
of
these
conversations
for
as
many
as
a
hundred
statements
and
answers.
Most
of
them
die
out
much
sooner
than
that.
A
few
of
them
are
incorporated
into
the
main
body
of
the
virus.
But
here's
the
most
interesting
thing--
it's
completely
voluntary.
Sometimes
one
virus
will
pick
up
that
dart
and
keep
it,
while
most
of
the
others
don't.
Sometimes
most
of
the
viruses
will
keep
a
particular
dart.
But
the
area
where
they
incorporate
these
message
darts
is
exactly
that
area
that
has
been
hardest
to
map.
It's
hardest
to
map
because
it
isn't
part
of
their
structure,
it's
their
memory,
and
individuals
are
all
different
from
each
other.
They
also
tend
to
weed
out
a
few
memory
fragments
when
they've
taken
on
too
many
darts."
"This
is
all
fascinating,"
said
Grego,
"but
it
isn't
science.
There
are
plenty
of
explanations
for
these
darts
and
the
random
bonding
and
shedding--"
"Not
random!"
said
Quara.
"None
of
this
is
language,"
said
Grego.
Ender
ignored
the
argument,
because
Jane
was
whispering
in
his
ear
through
the
jewel-like
transceiver
he
wore
there.
She
spoke
to
him
more
rarely
now
than
in
years
past.
He
listened
carefully,
taking
nothing
for
granted.
"She's
on
to
something,"
Jane
said.
"I've
looked
at
her
research
and
there's
something
going
on
here
that
doesn't
happen
with
any
other
subcellular
creature.
I've
run
many
different
analyses
on
the
data,
and
the
more
I
simulate
and
test
this
particular
behavior
of
the
descolada,
the
less
it
looks
like
genetic
coding
and
the
more
it
looks
like
language.
At
the
moment
we
can't
rule
out
the
possibility
that
it
is
voluntary."
When
Ender
turned
his
attention
back
to
the
argument,
Grego
was
speaking.
"Why
do
we
have
to
turn
everything
we
haven't
figured
out
yet
into
some
kind
of
mystical
experience?"
Grego
closed
his
eyes
and
intoned,
"I
have
found
new
life!
I
have
found
new
life!"
"Stop
it!"
shouted
Quara.
"This
is
getting
out
of
hand,"
said
Novinha.
"Grego,
try
to
keep
this
at
the
level
of
rational
discussion."
"It's
hard
to,
when
the
whole
thing
is
so
irrational.
At‚
agora
quem
ja
imaginou
microbiologista
que
se
torna
namorada
de
uma
mol‚cula?"
Who
ever
heard
of
a
microbiologist
getting
a
crush
on
a
molecule?
"Enough!"
said
Novinha
sharply.
"Quara
is
as
much
a
scientist
as
you
are,
and--"
"She
was,"
muttered
Grego.
"And--
if
you'll
kindly
shut
up
long
enough
to
hear
me
out--
she
has
a
right
to
be
heard."
Novinha
was
quite
angry
now,
but,
as
usual,
Grego
seemed
unimpressed.
"You
should
know
by
now,
Grego,
that
it's
often
the
ideas
that
sound
most
absurd
and
counterintuitive
at
first
that
later
cause
fundamental
shifts
in
the
way
we
see
the
world."
"Do
you
really
think
this
is
one
of
those
basic
discoveries?"
asked
Grego,
looking
them
in
the
eye,
each
in
turn.
"A
talking
virus?
Se
Quara
sabe
tanto,
porque
ela
nao
diz
o
que
e
que
aqueles
bichos
dizem?"
If
she
knows
so
much
about
it,
why
doesn't
she
tell
us
what
these
little
beasts
are
saying?
It
was
a
sign
that
the
discussion
was
getting
out
of
hand,
that
he
broke
into
Portuguese
instead
of
speaking
in
Stark,
the
language
of
science--
and
diplomacy.
"Does
it
matter?"
asked
Ender.
"Matter!"
said
Quara.
Ela
looked
at
Ender
with
consternation.
"It's
only
the
difference
between
curing
a
dangerous
disease
and
destroying
an
entire
sentient
species.
I
think
it
matters."
"I
meant,"
said
Ender
patiently,
"does
it
matter
whether
we
know
what
they're
saying."
"No,"
said
Quara.
"We'll
probably
never
understand
their
language,
but
that
doesn't
change
the
fact
that
they're
sentient.
What
do
viruses
and
human
beings
have
to
say
to
each
other,
anyway?"
"How
about,
'Please
stop
trying
to
kill
us'?"
said
Grego.
"If
you
can
figure
out
how
to
say
that
in
virus
language,
then
this
might
be
useful."
"But
Grego,"
said
Quara,
with
mock
sweetness,
"do
we
say
that
to
them,
or
do
they
say
that
to
us?"
"We
don't
have
to
decide
today,"
said
Ender.
"We
can
afford
to
wait
awhile."
"How
do
you
know?"
said
Grego.
"How
do
you
know
that
tomorrow
afternoon
we
won't
all
wake
up
itching
and
hurting
and
puking
and
burning
up
with
fever
and
finally
dying
because
overnight
the
descolada
virus
figured
out
how
to
wipe
us
out
once
and
for
all?
It's
us
or
them."
"I
think
Grego
just
showed
us
why
we
have
to
wait,"
said
Ender.
"Did
you
hear
how
he
talked
about
the
descolada?
It
figures
out
how
to
wipe
us
out.
Even
he
thinks
the
descolada
has
a
will
and
makes
decisions."
"That's
just
a
figure
of
speech,"
said
Grego.
"We've
all
been
talking
that
way,"
said
Ender.
"And
thinking
that
way,
too.
Because
we
all
feel
it--
that
we're
at
war
with
the
descolada.
That
it's
more
than
just
fighting
off
a
disease--
it's
like
we
have
an
intelligent,
resourceful
enemy
who
keeps
countering
all
our
moves.
In
all
the
history
of
medical
research,
no
one
has
ever
fought
a
disease
that
had
so
many
ways
to
defeat
the
strategies
used
against
it."
"Only
because
nobody's
been
fighting
a
germ
with
such
an
oversized
and
complex
genetic
molecule,"
said
Grego.
"Exactly,"
said
Ender.
"This
is
a
one-of-a-kind
virus,
and
so
it
may
have
abilities
we've
never
imagined
in
any
species
less
structurally
complex
than
a
vertebrate."
For
a
moment
Ender's
words
hung
in
the
air,
answered
by
silence;
for
a
moment,
Ender
imagined
that
he
might
have
served
a
useful
function
in
this
meeting
after
all,
that
as
a
mere
talker
he
might
have
won
some
kind
of
agreement.
Grego
soon
disabused
him
of
this
idea.
"Even
if
Quara's
right,
even
if
she's
dead
on
and
the
descolada
viruses
all
have
doctorates
of
philosophy
and
keep
publishing
dissertations
on
screwing-up-humans-tillthey're-dead,
what
then?
Do
we
all
roll
over
and
play
dead
because
the
virus
that's
trying
to
kill
us
all
is
so
damn
smart?"
Novinha
answered
calmly.
"I
think
Quara
needs
to
continue
with
her
research--
and
we
need
to
give
her
more
resources
to
do
it--
while
Ela
continues
with
hers."
It
was
Quara
who
objected
this
time.
"Why
should
I
bother
trying
to
understand
them
if
the
rest
of
you
are
still
working
on
ways
to
kill
them?"
"That's
a
good
question,
Quara,"
said
Novinha.
"On
the
other
hand,
why
should
you
bother
trying
to
understand
them
if
they
suddenly
figure
out
a
way
to
get
past
all
our
chemical
barriers
and
kill
us
all?"
"Us
or
them,"
muttered
Grego.
Novinha
had
made
a
good
decision,
Ender
knew--
keep
both
lines
of
research
open,
and
decide
later
when
they
knew
more.
In
the
meantime,
Quara
and
Grego
were
both
missing
the
point,
both
assuming
that
everything
hinged
on
whether
or
not
the
descolada
was
sentient.
"Even
if
they're
sentient,"
said
Ender,
"that
doesn't
mean
they're
sacrosanct.
It
all
depends
whether
they're
raman
or
varelse.
If
they're
raman--
if
we
can
understand
them
and
they
can
understand
us
well
enough
to
work
out
a
way
of
living
together--
then
fine.
We'll
be
safe,
they'll
be
safe."
"The
great
peacemaker
plans
to
sign
a
treaty
with
a
molecule?"
asked
Grego.
Ender
ignored
his
mocking
tone.
"On
the
other
hand,
if
they're
trying
to
destroy
us,
and
we
can't
find
a
way
to
communicate
with
them,
then
they're
varelse--
sentient
aliens,
but
implacably
hostile
and
dangerous.
Varelse
are
aliens
we
can't
live
with.
Varelse
are
aliens
with
whom
we
are
naturally
and
permanently
engaged
in
a
war
to
the
death,
and
at
that
time
our
only
moral
choice
is
to
do
all
that's
necessary
to
win."
"Right,"
said
Grego.
Despite
her
brother's
triumphant
tone,
Quara
had
listened
to
Ender's
words,
weighed
them,
and
now
gave
a
tentative
nod.
"As
long
as
we
don't
start
from
the
assumption
that
they're
varelse,"
said
Quara.
"And
even
then,
maybe
there's
a
middle
way,"
said
Ender.
"Maybe
Ela
can
find
a
way
to
replace
all
the
descolada
viruses
without
destroying
this
memory-and-language
thing."
"No!"
said
Quara,
once
again
fervent.
"You
can't--
you
don't
even
have
the
right
to
leave
them
their
memories
and
take
away
their
ability
to
adapt.
That
would
be
like
them
giving
all
of
us
frontal
lobotomies.
If
it's
war,
then
it's
war.
Kill
them,
but
don't
leave
them
their
memories
while
stealing
their
will."
"It
doesn't
matter,"
said
Ela.
"It
can't
be
done.
As
it
is,
I
think
I've
set
myself
an
impossible
task.
Operating
on
the
descolada
isn't
easy.
Not
like
examining
and
operating
on
an
animal.
How
do
I
anesthetize
the
molecule
so
that
it
doesn't
heal
itself
while
I'm
halfway
through
the
amputation?
Maybe
the
descolada
isn't
much
on
physics,
but
it's
a
hell
of
a
lot
better
than
I
am
at
molecular
surgery."
"So
far,"
said
Ender.
"So
far
we
don't
know
anything,"
said
Grego.
"Except
that
the
descolada
is
trying
as
hard
as
it
can
to
kill
us
all,
while
we're
still
trying
to
figure
out
whether
we
ought
to
fight
back.
I'll
sit
tight
for
a
while
longer,
but
not
forever.
"
"What
about
the
piggies?"
asked
Quara.
"Don't
they
have
a
right
to
vote
on
whether
we
transform
the
molecule
that
not
only
allows
them
to
reproduce,
but
probably
created
them
as
a
sentient
species
in
the
first
place?"
"This
thing
is
trying
to
kill
us,"
said
Ender.
"As
long
as
the
solution
Ela
comes
up
with
can
wipe
out
the
virus
without
interfering
with
the
reproductive
cycle
of
the
piggies,
then
I
don't
think
they
have
any
right
to
object."
"Maybe
they'd
feel
different
about
that."
"Then
maybe
they'd
better
not
find
out
what
we're
doing,"
said
Grego.
"We
don't
tell
people--
human
or
pequenino--
about
the
research
we're
doing
here,"
said
Novinha
sharply.
"It
could
cause
terrible
misunderstandings
that
could
lead
to
violence
and
death."
"So
we
humans
are
the
judges
of
all
other
creatures,"
said
Quara.
"No,
Quara.
We
scientists
are
gathering
information,"
said
Novinha.
"Until
we've
gathered
enough,
nobody
can
judge
anything.
So
the
secrecy
rule
goes
for
everybody
here.
Quara
and
Grego
both.
You
tell
no
one
until
I
say
so,
and
I
won't
say
so
until
we
know
more."
"Until
you
say
so,"
asked
Grego
impudently,
"or
until
the
Speaker
for
the
Dead
says
so?"
"I'm
the
head
xenobiologist,"
said
Novinha.
"The
decision
on
when
we
know
enough
is
mine
alone.
Is
that
understood?"
She
waited
for
everyone
there
to
assent.
They
all
did.
Novinha
stood
up.
The
meeting
was
over.
Quara
and
Grego
left
almost
immediately;
Novinha
gave
Ender
a
kiss
on
the
cheek
and
then
ushered
him
and
Ela
out
of
her
office.
Ender
lingered
in
the
lab
to
talk
to
Ela.
"Is
there
a
way
to
spread
your
replacement
virus
throughout
the
entire
population
of
every
native
species
on
Lusitania?"
"I
don't
know,"
said
Ela.
"That's
less
of
a
problem
than
how
to
get
it
to
every
cell
of
an
individual
organism
fast
enough
that
the
descolada
can't
adapt
or
escape.
I'll
have
to
create
some
kind
of
carrier
virus,
and
I'll
probably
have
to
model
it
partly
on
the
descolada
itself--
the
descolada
is
the
only
parasite
I've
seen
that
invades
a
host
as
quickly
and
thoroughly
as
I
need
the
carrier
virus
to
do
it.
Ironic--
I'll
learn
how
to
replace
the
descolada
by
stealing
techniques
from
the
virus
itself."
"It's
not
ironic,"
said
Ender,
"it's
the
way
the
world
works.
Someone
once
told
me
that
the
only
teacher
who's
worth
anything
to
you
is
your
enemy."
"Then
Quara
and
Grego
must
be
giving
each
other
advanced
degrees,"
said
Ela.
"Their
argument
is
healthy,"
said
Ender.
"It
forces
us
to
weigh
every
aspect
of
what
we're
doing."
"It'll
stop
being
healthy
if
one
of
them
decides
to
bring
it
up
outside
the
family,"
said
Ela.
"This
family
doesn't
tell
its
business
to
strangers,"
said
Ender.
"I
of
all
people
should
know
that."
"On
the
contrary,
Ender.
You
of
all
people
should
know
how
eager
we
are
to
talk
to
a
stranger--
when
we
think
our
need
is
great
enough
to
justify
it."
Ender
had
to
admit
that
she
was
right.
Getting
Quara
and
Grego,
Miro
and
Quim
and
Olhado
to
trust
him
enough
to
speak
to
him,
that
had
been
hard
when
Ender
first
came
to
Lusitania.
But
Ela
had
spoken
to
him
from
the
start,
and
so
had
all
of
Novinha's
other
children.
So,
in
the
end,
had
Novinha
herself.
The
family
was
intensely
loyal,
but
they
were
also
strong-willed
and
opinionated
and
there
wasn't
a
one
of
them
who
didn't
trust
his
own
judgment
above
anyone
else's.
Grego
or
Quara,
either
one
of
them,
might
well
decide
that
telling
somebody
else
was
in
the
best
interests
of
Lusitania
or
humanity
or
science,
and
there
would
go
the
rule
of
secrecy.
Just
the
way
the
rule
of
noninterference
with
the
piggies
had
been
broken
before
Ender
ever
got
here.
How
nice,
thought
Ender.
One
more
possible
source
of
disaster
that
is
completely
out
of
my
power
to
control.
Leaving
the
lab,
Ender
wished,
as
he
had
many
times
before,
that
Valentine
were
here.
She
was
the
one
who
was
good
at
sorting
out
ethical
dilemmas.
She'd
be
here
soon--
but
soon
enough?
Ender
understood
and
mostly
agreed
with
the
viewpoints
put
forward
by
Quara
and
Grego
both.
What
stung
most
was
the
need
for
such
secrecy
that
Ender
couldn't
even
speak
to
the
pequeninos,
not
even
Human
himself,
about
a
decision
that
would